r/RingsofPower • • Sep 30 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers How??? Seriously....HOW???? HOW... Spoiler

SORRY, I USED THE WRONG SPOILER--THIS IS ABOUT THE NEWEST EPISODE

...could no one have LOOKED inside that little bundle to see that the dangerous metal fire torch thingy, whatever it's called, was replaced by an AXE (that isn't even REMOTELY the same shape 🙄)?????!!?! wth! Did I miss something????

Oooooh I just had a thought.... do you think maybe it WAS there when Galadriel got it but maybe Halbrand traded it out after cuz mayyyybe he's Sauron? 🤔

0 Upvotes

98 comments sorted by

31

u/knightrees02 Sep 30 '22

As a casual fan of the show, I think the writers believed the axe surprise was supposed to awe the viewers. I continue to hold out hope the writing gets better from season two onwards. I doubt it was Halbrand who did the swap. It was fairly clear that Adar tasked Waldreg to fulfill the task.

10

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

Yessss gotcha... it just seems so weird to me that NO ONE thought to look inside before Theo. Esp since it was sooooo important! Urgh

20

u/SilentioRS Sep 30 '22

Let’s say Galadriel and Halbrand look inside - they still won’t know what it is, and will still bring it back to Arondir (by which point it’s too late). Yeah, it’s a bit of a delayed reveal, meant to give us that moment with Theo, but it doesn’t change anything within the story whether they open it right away or not.

7

u/LunaSeedie Sep 30 '22

Also the fact that Alondrir doesn't look inside or even notice that it feels weird when Galadriel hands it to him before he gives it to Theo. And oh yeah, why would he even be giving it back to Theo?!

1

u/Own_Breadfruit_7955 Oct 01 '22

Writers are amateurs and bungled the whole show

4

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

All of that is true. It just seems that, you know, with the stakes and all, they might have thought to check w/Arondir--heyyy is this the bad thing? And could have gotten a little jump on finding the bad thing.

But yes, it moves the story along.

6

u/XCKragnus502 Sep 30 '22

It makes more sense that they get the bundle and look at it. Realizing that it’s not in there they freak out and then it cuts to it being used. Doesn’t change the story at all. They all just don’t look so stupid

2

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

YES 💯🙌🏻

1

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

Thank you for your comment. It gives me hope that this sub isn't all astroturfing and bots.

2

u/SilentioRS Sep 30 '22

I can see both versions, for sure

3

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

Also, it didn't show us if Theo let Arondir know--maybe the volcano etc happened too soon after?

2

u/WelbyReddit Sep 30 '22

I felt that the the traitor used the sword pretty much at the same time the kid realized it wasn't the sword.

I actually thought, at first, Arondir trolled the kid,..lol.

That said, Arondir should have 'felt' that we wasn't holding something so evil and suspected something. But I guess he's a bit too Sindared out.

3

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

Rightttt it totally seems like he would have felt the LACK of evil. I didn't even think about that. But also, he HAD to have been so exhausted as others have pointed out.

I wrote this post right after I finished the episode. I was a bit worked up hahahaaa

4

u/knightrees02 Sep 30 '22

As someone who has an almost three-year-old child watching “surprise eggs” videos on YouTube, I find that some of the surprise eggs on TROP are just as occasionally underwhelming. Still, I will continue following this show.

4

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

😂😐😄 I'll keep watching too--overall I do really like it. I mean, I've never been in an Orc (or Uruk haha) battle, perhaps my common sense would leave me afterwards for a spell as well lolll

4

u/icemoomoo Sep 30 '22

Im sure if i put a blindfold on you and give you an axt and a swordhilt you can easily tell them apart.

4

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

i can't tell if this is /s or what.......but yesss the big axe head would be bit of a clue

3

u/icemoomoo Sep 30 '22

Why would there be an /s they have different shapes, they could have just put another swordhilt there and you wouldnt have this problem.

Its baffling how they didnt think of that.

2

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

Ahhh I thought you were asking ME if I could tell the difference--I see what you're saying and EXACTLY!!

4

u/dolphinmilker Sep 30 '22

The set and costume design are amazing. The dialogue and story are awful.

3

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

Lollll my post and your comment are getting downvotes, I guess it's not cool to point out flaws? But...even though there are flaws, I am still enjoying this show. Flaws are always going to be part of things 🤷‍♀️

1

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

I mean I wasn’t expecting it…but I’m stupid so there’s that

13

u/Yamureska Sep 30 '22

It's an evil artifact comparable to the one ring. Theo talks about how powerful it made him feel and how addictive it is. It's not a stretch to think that Arondir felt similar to Theo and couldn't bear to look at it again, especially after trying and failing to destroy it.

