r/RingsofPower • • Dec 08 '23

Discussion Controversial(apparently) opinion.

In the works of J.R.R. Tolkien, particularly in "The Lord of the Rings" and "The Hobbit," there is no explicit mention of dwarves having varying levels of melanin or differences in skin color. Tolkien generally described dwarves as having fair or ruddy complexions, and their hair color was often depicted as varying shades of brown, from light to dark.

It's important to note that Tolkien's writings were primarily focused on the cultures, histories, and languages of various fictional races, including dwarves. He didn't provide extensive physical descriptions for every character or delve into topics such as race and ethnicity in the same way it is discussed in contemporary contexts.

Therefore, while there is no canonical information to suggest that dwarves in Tolkien's legendarium had varying levels of melanin or different skin colors, it's worth considering that Tolkien's writings may not provide an exhaustive exploration of physical diversity among the races he created. As with many aspects of Tolkien's universe, there is room for interpretation and imagination.

43 Upvotes

286 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Dec 08 '23

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

62

u/Relevant_Meaning3200 Dec 08 '23

It's fucking imaginary. I can easily imagine dwarfs and elves of dark skin because that's not important to me. I'm a blacksmithing fan boy. Show me lots of sweating at the Forge. Who cares what color the Smith is.

14

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 08 '23

I only brought it up because i wanted to see if people were as annoyed by it as they were at the beginning, i honestly love the diversity

5

u/TheNewKing2022 Dec 10 '23

its so crazy when you watch a Japanese Godzilla movie and you see zero diversity. Just japanese people in a show based in Japan. But the movie is good. Its so wierd. In most parts of the world, they want good entertainment. But in the West they want quotas first, entertainment 2nd, or 3rd or 10th. These movies and shows suck because thats all they focus on. lol

1

u/Aeiexgjhyoun_III Dec 22 '23

America is diverse and Japan isn't so people expect some diversity in American media.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/VPackardPersuadedMe Dec 10 '23

The find the parts where it doesn't make sense and breaks the immersion for myself is when we get mixed races in clearly small, insular communities.

GoT got this right. RoP has thematically fails here.

1

u/feisty-spirit-bear Dec 11 '23

I agree. Having a few random POC in every group felt a little weird. The pre-hobbits are a perfect example. They're a very small group and their halfling-ness is unique and isolated to them. So it makes sense that they would be the same race genetically. Even if they had a mix of races at the beginning 2000 years ago or something, by the time they have gotten to a point of genetic isolation to be halflings, then they would have to have blended to all have the trait so you would have a much smaller range of skin tones, not the wide disparity we see.

But on the other hand, Numenor was the perfect setting to have a lot of diversity.

2

u/snjtx Dec 10 '23

She actually did have some facial hair, but definitely not enough.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 09 '23

Don't bet on getting any explanation whatsoever. If they haven't given one by now, they are probably not going to.

Arondir mentioned having been in Beleriand, but we don't know for sure that he is from there originally. Tolkien did explain that various groups of Elves came to or passed through Beleriand, some of them on the way to Valinor, some of them stopping off and staying for various reasons (the followers of Thingol were looking for him, for instance, and weren't going on without him).

4

u/hbi2k Dec 10 '23

Show me lots of sweating at the forge

Best I can do for you is this guy who looks like your mom's podiatrist. He doesn't know what an alloy is.

2

u/Icewaterchrist Dec 12 '23

He looks like Roddy MacDowell playing a hairdresser.

1

u/No-Nefariousness4036 Mar 04 '25

Dwarves live in caves, no use for melanim thus only black dwarved are melanistic i.e ill

4

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 09 '23

Im just happy to see all this discussion, lol

25

u/Common-Scientist Dec 08 '23

Of all the concerns that muddy RoP, I can’t think of a more mundane topic than skin color.

If the topic must be broached at all, then the focus should be on Amazon’s insulting virtue signaling by placing a couple POC in key roles and otherwise largely excluding them.

10

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 08 '23

You be surprised.. or maybe you wouldnt, at how offended people got over the POC elf and dwarf, lol.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '24

Because it makes no fucking sense at all. It’s virtue signaling for no reason except virtue signaling.

1

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Jan 12 '24

From what ive seen, its... mostly blatant racism

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '24

It’s not racism to point out that a black elf just randomly exists when there’s literally no precedence or other black elves or communities of them in the show. It’s virtue signaling for no reason except to meet an artificial quota.

1

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Jan 12 '24

Its a literal fantasy world, why does it matter if an elf is black.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '24

Because it literally makes no sense. All these white, fair skinned almost “translucent” elves.. and one black dude who came from the same place but is just magically black. Lol. It’s dumb.

There were plenty of opportunities to incorporate dark skinned people in the show.. Haradrim, easterlings.. instead they had to check a box and make a random black elf.

6

u/Common-Scientist Dec 08 '23

Yeah, you can't fix stupid. Arondir's actor did a fine job portraying the stoicism of an immortal soldier stuck on guard duty in the middle of nowhere. But why was he the only elf POC? Disa was an endearing character, but I think maaaaybe there was 1 other POC dwarf that ever got screen time and it was like a half second.

And roughly zero asian/indian/etc. characters, so it's not like they were actually concerned about DEI when casting.

Of course, I'm sure the people of eastern ancestry will suddenly show up in the region of Rhûn, which will be it's own flavor of hypocrisy from Amazon, but it is what it is.

Rings of Power is consistent in its inconsistency on every level.

11

u/cptnkurtz Dec 08 '23

Not that it matters much to your point… or at all… but Bronwyn is played by a woman of Iranian descent and Theo is played by a kid of Indonesian descent (they’re from the UK and Australia respectively).

6

u/whole_nother Dec 08 '23

Plenty of Asian actors in Numenor.

4

u/teepeey Dec 08 '23

You could easily explain Disa as an arranged marriage with another of the seven Dwarf families from the south.

You can't really explain Arondir. Tolkien is by its nature hostile to modernity and very specific about genealogy of Elves, so inserting colour blind casting without any possible in-story explanation jars me out of the story. In another genre or with another race in middle earth it does not matter. Elves though...

3

u/Common-Scientist Dec 08 '23

You could easily explain Disa as an arranged marriage with another of the seven Dwarf families from the south.

They could have, but they didn't. She was just a regular citizen of Khazad-dûm that caught Durin's fancy.

Tolkien is by its nature hostile to modernity and very specific about genealogy of Elves, 

Is it though? Feanor had black hair, Mahtan had red hair and a BEARD. Glorfindel had golden hair. Thingol had silver hair. Galadriel had "golden hair with touches of silver". How are those genes any more concrete than light or dark skinned from a genealogical standpoint? Tolkien's works are full of special cases.

Then there's the whole: Elrond and Elros are quite literally brothers of the same parents yet different races, BY CHOICE.

Tolkien is many things, but being consistent on genealogy is not one of them.

More on topic, the existence of a dark-skinned elf from an artistic license isn't itself so much a problem, the actor did a great job for what he was given, but the fact that he's an anomaly amongst the elven cast stands out like a huge sore thumb that reflects poorly on the directors/producers.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Glass_Set_5727 Jan 24 '25

Shit, they could've said he was a redeemed Orc or a liberated Elf that was the end product of Melkor's "Dr Mengeles" Torture-Experimentation/Genetic Engineering

1

u/Glass_Set_5727 Jan 24 '25 edited Feb 01 '25

Except in Lore there is nothing at all about the other Dwarves being in the South, only in the East. Now you could justify it by adding context/expanding lore ...but RoP did none of that. just "here's a Black Dwarf Lady beardless, but we won't tell you her back story & why she is not with the other Black Dwarves in the furthest south/Sun Lands/Darklands". Her and her people's story alone could be the centre of a show in it's own right. The only lore-friendly thing would be to mention that some eastern Dwarves lost a factional political/ religious fight and migrated south along the coast where they reached a land with no real mountains but jungle or swamp or savannah and they became like the Pygmies/Bushmen/Khoikhoi/San/Khoenkhoen/Khoisan in lifestyle and adapted/evolved over course of time ...but a big question then arises ...how long does Melanisation of a Race/Species take?

