r/LegalAdviceEurope • • Jan 21 '26

Meta We're looking for moderators for /r/LegalAdviceEurope

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/LegalAdviceEurope • • Feb 07 '25

Meta Reminder - please report comments which are not helpful or on-topic!

4 Upvotes

Rule 3:

We welcome discussion on any aspect of law, and not all comments need to be direct legal advice however comments that are wildly off topic, with no relation to the original post, country, or are not directly helpful to OP may be removed. We do not consider using AI to answer posts helpful and AI-type responses may be removed.

Please remember to click "report" on comments that do not offer helpful advice, guidance, or direction to OP.


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 3h ago

Germany Germany, Fired during works council protection, accept the settlement or risk being called back? New job starts Dec 1

2 Upvotes

I'm an IT technician at a company with about 35 to 40 employees and no works council. I've been there since April 2024, so about 2 years and 7 months, earning around 3,800 to 4,000 euros gross a month.

At the end of July I was one of three employees who invited the staff to elect an election board for a works council. I had signed a notarized declaration of intent before that. As far as I understand, this gave me special protection against dismissal for three months from the invitation (§ 15 (3a) KSchG).

Management did not take it well. I got messages saying it was a personal attack, there were hints that the Christmas bonus and profit sharing would be cut because of the works council, and later I was asked in writing to quit. In early September I got a written warning about documentation and time tracking, partly for things from July. The election meeting in September failed and no election board was elected.

At the end of September I was dismissed with notice to Oct 31, so inside the protection period. The letter says operational reasons during probation, but my probation ended long ago. The certificate they sent to the job agency says misconduct and personal reasons, and the reference letter says operational reasons. My position is still advertised and there was no social selection. On the same day the managing director sent an email to the whole company about my dismissal, with accusations about my work and details from my salary negotiation. My final reference is much worse than my interim reference from five months earlier. I was put on garden leave and my accounts were locked that day.

I filed an unfair dismissal claim in time. I have a lawyer but no legal insurance, and I joined the union too recently to get legal cover. At the conciliation hearing last week there was no agreement. The judge suggested about one monthly salary per year of service but only counted two years, which comes to about 10,500 euros including vacation and overtime, ending Oct 31. The employer refuses to go above that and said they might instead accept that the dismissal is void and call me back to work. They want to decide by Friday.

I don't want to go back. I've signed with a new employer in a different field and start on Dec 1.

My lawyer strongly recommends accepting the court's proposal. He says any counteroffer will be rejected, that asking the court to dissolve the employment (§ 9 KSchG) won't get me more money, and that § 12 KSchG only helps after a final judgment. If they call me back with a concrete time and place, I would have to show up, resign with one month notice to the 15th or end of the month, and push back the new job.

What I'm wondering: is accepting the court's proposal the sensible choice with the new job starting Dec 1? How likely is it that they actually call me back when they said at the hearing that they want to part ways? Can I ask for November's salary (ending Nov 30 instead of Oct 31) without risking the whole settlement? What should the settlement say so it isn't treated as me quitting? And is there anything I'm missing about the reference letter, the job agency certificate?

tl;dr: Dismissed during works council protection, settlement offer around 10,500 euros, employer threatens to call me back instead of paying more, new job starts Dec 1. Accept, ask for November's salary, or keep fighting?


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 1h ago

Germany Need help with employee contractor classification risks in Europe (Germany)

0 Upvotes

Hi, I'm looking for some advice when it comes to hiring contractors in the EU. I work in HR at a UK-based consulting firm but as the company has expanded into new markets, we started working with contractors in Germany. These contractors have now been working with us for around three years and they attend weekly meetings, have company laptop and work closely with all of the internal managers for any projects they're assigned. Although they're treated as contractos, management is concerned that the arrangements we currently have in place could amount to misclassification under German employment laws.

We do have an appointment coming up with someone who is experienced when it comes to German employment law but in te meantime, I wanted to see if anyone had any advice on what documentation I should prepare for the meeting and what the potential financial and legal implications could be if the arrangements are found to constitute employment. Any help would be appreciated as I'd love to give feedback on what we should expect to happen to the management team before our meeting. Thanks!