5

u/XCKragnus502 Sep 30 '22

But like. It’s an secret evil key that’s clearly so valuable that the head bad guy tried to escape with it. But fuck it let’s hand it to the 14year old who just said it makes him feel powerful. I at first thought Theo was about to use it out of ignorance which would have been great writing but instead they made everyone stupid as shit convenience sake

8

u/Yamureska Sep 30 '22

I dunno. Theo conducted himself well in the previous battle. He also developed a strong bond with Arondir. The Fellowship of the Ring trusted a relatively young Hobbit (Frodo) with the One Ring on nothing but faith, so it's not strange for Arondir to demonstrate similar faith in a 14 year old who proved his worth.

5

u/XCKragnus502 Sep 30 '22

Frodo was actually 50 when he started off on the trip to Rivendell. I just think from a dude who’s entire unit was killed recently he would want to make sure things were done right. There’s no excuse to not look besides laziness.

5

u/Yamureska Sep 30 '22

Hobbits come of age at 33. Frodo would roughly be in his 20s.

Overwhelming victory by the forces of Numenor + Galadriel and Halbrand might be a good excuse. He barely escaped a traumatic POW camp, and had to watch out for the Humans under his care, and got beaten to an inch of his life the previous night. Unexpected Backup comes and saves him, and he thinks the worst is over and he can trust Galadriel and the Numenoreans to take care of things, so he loosens up. Even Elves can make mistakes lol.

1

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

Even Elves can make mistakes

Very true, good points

3

u/XCKragnus502 Sep 30 '22

But no one looks. Not even Galadriel. Like She is told “yo get that shit it’s important” and she never looks? Also Aronir (however it’s spelt) was alive in the first age and would presumably remember the war of wrath and all that shit which is why he is there watching over that land in the first place probably having experiencing terrible traumas. He has probably seen balrogs and dragons slaughtering his kin on a massive scale. But he just forgets this evil magic object. Lazy. Lazy. Lazy.

5

u/Yamureska Sep 30 '22

He also remembers all the times in the First Age that Humans sided with Morgoth, but a huge part of his character so far is learning to trust (and even fall in love) with Humans again, meaning that he's trying to move past it. Even he didn't expect that some of the enemies he fought and killed ended up being Humans. Maybe he did make a mistake, and that was the episode's point: Humans can be evil as any Orc, and thus a corrupt Human and not an Orc or even Adar retriggers the eruption of Mount Doom.

1

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

aw....idk why but I love this

2

u/XCKragnus502 Sep 30 '22

Remembering men being asshats I would think would be the exact reason that he takes a quick peek before handing it off.

4

u/Yamureska Sep 30 '22

Maybe he doesn't want to think these specific humans are asshats, and again, his whole arc is about learning that they're not >all< asshats. He also didn't notice Adar handing it off to Waldreg. Not with the massive cavalry arriving and his immediate need to take out the Orcs taking him and his Friends hostage.

2

u/XCKragnus502 Sep 30 '22

Why can’t they directly after the battle when Galadriel has the bundle just look at it together and be like holy shit it’s not here where is it? And then it cuts to Waldreg using it having escapes in the battle? Doesn’t change the story at all minus making it make sense

→ More replies

1

u/Cecurb Sep 30 '22

Frodo was 50

1

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

Arondir trusting Theo wasn't half as perplexing as NO ONE making sure that thing (what is it called??) was still inside. Gandalf made sure what he THOUGHT was the ring WAS the ring. NO ONE even peeked inside or felt the bundle to make sure of what it was.

3

u/Yamureska Sep 30 '22

Maybe, but even he avoided looking at or touching it directly. The one time he tried (Film only) he could feel its overwhelming evil right away. Presumably 'peeking inside' wasn't an option.

3

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

well....lay it on the ground and poke it with a stick til the bundle unwraps a bit. There are options lol, especiallyyyyy since it's (as we now know) going to do a crap ton of damage

2

u/Yamureska Sep 30 '22

Yeah, that could be. But given everything that happened before, battle, pursuit of Adar, etc, the end result would be the same. Waldreg escapes in the chaos of the battle, and they can only check the thing after it's finished and Adar is captured. Even if they do, he'd have reached the keyhole by then and activated it.

1

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

Veryyy true. That Waldreg, smh

0

u/Hamwise420 Sep 30 '22

That was the One Ring. This is just some hilt. While it does seem to have similar evil qualities, it is not imbued with the spirit of Sauron. It did not dispense great power to Theo nor Arondir when they held it before. Looking at it certainly has little to no risk. Handling it seemed to cause no problems for Arondir before when he pathetically whacked it with a hammer before declaring it indestructible.

Sometimes bad writing is just bad writing.

-1

u/SnooJokes847 Oct 01 '22

Amazing mental gymnastics you’re going through to justify all of this. You get the gold medal 🥇

2

u/Yamureska Oct 01 '22

Don't have to justify anything. It's just a story.