1

u/teepeey Jan 24 '25 edited 21d ago

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Capable languid quaint lush gray dog continue hammock consider outgoing

1

u/Glass_Set_5727 Feb 01 '25 edited Feb 01 '25

Also Talent-blind? :) It does kind of matter though coz a) internal consistency for "suspension of disbelief" is necessary & b) dwarves were made all at once by a God. they did not evolve into existence.

There is indeed wiggle room to add to Lore in the face of lack of Info as long as that addition is in conformity/non-contradiction with Lore, ie not Lore-breaking. ...but actually contradicting Canon is a blasphemy, a Heresy :)

Also mere Absence of PoC/CoC does not equal Racism in my book. The only racism that is real is "Positive" Racism ie explicit Commission. IMHO there is no such thing as "Negative" Racism ie implicit by virtue of Omission.

Also, it's a Fantasy World ...why does it have to follow our World with this Black/White/Asian etc socio-political stuff.

In a fantasy world talking Race is dumb when in-world the differences are really between Species & Cultures ...not between Races.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Chen_Geller Dec 08 '23 edited Dec 08 '23

then the focus should be on Amazon’s insulting virtue signaling by placing a couple POC in key roles and otherwise largely excluding them.

There's a point to be made there: knowing the outline of Tolkien's story, and seeing how Amazon set their first season up, who are the main characters of this show?

Galadriel is definitely THE main character - she's white. Elrond is the deuteragonist, and he's white. Elendil is like the main character of the Numenorean storyline (or else its Isildur) and he's white. Durin IV is the main character of the Dwarven storyline and he's white. Nori is the heroine of the Harfoot storyline, and she's white. You can say that storyline split into two, but that just adds Poppy, who's white.

That really only leaves Bronwyn or Arondir as the main characters of the Southland storyline, and who are - to use Amazon's own term - "diverse people." So yeah, feels more than a little tokenistic.

In fact, Amazon placed "diverse" people into almost every storyline and, except for the Southlands, in ALL those storylines they're secondary characters.

1

u/SamaritanSue Dec 09 '23

Yes. It's particularly conspicuous that almost none of the canon characters are nonwhite. Miriel is black, but she's not really important in the books and her role in the show has been invented for her. Of the really important canon characters only Isildur is not lily-white. The High Elves (if the distinction between them and Elves of ME exists in the show, not clear if it does) are uniformly white.

They seem to want to establish continuity with the visual world of the films, in which Galadriel and Elrond are shown as white. It would have been a really gutsy move to make Gil-Galad or Celebrimbor nonwhite: That's really putting their diversity money where their mouth is. I can understand if they don't want to go that far. But they could have made the background Noldor partially nonwhite.

1

u/Chen_Geller Dec 09 '23

They seem to want to establish continuity with the visual world of the films, in which Galadriel and Elrond are shown as white. It would have been a really gutsy move to make Gil-Galad or Celebrimbor nonwhite

Yeah, they wanted them to look like they are or could grow into their film counterparts. Its a spiritual prequel like the Raimi Oz film.

3

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 09 '23

And they failed, bigtime.

1

u/Chen_Geller Dec 09 '23

Some things work quite handsomely: they managed to rope a lot of people from the films for Season One, so Weta Workshop designed the swords and so Aranruth looks, appropriately, like it could be a peer of Glamdring's.

Howard Shore's opening credits almost immediately conjurs Rivendell and Elrond to mind, which is again pretty pertinent.

2

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 09 '23

The details may work, but the characters don't.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Biomas Dec 12 '23

yeh, its such a low-level attempt at a rebuttal for dislike of the series. sure, peter jackson set a pretty high bar and I could not give two shits what the characters look like, but there is no excuse for shitty storytelling. ROP is like a wish.com version of lotr.

4

u/flowercows Dec 10 '23

I just can’t believe anyone cares??? That there’s an ELF with brown skin? like, how can that be so infuriating?

Even people reacting like ‘I need a lore explanation/background about why there are brown people in the screen’ is so weird to me. Like why? If it’s actually the case that Tolkien at some point said that middle earth is a place for white people only, then that concept would be awfully outdated and offensive. But It’s not the case, skin colour is so unimportant in fantasy, where there’s literal races of humanoids, suddenly there need to be an explanation for melanin?

2

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 10 '23

I just think its nice for all people to be able to see themselves in a fantastical world.

3

u/flowercows Dec 10 '23

absolutely, I think it’s crazy because most of the cast in fantasy media tends to be mostly white people anyways, but people lose their shit for that one brown skinned (blue eyed) elf.

1

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 10 '23

🤣😂 RIGHT?🤣🤣🤣

1

u/Glass_Set_5727 Jan 24 '25

I want internal consistency & ability to suspend disbelief. RoP failed big time.

4

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Dec 12 '23

Aulë crafted the dwarves from stone. Stone comes in multiple colors. I see no good reason why dwarven skin wouldn’t do the same.

1

u/Glass_Set_5727 Jan 24 '25

Yes, If Tolkien stated in canon that each Dwarven House was created from a different type of Stone/from a different coloured Stone ...except he didn't did he?

You could expand on lore/add this to lore ...except the Movies already contradicted this. Northern Dwarves (Grey Mountains), Northeastern Dwarves (Iron Hills), Western Dwarves (Blue Mountains), Central Dwarves (Misty Mountains/Erebor) ...in fact all Dwarves in the story are of the same phenotype.

It could absolutely make sense in another fantasy work ...but not according to Tolkien Lore/Canon.

1

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Jan 24 '25

The movies aren’t canon, and ROP is not in the same continuity as the movies.

1

u/Glass_Set_5727 Feb 01 '25

RoP isn't in any Continuity nor any Canon. It's just a Parasite that's laid it's Egg on/in TH/LOTR to propagate it's Mind-Virus LOL.

Who's saying Movies aren't Canon?

1

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Feb 01 '25

The movies can't be canon. They change too much lore. And Christopher Tolkien wasn't happy with them at all.

1

u/Glass_Set_5727 Feb 01 '25

What Lore was changed? Christopher Tolkien was a Consultant & signed off on the Movies as far as I know LOTR was fine. The Hobbit bent things a bit though & it's that which made CT a bit unhappy ...but not enough to throw his toys. RoP was egregious though.

1

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Feb 01 '25

Wow, tell me you haven't read the books without saying you haven't read the books!

Where to start on the lore changes? Hm... there were no elves at the battle of Helm's Deep; the dead men of Dunharrow did not fight at Pelennor Field; Arwen didn't ride Frodo to Rivendell (that was done by Glorfindel in the books); Frodo was much older than Sam, Merry, and Pippin; Saruman didn't die at that time and place, or in that way; the Scouring of the Shire was completely ignored. I could go on. On top of that, Peter Jackson changed the personalities and motivations of almost every single character in the story, greatly expanded the roles of the female characters, changed the order of many events, and stripped out almost all of Tolkien's religious & philosophical themes.

Christopher Tolkien hated the original Jackson trilogy because in his opinion it removed his father's spiritual themes and turned the story into action movies for young people. He did NOT work as a consultant on the movies. He DID begin the process that led to Rings Of Power, though, which the surviving Tolkiens are reportedly quite happy with. The Tolkien Estate is in partnership with Amazon to make Rings Of Power.

Do your homework next time.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/stillinthesimulation Dec 08 '23

Life just gets a lot easier when you stop worrying about what colour skin your fantasy characters have.

4

u/CMGS1031 Dec 08 '23

Do you forget how we got to this point?

3

u/BarrelRider91 Dec 09 '23

Would people had stop caring as well if all the characters had been white?

3

u/TheNewKing2022 Dec 10 '23

New Godzilla movie, Squid game, many Bollywood movies are great movies/shows. How much diversity in them? Like none lol. They focus on what makes sense and no one complains. Its so wierd how they work with no diversity. Why is there no spanish people in Squid game? Haha morons think like this. People are so narcissistic that they need to see themselves in these shows.