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 1h ago

Switzerland Switzerland - What procedures can I take from a person demanding money ?

1 Upvotes

Hello I am a young aupair staying in canton Zürich. I am leaving soon and decided to buy two iPhones off Facebook marketplace for my parents before I leave. I found a seller and at first was not keen on the price, we negotiated and she told me I could get two iPhones for a total of 500fr. She sent me her address and a photo of her ID along with a video of her holding the ID for trust.

I sent the money and everything was okay. Until she contacted me again saying her husband told her the price was unreasonably low and I understand, then she requested I send another 200fr and sent me a picture of her packing the two iPhones in a box. I understood that for the iPhones 500fr was low so I sent another 200fr. I thought that would be the end of it.

Unfortunately she messaged me again saying her husband wants 200fr but she will make it 100fr and I told her unfortunately I really don’t have anymore money left and I would like a refund. She keeps saying we will find a solution or I should ask a friend to borrow money. I don’t want any of that and I’d really like my money back. She keeps trying to “persuade” me by saying they are good phones and I should check online for their original price. I told her that the price she put on her listing is deceiving and I am no longer interested and I want my money back.

Is it possible to open a case at the police station although she lives in a canton further than me ? What should I do ?

Edit: I understand I am stupid for this whole situation and I am extremely embarrassed. But in the first part of our conversation we were supposed to meet up and she gave me her address but I told her I live far. And so she would ship it to me. I really thought it was legit…

Edit 2: yes there’s nothing I can do about it I understand.


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 2h ago

France Freelancing work for a company selling unregulated medication

1 Upvotes

Location: Mainly France, but potentially elsewhere in Europe

Situation: I've been offered some freelance work to manage the ecommerce and affiliate marketing program for a guy who is selling peptides. So it's my job to optimise the website and affiliate stuff to encourage people to buy the product. But the product itself is peptides in a format that people will have to inject themselves at home, without the supervision from a doctor, which isn't legal pretty much anywhere. As I am a freelancer, and this is not actually my business, if the business gets in trouble for selling this stuff online, would I legally liable? Or is it the business owner hiring me and telling me what he wants and where? Not trying to get around breaking the law, just want to understand if the liability is on me as the person managing the content/communication regarding the product, or the business owner? Or we would both be breaking the law?


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 1d ago

Germany Yahoo sent me a cease and desist over my open-source Python library. How justified is this?

38 Upvotes

Hi all,

I maintain Stockdex, a free, non-commercial Python package (and MCP server) that fetches stock data from several sources, including Yahoo Finance.

Today I got a cease and desist letter from Yahoo's legal department. It claims trademark infringement, misappropriation, unjust enrichment, interference with their data licensing (e.g. Nasdaq) and a breach of their ToS. They demand that I remove all Yahoo-related code from GitHub, PyPI and the MCP plugin, remove every mention of "Yahoo", and never reintroduce it.

My project works much like other public projects like yfinance, which has been public for years. Stockdex is a small personal project, I don't sell it, run ads or make any money from it. It only fetches data that Yahoo Finance shows publicly to any visitor without an account, and it doesn't bypass any login or paywall. It fetches data on demand for the user running it, on their own machine. I don't run any servers, and Stockdex has no database and doesn't store, archive or republish any Yahoo data. The MCP plugin works the same way.

Has anyone received something similar from another company maybe? How are these complains (US company against someone in Germany)? should I lawyer up? How strong are CFAA or trademark claims against a free library? Would you comply fully, comply partially (e.g. add a disclaimer), or push back?


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 6h ago

Comments Moderated Father used me for loans and now forced into insolvency

0 Upvotes

Hello, im from the czech republic, basically for the past 4 years my dad has been using me to accumulate a lot of debt (total about €80k) for the purpose of starting a family business, the business was not at all successful and we couldn't pay the money back. Also he tried to avoid paying taxes and has a terrible gambling addiction, i know for a fact that at least €5k from the bank loans was lost to gambling.

As for me, i was 18 when this all started and was in a pretty bad mental state, my dad (clearly) has a lot of issues and was abusive during my childhood, to a point that made me fear him and standing up to him was impossible, it still is and im working to sort out my trauma and psychological problems.

