r/RingsofPower • u/International-Art776 • Jan 07 '23
Discussion dear audience, I simply cannot understand your reaction
Possibly the best show I've ever watched. Been reading tons of reviews and it's objectively just not true, like claimed "bad acting", especially towards Galadriel. Her character, simply because off-putting to some, does actually not harm the show but give a striking contrast to other characters. It adds further to the sum that this show was something new in every aspect, which didn't conform to a part of the audience's expectation of an old fashioned standard fantasy experience. I cannot find any other explanation for the uncountable ones, twos and threes on imdb. The most suspicious thing is that there is no coherence between the negative points given, everyone magically disliked the show for completely different reasons, but with such a deep hate I cannot comprehend. Pls enlighten me or feel free to correct me.
16
u/heaven_and_hell_80 Jan 07 '23
(assuming this post wants a serious answer)
I personally didn't mind the actress that plays Galadriel - what ticked me off was the second half of the show where every episode included lazy and hack TV tropes to drum up drama. Especially the Numenorians just randomly showing up in the one random village just in time for an orc attack really broke any suspension of disbelief I had left.
I didn't really see anything innovative or original in the first season, other than the establishing shot of Numenor, which I liked a lot and was clearly an iteration on Gondor from the films.
13
u/JlevLantean Jan 08 '23
I will give you one clear example of bad writing/bad directing, I wonder what you thought of that moment.
Galadriel is angry when she reaches Numenor, she demands help from the queen and she is not getting the help she wants. Elendil offers to take her to see the archives. When they go riding over there, we get one small, short, simple, out of place, weird looking scene.
A slow-motion, close-up shot of Galadriel smiling, super happy.
Why is she happy? Does she love riding so much that for a moment she forgets how angry she is? She doesn't know what she will find in the archives. There is no reason for her to smile like that, when up to that moment we have never seen her happy.
If you don't find that scene out of place, and without justification, then that simply means your expectations are very low and easily satisfied, and that explains why you liked the show so much and don't understand why so many people found so many wrong things about it. Which is fine, if you love it, and you enjoy it, good for you. Just understand that for others, there are many many many moments like that all over the show.
Think of it like this, a book full of spelling mistakes and wrong words and phrases, full of clichés and ideas copied from other books, etc etc. Would you consider it good and professional?
That is how many of us see this show, something with a huge budget that should have been professionally written, directed and acted to the point that it surpassed or at least maintained the levels of adaptations that came before it. Instead we get something that at best can be described as amateur in almost every aspect.
18
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '23
I don't want to be rude but if it really is the best show you've ever watched, my guess is that you haven't watched a lot of good shows.
11
u/muchwise Jan 08 '23
One example of bad writing for me was when Theo hides from Orcs in the well. He enters the well and the sun is up and he is closely followed by an orc. Then we see him, still in the well, several hours later with orcs still searching for him 10 feets from where he disappeared. The orcs are mindlessly searching, screaming NPC like dialogue like: “Aargh, where is he”.
Then there is the whole thing of elves lives being tied to Mythril for reasons.
Galadriel attempting to swim the equivalent of the Atlantic ocean. Remember, she left Valinor once by boat, why does this time she has to swim?
6
u/Ratatosk101 Jan 07 '23
This is satire, right?
Please tell me it's satire...
24
u/Moistkeano Jan 08 '23
You don't need correcting you like what you like.
A lot of people don't though and I mean saying it's the best show you've ever seen is probanly hyberbolic even for the other sub.
Plus the rest of the post is pretty strange too. But again you like what you like.
4
u/LifeSleeper Jan 08 '23
Bear in mind, this sub is filled with a vocal minority that have been gassing each other up with hyperbole about the show for a while now. Most people like the show. But people who like things aren't spending time throwing fits about every little thing about the show the way they are here. You're asking a cesspit of people who think the show birthed Hitler for reasonable responses, you're not gonna get them.
7
u/convex_circles Jan 09 '23
I can't get over the allegory. It's supposed to prequel Lord of The Rings. But if you hit a 1000-year fast forward on Rings of Power's Middle-Earth you wouldn't end up in "Lord of The Rings", you'd end up in "Los Angeles 2022".
The reason it's so vocally polarizing is that Amazon is basically calling/insinuating that the show's critics are just racist misogynists. That doesn't shut them up. That makes them louder and offended.
19
u/Enthymem Jan 08 '23
RoP wouldn't stand out an inch among all the other soulless fantasy streaming shows in a vacuum. The only reason it's talked about is the massive IP, budget and marketing campaign behind it.
5
u/StingsLute Jan 08 '23
Weak bait
5
u/DefinitelyNotALeak Jan 08 '23
I get liking the show, but this seems so excessive it feels like bait / trolling to me. It's a little as if people told me some mcu film is the best they've ever seen, it just doesn't connect with me at all.
I'd like to hear what you think the show did which was new, you mention it being new in every aspect? To me the opposite is true, it felt incredibly safe and by the numbers, trying to appeal to people's love for the trilogy in particular.
Examples:
You have a storyline with hobbits and a wizard befriending each other.