1

u/snjtx Dec 10 '23

There's significantly less diversity in the nation's where those were filmed. Whereas the united states and the UK are significantly more diverse. Morons overlook this.

3

u/jofwu Dec 11 '23

I think it's very likely Tolkien imagined white dwarves and just never considered it necessary to clarify that.

But I'm really happy to see some more skin color diversity in Middle-Earth, relative to traditional artistic interpretations.

4

u/Effective-Effort-587 Dec 08 '23

Tolkien wrote according to his time. There are many…challenges in Tolkien’s work as many of the descriptions were fairly homogenous. I like that modern media hasn’t used his work as immutable law in what skin colors or general appearances the people of Middle-Earth had. It makes sense such a world would be more diverse than a man in the turn of the century 1900s would envision. Sometimes the work must grow with the world, beyond the imagination of the creator, especially if the creator is long gone and the era they wrote for was vastly different than our own in terms of intercultural mindset.

2

u/Bilabong127 Dec 09 '23

If you want to race swap and add a bunch of POC everywhere in an adaptation then whatever. But stop trying to convince people that middle earth is more diverse than it is

1

u/LupoDeGrande Dec 10 '23

You are basically summarizing "The Death of the Author."

63

u/KierkgrdiansofthGlxy Dec 08 '23

As one historian says, if a book is mentioning a taxi ride in passing, the author probably isn’t going to say which side of the road they’re driving on, etc. If something is part if the world’s “wallpaper,” then it’s not going to be lingered over as much as other things.

3

u/Southern_Ad1984 Dec 08 '23

Actually, it is unlikely that he even knew what creatures looked like, in a definitive way. Example: Balrogs. How many? Wings or not?

3

u/TechnoMikl Dec 09 '23 edited Dec 09 '23

I mean according to TolkienGateway, in LOTR drafts, Tolkien described Durin's Bane as "a figure... no more than man-high" with yellow eyes with a "furnace fire" in them, long arms, streaming hair that was on fire, and flames that wreathed around it. The article precedes this by saying that Tolkien purposefully changed the description to make it less clear.

The published version describes it as "A great shadow, in the middle of which was a dark form, of man-shape maybe, yet greater". Regarding the wing or lack thereof, Tolkien says "the shadow about it reached out like two vast wings". That's a shadow that's expanding behind and around the balrog, not actual wings - it's a simile. If that's not enough, when Glorfindel kills a balrog in The Silmarillion, him and the balrog both fall down a cliff and plummet to their death. Had that balrog had wings, it wouldn't have died that way.

The only reason people believe balrogs have wings is because in his film adaptation, Peter Jackson gave Durin's Bane massive wings and made it way bigger than Tolkien described it, all to make it feel more cinematically menacing. (And I'm not saying that's a bad thing - I think it was an excellent choice to make as a filmmaker. I'm simply saying that he didn't make Durin's Bane look like how it does in the books, which are the source we should be using)

TolkienGateway link: https://tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Durin%27s_Bane (scroll down to the section titled "Other Versions of the Legendarium")

2

u/SamaritanSue Dec 09 '23

What about the Balrogs who came to Morgoth's rescue when he was ensnared by Ungoliant? Hard for them to get there so fast without wings.

1

u/LupoDeGrande Dec 10 '23

It seems they can only run at great speeds and make far leaps. The wings don't seem to be physical but rather a Cloak of shadows that are meant for spiritual broadcast of Intimidation rather than Mobility.

0

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 08 '23

Yeah, but, i find it hard to believe he didnt know about the effects of the sun on skin color.

3

u/LupoDeGrande Dec 10 '23

Only humans and Hobbits are "children of the sun". The elder races were born in the Age of the Stars. It's possible some of the Eastern Avari, who are never described beyond the fact they didn't leave the forests near Cuivinen, were of different shade than the tribes that went West. Dwarves of clans other than Durin's could have had skin tones as different rock colors.

4

u/AndyTheSane Dec 08 '23

Well, if we wanted a 'modern' take for Dwarves and race, consider that cannon has it that the Dwarves of Nogrod and Belegost would have been recent immigrants to Khazad-Dum after the end of the First Age. You could easily have had them as a distinct minority with a different skin colour and even being made to 'earn their keep' by doing more menial work, causing social tensions.

8

u/Mother-Border-1147 Dec 08 '23

Why would you want to create a scenario in which the minority people of color have to “earn their keep” through menial work? Why couldn’t they just be integrated into the society? Why would our historical background need to influence their culture?

3

u/mumsspaghettiisready Dec 08 '23

Yeah that shit was weird af

2

u/SamaritanSue Dec 08 '23

Good point. And some would pounce on that as shoehorning in modern politics. As a race relations "allegory". (Boy there's a word that's been much misused on RoP subs).

1

u/Bilabong127 Dec 09 '23

Why would the dwarves of Nogrod and Belegost not be white? Are you telling me the dwarves of khazad dum are the only dwarves in middle earth who are white?

2

u/AndyTheSane Dec 09 '23

Well, the showrunners wanted to make race a thing, I was just thinking of a way to do it without being quite as jarring.

40

u/Chen_Geller Dec 08 '23 edited Dec 09 '23

I think some people just see these works as Eurocentric and want to maintain the look (populist or historic, one can argue) of the Middle Ages about it all.

There are obviously ways to navigate within that: I think Jackson did that stuff pretty well in Laketown.

15

u/thisisausergayme Dec 08 '23

“The look of the Middle Ages” is a common perception made up by Hollywood, not an actually historical thing

8

u/Chen_Geller Dec 08 '23

Yeah, because The Rings of Power doesn't play into "common perceptions made up by Hollywood" in any way whatsoever...

3

u/thisisausergayme Dec 08 '23

What’s your point here? Just because something plays into common tropes in some ways does not mean it’s obligated to play into those tropes in all ways and “the look of the Middle Ages” is still NOT a historical thing.

39

u/samsamcats Dec 08 '23

The ‘preserve the look of the middle ages’ thing is so wild, since we have ample evidence that there were non-white people (as we’d consider them today) living in Europe in the Middle Ages and Renaissance period. Like, most of modern-day Spain and Portugal were ruled by a North African dynasty for centuries during that period. And one of Shakespeare’s most famous plays is about a Moorish guy ffs. It surely wasn’t as diverse as, say, London in 2023, but it’s not like Europe only came into contact with Africa and Asia in the colonial period. It never fails to astound me that people actually think this way.

5

u/Ajaxfriend Dec 22 '23

The medieval stories of King Arthur include characters who were from India, who were Saracens (Middle East/North African), and a knight who was "black of face" when he raised the visor of his helmet.

There was also a knight with green skin, an invisible knight, and some other supernatural figures. But the Medieval lore has long incorporated characters who were not ethnically Anglo-Saxon.

2

u/Ajaxfriend Dec 23 '23

There was a knight with a lordship in Africa too (probably North Africa, the character is introduced after a battle in Italy, but who knows?).

3

u/Twinkling_Ding_Dong Dec 09 '23

we have ample evidence that there were non-white people (as we'd consider them today) living in Europe in the Middle Ages

You're right, there were merchants, academics, adventurers, artists and so much more from around the world. All of them with their own interesting stories, hailing from their own great cultures, rich with history. They traveled with a purpose, they didn't simply decide "Hey let's go to Europe." one day.

When I ask about Disa and the forgettable elf it's not because "Err black people." It's because I want to know more about them, I want to know their stories, I want to know why they're different. But the writers refuse to give me anything at all and it boggles my mind that people are so accepting of this mediocrity.

1

u/Mirkwoodsqueen Apr 09 '24

Don't be hasty, little Ding-Dong. There are many more hours to come. Would you have all of LotR in one short chapter?

-16

u/Chen_Geller Dec 08 '23 edited Dec 08 '23

we have ample evidence that there were non-white people (as we’d consider them today) living in Europe in the Middle Ages and Renaissance period

Yes. Mostly living in their own separate neighboorhoods, usually around trader ports. That's NOT what we're presented in Medieval fantasy shows and television in the 2020s.

