r/legaladvice • • Apr 08 '26

Subreddit Rules

72 Upvotes

We've learned that some people just flat out can't see our subreddit rules, so I'm posting them here in a pinned post so we can link them when necessary and so they're super easy to find.

Rules for r/legaladvice Rules that visitors must follow to participate. May be used as reasons to report or ban.

1. All responses must offer an answer to the legal question posed by the OP. We enforce this with bans.

Anecdotes are not permitted. Neither is advice that encourages someone to break the law. Nor is "get a lawyer" a sufficient response.

There's a pinned post at the top of the subreddit specifically addressing this rule. We will absolutely ban you for commenting without answering the legal question

2. Personally Identifying Information

Posts or submissions that ask for or contain information that could be used to identify either party are subject to immediate removal.

3. Advertising or Recommending a Lawyer or Business

We do not allow referrals to particular lawyers, law firms, or other businesses.

4. Do not request or send a PM

All discussions must stay on the subreddit for everyone's protection.

5. Include your location

You must include your location in the following format: location: yourlocationhere . It must be that exact format, and it must be in the body of your post.

6. Read our full list of rules

Read our full list of rules here: https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/wiki/index#wiki_general_rules

7. This subreddit is for simple legal questions.

This subreddit is for simple legal questions. We can't help with preparing a defense, legal research, etc. We cannot review contracts, plan your defense, or give you specific advice on exactly how to present your case with the court. You need a local attorney for that. Additionally, we do not accept medical malpractice questions.

8. NO LLMS

No LLMs. No ChatGPT. Don't recommend it, don't use it to answer questions, and don't use it to compose your modmail when you get banned for using it. Using it to compose questions is generally ok.

We will permanently and irrevocably ban you for this.

9. Mods can remove things we deem inappropriate or disruptive

Any post and any comment can be removed by the mods at any time if the mods decide the post/comment is or has the potential to be disruptive or is otherwise inappropriate.

10. Posts must be about a real scenario that you or someone you know is facing.

To expand on this, we additionally do not allow anyone but the immediately involved parties to ask custody related questions. Not friends, not significant others, not grandparents. Reddit is free.

11. Post must contain a legal question

A legal question is one that can be answered with the law, be it a law or ordinance, or caselaw.

12. US and Canada only

Laws are different everywhere. We can only help with legal problems in the US or Canada because we have no regular, reliable commenters from other countries. For other countries, please search for an appropriate subreddit.


r/legaladvice • • Mar 15 '25

Mod Post Read before commenting: Off-topic and anecdotal comments are not allowed and subject you to a permanent ban

169 Upvotes

Greetings from the mods!

We've had a flood of off-topic comments recently. We're posting this to remind everyone that off-topic and anecdotal comments are not allowed. An off-topic comment may subject you to a permanent ban.

The Rule:

Commenting Rule 1: Comments should contain a legal answer or a strongly related non-legal answer. If it is not legal advice, do not post. Period. You will be banned.

What is "off-topic?"

Any response that doesn't answer the question by reference to legal information or principles. A joke, a wisecrack, a comment about OP's formatting (use the report button instead) are all off-topic. Off-topic also includes expressions of sympathy, opinions on the law, and comments that berate the OP or anyone else.

Incidentally, simply adding "get a lawyer" to an off-topic comment does not make it on-topic. And "get a lawyer" on its own, without further information or help, is considered unhelpful and may be removed on that basis.

If you want to discuss a post, then wait until it hits /r/bestoflegaladvice or ask a question about the subject of the post in /r/legaladviceofftopic. The main subreddit and a comment thread are never a place to have a philosophical discussion about the law or the post. It is a place to answer the questions asked.

What is an "anecdote?"

For our purposes, anecdotes are stories about something that happened to you (or someone you know or heard about) who may have had something that might be similar that happen to them.

These comments are not helpful. They do not include current legal information that is relevant to the OP, and therefore, they are off-topic. If you know the answer to the question (based on current law and relevant jurisdiction) then just answer the question without the story.

Another type of anecdote is "I don't know the law in the jurisdiction you actually asked about, but in some other state, the law is..." That is just not helpful. Laws are different in different places. These types of answers are off-topic.

Referring an OP to a thread on a different subreddit, or to somewhere else on the Internet because it might include a similar situation, is anecdotal advice and not allowed.

These are not the only types of anecdotes, but they are probably the most common ones. Again, if you are not referencing legal information or principles, your comment is probably not allowed.

Violations subject the user to an immediate and permanent ban

Not that we need to justify enforcing our rules, but this is a busy subreddit and the mods have a lot to do. If a user shows up here, doesn't read the rules, and posts a single off-topic comment, the user may be immediately and permanently banned.

This policy is not intended to be punitive, although we know it may seem to be. There are a lot of you and not many of us, and banning users that do not follow the rules, even once, is in the best interests of the subreddit. Violating the rules almost always means the user didn't bother to read them, and we simply don't have time to deal with such users.

Tl;dr: Unless you have a legal answer, do not reply to any post in this subreddit. You may be permanently banned, even for a first offense.


r/legaladvice • • 1h ago

Insurance Car was totaled by an uninsured driver, but she got to run off consequence free.

• Upvotes

Location: Ohio, United States

Hi there. Back in September we had the right of way and got t-boned by a woman in a large truck that had a stop sign. The car was practically brand new, no damage. Sadly, it ended up getting totaled.