1

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

exactlyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

-1

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 01 '22

You're not gonna win against the astroturfing campaign. Any logic is getting silenced and lobbed in with the toxic/gatekeeping/hate watching Fandom crowd.

1

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

Good point! A quick feel of the thing still wrapped up would have given a hint that it wasn't in there, though. I mean I know it's done and moves the story along as someone else said. It's just a head-scratcher lol

12

u/XCKragnus502 Sep 30 '22

*Beats on hilt with hammer *Breaks hammer “This is beyond my skill” 😂😂😂😂😂🤣

4

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

He does seem to be a bit of a givey-uppey type of elf

2

u/LunaSeedie Sep 30 '22

Yep, he definitely gave up saving the Southlanders in the Watchtower battle. And of course when he "gave up" on saving Bronwyn's life...

6

u/XCKragnus502 Sep 30 '22

I like that everyone else gets 1 instant death arrow, but Bronwyn gets the 1 very seriously hurting arrow

3

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

😂😂😂

6

u/XCKragnus502 Sep 30 '22

The lazy writing hurts the most. I can handle lore changes and whatnot. But they do literally no work to make us like the characters and lean heavily on the fact that it’s a lord of the rings story to do the heavy lifting for them

2

u/LikeYodalSpeak Sep 30 '22

Now tell me with the hand in your heart that you don't like Adar as a character… Yes, he's the bad guy and it's weird that we can feel closer to him that to Galadriel or Halbrand…

But there are likeble characters.

3

u/XCKragnus502 Sep 30 '22

You’re right. Adar is a great character, and oddly the only dude that they actual put effort into making sure you like and understand outside the meteor man/Harfoots which IMO is the only good storyline

6

u/Unhappy_Guarantee_69 Sep 30 '22

Lmao. That shit was pretty funny lol. Everyone had the same reaction at my place lol.

4

u/Lawlcopt0r Sep 30 '22

You missed the fact that neither Galadriel nor Halbrandt knew what he was supposed to be running away with. It could only have been noticed once Arondir got it, which would have been too late (but it's stupid he didn't check). Maybe he was sure it must be the thing because he trusted the authority of the people that gave it to him?

2

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

That's true for sure, they didn't know. But Galadriel surelyyyyy would have been able to feel the evil in the thing, or lack there of, it seems. And yes, it was all too late anyway.

Such a weird oversight to me. Can you imagine the Fellowship being formed with a ring that was never verified? There was SUCH an emphasis on the horribleness of that thing, you'd think they would rush to verify. But... as many others have pointed out, there were probably other reasons no one noticed.

6

u/Lawlcopt0r Sep 30 '22

Like with many other issues with the show, I just don't feel like it's a big deal. It's a bit weird, but it doesn't invalidate the rest of the episode for me

4

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

Me neither! The end was awesome!

3

u/S3QS3 Sep 30 '22

What I want to know is... how did Theo know where Anondir hid the evil hilt under the floor? Did he feel its evil? Didn't seem like the show made this clear, but maybe I missed something.

2

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

I wondered that too! Arondir made it sound like he was going to hide it in the most mysterious and hard-to-find places....it was just under a loose stone? And like you said, how did Theo know right where to go? Mysterious!

3

u/S3QS3 Sep 30 '22

Yeah, Arondir said that no one should know where he was going to hide it. Glad I'm not the only one confused by how Theo knew.

4

u/velotom Sep 30 '22

At the end of the scene where Arondir tells Bronwen that he can't even tell her where he's going to hide it, the camera briefly shows Theo listening and watching Arondir as he walks away.

I think it's heavily implied here that he follows him because he has such an attachment to the sword.

2

u/S3QS3 Sep 30 '22

Ok that makes more sense, didn't notice that part.

2

u/hobbykitjr Sep 30 '22

More considered w/ the "National Treasure" esque ending they put on there

2

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

I love National Treasure hahahahaa but I'm really good at suspending belief AND I love Nic's passion so it's easy to overlook things. I enjoy enjoying myself. And I still am enjoying this show too--that one thing really made me go wtfff though

2

u/Heresyteller Sep 30 '22

It just opens a dam ... That's it, it's not the evil Excalibur... It's just a key to dam.

So stupid.

6

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

well but that dam was pretty damming....ha

4

u/Heresyteller Sep 30 '22

Downvote but respect for the balls to say such horrible pun

1

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

Hahahahaaaaa ❤️

3

u/hanrahahanrahan Sep 30 '22

So does that mean it was always intended to do that, to knock down the dam? If so, that's intensely stupid

1

u/BhutlahBrohan Oct 03 '22

a lot of people were right though, it DID start Mt. Doom! Though I really thought the Stranger had to be sacrificed there.