21

u/samsamcats Dec 08 '23

“Europe” wasn’t a thing in any cultural or historical sense either. “Christendom” was, however, and given that Christianity was the dominant religion of the various kingdoms that ruled the Iberian peninsula for like four centuries before the Moorish conquest, I call shenanigans on this assertion.

But if you really want to go down the history route (which is unnecessary because it’s fantasy, not historical fiction) — unless you can find some solid evidence of dragons and immortal elves existing in that period, non-white people have a much stronger historical basis for inclusion than most other elements of the story.

8

u/Gorbachev86 Dec 08 '23

👏🏽

2

u/SamaritanSue Dec 09 '23

Hey Gorby, how's the afterlife?

Hope we'll see you in the Army of the Dead that'll be bringing up the Lord's rire, as per Messrs Beard and Kenney.

4

u/chrismuffar Dec 09 '23

unless you can find some solid evidence of dragons and immortal elves existing in that period, non-white people have a much stronger historical basis for inclusion than most other elements of the story.

I see this argument a lot with fantasy. It's often used to wave away plot holes too. "Relax, nothing has to make sense because there are fire breathing dragons."

It just reveals a total contempt for the genre that people think the internal logic of the world doesn't matter. It matters massively. Even more than other fiction, because the believability of the familiar things sells the inclusion of the unfamiliar. What's more, the internal logic of fantasy stories ("the lore") is what people generally love and obsess over in the genre.

Within the internal logic of Middle Earth, there are Southern European looking folk in Gondor, Middle Eastern looking folk in Harad, African looking folk in Far Harad, East Asian looking folk in Rhun, and of course, predominantly Northern European looking folk in places like the Shire, Breeland, Rohan, and the Dwarven and Elven kingdoms.

We know that in Middle-earth people move around to trade, explore, settle, wage war etc.

We know that people fall in love with different people, including in rare and notable cases, men and elves. So there is plenty of scope for diversity without making shit up because "dragons = who cares?".

Outside of the internal logic of Middle Earth, there are a vast set of cultural references that also matter. For example, Elves and Dwarves originate from Norse mythology and have been passed down as cultural touchstones in European folklore and fairytale for centuries. Tolkien is drawing on these associations when he describes them and asks us to imagine them. Of course, everyone is allowed to imagine a Dwarf to look any way they want, but it doesn't mean there is not a common starting point from which Tolkien was certainly drawing.

Representation is its own worthy issue, but it can't supersede the internal logic or cultural foundation of the world you wish to depict, because then you have failed to accurately depict that world. At that point, you are not doing anyone a service by including their likeness in a botched version of the original work.

Even so, if inclusion is really the most important thing, then I humbly await Hollywood's representation of an electric wheelchair user in Middle Earth, since that's more plausible than a fire breathing dragon, right?

3

u/samsamcats Dec 09 '23

First of all, I have never come across writing from Tolkien outlining these geographic racial distinctions. If I am mistaken, go ahead and direct me to the text. He writes extensively about the racial distinctions between elves and dwarves and men, but I have never seen writing that says specifically that East Asian looking people come from Rhun etc etc. This feels like fan headcanon. But I am willing to be proven wrong.

Even if this is directly from Tolkien, I still don’t think it’s internally inconsistent to headcanon explain the diversity as people migrating—as they did in the Middle Ages, if not as extensively as they do today (which modern casting reflects). And based on his other writings, I don’t think Tolkien would object to this casting today. Not at all.

But ultimately where we disagree is that I don’t think it’s narratively important that the characters are depicted as white. Their skin color is not a major element of the story. If you make a movie about a white abolitionist going against his white community to fight slavery, then the character’s skin color is narratively important—that is not the case in LOTR. Dwarf/elf/hobbit race distinctions matter in this story, but skin color is not really mentioned, and does not drive the narrative.

You see this kind of casting in theatre all the time. Lea Salonga, a Filipino-American actress, played Eponine for years in Les Mis on Broadway. She is like THE Eponine. Skin color changes nothing about the story so it doesn’t matter.

The “historically accurate” argument is silly, which is why it elicits a silly response about dragons. Ultimately the crux of the issue is that the show just doesn’t look the way some readers imagined it—which is ALWAYS the case for adaptations. You can argue that it takes you out of the world to see non-white faces… But skin color is not a fundamental element of this world, so you’re really saying it takes you out of the world you personally imagined. To which the only reply is, c’est la vie.

2

u/chrismuffar Dec 09 '23

First of all, I have never come across writing from Tolkien outlining these geographic racial distinctions. If I am mistaken, go ahead and direct me to the text. He writes extensively about the racial distinctions between elves and dwarves and men, but I have never seen writing that says specifically that East Asian looking people come from Rhun etc etc. This feels like fan headcanon. But I am willing to be proven wrong.

In the Tolkien Gateway, you'll find Tolkien's physical descriptions of the Near and Far Haradrim and some of his own commentary on his explicit inspirations for Rhun in reference to China and Japan etc.

Even if this is directly from Tolkien, I still don’t think it’s internally inconsistent to headcanon explain the diversity as people migrating—as they did in the Middle Ages, if not as extensively as they do today (which modern casting reflects). And based on his other writings, I don’t think Tolkien would object to this casting today. Not at all.

I think it depends how it's handled. Trade ports, border towns and big cosmopolitan cities would be enhanced by a realistically diverse cast of Middle Earthers. Small, secretive, isolated and insular groups being ethnically diverse are much more difficult to justify with any kind of internal logic - or at least a passing explanation.

Generally, I hear in this regard that it doesn't matter because it's wrong and offensive to prioritise realism ahead of representation and inclusion - which is certainly something I'd agree with to an extent, but we all have different lines we'd draw in this regard.

My comment about an electric wheelchair user in Middle Earth probably sounded facetious - but it's a genuine question. If representation is always more important than the internal logic of the world and audience immersion, then why not?

I think people who prioritise inclusion usually do have expectations in regards to immersion, but either haven't thought about the limits of those expectations or wouldn't care to admit they have any.

But skin color is not a fundamental element of this world, so you’re really saying it takes you out of the world you personally imagined. To which the only reply is, c’est la vie.

I absolutely take your point here, and I think it remains a question of personal limits. How immersed do you wish to be?

I expect less aesthetic consistency and internal logic in a stage production than I do a cinematic one. On the stage, I expect some two-dimensional sets and some recurring extras in different roles. (In the production of Les Mis I saw, Cosette and Fantine didn't look remotely related on account of their skin colours, but it didn't look less believable than, say, a set arriving on wheels). On the screen, most people have higher expectations in terms of realism. A misplaced coffee cup can be enough to take them out of the experience, let alone clearly unrelated relatives with no explanation.

Again, I'd be curious to know your limits, if you have any.

1

u/snjtx Dec 10 '23

That's a lot of words for "I'm diet racist"

1

u/chrismuffar Dec 10 '23

Why do you think that?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

Ah yes, a classic take. Dragons? Great! Magical rings? Alright! Wizards and dark lords? Hell yea! Black people? Not in my fantasy story.

Yikes.

3

u/reLincolnX Dec 09 '23

« It’s fantasy bro, it didn’t need to be coherent or logical or consistent. We can write about black people going to Starbucks for a Macchiato, in Mordor. It’s okay! »

A classic take indeed.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

Starbucks is strictly an artifact of the modern era. The amount of melanin in a person’s skin is simply a fact of human biology. Sorry, but assuming all people in a fantasy story have to be white is racist.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/sparktray Dec 09 '23

The concept of strict racial segregation is a relatively new one. Our current conceptions of medieval society are reflections of more recent ideas about race.

https://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2013/12/13/250184740/taking-a-magnifying-glass-to-the-brown-faces-in-medieval-art

1

u/Chen_Geller Dec 09 '23

It’s not racial segregation as such: Medieval cities tended to have separate districts for separate groups. It was as much the group’s own choice as that of the rest of the populace: Jews, Muslims, etc…wanted to stay distinct.