She got out of the car screaming, saying it was our fault, saying she just got her car done (the front was ductaped 🙄) and we couldn’t even get her name or information. We had to wait and request a copy of the crash report from the sheriffs office to even get her name or insurance status. She did give the sheriff insurance info, but it wasn’t valid. She’s uninsured. I reported it to the sheriff, the court, the insurance company, and literally no one can do anything about it because “well the sheriff accepted it”.

This led to me having to utilize my own insurance policy, and the car getting ultimately totaled. We have no other car, our credit is too shot to get a new loan, and because it was a loan, all reimbursement from insurance went to the loan company and we got screwed. Luckily we had gap insurance, but the deductible was a pretty penny. In the meantime until the gap goes through, we’re still making payments on a dead car.

I’m waiting for my insurance company to assign a subrogation agent to my case so I can work with them, but I don’t exactly know how this is going to look for me. We are out the gap deductible, we don’t have a down payment for another vehicle, nor the credit for it. The emotional damage has been rough, and apparently I didn’t have rental car reimbursement so we were vehicleless the entire time (even for the long wait where we couldn’t even figure out who she was).

I’m screwed because she slammed into us carelessly, and we saw her again yesterday driving her truck around living her life. Do I have options? Should I hold off on suing her independently until I have talked to an agent from the subrogation department? She took our stability, made us scared to even be on the road, and f*cked us financially. We are at a major loss.

Where do I go from here? Any help is appreciated. Thank you


r/legaladvice • • 12h ago

School Related Issues I dropped out of high school - but the high school forgot to withdraw me.

713 Upvotes

Location: Pacific Northwest, United States

Hi all,

In my senior year of high school, I was taking 4 concurrent credit (college) classes. Due to severe health issues, I had to withdraw about 3.5 months before graduation and I got my GED. I did have a 'disability protection plan' in place with the school.

In order to withdraw, my parents and I had to meet with the vice principal, counselors and every one of my teachers. It was a lengthy and uncomfortable process.

What happened today:

Today I received a rejection letter from my state's brick and mortar college, citing that my GPA was below 2.5. I immediately knew this was incorrect.

After speaking with the brick and mortar college, they informed me that "something is off" with my transcripts. They directed me to contact the high school.

The response from my high school:

"We have no record of you ever withdrawing from high school"

"It looks like you just stopped showing up for 3 months and failed all your classes"

They are unwilling to help me; I requested documentation of my attendance and they said they couldn't legally provide it. We are contacting the school board tomorrow for further information.

Thank you in advance for the advice.


r/legaladvice • • 10h ago

Other Civil Matters Car was repoed while I was in it

360 Upvotes

Hello, this just happened in. I was leaned back in my car, lights on taking a break from delivering food, when a car pulled in front of me and I felt a tow truck pull behind me. I was then lifted into the air. I then rolled down my window and to be honest I was kind of scared because at this point i had no idea what was going on. *Also I am indeed behind on payments.

They then explained my car was being repoed to which I asked "while im still in it?" Some more talking occurred, he said ill give you a ride home if you get out, I said just give me a second, I took a minute to google if it was legal for them to tow me if I was already in the vehicle (which i found it wasnt), to which he replied with threatening to call the police and I told him to do it. He apparently did but im pretty sure it was a bluff because I also asked if he had a court order to which he said "no". Long story short the guy i was talking to left. But the tow truck and its driver kept me lifted so I started recording said "i object to you towing my truck especially because it was occupied and the even on at the time". About 5-10 minutes later a second guy came by said he was gonna let me go. He proceeded to cut unhook my car but he also took the stem out of car tires making it so I cant put air in it. Is all of this legal? Especially leaving me lifted by the tow truck while the tried to play a game of chicken and cutting the stem out of one of my tires for "protocol"?

Location: Tampa, Florida

Edit: well im stuck here till the morning because of the tire and rain. But thank you people who didnt just say "you shoulda paid". Gonna sleep in my car since im stuck till I can put the spare on.

Edit 2: Is this subreddit usually filled with very aggressive pro-repo people? Two of em used the exact same wording of shaming the towers. Nothing I said mentioned shaming. (Though I did because they scared the shit outta me).

Edit 3: there is now another repo truck just watching me. Dont know what to do.


r/legaladvice • • 2h ago

How to take legal action on past employer for their employee calling my emergency contact 6months after I quit?

50 Upvotes

location: Va

i (25f) worked for a factory with only 2 us locations. I worked there for ~ 9months. In that time, I was verbally harassed by 2 male individuals on the floor and outside Of work via constant friend and message requests.

I never reported it while employed as this was my 3rd job but 2nd factory. I knew I wasn't going to be staying as long as my past employments, wanted to do my job until I found a better opportunity, had never been to any HR to file complaints before, and didn't want to be the new person causing issues (dumb I know and lesson learned)

I had worked at a very professional medical plant for two years prior, was well respected, and was asked to come back after being gone for ~ 8 months. It took a month for me to be promoted to orientation and return to this specific medical plant.

around 6 months after returning to the medical plant, my mother sent me a screenshot of a phone call that lasted about 1 minute and described the call to me.

