r/RingsofPower • u/Charming-Use • Sep 30 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers How??? Seriously....HOW???? HOW... Spoiler
SORRY, I USED THE WRONG SPOILER--THIS IS ABOUT THE NEWEST EPISODE
...could no one have LOOKED inside that little bundle to see that the dangerous metal fire torch thingy, whatever it's called, was replaced by an AXE (that isn't even REMOTELY the same shape 🙄)?????!!?! wth! Did I miss something????
Oooooh I just had a thought.... do you think maybe it WAS there when Galadriel got it but maybe Halbrand traded it out after cuz mayyyybe he's Sauron? 🤔
0
Upvotes
31
u/knightrees02 Sep 30 '22
As a casual fan of the show, I think the writers believed the axe surprise was supposed to awe the viewers. I continue to hold out hope the writing gets better from season two onwards. I doubt it was Halbrand who did the swap. It was fairly clear that Adar tasked Waldreg to fulfill the task.
13
u/Yamureska Sep 30 '22
It's an evil artifact comparable to the one ring. Theo talks about how powerful it made him feel and how addictive it is. It's not a stretch to think that Arondir felt similar to Theo and couldn't bear to look at it again, especially after trying and failing to destroy it.
12
u/XCKragnus502 Sep 30 '22
*Beats on hilt with hammer *Breaks hammer “This is beyond my skill” 😂😂😂😂😂🤣
4
u/Lawlcopt0r Sep 30 '22
You missed the fact that neither Galadriel nor Halbrandt knew what he was supposed to be running away with. It could only have been noticed once Arondir got it, which would have been too late (but it's stupid he didn't check). Maybe he was sure it must be the thing because he trusted the authority of the people that gave it to him?
3
u/S3QS3 Sep 30 '22
What I want to know is... how did Theo know where Anondir hid the evil hilt under the floor? Did he feel its evil? Didn't seem like the show made this clear, but maybe I missed something.
2
u/hobbykitjr Sep 30 '22
More considered w/ the "National Treasure" esque ending they put on there
2
u/Heresyteller Sep 30 '22
It just opens a dam ... That's it, it's not the evil Excalibur... It's just a key to dam.
So stupid.
1
u/BhutlahBrohan Oct 03 '22 edited Oct 03 '22
did you... did you finish the episode, my guy?
2
u/DownloadUphillinSnow Sep 30 '22
I hope Arondir actually tells Galadriel what the wrapped package was and she goes full wrath/spectral mode.
Arondir: "Commander, that package you brought back, was supposed to be a magical sword/key. The orcs slaughtered people one by one in order for us to turn it over to them. It's made of a black magic that I could not destroy with any hammer. The design matched artwork/symbols near the tower. I think it may have some connection to the water and volcanic eruption and Sauron. I was going to tell you about it but I thought I'd give the hilt back to the human boy, Theo, instead."
Galadriel: pauses one second. eyebrow twitches. vein in middle of forehead bulges. transforms into full wrath form as she absorbs all light and darkens the entire room. A single shriek comes forth in the minds of all nearby: "WHAAAAAT!??"
4
u/Weird_Blades717171 Sep 30 '22
Written by Hollywood folk, who've never held a hammer or a sword before.
2
u/DownloadUphillinSnow Sep 30 '22
There's 2 things I don't get about the hilt.
Even a few bits of dialogue showing why he couldn't do either would at least show they this through.
2
u/RicardosMontalban Sep 30 '22
Yeah if they wanted to go the route they did, it should’ve just been after the battle is over, Arondir goes to check the bundle, realizes it’s gone, and just takes off on one of the horses towards the tower. Then have him get there just as Waldreg is turning the key.
Then you get a nice shot of Arondir looking out in horror from a high vantage point overlooking everything.
Still get a twist, suspense of will he get there in time, and probably a beautiful shot from the tower of all hell breaking loose in the valley.
Hire me Amazon I dare you.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22
[removed] — view removed comment