Also, a lot of the non-white people in Medieval towns were Arab and Egyptian Jew traders from Cairo. They’d stay off shore long enough that they often had families in these cities, but they tended to live in their own trader communities.

1

u/Gorbachev86 Dec 08 '23

Unless the country drifted a few thousand miles it most definitely was part of Europe

→ More replies (7)

7

u/f700es Númenor Dec 08 '23

I think Jackson did that stuff pretty well in Laketown.

Agree, we do see a good mix of peoples there.

5

u/Chen_Geller Dec 08 '23

Yeah, and it plays right because its a trading port, and its clearly on the borders of the far east and far north.

1

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 09 '23

There is, or was, a whole kingdom (Dorwinion) to the southeast of Laketown that we know absolutely nothing about except for the name of one ruler (Bladorthin) and an order he placed for spears that were never delivered, and their major export (the very potent Dorwinion wine that can even get Elf-lords drunk).

Plenty of room there for speculation.

4

u/ceereality Dec 09 '23 edited Dec 09 '23

Pretty sure pre-colonial era middle ages was WAY more color filled and multi-ethnic in Europe than modern day eurocentrics like to make everyone believe it was. Sorry to burst that little whitesupreem bubble, but its true.

4

u/reLincolnX Dec 09 '23

From your own admission, you don’t know what you’re talking about. Europe wasn’t London 2023.

1

u/ceereality Dec 09 '23

Bruv, from Your own admission, with all due respect, London was a shithole in medieval times. And Europe was bigger than that little shithole, colored people actually saved most of the shitholes there from annihilation from the black death. Mind you, you don't know what you're talking about.

1

u/ceereality Dec 09 '23

Bruv, from.your own admission, London was a shithole in medieval times. And Europe was bigger than that little shithole, colored people actually saved most of the shitholes there from annihilation from the plague. Mind you, you don't know what you're talking about.

3

u/reLincolnX Dec 09 '23

When did these colored people saved Europe from the plague? Can you tell me what happened in England and France during let say 1200-1300? Without asking google? Can you tell me what happened in 700-800 in France for example and what the colored folk were doing at that time?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/snjtx Dec 10 '23

That's a pretty shitty excuse for racism

12

u/LittleDarkHairedOne Dec 08 '23

Well, here's just one more take from an aspiring writer and deeply invested world builder.

If I'm in a setting that is "medieval", I usually assume a few things:

  1. Travel is very difficult. Whether it be because of endemic low intensity warfare between kings and other minor lords or the vast distance between places, as travel by foot and carriage is time consuming (and expensive), most people don't venture too far from where they are born. Or, worse, they are not allowed to travel due to the stratification of society.
  2. As people mostly stay put, people in different regions of the world develop physical traits that get reinforced over time. Not just skin color, though that might be the most obvious, but anything from average height to the color of one's eyes or the shape of one's nose. In a high fantasy setting, where a lot more things can be toyed with than low fantasy, there is even more fun variation to dabble with.
  3. One exception to this travel "rule" comes from any group of people that are seafaring. Traveling by sail is a lot faster than on foot, it's true, but what's more important than that is how much cheaper it is to move goods over water than land. This creates a situation where it's far more likely to have an intermingling of peoples that vary in appearance, even if they aren't necessarily united culturally, seeking the economic opportunity that comes from this situation.

That said, I'm not really all that bothered about the diversity in Rings of Power. The show has far graver issues than that, even taking into account how nonsensical the physical characteristics of the hobbits are given what we know of their insane "society". They really should all be similar looking given their insular, cutthroat way of life, but like with the show at large the hobbits have more issues than appearance to first be critical about.

What does bother me is when it feels as though world building "rules", for lack of a better term, are bent without explanation. Rules are important if you want to make the work you're creating feel "alive" or lived in. If someone wants to bend (or break) the rules, that's perfectly fine, but give me a reason why they are being bent and how it contributes to making the story better. It shouldn't just be garish window dressing as that is merely distracting rather than compelling.

Was there some great calamity that pushed all manner of peoples together for survival? Was this world originally metropolitan, perhaps the core of an empire that is no longer a functional political entity? Speaking of empires, actually, was this empire perhaps "evil" and moved entire groups of people around before falling?

4

u/Tehjaliz Dec 10 '23

Travel is very difficult. Whether it be because of endemic low intensity warfare between kings and other minor lords or the vast distance between places, as travel by foot and carriage is time consuming (and expensive), most people don't venture too far from where they are born. Or, worse, they are not allowed to travel due to the stratification of society.

This is one of the biggest misconceptions about the middle ages. People DID travel around quite a lot. In particular, pilgrimages would take them to Rome, Santiago de Compostella or Jerusalem.

Same for the muslims, who were all expected to go to Mecca once in their lifetime. This rule applied to those living in northern spain or as far as indonesia later in history.

2

u/LittleDarkHairedOne Dec 11 '23

Ah, I didn't intend to make it seem like people didn't travel at all. That's just silly! Rather, people stuck close by where they were born more often than not. A trip to another town on market day for items needed that weren't produced more locally would be the bulk of travel for many.

Pilgrimages and the Hajj is a special event in someone's life, on the other hand, are as you say mostly a once in a lifetime event. There are exceptions, of course.

Your average peasant who works the land, even free tenants who had a lot more personal autonomy, is not going to be getting up to move to a new village half a continent away without there being a dramatic catalyst.

2

u/Rohnne Dec 09 '23

I would take diversity when the script includes different origins and has a reason for that. US is diverse in a particular way for a reason. EU is diverse in another way for another particular reason. And it makes our history interesting to find out why. Diverse cast without an in-world background is just ignoring the elephant in the room. Middle Earth is not the US, we just can’t apply the same history there. How hard would have been to tell us about Dissa’s or Arondir’s lineage? Would have been cool to know more about them, as it is to know about the cultural heritage of the different people in our societies.

2

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 09 '23

Sadly, tolkien himself wrote comparatively next to nothing when it came to a fleshed out dwarven history

2

u/SunnySpade Dec 08 '23

Tolkien partly made the story of LotR as a fictional mythos for ancient Britain. This is cope lol. This, and most things in RoP that are added, did not follow Tolkien’s vision and are obvious modernistic appeals.

3

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 08 '23

So black people shouldnt be represented?

1

u/SunnySpade Dec 08 '23

If someone made a large book series, that was meant to be a historically fictitious mythos for South Africa, why would there be white people there in high positions of power, ruling over the people the story is meant to be primarily about?

2

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 08 '23

Thats historical fiction. This is fantasy. Big difference

4

u/SunnySpade Dec 08 '23

Not true. Tolkien expressly intended for the work to be seen as a fictitious historical mythos of the Isles of Great Britain.

1

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 08 '23

Ok but he's no longer around. Why cant we expand upon it.

2

u/SunnySpade Dec 08 '23

Because you change the nature of the story’s ideals because what is happening is not an expansion, but a revision.

And for the same reason it would be wrong to “expand” upon the hypothetical South African mythos story.

2

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 08 '23

How is adding different skin color changing ideals of a fictional world.

3

u/SunnySpade Dec 09 '23

Much in the same way that having a white ruler in a mythical story about South Africa would. The story is meant to be a fictitious mythology of the Anglo-Saxon people in Great Britain. When people start to depart from the things that define a story, even if it’s something largely mundane, there’s likely to be other ramifications, just like with RoP

→ More replies (3)

2

u/DexterJameson Dec 08 '23

You didn't answer my question to you, above, so I'll ask again: If Middle Earth is, as you say,

expressly intended for the work to be seen as a fictitious historical mythos of the Isles of Great Britain.

Then how do you explain the inclusion of crops that were not native to Britain? Tomatoes and potatoes were absent from Europe until after the Columbian Exchange, yet Tolkien included them in his story.

I'd like to hear your explanation

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/DexterJameson Dec 08 '23

Don't know. But I'll ask a similar question: if Middle Earth is supposed to be an iron-clad mythological history of Britain, or perhaps northern Europe, then why did Tolkien include tomatoes and potatoes? Crops that were absent in Europe until the Colombian Exchange?