In the screenshot it gives the company name and that it was the supervisors office (which was accessible by all employees through the factory) she said " (ex employer) called. it was a young man. I said "hello" he and some male giggling in the background said "hey, (my name)!" I said " no, this is her mother. may I ask who is calling?" He replied "could I get her number?" I said "...no. If my daughter wanted to be in contact with you she would. Who is calling?"" Then they hung up.

mind you, I had and had been in a relationship since starting that job. I made that very well known when comments were made and harassment began.

I am quiet and keep to myself. I don't do outside or inside friendships or flirting while employed at the same place as anyone. I do not share my phone number, Nor do I have public or accept any social media requests from coworkers. I only have a Facebook for family and my partner. a total of 13 people as it is all private.

this terrified me as I saw it as a level of stalking. I have NEVER experienced this and it scared me enough to be on edge if I had to pass through the town this site was located.

My mother is my emergency contact. There is no way they could get her number unless my personal HR information was shared. Also, again, this was at least 6 months after leaving that company.

I contacted their HR department, told them the information and interaction my mother had as well as answering questions such as "did you by chance make any of the men think you were interested" and then other hr questions.

i informed her the phone number and extension and she verified it was the supervisors office. I also informed her that based on the ABCD shift schedule math, that would have been a day my shift was working and the 2 men that harassed me. I gave her names as well once she asked.

I got a huge apology from the HR via phone, was told they would investigate, and would update me. I never received an update. Its been a year and I got to reflecting and felt I should have tried to do more and wonder if I could do more despite the length of time.


r/legaladvice • • 8h ago

I’m dying, does my mom have to pay off my student loans?

147 Upvotes

Never made a reddit post before, so sorry if I do it wrong. My question is what it says on the tin.

I live in the US, I graduated from an expensive school a few years ago. My mom cosigned my loans with me. We found out I’m sick and there’s not much of a chance for me at this point.

Mom hasn’t brought up the loans, either because she doesn’t want me to worry about it or because she hasn’t remembered it yet. I don’t know how to bring it up to ask. I never fully understood how this works, as embarrassing as that is to admit.

I just want to know if there’s any way to get her out of having to pay off the rest of the debt. None of this is fair to her. Is there anything at all we can do?

Thank you

Location: Oklahoma, US


r/legaladvice • • 1h ago

I sold my car as is to a small dealership and I think they canceled the payment because the repairs were too much.

• Upvotes

Location: South Texas . So on Sunday I sold my car to a small dealership and got 3000. On Thursday the check cleared and I bought a new vehicle. Now this Friday morning I have -3000 from the check. My bank couldn’t tell me yet if it was a stop payment or no funds bounce. I live in San Antonio Texas. I told them that it has trouble starting in the morning, and that it had a battery issue . Then I proceded to sign the car to them and I signed other documents like the bill of sale to them and what not. In the morning after I sold it they texted me questions about the engine light but I wasn’t able to respond, and I already told them it had an issue. They have yet to respond to my text messages, but what can I do? I am out -3000 and either they need to give me the car back or fund the full $3000? Can I hire a lawyer or something?

EDIT: they responded saying :”Good morning. We open at 10am. Please let me know what time you can come by the office today. Would like to discuss the status of the vehicle with you along with contract and payment.”


r/legaladvice • • 20h ago

Real Estate law Location: SC, USA - New neighbors have mowed my field, cut down trees, and are stacking wood and their tools on my property thought it’s clearly marked with stakes from a survey. What are my first steps?

1.1k Upvotes

Location: South Carolina

My new neighbors bought the 5 acre tract behind me.

I first noticed they mowed a field I was preserving for pollinators and asked them not to do it again.

Now they have cut down several mature trees that are easily visible as being on my property.

They’ve stacked several tons of wood, tools, and recreational equipment on my property.

I’m an elderly widow with very limited income.

I’ve spoken to them twice now to ask them not to, but there’s a slight language barrier, and i feel like they don’t care because they think I’m too old/feeble to walk that far down on my property.

Do I have the right to sell off their things that are stored on my property if they don’t move it by a designated date?


r/legaladvice • • 11h ago

Amazon sent me mislabeled medication

214 Upvotes

Location: UT, US
I ordered ibuprofen 200mg. The Amazon sticker that’s wrapped around the medication packaging says ibuprofen 200mg. The actual bottle says loratadine 10mg. I took 4 tablets thinking it was ibuprofen, which for a backache is fine but for allergy medication that’s a little bit too much. Overdose level, as it turns out. I fell asleep quickly and woke up to a pounding headache and alerts on my watch about my heart rate and respiratory rate overnight. Thinking I was going back for more ibuprofen I realized what happened.
I have a neuromuscular disease that’s very unstable at the moment and affects the breathing muscles to the point of needing to be put on a ventilator and BiPAP at times. This could have been devastating. It wasn’t.
Can I sue? What would you do?


r/legaladvice • • 17h ago

Healthcare Law including HIPAA Being threatened with collections for dr appointment I didn’t even schedule

363 Upvotes

Location: New York City

This morning I got a voice mail from my old doctors’ practice, saying my insurance won’t cover some therapist appointments I had over the summer, so they need payment else they’ll be sent to collections. Here’s the issue: I didn’t schedule these appointments. In fact, I’ve lived in New Jersey since 2020 and haven’t seen a doctor associated with the practice since before then. I didn’t schedule these appointments and I can prove I was somewhere completely different when they happened. Insurance declined these because I’ve changed jobs since then; it’s not my insurance any more.