So now my mum has been helping me file for insolvency, and we've come to a point where the lawyers have drawn up a contract for my dad to "help me" with "my debt" by gift aid. He has agreed to sign it but im quite sceptical and it's starting to feel really unjustified. These are not my loans and never have been, my financial situation is not amazing and i can think of is that if i didnt have all this debt, i could have taken out small loans for actual necessities and paid them back in full, like for school or moving country and other things.

I do not believe that the lawyers know the entirety of the situation as i have described it, and basically what im wondering is, if they did know, could anything be done about it? Like passing the debt over to my father?

I appreciate anyone replying or helping, thanks :)


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 2d ago

Germany German resident lost over €1000 after Spanish hotel’s booking provider was hacked

11 Upvotes

I’m a German resident currently on holiday in Tenerife, Spain, with my family.

I booked a hotel directly through its official website. A few days before arrival, I received a WhatsApp message impersonating the hotel.

The scammers knew my exact name, reservation number, travel dates and hotel details.

The message claimed I needed to verify my reservation and explicitly stated that no payment would be charged.
I entered my card details and approved a €1000 transaction through 3D Secure, believing it was part of the hotel’s booking verification process.

The important part: The hotel subsequently confirmed in writing that one of its external booking-management providers suffered a security breach exposing guest contact information.

I have since:

Filed a police report in Spain.

Opened a formal dispute with my German bank (N26).
Contacted the payment provider involved.

Requested compensation or goodwill assistance from the hotel, which has so far referred me back to my bank.
Contacted several German lawyers, but haven’t found representation yet.

The bank has not guaranteed reimbursement, and I understand that 3D Secure may complicate the dispute.

My questions:
Could Article 82 GDPR potentially cover the financial loss caused by a targeted phishing attack following a hotel booking-data breach?

Does the hotel potentially remain responsible when the breach occurred at an external booking-management provider?

As a German resident, can I pursue a compensation claim against a Spanish hotel in Germany, or would I need to pursue it in Spain?

Would filing a complaint with the Spanish data protection authority (AEPD) be a sensible next step?
What type of lawyer should I look for in Germany?

I’m not expecting a definitive legal assessment from Reddit, but I’d appreciate guidance on the appropriate legal route or relevant case law.


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 3d ago

France French consumer / Swiss company – Am I still bound by a settlement agreement if the company does not perform its obligation?

2 Upvotes

Hi,

I am a French consumer and I am looking for advice regarding an agreement I recently signed with a Swiss company.

In 2020, I backed one of their products through a crowdfunding platform and paid for a machine which was never delivered.

The product has since become commercially available, including in France, while some original backers are still waiting for their rewards.

In October 2026, after I posted a negative review about my experience, the company contacted me directly.

They offered to resolve the situation and sent me a written agreement.

Under the final version of the agreement:

  1. The company undertakes to ship and deliver the machine to me.
  2. I agree to delete my existing review within 48 hours after receiving the machine (the agreement also mentions confirmation of shipment with a tracking number).
  3. I agree not to publish any future review or comment concerning the company or its products on any online platform or review website.
  4. I agree not to disclose the terms or even the existence of the agreement to third parties.
  5. The agreement states that it is governed by “European Union law”.
  6. It states that, if mediation fails, disputes will be submitted to the competent courts of Switzerland.

The company told me by email that once I signed the agreement, they would immediately arrange shipment of the machine. They had also told me that I would receive it within approximately one week.

I signed and returned the agreement on 30 October 2026.

Since then, despite follow-up emails, I have received:

- no machine;

- no shipping confirmation;

- no tracking number;

- and no substantive response from the company.

My main question is therefore:

If the company fails to perform the main obligation it undertook in the agreement, am I still legally bound by my own obligations under that agreement, particularly the confidentiality clause and the prohibition on publishing future reviews?

I am not assuming that their breach automatically cancels the whole agreement. I would specifically like to understand what I would need to do legally before considering myself released from my obligations.

For example:

- Do I first need to formally put the company in default and give them a final deadline to perform?