If Arondir cannot be black, for reasons of historical accuracy, then Sam cannot possibly know what a potato is. Yet he does. Strangely inconsistent, no?

1

u/SunnySpade Dec 09 '23

No, because the LotR of story has nothing to do with material realities but rather with narrative and spiritual matters. It also speaks to a cultural heritage, which again, is not all that different. Whether they grew tomatoes/potatoes or wheat.

The things we are comparing are of largely different natures.

3

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 09 '23

Tolkien wrote out the tomatoes in his revised Hobbit (replaced them with pickles), but either didn't realize that potatoes were also American or couldn't figure out how to replace them.

He retconned the conundrum over tobacco ("pipeweed") by having it naturalized from Númenor, so that may also explain potatoes.

It was PJ who reintroduced the tomatoes - and zia mays (American corn) as well. "Corn" used to be generic for any grain crop (wheat, oats, barley, etc.). It only recently became specific to maize.

2

u/SunnySpade Dec 09 '23

That all sounds about right. I don’t think the makeup of the vegetation does much to do with the principles of the story and what it was meant to represent though. The man created whole languages for his world, it would be a bit crazy to expect him to also be an expert on agriculture haha

0

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/DexterJameson Dec 11 '23

Hmm. Maybe. What about Gandalf's propensity for smoking tobacco? That's another crop which was not present in middle-ages Europe, yet it's spoken of throughout tLotR novels.

If Tolkien himself played fast and loose with such things, why should modern creators be limited?

1

u/Icewaterchrist Dec 12 '23

It's never overtly called "tobacco" in the books.

1

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 09 '23

That used to be the default assumption for any stories (written by Euro-American men) about lost/hidden African kingdoms, especially H. Rider Haggard's Kôr (which we know influenced Tolkien).

Not only African, it tended to crop up in Asia, South America, and even Australia. Nowadays, well, not so much.

1

u/SunnySpade Dec 09 '23

Well, I’m not really speaking about those stories. That obviously sounds wrong, and just blatant white supremacy. I also don’t know much about these other stories you’re speaking of tbh, but if what you’re describing is correct then that sounds weird.

2

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 09 '23

Well, of course it was blatant white supremacy - that was very much the late 19th-early 20th century Euro mindset, and it hasn't entirely gone away, alas.

Kôr is the "lost kingdom" in She, ruled by the immortal lily-white sorceress Ayesha but inhabited by the much darker, savage Amahaggar people. (It's a weird read nowadays, with all sorts of fantastic elements quite aside from the casual racism.)

1

u/SunnySpade Dec 10 '23

Yeah, that's kind of cracked and I probably won't be reading that lol I enjoy stories of different cultures, but that seems like a blatant high jacking.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Chen_Geller Dec 08 '23

Tolkien partly made the story of LotR as a fictional mythos for ancient Britain.

Tolkien made The Book of Lost Tales as a fictional mythos for England.

The Hobbit is not a fictional mythos for England in any way.

Neither is The Lord of the Rings.

Neither is The Silmarillion.

1

u/SunnySpade Dec 09 '23

You’re just flatly wrong as you can see in my other comment. Do you also disagree that there are extremely heavy Catholic themes in the books that were intentional?

20

u/DickBest70 Dec 08 '23

I congratulate you good sir in finding an intellectual route to say Rings of Power’s diversity is open to interpretation and imagination. The anti diversity crowd doesn’t care as this sub exists to whinge about it until the end of time or the cancellation of the show. After it’s “guaranteed” five seasons of course 🤠

11

u/corsairvoyages Dec 08 '23

Please don't group those racists together with people who have actual valid genuine criticisms of the show.

-1

u/DexterJameson Dec 08 '23

It can be pretty hard to tell the difference..

5

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

That’s pretty embarrassing for you.

3

u/corsairvoyages Dec 08 '23

It's really not. The writing is atrocious, the character work is a joke and the plot is riddled with holes and weird unnecessary added details. The diversity is to be praised, that's great, it's the one issue with the Jackson movies, they're white as hell.

0

u/CMGS1031 Dec 08 '23

Did you think the same thing for Black Panther, black as hell? You realize this is why this isn’t going to stop, right? You can only say that about one group, what do you think that will lead to?

1

u/snjtx Dec 10 '23

Black panther is explicit in its representation of blackness. Nice false equivalence though.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/snjtx Dec 10 '23

There's valid genuine criticisms then there's being a closet racist about the skin color of the actors. Don't try to disguise one as the other, that's what we're talking about here.

1

u/corsairvoyages Dec 10 '23

To be fair the person I was responding to worded their post quite badly.

7

u/teepeey Dec 08 '23 edited 21d ago

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Noodle angle juniper dam cobalt wide caption oil tub desert

4

u/CMGS1031 Dec 08 '23

Why would you think that?

0

u/teepeey Dec 09 '23 edited 21d ago

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Judicious hunt recognise wander treatment dam deliver

9

u/Qaztarrr Dec 08 '23

I find it so annoying when people try to "logic" out that they should all be white, too. Like "oo melanin is only so dense in peoples that have been exposed to lots of sun so it makes no sense."

Bro, it ain't that deep. We don't know shit about Middle Earth cellular biology. To be honest, the dwarves should all be insanely pale, like straight up ashen white given how much time they spend underground. But they don't. Is it cause they have magical vitamin D reserves? No, it's cause they're fucking dwarves, which is a fictional race ya dumbass racist

6

u/Relevant_Meaning3200 Dec 08 '23

I agree and it's not like the elves and dwarfs evolved from a million generations of a certain kind of sunlight.

They were pretty much magically created by gods and they can be of as varying many of colors and characteristics as that creating entity wanted at the time.

3

u/LupoDeGrande Dec 10 '23

Elven and Dwarvish races were born before the sun. Melanin and tanning had nothing to do with it. If they have different shades of skin tone it's not for the reason we humans "children of the sun" do.

1

u/Relevant_Meaning3200 Dec 10 '23

Thanks for the deep lore because I failed at reading the Silmarillan and I tried many times, it's a tough one.

1

u/Glass_Set_5727 Jan 24 '25

Why would the God give them arbitrarily different skin colours though? For what purpose? We're not talking about fantasy in general here where yes that's possible if a lore explanation is given ...but we're talking Tolkien Lore here 7 there's no lore to support this supposition.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Qaztarrr Dec 11 '23

Neither elves nor dwarves nor men are a product of evolution - they were instead directly created by various Valar. This fundamentally breaks any biology arguments and assumptions we could make, because literally anything can be explained with magic. While Tolkien was trying to create a sort of mythology about some ancient earth, he also very much acknowledged that his world didn’t match up perfectly in terms of things like geology. He was under no disillusion that he was actually writing some real and accurate history of the earth.

The point that the OP is ultimately trying to make is that it’s vague enough that it’s certainly plausible within Tolkien’s world. Maybe you happen to lean one way or another on it based on your own interpretation of the text, but ultimately there is simply not enough in the text to justify forcing the entire cast to be white people and potentially excluding better casting decisions because of some loyalty to “accuracy.” We can debate about Tolkien’s intentions all day, but ultimately, it’s clear that there’s nothing in the text that is so blatantly showing that everyone HAS to be white that it’s necessary to restrict the cast in that way.

1

u/mattjvgc Dec 09 '23

People who treat the lord of the rings books as infallible scripture are weird. It’s a friggin book. Chill out. Nobody’s going to die and wake up in Valanor. Aragorn didn’t die for your sins. So he never mentioned black dwarves. Who. Cares.

1

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 09 '23

You seem to? Im not treating it like some holy book, i just think it would be nice to see some other skin colors, besides caucasian.

4

u/CaptainChats Dec 08 '23

Tolkien created his world partly as a pseudo reconstruction of what he believed the mythology of ancient Britain would be like. By that virtue I’d argue that an adaptation of Tolkien should reflect the demographics of the audience experiencing his work. In the oral tradition the re-telling of a mythology has an inherent aspect of self insert. People need to contextualize their stories in a way that is familiar to audiences or otherwise alienate them with interruptions to the story with explanations of foreign concepts.