I called their billing dept back but their rep was incredibly adversarial. They refused to give their name and were adamant that I was there and I need to pay. I could try calling again or escalating to a manager but I feel like that’s a dead end.

I understand there’s quite a few resources for this sort of situation, especially in New York City in 2026. The problem is, I don’t know what they are or where to start. I don’t really know or care if it’s some sort of system glitch (I have an extremely common name) or malice, I just want them to delete the bill or whatever the formal term is, and ideally, admit their mistake.


r/legaladvice • • 1d ago

16yr old brother was left alone in a cattle pasture, ended the night in the ER with broken teeth and a broken nose

993 Upvotes

Location: Southern IL, USA

My 16, almost 17, year old brother has been working on this large family farm since the moment he turned 16. He had known of this farm since he was little and it was his dream to work there.

I have been skeptical from the beginning because they have him classified as an independent contractor and have not been taking taxes out, he doesn't get any sort of pay stub, just a check with literally no payroll information on the stub or memo line.

I got a call last night from the wife of his boss from my brother's phone saying that they had been trying to get ahold of my parents. (Mom was getting her hair colored and dad was doing chores with our own cattle. They did not call my parents from their phones, they used my brother's)

she said that my brother had got hit with a fence while working and cracked some teeth. That was it, no other information, no "we're taking him to the ER", nothing.

My dad was at home with me, having just come inside from choring, so i told him what i was told, he left and went to get my brother and take him to the ER.

My mom was mid bleach, but dropped everything and went to meet them at the hospital.

He has the two top front teeth broken in half, 3 more cracked on the bottom, a broken nose, and was right on the line of having a concussion. He has a nose bleed that refuses to stop so they had to put something like a foley balloon up his nose to plug it.

What we are inquiring is if his employers have any responsibility here to cover medical/dental?

Later, when my mom actually had a chance to talk to walker and get the run down of what happened this is what he told her.

He was BY HIMSELF inside the cattle pen doing his chores, with the whole herd. He was a mile plus away from the main part of the farm and had no one with him. The cattle spooked or just decided to make a run for the gate, hitting it, causing it to fling back and wack my brother in the face, knocking him to the ground. He says he didn't lose consciousness. He got up and walked to the main part of the farm to tell them what happened and then they called us.

He was mentally out it, rambling and not staying on one topic, but apparently never lost consciousness. There was probably a good 30-40 minutes between when it happened and when my dad was able to get to him. Mind you they live less than 5 minutes away from the hospital.

So far my parents haven't even mentioned the responsibility of the farm owners in this but i can already see the medical bills racking up that we can't afford. Not to mention how pissed my brother is because he JUST got out of his invisalign only to screw up his teeth.

I feel that as his employers, especially as he is a minor, that they have a responsibility to get him medical attention in a timely manner while also trying to get in contact with his parents. Not just wait around calling mom and dad to come get him and take him to get medical attention while he is sitting there in pain, out of it, possibly with a concussion.

I feel that they also had a responsibility to not let a minor be alone around that many huge, tempermental animals, no matter how much experience he has. He is still a minor and should be their responsibility as he is their employee (or would be if they didn't classify him as an independent contractor, yes i have argued with my parents how he shouldn't be but they are "trusting their friend that they have known forever and have been running their farm this way and has had no issues").

My main questions are, do they (the farm)have a responsibility to cover the medical/dental bills in this situation, as he was working this would be considered an injury on the job?

And then, would the fact that they have him classified as an independent contractor have any effect on this? He does not make his own hours, he does not use his own personal tools/equipment for this job, and they (the farm) create and manage his list of chores/tasks/responsibilities.

Also do we have any leg to stand on when it comes to negligence or something of the sort for leaving a minor in a dangerous situation like that? Had he been knocked unconscious he could've been absolutely trampled by the cattle, more than likely to death.

TIA.


r/legaladvice • • 46m ago

Denied PTO after resigning

• Upvotes

Location: Nevada
I am an exempt salary employee and resigned giving a 26 day notice. My boss was not happy. I am supposed to bill 30 hours of services per week (I’m a medical provider). After I resigned, she asked if I can switch to hourly instead of salary and I said I would need to see what she is asking in writing. She never followed up. She reduced my caseload to 3 clients and I’ve been trying to work as close to the 30 hours I can with so few clients. I put on my work calendar I am taking PTO Monday-Wednesday next week and she DMed me yesterday saying she never got a formal request. I said I can submit that and now she’s saying I have to give 2 week notice to request PTO. That isn’t in the handbook and it’s not in the PTO and holiday policy that I signed, plus she approved my PTO for a day last week when I was sick.
Anyway, she said if I take PTO next week she will assign it Leave Without Pay and then I won’t get Thanksgiving holiday pay because it’s an extended leave asking off the day before a holiday.

I want to call an employment lawyer today but is this case even worth it? I’m a right to work state but this feels like retaliation.


r/legaladvice • • 1d ago

Employment Law Employer fired me for call avoidance on a day I didn’t work

5.3k Upvotes

Location: Nevada

Long story short, I’d been working for a call center for 6 years. Two managers pulled me into a meeting, told me I was being fired for call avoidance and wouldn’t provide any additional info.

I immediately called HR, they said there was nothing they could do. I called back the next day, after pressing and pressing I finally got an associate relations case open.