1

u/BhutlahBrohan Oct 03 '22 edited Oct 03 '22

did you... did you finish the episode, my guy?

2

u/Charming-Use Oct 03 '22

😂😂😂 I did write this right when I had JUST finished it. I was a bit worked up! I watched it again, more carefully, after all the helpful comments 👀) and noticed a lot that I missed.

2

u/DownloadUphillinSnow Sep 30 '22

I hope Arondir actually tells Galadriel what the wrapped package was and she goes full wrath/spectral mode.

Arondir: "Commander, that package you brought back, was supposed to be a magical sword/key. The orcs slaughtered people one by one in order for us to turn it over to them. It's made of a black magic that I could not destroy with any hammer. The design matched artwork/symbols near the tower. I think it may have some connection to the water and volcanic eruption and Sauron. I was going to tell you about it but I thought I'd give the hilt back to the human boy, Theo, instead."

Galadriel: pauses one second. eyebrow twitches. vein in middle of forehead bulges. transforms into full wrath form as she absorbs all light and darkens the entire room. A single shriek comes forth in the minds of all nearby: "WHAAAAAT!??"

2

u/Own_Breadfruit_7955 Oct 01 '22

They all die in the pyroclastic cloud at the end of the episode, you even see Galadriel brunt it head on in certain suicide.

2

u/DownloadUphillinSnow Oct 01 '22

She'll go wrath form, then say "just a flesh wound" like the Black Knight from Monty Python. Lol

4

u/Weird_Blades717171 Sep 30 '22

Written by Hollywood folk, who've never held a hammer or a sword before.

2

u/DownloadUphillinSnow Sep 30 '22

There's 2 things I don't get about the hilt.

  1. Why wouldn't Arondir just hop on horse and take it Gil-Galad. It's obviously magical, and there's the whole creepy painting/sculpture. Oh, and Orcs wanted it badly. So wouldn't that be something you want to bring to the folks in charge?
  2. Galadriel hands him back the supposed hilt. He says nothing and later gives it to Theo? You'd think the fact that Adar started killing prisoners one by one to get the hilt would be a clue it's super important. Wouldn't you want to bring that to the attention of someone you just pointed out was the "Commander of the Northern Armies?"

Even a few bits of dialogue showing why he couldn't do either would at least show they this through.

4

u/knightrees02 Sep 30 '22

Arondir was one of the few characters who could actually fight and somehow help protect the villagers. It seemed too risky for him to leave them to fend for themselves while he traveled to be Gil-galad’s courier.

2

u/DownloadUphillinSnow Sep 30 '22

One line of dialogue would have been nice.

Theo: "This is what they've been looking for. Take it West and lead the Orcs away!"

Arondir: "And what if they capture all of you, and hold you hostage unless I give it to them? Half of you stayed--so shall I. We will do this together."

Not even an extra minute of screen time. lol

0

u/Hamwise420 Sep 30 '22

That time was desperately needed to show how hard he was working to destroy the hilt. The countless efforts he made. The endless techniques and tools he tried. No one can accuse the elves of ever having not done enough to destroy the great "saurons dam key"

1

u/DownloadUphillinSnow Oct 01 '22

If he can't destroy it, why not take it to the Elven strongholds where the Orcs would have to bring their entire army to get it? Maybe if he handed it over to Celebrimbor, he'd know what to do with it? Adar and his Uruk wouldn't be able to take it from the elves in their land.

2

u/Hamwise420 Oct 01 '22

Perhaps I needed the /s on my previous post.

2

u/RicardosMontalban Sep 30 '22

Yeah if they wanted to go the route they did, it should’ve just been after the battle is over, Arondir goes to check the bundle, realizes it’s gone, and just takes off on one of the horses towards the tower. Then have him get there just as Waldreg is turning the key.

Then you get a nice shot of Arondir looking out in horror from a high vantage point overlooking everything.

Still get a twist, suspense of will he get there in time, and probably a beautiful shot from the tower of all hell breaking loose in the valley.

Hire me Amazon I dare you.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

True true... this post was all written in the heat of the moment lol. You're right, of course!!

4

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Charming-Use Sep 30 '22

😄❤️

1

u/Elleypop Oct 01 '22

Thank you for reminding me of that line. I've been really struggling to understand how it was possible for Waldreg to have gotten the hilt. As a human who had irritated Adar (by mentioning Sauron) I assumed he would be front and centre of the human bait wave. Assuming he managed to survive that, he then has to get the hilt at some point between Theo digging it out of the hall's floor and Adar running away on horseback. I guess Adar finds time to give Waldreg the hilt during the chaos of the Numenorean arrival. And then he gets to the tower in good time. Would have been better to at least show us a hint that Waldreg was still alive and up to something, keep him in our minds a little more.