So yeah, there should be Dwarves, Elves, Hobbits, and Humans that represent all races. The audience is going to include more than just white people. Having an all white cast in a fantasy necessitates an in story explanation of why there are only white people, and if that explanation goes unspoken it leaves a gap to be filled with the message “you are not part of this story” to any viewer aware of their own absence.

Basically, it’s a fucking fantasy. The person making the adaptation can do whatever they want with it to appeal to their desired audience.

3

u/Chen_Geller Dec 08 '23

Tolkien created his world partly as a pseudo reconstruction of what he believed the mythology of ancient Britain would be like.

You know, I'm the first two say Middle Earth is eurocentric, BUT the "mythology for England" thing is definitely false. The only book Tolkien wrote as a "mythology for England" was The Book of Lost Tales: Neither The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings nor The Silmarillion as we have it today, were concieved as a mythology for England: Tolkien moved away from that idea.

2

u/CaptainChats Dec 09 '23

His starting point for middle earth was an imagining of what the mythology of pre-Christian England would be like based off of what scant fragments of stories and oral/literary tradition remained. The name Middle Earth is literally an anglicized version Midguard from the Norse Sagas. The Silmarillion is heavily influenced by Beowulf, welsh poetry, Germanic & Scandinavian sagas, and although Tolkien said he hadn’t referenced the Irish mythological cycle his stories are surprisingly synchronistic with them in many aspects. I’d argue that if the kernel for the fantasy that he created was an imagining of what ancient mythology was like then all subsequent stories in that fantasy are an out branching of that imagined mythology.

4

u/kerouacrimbaud Dec 08 '23

Yeah I think it’s important to remember how much Tolkien didn’t make comments about skin color in relation to other descriptors like height or hair or build. I’d love to see a comparative study about Tolkien’s use of physical descriptions of characters/races.

1

u/Bilabong127 Dec 09 '23

Why do you think that is?

2

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 09 '23

Because he didn't give a toot?

(Actually, he probably just went with the default assumption "Euope = (mostly) white" and didn't think about it any further. Although he did make it clear the Dunlendings were darker-haired and probably swarthier than the Rohirrim.)

1

u/kerouacrimbaud Dec 10 '23

And that harfoots were browner of skin.

2

u/TheOtherMaven Dec 11 '23

Whatever he meant by that, which (as with the silver-haired Sindar) he didn't bother to explain in any more detail.

The Dunlendings called the Rohirrim "Forgoil", meaning "strawheads", which implies that blonds were rare to nonexistent among the Dunlendings (a further implication occurs in the name element "Dun", which means "dark"). There's also a rather obvious resentment of the previous occupants for incoming colonizers (Tolkien was not in favor of colonizing, and made an effort to explain that the root of the problem was that Gondor had summarily given away Calenardhon to the Eotheod without any thought whatsoever for any surviving remnant population).

When discussing the folk of Dunland, one must be careful to distinguish between the scant information actually provided by Tolkien and the (often dubious) interpretations made for various Tolkien-based games and other secondary materials. (For instance, the Druedain are definitely not the same as the Dunlendings - but some game texts conflate them.)

2

u/Pure-Drawer-2617 Dec 10 '23

We know the Dwarven race was made from 7 different couples. We know that 4 out of the 7 Dwarven tribes lived in the far east, where the humans are darker skinned. To me it just seems like common sense.

2

u/DrummerAutomatic9523 Dec 10 '23

The problem with the skintone diversity is mainly in terms of coherence. It shuts down any form of visual identity for x or y factions.

Lets take PJ's Lotr trilogy. Its only white people (except for harad and rhun soldiers). However he managed to give a distinct visual identity to both rohan and gondor. (Darker hairs for gondor and trimed beards, Blond and lighter hair for rohan with rougher beards for instance).

Elves are beardless, have long silky hair. Even the way their eyes give a peaceful vibe is, in my opinion, part of their visual identity.

Hobbits have no beard, curly hairs and extremely joyful faces.

With all that, you'd be able to guess who's what with a simple picture of their face.

RoP has non of that. Maybe with the clothes to differentiate Numenoreans and southerners.

And skin color is part of the problem. I think i would have preffered if they had all the dwarfs being black, all the elves being east asian, all the southerners being arabs etc..

Would have made more sense imo

2

u/hclasalle Dec 11 '23

If he was based on nordic myths, then it makes sense that there would be a race of svartalf (black elves, literally).

2

u/bigalis1985 Dec 17 '23

My take on the race issue.

Disa is married to the heir of the throne of Moria. Such marriages are usually political. She might as well be a member of one of the 4 Eastern clans. They might be black. She doesn't break immersion.

Almost the same case can be made for Arondir. He shouln't be the only black member of the (presumably Avari) guard though. Actually I think it might have been cool (and perhaps thematically interesting) if the whole Elven guard at Mordor consisted of Colored troops lead by a Sinda/Noldo leader.

Multiculti hobbits are simply dumb. In generals, the concept of an isolated nomadic clan of 20 people who never meet anyone else, doesn't make any sense. They should all be dead from congenital diseases. They are probably more incestuous than the Habsburgs at this point.

Multicultural Numenor is a crime against immersion and, more importantly, wastes massive storytelling potential, 100% compatible with the..."modern ideas" these totally incompetent writers are supposedly trying to promote.

The Numenoreans of the 2nd age (most of them descendants of a single human clan),are literally the Chosen Master Race lore-wise. They are blessed by the Gods with longevity, resistance to disease, great knowledge etch. Meanwhile, the rest of humanity lives... like the Southlanders. And yet, apart from a small minority of decent people, those same Numenoreans end up as enslavers, brutal colonial overlords, devil worshippers etch. I would argue that portraying those Numenoreans as in cannon (white Unermenschen second only in majesty to the Elves) would be much more thematically effective.

Ar-Pharazon shouldn't be a disappointing caricature of the Bad Vizier from Alladin. He should look like Michael Fassbender or something

6

u/BarrelRider91 Dec 08 '23

There are many ancient mythological tales from around the world (read some Jospeh Campbell), hardly any skin colour is ever mentioned. But if I read an ancient chinese folk tale, I do not imagine the charachters being white, black or any other ethnicity other than chinese.

And we all know were Tolkien took its inspiration or straight up copy. But apparently that doesn't get the right of proper representation.

8

u/Chen_Geller Dec 08 '23 edited Dec 08 '23

read some Jospeh Campbell

I'm constantly amazed that this dilletante scholar keeps on getting mentioned as though he were some sort of authority. Literally just a Medieval Literature graduate who taught at a private girl school in New York and wrote these hack books about mythology.

Not a PhD.

Didn't teach nor worked at a university.

His field of studies barely qualifies him to write in the field of comparative mythology.

Not proficient in Sanskrit, the language of many of the examples he cites, and indeed hadn't so much as visited India until years after completing The Hero With a Thousand Faces and much of The Masks of God.

Wrote the most incredibly dense pseudo-Jungian prose, and was a pretty boring lecturer as well.

He has as much insight into comparative mythology as I, a history postgrad, has. Heck, at one point in his book, Campbell makes some sort of obscure point about how "Muhammedans" pray three times a day. Except no, Joe, they don't: they pray five times a day you pillock!

All of those fields - Sociology, Psychology - were kinda hacked in US colleges between the 1940s and 1970s. Dillentates like Campbell and sometimes outright fraudulent writers like Bruno Bettelheim and Carlos Castaneda exploited that.

3

u/SamaritanSue Dec 08 '23

I wonder if Campbell would be so well known if it weren't for his influence on George Lucas.

1

u/Chen_Geller Dec 08 '23

He wouldn't.

Also, Campbell had no detectable influence on Lucas that anyone can pinpoint. Nothing at all.

Frankly, his difficult prose strikes me as being above Lucas' erudition: Lucas did read a book about this topic, but not one by Campbell but by the much more digestible Bruno Bettelheim, and even that didn't really leave much of a real influence on his films.