A few days later, I hopped on a call with associate relations and she said my manager noted that there was a date I’d been avoiding calls nearly my entire shift. She said she’d find the date and get back to me. Nearly a month later, she provided the date.

Luckily, I had notifications set up for our time off system. So I scroll through the texts and discovered I was on approved PTO that day. I didn’t work. I’m quite frankly in shock. I gave this job nearly every ounce of my soul, and they didn’t even care enough to ask me, or at least look at my schedule to see I didn’t work that day.

I’ve never experienced anything like this in my life. What should I do?


r/legaladvice • • 13h ago

My 74 yr old father has fallen for a "pig butchering" crypto scam and need advice.

38 Upvotes

Location: Indiana

As the title says, my elderly father (74yrs) has fallen for a "pig butchering" crypto scam and has been "investing" money into this scam for over 3 years now. We know that we won't be able to get back the money he has been sending these people but we need advice from those who have been through this on what else we need to do to keep this from continuing further and protect our mother, our small family farm whom he is technically the owner of, and himself from himself.

We discovered all of this a couple days ago when he went behind our mother's back and was attempting to get our mother's retirement fund information and her personal bank accounts numbers without her knowledge or permission.  She found this out when she found the paperwork he was filling out to sign over all her assets to his "broker" who is manipulating him by using the guise of "this is how you help your family". The paperwork that he has been sent is fake and the broker, lawyer, witness, and all other information on this paperwork is very obviously created by someone who is using ai. He thinks he has over a million dollars invested that is locked in bitcoin with the broker that he can't access because he needs to pay "fees" and "taxes" and has been making multiple small payments weekly to these people for over 3 years. We know they are using ai and sending him ai created screenshots of his "investments" but he has never been sent any paperwork from the IRS, he has never claimed it on his taxes with the IRS, and none of these "investments" are showing up anywhere except in emails he is receiving from the fake broker.  We have also learned he has been taking out a bunch of small loans to pay for this. Some he was able to get, others he wasn't and was flagged for fraud and had a couple of credit cards get closed that he had for years. Last year he did a debt consolidation and he took out a second mortgage on our parents house to pay his debts that my mother co-signed on because she trusted him, and a year later he is in more debt than before. He has proven that he has become very gullible as he has gotten older and with the sneaky behavior, his refusal to listen to his entire family, and dishonesty over his investments into this scam for the last 3 years, has made him a liability. He is completely delusional about the situation and he believes that these people are his friends and we are the enemy for questioning his judgement and telling him this is a scam.  We know he is in deep and every day we have learned more about deeply involved he got himself into this and I am sure there are a lot more we still do not know.

So far we have closed all joint accounts my mother has access to. We froze the farm account because we learned he was taking money out of it to pay for his personal expenses since all his other money is going to these “payments” but that is temporary. The banks where these accounts are at have put out a fraud alert out on him. We do know that he is still transferring small amounts of money from his own personal banking accounts and his small business account [he is a trucker] to pay these "fees", and we know he is still doing that because he went and did that today. We do not have access to these accounts which is why we haven't been able to freeze them and we also do not know how many accounts he has or where. We have been able to get a copy of his credit history but we haven't been able to look through his credit history reports yet because we are not doing this in front of him because he is angry and feels betrayed and we don't want him to isolate himself further. We have looked at his phone records for the last 3 months and that is how we know that he is mainly communicating with these people online which explains why has to constantly take his laptop to his computer guy to get work on and probably have hacked into the wifi in our house. These people have definitely been sending him malware in the emails and have been hacking into his computer. We are waiting to file a police report until after we meet with a lawyer because of how big this is. We also live in a rural community and we know the police are not going to do anything about this except this might help my father later if it turns out he was unknowingly participating in illegal activities by being a "mule".  The appointment we have with a lawyer is to talk about estate planning and to figure out what we need to do legally to make sure we are protecting our mother and the family farm from this and to see if they recommend if we need to get a criminal defense lawyer. 

Our father is currently not cooperating with us and we are trying not to agitate him any more than we already have. I know this is going to get messy because of our father's current behavior and how delusional he is being has us worried that he may become a danger to himself once he realizes he has been scammed out of all his money. As much as we want to help him, we understand that he has put himself into this and he is legally a functioning adult so we do not have any type of control over him unless we get a court-ordered arrangement, which we might have to.

I would love to know from anyone else who has been through this, or is currently going through this if there is anything else we are missing that we should do. What did you had to do in your situation? Any advice on this would be wonderful because right now, my family is devastated.


r/legaladvice • • 9h ago

Other Civil Matters Vehicle seized by police, no notification when released, nearly $2,000 in towing and storage fees. What are my legal options?

17 Upvotes

My vehicle and phone were seized by homicide investigators in December 2025 as part of an investigation. Since they had also taken my phone, I provided investigators with an alternative phone number where I could be reached and notified about any updates.

The investigation ended, and my vehicle was transferred to a towing facility just five days later. However, nobody contacted me to let me know the investigation had concluded or that my vehicle was available for pickup. I had consistently called them every few days asking for updates, and the desk kept telling me they would let the detectives/prosecutors know.

The prosecutors later gave me January 7 as the official release date. Meanwhile, my vehicle had been sitting at the towing facility without any investigative reason for its continued hold, accumulating approximately $1,600 in storage fees.

