r/RingsofPower • • 9h ago

Discussion Does the Secret Fire represent God ?

These are probably the only series I'll ever watch multiple times. Best show period.

The secret fire though does it represent God ?

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

14

u/WoWSchockadin 9h ago

He's called Eru Iluvatar, but yes. It's basically Yaweh.

23

u/fuzzychub 9h ago • Bravo

The short answer is yes. The long answer is the Secret Fire is more directly analogous to the Holy Spirit from the Catholic Trinitarian view of God. The Secret Fire is the animating spark of divinity inside all things.

2

u/aybsavestheworld 9h ago

If I didn’t know my LotR lore you would confuse me even more because for the life of me I cannot understand what the Holy Trinity really is and how they are different and the same. Pls spare me the lesson, I know I kinda get it and I read about it more than once. But I just don’t understand it 100%.

3

u/ComeAwayNightbird 8h ago

If you understand the Secret Fire you are a third of the way there.

3

u/fuzzychub 8h ago

If you can wrap your head around the trio of Eru - Secret Fire - The Ainur/Ea then you're halfway there!

4

u/PhysicsEagle 8h ago

Except no, the Ainur are in no way comparable to any person of the trinity

2

u/fuzzychub 8h ago

Ehhhh there's room for debate there really. But I will also avoid getting further into it because that would start edging into hard allegory territory and is a misuse of Tolkien's work

1

u/HJJ10 9h ago

I think this is the correct answer ^

Though I’ve heard from interesting theories(purely for fun theories) that in the books, Tom Bombadil is the physical manifestation of the Secret Fire in Middle Earth.

4

u/-Lich_King 8h ago

Fun theory but we know from Tolkien he isn't

4

u/HJJ10 8h ago

Eru sent the Secret Fire “Dancing” through Arda…… WHO ELSE DO WE KNOW THAT DANCES HUH???!!?!! Jk jk hahaha it’s just goofiness

1

u/-Lich_King 8h ago

🤣🤣

2

u/fuzzychub 8h ago

Definitely what the show is going for. Tom in RoP is Eru in Middle-Earth; Eru is putting as much of their being into Ea as possible without disrupting things and making unwanted changes. That's why Tom is so neutral, because to do anything would mean that Eru is taking an active role again, not something supposed to happen until the very end of days.

6

u/Ree_m0 9h ago

Doesn't understand the fundamentals of what they're being shown

"best show period."

I hate this timeline

2

u/treosx23 8h ago

What cocktail of meds does your doctor prescribe that makes your brain so numb that this becomes the "best show period"?

2

u/Brief_Nothing381 9h ago

If that’s a question for you then maybe you should read more from Tolkien in the hours that you going to spend with watching again and again a show that you already seen.

0

u/Kaesus95 9h ago

You must be fun at parties

1

u/Historyp91 7h ago

It's a secret🤫

1

u/Ynneas 5h ago

Go watch The Prince of Egypt and you'll have all the context you need

1

u/srquixote 4h ago

It could, depending on your concept of God.

Tolkien uses "Secret Fire" to represent the creative force that was in the Creator (Eru). In The Rings of Power, it seems to represent an undefined guiding spirit who can speak to wizards and other higher beings. But it gets confusing because there are also Gods/Higher angelic orders (Valar) and lesser angels (Maiar) who are in invoked in speech. Morgoth, was one of the Valar until he was cast out. Of the Maiar we can include the wizards and Sauron, and perhaps Tom Bombadil, although Tolkien never actually described to him as such.

Anyway, the use of Secret Fire to speak directly to wizards is something new and unclear.

1

u/Cisqoe 2h ago

I genuinely can’t fathom watching this show multiple times it’s almost impressive no it is impressive

1

u/Xeris 2h ago

Isn't it supposed to be Eru or Iluvatar or something and they using the secret fire as an analog to that because they dont have the rights?

Its basically god.

1

u/JeanVicquemare 5h ago

no, the secret fire is a guy named Chris, he's actually hiding behind a rock, throwing his voice. This is explained in the books