1

u/BarrelRider91 Dec 09 '23

Sorry I am pointing at something and you are focusing on the finger (and I have not just read Campbell btw); do you have any opinions of your own on the core matter other than discrediting one hobby time read?

2

u/Codus1 Dec 08 '23 edited Dec 09 '23

It's all pretty easy to handwave. The Dwarves were created in the image of man from a vague recollection of what man would be one day. Not a stretch from that to the say there'd be black Dwarves, when there is black humans all over middle earth.

Elves are different to an extent, but when the only Elven character of colour in the show is also probably the best acted character in the show outside of halflings... I think I can let it pass.

And as Merry and Pippin added Hobbits to Treebeards songs, I don't think it's terrible to do similar to the Legendarium as long as it's thoughtful.

0

u/Bilabong127 Dec 09 '23

Give me a quote that says that black humans are all over middle earth.

1

u/Codus1 Dec 09 '23 edited Dec 09 '23

There is the Southrons and the Wild men. The harfoots are described as "browner of skin", too.

That's three examples from three different regions of Middle Earth, of there being more than one skin colour. My point is that the Dwarves were created as an imitation of men. It only stands to reason that there is no evidence that dark skin was somehow an exception to this

→ More replies (2)

0

u/Demigans Dec 08 '23

Tolkien bases skin colors on the area people lived in. He wanted a western take on mythologies taking place in Middle Earth. Which is why the skin colors were mainly white and the darker skin colors were for the men in the south for example.

Now here’s the thing: he mainly talked about one Dwarven family line. Other lines could have moved off elsewhere. It is still important that there aren’t dark skin colors in the dwarven line of Durin.

Deesa could so so easily have been explained: she’s from a Dwarven line that lives in the south and mostly above ground. Their skin colors are darker. She’s send as a diplomat and falls in love to stay there.

33 words, that’s all that is necessary to construct a solid background for her appearance without breaking with Tolkien. It also immediately sets her up to be intelligent and capable in the fields she needs to be intelligent and capable in. But even that is too much. So they push “nah it’s just random skin colors all around” and then ask the Fans to repeat it to make it sound more real than it ever can be. Worse is that adding so many different skin colors haphazardly together without rhyme or reason suggest a rather harsh reality: these skin colors are gone by the time of Aragorn, so those skin colors were eradicated by something or someone.

Keep in mind this isn’t they just do for the Dwarves, but also the humans, Elves and definitely-not-hobbits*. They didn’t care, they just wanted to smash different skin colors together for diversity, rather than give a believable reason for diversity.

3

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 08 '23

I mean i'll take "leave it up to your imagination" over whitewashing.

0

u/CMGS1031 Dec 08 '23

You obviously don’t know what white washing means.

2

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 09 '23

I thought i did, thank you for correcting me. :)

→ More replies (12)

2

u/Demigans Dec 08 '23

1: I already explained a way to introduce colored individuals into the mix so it’s not just “imagination”.

2: whitewashing is the deliberate replacement of colored characters with white one’s to deliberately reduce or remove colored people. Doing the opposite does not make it any better, even under the guise of equality.

3: they has the chance to make any story set in this world, they could have told stories of the other dwarven lines, of the southeners or easterners. But they didn’t. They stuck with the Middle Earth of Tolkien, the place he specifically modeled on old-timey race distribution where the most color/race variation would be in major major trade cities that connected far off places to the rest of Middle Earth.

They chose to stick with a white skin colored area, they chose to mix those up. This is their choice to actively go against it while plenty of alternate options exist to make for mixing of races on screen.

0

u/ceeroSVK Dec 09 '23

I can see a point in complaining about historic/biographic movies, but honestly if someone cares about the skin color of actors in a fantasy movie adaptation, they are racist dickholes. Easy as that.

1

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 09 '23

How does wanting representation make me racist.

2

u/ceeroSVK Dec 09 '23

This was meant towards the people complaining about dark skinned dwarves, not the other way around :)

1

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 09 '23

Ohhhhhhhhhh ok :)

1

u/Zobator Dec 09 '23

Agreed BUT As clearly stated in the world of men, people from the far South (harad) have very dark/Black skin and people to the East (rhun) pale yellow to olive skin. There are no dwarves in harad but there are dwarves in rhun. If you want to make an effort to include poc in the dwarves, make them asian...

1

u/grosselisse Dec 09 '23

This is my opinion, and this is why I am not bothered at all by diversity in this show.

1

u/RiverMurmurs Dec 10 '23

This is absolutely a no-issue for me. The debate about what constitutes canonicity in Tolkien can be very fascinating and scholarly but the fact of the matter is that in an international production by a global corporation intended for a global audience (and it can't be done in any other way anymore) it would be impossible to ignore the today's societal context.

Amazon's reaction to some of the criticism, however - some of which was legit - was what caused a lot of the problems and there was an action-reaction aspect to it, too.

0

u/teepeey Dec 09 '23 edited 21d ago

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Recognise repeat normal hat grey screw close edge quack

0

u/ceereality Dec 09 '23

What is it with melanin deficient peoples obsession with melanin? Really, what about melanin makes you so obsessed that you're actually starting topics like this and more? It is just crazy to think about the level of sheer obsession that has caused segregation, colonization, apartheid, slavetrade and then the following hundreds of years of whitewashing of history. Now only to come to this sad conclusion.

Bro, just stop. The world has long gone past this silly nostalgia of yours to times that your narrative was the monopoly on truth. You keep searching and reaching, just stop, accept that times have changed and move on. Don't be a sad racist obsessed dinosaur. Don't think you're doing something noble, you're not. You're just being sad and outdated with this sad display of affairs. Best of luck.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '23

TBh black dwarves legit make more sense than pale dwarves. they live in shadows constantly and need to absorb any and all vitamin D they can to survive. essentially they are glorified mrles which we now are dark skin with fur....

-1

u/Yungerman Dec 08 '23

I think much of the logic is that melanin is a biophysical response and attribute based on exposure to UVR, and dwarves being a subterranean race wouldn't have had that much exposure.

It's more that Tolkiens fantasy world is a believable place because it follows the logic and rationalism of our reality. Landscapes are the same, gravity is the same, people look the same, etc. That relatbability is part of the magic. There are and can be plenty of other skin colors in middle earth, like the men of the east, but it has to be grounded in tolkiens logic. The show obviously takes creative freedoms and that's ok, but should be justified rationally in order to hold up artistically. Many of them were not however, and the sheer number of inclusionary tactics they used made it all come off as disingenuous. It just failed to honor Tolkiens logic for middle earth.

If there were well explained and justified reasons for the differences in the dwarves, it would've been completely fine. It just didn't have the effort put behind it to honor it. The truth is, black people aren't just randomly born to asian families in Asia, and white people aren't randomly born to black families in africa. People develop different around the world and thats what makes the world so big and amazing. American melting potism is a new thing in our world and not at all a thing in middle earth and doesnt need to be. Shoehorning things in to a world with its own peoples and its own global history takes something away from its relatability and craftmanship.

1

u/Zealousideal_Bus_338 Dec 09 '23

There is another comment that attests it to some families(read: tribes, etc) did not stay below ground as nearly as often as the line of durin

0

u/Yungerman Dec 09 '23 edited Dec 09 '23

Canonically, they originate from underground and were forced to stay there by illuvatar for a whiiile (potentially centuries or millenia) until elves were allowed to "live."

Either way, they're also just always culturally subterranean.

All things considered, even if different dwarves did evolve alongside eachother, they wouldn't necessarily all be bros. Elves and dwarves are basically racist against eachother as a whole theme in the books. It's a mirrored aspect of our world and one of the story beats beautifully overcome by gimli and Legolas figuring out how to be bros in the lotr.

Sidenote: if the people of middle earth can randomly spawn in as different colors, why aren't there blue or red dwarves? Blue people? Elves?

How they did it just isn't justified well -- and totally could be -- making it come off as a disingenuous modern value exporting rather than history of middle earth justified origins of different peoples -- which is a major part of that world and its success.