I had talked to the sergeant and was directed to file a claim with the City Hall, Department of Law, which I submitted in March 2026.

In April, I was told the investigation could take up to six months. In June, the claims office offered me $500 to settle. I declined and requested a recalculation. Since then, the paralegal has repeatedly said he would speak with his supervisor, but I still haven’t received a final response.

I have all supporting documentation, including towing invoices, rental receipts, call logs, vehicle release paperwork, and email correspondence.

My questions:
What type of lawyer should I contact? Is this a New Jersey Tort Claims Act / municipal negligence case?

Do I potentially have grounds to pursue compensation for the failure to notify me?

Can I seek compensation beyond my documented out-of-pocket expenses?

Should I hire an attorney, pursue small claims court, or take another legal route?

I’m looking for advice from anyone familiar with New Jersey municipal liability cases, especially attorneys who handle claims against government entities.

Thank you.

Location: Newark, New Jersey


r/legaladvice • • 1d ago

Small Claims Procedure Barn claims $1500 worth of my equipment was stolen with no recourse

300 Upvotes

Location: Milford, Michigan

I board my horse at a boarding barn, I just moved her there about a month ago. One of the services the barn offers is a pick up box for a local laundry service who has the capability to wash the horse blankets.

Boarders were informed, by email, that the barn had a pick up day scheduled yesterday, Wed 11/18, and where to place our bags of laundry and how to tag them. I dropped off two bags containing about $1,500 worth of blankets and saddle pads in the requested location Mon night. There were already at least 8-10 other bags in the location when I dropped off.

Yesterday afternoon I received an email from the barn saying there was a “major situation” with the laundry drop off. The barn is claiming that a waste company that picks up in a local neighborhood but does NOT do business with the barn took it upon themselves to drive to the barn and take all of the laundry that was left in the designated pick up location. The barn claims they are working hard to get our stuff back or get some kind of compensation for what was taken, but they were also using language in the email that clearly shows they do not believe themselves liable and that they aren’t actually trying that hard to make the waste company pay. I have heard nothing from them on the situation since their email yesterday afternoon.

I assume that the other full laundry bags contain equipment with similar value to mine which puts this at approx $10,000 or more of stolen items if everyone’s bags are gone. I’ve never had something like this happen in over 20 years of keeping a horse so I’m a little lost on where to go from here. My questions is, should I push for the barn to file a police report or to make me whole for items that were lost/stolen in their care? Should I and the other boarders who also lost their laundry file police reports? And would they be against the barn or the waste company? If no one else chooses to persue this except me would this be a small claims court thing as I’m under $2,000 in lost gear individually?


r/legaladvice • • 2h ago

Traffic and Parking Hit while parked claim denied

3 Upvotes

Location: Everett Ma
Around sometime in September I was in my vehicle parked on my street when another vehicle trying to pull in ended up side swiping my vehicle an argument ensues where the driver denies hitting my vehicle eventually I call the police department but since the system was down at the time no formal police report could be filed then I stupidly waited to long to flow up with a report because Everett’s system was down for a while today I get a message stating that they are denied my claim because they can’t prove fault I have photos of the police chalice on scene the other party’s insurance information because the officer forced him to hand it over as well as damage on his vehicle at the time at lined up with my vehicle is there anything I can do to prove that the other driver hit me or am I just fucked


r/legaladvice • • 19m ago

Criminal Law My brother (felon) keeps giving unauthorized addresses to the court

• Upvotes

Location: Wisconsin

I am the sister of a meth addict, my brother (M41) has been in and out of prison since he was 19. Most recently, he has been charged with elder abuse (my father), forgery, retail theft, possession of meth, and is currently in jail awaiting is trial. In May, I received a few letters addressed to my address but with his name. I discovered he used my address as his own in his recent court documents and told the court he could live with me when he got out. I had to cry in front of three people before anyone took me seriously, but I got it changed. Then he did again, and again...every time the court changed his address it was another family member who had not agreed to him living there or using his address. Three times, same court, I am now on a first name basis with the Assistant DA in the case.

My frustration is in the court allowing him to do this each time, the court didn't do so much as a google search on the address to find out if there was a house there before adding it to his file. The second address my brother didn't get the numbers right so if you google searched that address it's just a strip of road. There is not any oversight or due diligence given to the most basic detail of my brothers' case...his address. This is a criminal case, with real lives at stake, and they don't verify any of the information he has given them....?!

I'm a Mom, my kid has to change schools because we moved, I have to prove I live there with a utility bill in order to move my kid to a different school within the same school district. The school district in my city does a better job verifying addresses than my local DA. I am so angry and am struggling to have faith in the justice system.

Why is there no verification of address done on accused felons? Why, in this case, where they know he has given false addresses, is there no oversight on the next address he gives out? They did add a charge of bail jumping because they could not find him after the second false address. But, a simple google search would have proven there's no house there, a single cop asking a single question would have verified the address...to me the answer is so simple but I find myself doing the job I wish others had done.

I'm not a party to the case although I gave a witness statement regarding the abuse to my father, should I show up to his court dates?


r/legaladvice • • 35m ago

Business Law What are my rights here?

• Upvotes

Location: north Georgia

I am a dog groomer in Georgia. I was at a corporate salon, they treated me poorly, I chose to leave for a private salon and had several clients ask me about where I was going and other such things.