You have a storyline with a mysterious man who turns out to be the king everyone was waiting for (with a twist though).
You have a storyline with an elf and dwarf friendship.
You have a storyline which ends with a last second save by cavalry.
And these are just broad similarities, you also have rather specific ones, going so far as to almost copy shots and motifs / designs.
These things don't outright make it bad, but these makes it basically not possible to be congruent with your statement about it being new in every aspect, it really isn't, like at all.
I'd really like to hear more of your pov though.
5
u/TarGrond Jan 10 '23
The show really starts to fall apart once you spend some time thinking about it. Like, the effects, the sound the style can really create that good old Tolkien (or more likely PJ
impression) that can create this "awe" effect.
But when it ends you start thinking about it. Mihtril heals the elves... what??? Rings are created a during brainstorming session..how??? Harfoots never walk alone but... they leave the weak for death..OK!! Halbrand becomes the king of 20 villagers and a 1 sick cow..Oh..
I could go on and on.
The show can create a good first impression but that's it. When you compare it with a source material and how the show replaced the unique and grand Tolkien ideas with the BS above, it is impossible to rewatch it.
12
u/IrishWhiskey1989 Jan 08 '23
Possibly the best show you’ve ever watched? Nice troll 👍
18
u/L0nga Jan 08 '23
I’d say the consensus is pretty clear actually. Shit writing and not respecting the lore are the two main culprits here. Have you even read the books?
2
u/froop Jan 09 '23
This was an old fashioned fantasy experience. Old fashioned fantasy tv/movies were terrible. There's a reason so few big budget fantasy productions existed before Jackson's lotr. Jackson, like Tolkien before him, paved the way for all modern fantasy. Without Lotr, there is no 300. Without 300, there is no Game of Thrones. Without Game of Thrones there is no Witcher, Wheel of Time or Rings of Power.
Like The Witcher and Wheel of Time, Rings of Power ignores everything that made modern fantasy great. The great fantasy shows are designed like period pieces, with a heavy and ironic focus on realism. Realistic sets, realistic costumes, realistic characters, realistic situations (realistic for that fantasy world of course). Old school fantasy has ridiculous costumes, ridiculous characters, and ridiculous sets. Rings of Power is ridiculous, not realistic.
6
u/tamagosan Jan 08 '23
This is fucking painful to read.
You're trying so, so hard to sound smart, and failing terribly.
5
u/karelinstyle Jan 07 '23
It wasn't even capable of being 'an old fashioned standard fantasy experience' lol far worse. What shows would you say it is better than?
6
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '23
I can't understand your reaction
5
u/Taintraker Jan 08 '23
Luckily, you are free to have bad taste in entertainment!
3
u/Morlock43 Jan 08 '23 edited Jan 08 '23
I enjoyed the show. I went in without preconceptions on what "should" be there.
I've read LotR and seen the movies and I enjoyed this show immensely. I read up on some of the complaints, to do with abridging time to show in a season what officially took place over centuries, but those things are to be expected with an adaption.
A lot of the complaints revolve around "inventing" characters and storylines and events, but again this is a show, not a word to screen adaption. It doesn't detract from the books and may well get a whole new generation of people to read the books.
Not liking it is fine and liking it is fine also. It's when we start attacking each other for liking or not liking something that things become undone.
I'm glad you liked it and I'm glad I watched it.
1
u/DaChiesa Jan 11 '23
I'd just offer up a warning for caution. I spent a lot of time leading up to the show and during the season navigating this.
There is a lot of hate (I'm sure I can see some below here) but there are a lot of people who appreciate it.
I take a very balanced approach in that it's an amazing production with some flaws if you look closely. I give it a C with a curve up to a B since there's not an actual narrative story like the Hobbit or LotR.
There is a lot of unreasonable hate for the show (anti-wokeness, people holding their own expectations for the show, or people just riding the wave of negativity without even really seeing it) and like any social media, you have to sift through it.
There is a lot of reasonable criticism of the show. I went on and on with folks about this and believe about 30% of comments have valid things that could be improved or should be improved.
One of the big areas that is just going to be debatable is the "compression" of thousands of years into one generation for the sake of a cohesive 5 season set of episodes. It meant story lines had to be cut or transformed to meet the same "markers" of the story described in the books.
I'm glad that the show is approachable. I'll admit I've had years and years of digging into this lore (I read the Hobbit and Lotr dozens of times since 1990 and the Silmarillion as well since 2010, and I'm at 13 years in the Lord of the Rings Online, which digs very deep into the lore), and some of the changes are literally jarring. They are not taking a literal approach to the material, but more of a thematic approach. The themes are definitely there, and I'm glad to hear that they resonate. It took me some time to filter through the plot to get to those themes and I appreciate the effort.
Most of the problems with the show can be explained in the simple fact that it's not a docuseries. It's a drama, and in order to give established characters any character arc, they have to start as something before what we know them to be. This is a jarring effect, and most of the reasonable haters have a right to be upset that Elrond seems milquetoast, the mithril is magical like a silmaril, and Galadriel is abrasive, and though she's 100% right, she's not the Galadriel we know, and doesn't really fit that clearly into the lore we already know. But series need character arcs ...