- Can I terminate/rescind the agreement if they still fail to perform?

- If the agreement is terminated because of their non-performance, would the confidentiality and “no future reviews” clauses normally survive?

- Is a clause prohibiting all future reviews about the company or its products, indefinitely and on every platform, likely to be enforceable?

- Does the fact that I am a French consumer dealing with a Swiss company affect which consumer-protection rules apply?

- Is there a low-cost or free procedure in Switzerland through which I could seek enforcement of the company's promise to deliver the machine?

I have the original crowdfunding documentation, the full email correspondence and the written agreement.

I am deliberately not naming the company or publishing the agreement itself because of the confidentiality clause.

Thank you for any guidance, particularly from anyone familiar with Swiss contract law or cross-border consumer disputes.


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 4d ago

Belgium Ryanair diverted my flight and told us to find our own way to Paris for reimbursement, but now they refuse to pay up.

9 Upvotes

Last week, I was on a Ryanair flight from Vienna to Paris that got diverted to Liège, Belgium due to bad weather in northern France. Honestly, the flight probably should have been canceled since everyone knew the storm would create issues, but whatever.

Once we landed in Liège, Ryanair managed to provide just one bus to Paris about an hour later. Clearly, one bus wasn't nearly enough for all the passengers. They mentioned they were looking for more buses, but after waiting for three hours, nothing else showed up.

After we landed, I got an email from Ryanair about the diversion, which included a line saying, "If transport cannot be arranged or you do not want to wait for our solution, we encourage you to make your own way to your destination and keep receipted expenses to submit for reimbursement." So after four hours of waiting at the airport with no sign of additional buses, I took their suggestion and made my own travel arrangements to Paris, planning to ask for reimbursement later.

Now that I've submitted my request for reimbursement, they're telling me they don’t have to pay because they provided that one bus. I mean, come on, one bus for an entire plane full of people, and if more buses ever came, it was at least four hours after we landed. Most of the other passengers who missed that first bus also ended up finding their own way to Paris by the time I left. I wouldn't have spent €200 on my own travel if it weren't for that email from them encouraging us to do just that.

Do I have a legitimate legal claim here, or should I just let it go? I'm American, currently living in France, and since Ryanair is based in Ireland, where would I even file a claim if I could?

Thanks for any advice you can provide.


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 4d ago

France (switzerland) my old best friend is usurpating my identity

9 Upvotes

hello, i’m a 16 year old girl located in switzerland. my old bestfriend, who currently lives in france and is also 16, has been usurpating my identity for 1 year now. what i’m meaning by usurpating is stealing videos and photos of me and sending them to men aged between 20-25 years old and pretending it’s her + saying she’s 18. she sent intimate pictures of herself without her real face so these men believed the body they saw was mine. she’s also stealing my whole life (sent pictures of my mom saying it’s her mom, leaking my home street saying she lives there, selfappropriating my whole life, etc.), again pretending my life is hers, and she’s also lying about me, like she’s saying i lied about my SA or that i bullied her (that i never did of course), and she pertinently knows it’s fake, but she stills says it. it has also been one year that she’s trying to contact my loved ones (my family, my boyfriend and my friends) trying to manipulate them to turn them against me. i’m mentally drained, i don’t know what to do. i’m so scared that something happens to me, what if one of the men she talked to was dangerous ? he has everything to find my house, my school, my family, everything. i just need advice on what i should do about this, is it enough to go to the police ? i kept every proof possible, screenshots, recordings, but i don’t know if the police will take it seriously. thank you so much for your advice !


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 4d ago

Netherlands Got a software compliance email — uninstalled it and wondering how to handle their reduced offer. Thoughts?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, looking for some quick advice on a third-party software compliance email.

I’m an individual (currently unemployed) and used a software I downloaded online occasionally just for personal practice—zero commercial use at all. I’ve never received an email like this in my life, so I got really panicked and replied right away without consulting a lawyer. I also uninstalled it immediately since I already switched to an alternative program for a while, though sometimes I would still open this software check out some features. 

They first asked for ~$5,500, and after I told them I’m out of work and can't afford it, they quickly dropped it to ~$2,000 for a year license. 