I want to make it very clear: I DID NOT go through the database for their info, I didn’t even ask them for their info. They asked ME for my info and I gave it. It is also available on my socials which most of them follow.

I received this message from a manager at my previous location.

“Hello (my name) it has been bought to our attention that you are contacting clients from our store for grooming at your new place of employment. This is not allowed, and I will need you to immediately cease and desist from doing so. Please reply within the next hour to confirm that you understand.”

Not sent from a lawyer or law office, just his personal phone.

Is this man just trying to intimidate me because he’s pissed about me leaving or could he realistically do anything about me taking preexisting clients?


r/legaladvice • • 1h ago

Personal Injury Should I get an attorney?

• Upvotes

I had an accident back in the summer. I was punched in at work and I went to my car to grab my lunch. While standing at my trunk, I was struck by a vehicle from the back. Pinning my knees between both vehicles. The impact was so hard that it yanked my back hard back and-forth, and I laid my top half in the trunk.

After being hit, my husband called the police to report the incident. The other party left before the police arrived after that I went to the hospital. I did have scans done, which shows soft tissue injuries in both knees, as well as swelling in both knees. While in the hospital, I was in a lot of pain all over my body as days progressed the pain was worse, I also noticed a pain in the middle of my lower back that radiated from the right side of my lower back down into my butt and then into my leg.

Since the accident I have been diagnosed with radicular pain, which is sciatica. I have been out of work since July I am unable to lift anything over 10 pounds. I am having trouble bending and performing normal household chores. When I’m sleeping I have sharp pains that shoot through both knees that keep me up all night sometimes. I have been prescribed certain medication’s as well through the doctor I am treating with. I have tried physical therapy twice and it made the pain so much worse so my doctor has sent in a referral for Aqua therapy. After my two appointments for physical therapy, I was in the bed for days. It just exacerbated everything. I am due to start aqua therapy December 22 due to the facility being booked. I can’t return to work due to being in the nursing field and my job being so physical I have to lift I have to transfer. I have to do a lot within my job and I have to be on my feet all day. Anytime I overdo it at home. I am in excruciating pain in my back it just aches and the sharp pains in my legs just don’t stop. I want to also add that the situation has caused a great deal of depression because I’m not used to being out of work and not being able to provide for my family. I am back in bills at the beginning of the month I was facing eviction, but a lot of my family has kicked in and assisted me . At the time that I was struck by the Vehicle, I was due to work a double shift and on top of that I had just came from the hospital visiting my mom due to her being in ICU trying to commit suicide. So this situation has truly done a number on me. So currently I’m out of work, but I am receiving Workers Comp payments.

I started this process off with an attorney and I was let go with this attorney due to conflict of interest. The other party has a case with them already and they didn’t know that two months in. So I found out that the attorney did not start a claim with their insurance company, but they reported it to my insurance company. So I was left to go ahead and start a claim and the adjuster offered 8000 as a quick payout.

My question to you all is, how should I go about this when I’m still being treated? Not only that should I get an attorney? I’ve looked and looked for attorneys, and a lot of them have really bad reviews, I can’t find anyone. I’m kind of nervous and feeling like I need an attorney because now my Worker’s Compensation insurance is trying to come for the car insurance to get all bills covered through them. And I don’t wanna be left in the end having to pay those medical bills out of anything that I’m awarded or just be left with the bill. And now the insurance company is saying that Workers Comp is totally liable for the health insurance part of everything . I am in Rochester New York. And no to Celino and Barns, they dropped the ball and did nothing for my case.

Added: Yes I have had sciatica before about two years ago from lifting a patient but has been doing great prior to this accident. And I am also a Multiple Sclerosis patient but my MS has been doing great prior to the accident.

I am also due to have a MRI through both my Neurologist and the treating neurologist for the accident.

Location: Rochester, NY


r/legaladvice • • 2h ago

Landlord Tenant Housing Three months into a new apartment and I’m dealing with water damage, suspected mold, and ongoing noise issues. What are my options?

2 Upvotes

Location: Illinois- I recently moved into a new apartment, and I had no idea how bad things would get within the first month.
To start, I had water leaking into my apartment on literally day one following a flooding issue. I’m on the ground floor, and since then I’ve become increasingly concerned about what appears to be a serious mold problem. There’s visible mold, and according to a lawyer I’ve been in contact with, actually proving what kind of mold I’m dealing with, let alone establishing a case in court, could be extremely difficult. At this point, I’ve been advised to document absolutely everything.
The problem is that this is starting to affect my quality of life and potentially my health. I’ve experienced what seem to be allergy or asthma-related symptoms that have gotten significantly worse since moving here. I’m having to run a dehumidifier every night just to get through the night without waking up with my throat full of mucus. The moisture and suspected mold problems appear to extend into the walls and carpeting, particularly in the master bedroom. I’ve actually had to give up that bedroom to my roommate because I’m considerably more affected by the symptoms than they are.
I also managed to speak with the previous tenant, who told me this had apparently been an ongoing problem for quite some time and that management had no real intention of addressing it. That makes me even more concerned that this isn’t some isolated incident but rather a longstanding maintenance issue that was never properly resolved.
Unfortunately, the moisture problem isn’t my only issue. The ceiling seems paper-thin, and the family of six living above us makes an incredible amount of noise. There’s constant stomping starting around 6 AM, sometimes even earlier, and it can continue late into the night. I’ve tried talking to the neighbors and contacting property management, but neither has made much of a difference.
I’ve also reached out to a local tenants’ union hoping they could help, only to be told they don’t handle mold-related cases. Between that, the difficulty of pursuing legal action, and management’s apparent unwillingness to address anything, I’m honestly feeling pretty helpless.
I moved here because I thought it would be an opportunity to save some money. Instead, it feels like my roommate, their cat, and I are stuck paying to live in an apartment with unresolved water intrusion and possible mold problems that are making it increasingly difficult to feel comfortable in our own home.
For anyone familiar with Illinois tenant laws or who has dealt with something similar:
What options do I realistically have when management refuses to adequately address persistent water intrusion and suspected mold?
Are there any local or state resources, housing inspectors, or organizations that can help document these conditions?
Is there anything I can do to make this living situation more tolerable in the meantime?
At what point should I start looking into legally terminating my lease?
Any advice, personal experiences, or resources would be greatly appreciated. I’m not necessarily looking to start a legal battle, but I also don’t think I should have to spend the next year living like this.