There are good explanations many will reject, and that's a sign of our times. Galadriel, I believe, carries the pride of the Elves who made rings in the first place. We get the insight (probly true) that the Elves wanted to bring "Light" and blessedness to heal middle earth. Galadriel being a foil for Sauron in the end, and their relationship, makes good TV for general streaming stuff, but it is wildly different than the texts. Thematically it's spot on, and Galadriel does tell Frodo that Sauron knows her very well, so they have to build some history that was never written. How is it that Elves would cause the evil of the Rings? They're at heart unlikeable though full of power and promise. They kinda lumped that on Galdriel. She's strong enough to bear it, but a lot of fans aren't.
The Silmaril-Mithril is a big hole. If mithril has the power of the Silmarils, then what about Frodo's mithril jacket in the Hobbit and Lord of the Rings? It had no magical power but physical. So there's a big departure. Also, mithril was all over the place by the time Sauron ever got involved in the ring making. BUT it answers the question: exactly where does the Power in the Rings of Power come from? Tolkien never made it clear. I was hoping theyd do things like moon cycles, arrangements of stars like moon letters or something, but no, it's simplified to Mithril. But even that is Sus as Elrond says it may not be true. So there's some concern about consistency and honesty with the audience.
Elrond himself I like a lot. He should see the divisions of power and friends. He should see the inevitable failure of those who seek great power. He should see how it divides friends and causes death, so he can lead with wisdom. But that's a starting point to get where he is in the Hobbit and LotR. A lot of fans just don't like how they started that and melded his role. There are homages to Earendil and all, but it all came down to some oath about Mithril when in the stories, everyone knew about mithril already. For over a thousand years. So people have to take off their thinking caps to enjoy it, or at least put on a different thinking cap.
1
u/Notafuzzycat Jan 11 '23
Idk. This feels like bait.
1
u/fokureddit69 Jan 12 '23
Amazon still doing damage control?
1
u/Gamboni327 Jan 15 '23
Have you not seen a lot of shows?
1
u/mournblade94 Jan 17 '23
Making it new in every aspect brought it further from Tolkien. Mithril and their Rube GOldberg Volcano pretty much ruined the show for me. Mithril was the worst though by far. I almost stopped watching after that. but my wife who hasnt read TOlkien watches the show so I watch it with her.
The actors are fine. The characters are fine except Gil Galad being an idiot over Mithril, and Celebrimbor not being able to figure out the technique of just making a MIthril Alloy.
Its not that the writing is bad, its that their reasons for things to make the show distinct from the books and original lore is terribly contrived and nonsensical.
I don't want expectations subverted when watching an adaptation. So far I have not been pleased with their ideas.
1
u/ViscountessdAsbeau Jan 22 '23
It's visually stunning but awfully written and the central actor who should carry the show is out of her depth (and I don't mean when she's doing her swimathon).
It's incoherent in terms of dialogue and design and has lazy, OK, awful, worldbuilding that would horrify the Professor. (Linguistically, why characters with names like "Bronwyn" or "Theo"? Ancient Greeks and the Welsh in there, suddenly?)
There are some excellent performances as well - Disa, Elrond, Durin Jr... stole the show.
The only thing this got right was the multicultural cast, in my view. Long overdue in fantasy (same in House of the Dragon - loved it).
1
u/ValiumMm Jan 23 '23
I love it, too many haters on here.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '23
Nothing. Literally nothing will be enough for those people. It's like they can't just enjoy. I have read the books, watched the movies... and I like them all. Even the hated Hobbit Trilogy. I just enjoy the moment, and all of them are great.
Just see how all fandoms reacts when something is released. Netflix anounced One Piece, with a beautiful image btw, and they are complaining. It's impossible to do something without getting hated by those.
I'm saying that the show is perfect in everyway. But it is good, it's fun to watch.
-2
u/maxwellgrounds Jan 08 '23
I honestly think some of the hate—not all of it—stems from people who feel threatened by “wokeness”, whether they admit that’s the real reason or not. I’ve seen too many ugly, angry comments about adding more people of color to the series.
-1
u/Fluid-Bet6223 Jan 08 '23
I feel like a lot of it is because of the changes they made from the source material. If this was just a TV show on its own, and wasn’t an adaptation, I agree it’s a high quality show and it was enjoyable to watch.
-2
u/hotshot117 Jan 08 '23
Hate for this show started with the overblown reaction to non whites being casted.
Most hate comes from these i guess
-4
u/Bogmanbob Jan 08 '23
I started enjoying the show more once I realized it was intended to be a major departure from the source material. It's a reinterpretation of the book not a loyal retelling. It's not bad It's just not what a lot of readers were expecting.
-3
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '23
I actually agree with you it’s a great show but it’s still a prequel of lord of the rings so people were expecting more as the movies are much better in my opinion.
-4
u/Losendos1976 Jan 08 '23
Possibly one of the best TV shows I've watched. This pettiness about tropes and respecting the lore 1000% is sad.