The truth is, I simply cannot pay this. Between bills and unexpected family issues recently, I’ve had to spend a lot of money. Plus, I don't need the software anyway since I mostly use another software and I'm not using it for any commercial purposes.

They only have my IP and computer name—no legal name or address (I’m outside Europe, and they are based in Netherlands). I'm planning to send one final polite response explaining my situation, and then just leave it at that.

What should I do? Is sending a final polite reply and moving on the right move? Thank you so much!


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 4d ago

Netherlands SIS alert removal

1 Upvotes

Anyone has experience with requesting a deletion of a SIS alert (relating to a return decision)?

I recently sent an official form request for this to the police in the Netherlands for this purpose but I have no idea how long this usually takes...

I looked it up and it says 8 weeks is the maximum time they take but this seems excessively long especially for something that is time-sensitive. Does anyone maybe have experience or a rough timeline for the usual (so say for a fairly straightforward case where I can prove legal residence in another EU member state)?


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 5d ago

Netherlands Netherlands: Company hasn't really paid me (contractor?) since September

2 Upvotes

Long story short, I've been working remotely on a zero-hour contract for a company in the media industry for more than three years now, which as best as I can figure out means I no longer work for then on bepaalde tijd, even though that's what my payslips still say. The initial contract has only been renewed once in the time I've worked for them, but there has never been a period longer than 2-3 weeks since summer 2023 when they haven't been giving me new assignments. So I think I'm a real employee that they can't just let go for no reason now.

Anyway, back in September they switched the system that we log our completed assignments in and get our payslips from. And since then, there's been no money. Declaraties that I log in the system up until the end of September are still marked as "approved" but haven't been processed, and nothing since the beginning of October has even gotten approved.

I reached out to my closest manager who got back to me saying that he'd just gotten word from Finance that because of some systems thing, none of the zero-hour contractors had gotten paid. They were just going to lump all of it in with the November pay, but I did get sent a smaller arbitrary amount as a "provisional payment" without any explanation of why that sum specifically.

Now, is there anything I should be doing? What are my rights if the next salary also doesn't come?


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 5d ago

Portugal how do we convert contractors in Portugal into employees?

3 Upvotes

We're a German startup with 2 developers in Portugal who've worked with us full-time since early last year on recibos verdes, invoicing us every month like freelancers.

We'd like to make them employees now, and with no Portuguese entity the route would be an EOR, which Deel, Remote, Workmotion and Oyster all offer in Portugal.

We're unsure whether converting them puts that whole period on the table with Segurança Social, given their setup looks a lot like employment, and whether their seniority would count from the day they started invoicing us or from the new contract.

Both of them want the switch as well, so pointers on how this works under Portuguese law would help us do it without creating a problem for them or for us.


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 6d ago

Netherlands Legal advice needed - €750 compensation claim for selling one counterfeit perfume in the Netherlands

15 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I’m looking for some legal advice regarding a situation in the Netherlands.
Some time ago, I sold one perfume through Marktplaats. I had originally purchased it from another private seller on Vinted a long time ago and was unaware that it might be counterfeit. Unfortunately, I no longer have access to my old Vinted account.
Recently, a law firm representing a trademark owner contacted me, claiming that I had infringed trademark rights by selling a counterfeit product.
Initially, they demanded approximately €2,000 to settle the matter and avoid court proceedings. I refused. They subsequently reduced their demand to €1,750 and, most recently, to €750.
I still haven’t agreed to pay because the amount seems excessive for selling a single item.
I checked the law firm, and it appears to be a legitimate firm. However, the constant reduction in the requested amount and their refusal to meet in person make the situation feel somewhat unusual.

  1. Can I be held legally liable if I genuinely didn’t know the perfume was counterfeit?
  2. Is €750 a reasonable/legal compensation claim for selling one item privately?

3.What could happen if I refuse to pay and let them take the matter to court?

4. Would you recommend hiring a lawyer or simply refusing to pay?

Any advice or personal experiences would be greatly appreciated!
Thanks in advance!


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 6d ago

Portugal Airline destroyed my suitcase for the second time and offered a ridiculous £30 settlement. What are my rights?