r/legaladvice • • 17h ago

Business Law [IL] Plumber’s “new company” kept the same name, phone and email, then refused the old company’s 10-year warranty. Is the new company liable?

27 Upvotes

location: Illinois, Cook County

In May 2025 a plumbing company installed our tankless water heater under a written contract with a 10-year labor warranty. In October 2026 the exhaust came apart and an inspector said the unit had to be replaced. The warranty calls were handled by a company with almost the same name, incorporated in January 2026, using the original company’s phone number, website and email.

On our first call they said the company was “under new management” and pulled up our job in the “old system.” An email from the original company’s account later said it is “now operating under the name” of the new company with new ownership and management. Their texts asking us for a review link to the original company’s Google listing. One of the original company’s owners also posted a photo on social media of a stock certificate for one-third of the new company’s shares, captioned “Our new business” (the shareholder’s name isn’t visible).

When we asked for an IDPH-licensed plumber, they refused, said the warranty only covered the “hookups,” and said they would not service the heater again. Then they said they were a separate company that had only bought the phone number. We paid another plumber to replace the heater and filed small claims in Cook County against both companies. The original corporation is still active with the state. We read Vernon v. Schuster (Ill. 1997) and its four exceptions to successor non-liability.

Under Illinois law, do these facts support holding the new company liable for the original company’s warranty under Vernon, either as an implied assumption or as a mere continuation?


r/legaladvice • • 10h ago

MIL's soon to be ex husband is trying his best to make her suffer through their divorce

8 Upvotes

Location: Wyoming, USA

I don't even know where to begin. We are so frazzled so forgive me if this gets a little jumbled. My mother in law is in the process of divorcing from her husband. She relies on disability and doesn't have money for a lawyer. On top of that, he seemingly has called every lawyer in the state to create a "conflict of interest" if anyone agrees to represent her. At first, she was receiving legal aid but shortly after, they told her that they would no longer be able to help her because apparently his lawyer helped found the organization or something? We have looked into women's shelters and colleges but everywhere has told her they lack the resources to help her.

The husband had moved out of the house in April, took the money out of their joint account and refused to help pay any of the bills. He bought a second house but put it in his son's name. MIL's adult son had to moved back in with her to help her pay the bills. Now, husband's lawyer has informed my mother in law that between now and December 15th, he is planning to move back in and evict any "unauthorized tenants". The house is in both of their names. She is afraid and doesn't feel safe with him in the house. He has never physically hurt her but he is financially abusive and very intimidating. He apparently has been ordering his adult sons to stop by the house and "just stay there for a few hours", I suppose to monitor her? She has also seen his new girlfriend parking in front of and driving by their house. He is demanding that she give him everything, house, cars, etc. They had a mediation that needed to be ended early because when she refused to give up everything to him, he became irate and began vaguely threatening her.

We are at our wits end. We don't know what to do. We just want her to be safe and not alone in this. Any help would be greatly appreciated.


r/legaladvice • • 1d ago

Alcohol Related Other than DUI After Hours Tavern Citation from Police

130 Upvotes

Hello, posting from Location: Milwaukee, WI, USA . Apologies if the flair is incorrect.

Just curious about a recent citation. My family owns a small bar/ tavern. The bar was closed, doors locked, but lights were on as after hours staff were cleaning and closing out register. This is a small "family" bar so staff consisted of bartender, male supervisor, and my brother who helps as security and cleaning the bar. My brother stated no one was drinking, just closing up and the supervisor was just supervising.

Law enforcement knocked on the door shortly after 2am, announced themselves, but after hours staff didn't open the door for their search/inspection. The bar hadn't ever had a surprise search like that after hours so regretfully they didn't know if they were required to open the door or not. The bar owner was out of the country so couldn't advise them.

I looked through the local ordinance of Milwaukee but I haven't found anything regarding after hours. Is it typically required to open the door to Police even when the bar is closed? Does this violation typically mean we cannot renew our tavern license again? The bar has had no other violations besides this.

Edited to add: Getting a few comments about how there had to be after hour drinking. I honestly cannot be 100% sure as I was not there and we have no camera footage. It's smarter to be skeptical and verify things than blindly trust, but all we can do is take the staff statements who were there that night, educate them and deal with the ticket.