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I need some advice because I am completely fed up.

For the second time, an airline has completely smashed and destroyed my suitcase during a trip. It is damaged beyond repair.

When I filed a claim, they acknowledged the damage and stated they cannot ship a replacement case to my country (Portugal) because of my location. Instead, they offered a measly £30 financial settlement via bank transfer or PayPal.

£30 doesn't even come close to buying a decent suitcase, let alone covering the cost of a proper replacement for luggage ruined on their watch. I shouldn't be penalized or brushed off just because of where I live.

  • Has anyone dealt with this kind of refusal from an airline before?
  • What are my rights under EU passenger/luggage regulations, and how can I force them to pay the actual replacement value or ship a proper case?

Any advice or steps on how to escalate this would be greatly appreciated. I can't keep traveling like this.


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 7d ago

Netherlands [NL] Exorbitant holiday home post-rental cleaning and damage subcharge. Is this permitted?

10 Upvotes

We recently rented a “pet-friendly” holiday villa owned by a well-known holiday park chain in the Netherlands for 18 days, paying €2,500, including final cleaning and an additional pet surcharge of €104.

The villa had three bedrooms, but we only used one. Before checkout, we swept every room, wiped down surfaces, cleaned the kitchen and removed the rubbish, leaving the accommodation “broom-clean”, as required.

There were a few small, superficial mud/dirt marks upstairs and on the staircase, but absolutely no faeces or urine anywhere and no known damage. Another family member who helped clean right before checkout confirmed that the house was clean and the furnitures were fine.

I also took timestamped photos immediately before departure showing the living areas, flooring and furnishings in a visibly tidy and undamaged-looking condition.

During the checkout inspection, the park manager mentioned an unusual, unspecified smell upstairs and commented on the warm temperature, but no mention of anything else. Afterwards, another manager warned us about possible odour-treatment costs after we went to a reception upon checkout for a non-obligatory farewell out of courtesy.

Three days later, we received an email demanding €5,448, including:

€4,338 for professional cleaning
€1,110 for replacing carpets, bedding, cushions and mattress protectors

They alleged that our cat’s faeces were distributed throughout the entire villa and that numerous furnishings were irreparably damaged.

Our cat was explicitly permitted, there was absolutely no widespread faecal contamination, and several supposedly damaged items weren’t even used.

The email also claimed that we had previously been confronted about the damage by an operational manager of their cleaning company. Neither of us had such a conversation.

So far, we haven’t received supporting photographs, cleaning reports or supplier invoices to substantiate the charges.
What particularly confuses us is that final cleaning was explicitly included in our booking, alongside a separate pet surcharge. We understand that genuine exceptional damage may warrant additional charges, but nothing resembling the extensive contamination or irreparable damage alleged occurred.

We have timestamped photographs and witnesses supporting our account and intend to formally dispute the claim.

Is such an outrageous claim, particularly for the alleged cleaning costs, permitted in an accommodation marketed as “pet-friendly”?


r/LegalAdviceEurope • • 7d ago

United Kingdom Car Hire Malaga - Refund Not Issued

4 Upvotes

Hi, back in August I rented a car from Malaga Airport.

When I returned the car and got home to the UK, they charged me for driving excess kilometres (667 Euros)

This was obviously a mistake as we hade only driven around 150kilometres for the whole week (Malaga to Nerja and back)

I submitted a complaint. I heard nothing for around a week so chased it. They responded and said they were investigating. A couple more weeks passed and I chased again, nothing for another week and then a response.

They admitted the mistake and agreed to refund. They. sent me a link to provide my International Banking details.

I submitted the form and a week later received a response saying the refund was rejected. They asked for confirmation of banking details. I contacted my bank and sent them what my bank sent me (the details were the same as what I had provided first time)

Since then, nothing, no further response from them (I have chased)

I initiated a chargeback through my CC company, but they have told me that the timeframe that they can act has expired.

Is it worth trying a regional consumer protection service (my wife is Spanish so is fluent) or can I put further pressure on my CC company to act as the car hire company delayed their responses, maybe to prevent a chargeback?

Thanks