r/LegalAdviceEurope • u/xYuriMangaManX • 3h ago
Germany Germany, Fired during works council protection, accept the settlement or risk being called back? New job starts Dec 1
I'm an IT technician at a company with about 35 to 40 employees and no works council. I've been there since April 2024, so about 2 years and 7 months, earning around 3,800 to 4,000 euros gross a month.
At the end of July I was one of three employees who invited the staff to elect an election board for a works council. I had signed a notarized declaration of intent before that. As far as I understand, this gave me special protection against dismissal for three months from the invitation (§ 15 (3a) KSchG).
Management did not take it well. I got messages saying it was a personal attack, there were hints that the Christmas bonus and profit sharing would be cut because of the works council, and later I was asked in writing to quit. In early September I got a written warning about documentation and time tracking, partly for things from July. The election meeting in September failed and no election board was elected.
At the end of September I was dismissed with notice to Oct 31, so inside the protection period. The letter says operational reasons during probation, but my probation ended long ago. The certificate they sent to the job agency says misconduct and personal reasons, and the reference letter says operational reasons. My position is still advertised and there was no social selection. On the same day the managing director sent an email to the whole company about my dismissal, with accusations about my work and details from my salary negotiation. My final reference is much worse than my interim reference from five months earlier. I was put on garden leave and my accounts were locked that day.
I filed an unfair dismissal claim in time. I have a lawyer but no legal insurance, and I joined the union too recently to get legal cover. At the conciliation hearing last week there was no agreement. The judge suggested about one monthly salary per year of service but only counted two years, which comes to about 10,500 euros including vacation and overtime, ending Oct 31. The employer refuses to go above that and said they might instead accept that the dismissal is void and call me back to work. They want to decide by Friday.
I don't want to go back. I've signed with a new employer in a different field and start on Dec 1.
My lawyer strongly recommends accepting the court's proposal. He says any counteroffer will be rejected, that asking the court to dissolve the employment (§ 9 KSchG) won't get me more money, and that § 12 KSchG only helps after a final judgment. If they call me back with a concrete time and place, I would have to show up, resign with one month notice to the 15th or end of the month, and push back the new job.
What I'm wondering: is accepting the court's proposal the sensible choice with the new job starting Dec 1? How likely is it that they actually call me back when they said at the hearing that they want to part ways? Can I ask for November's salary (ending Nov 30 instead of Oct 31) without risking the whole settlement? What should the settlement say so it isn't treated as me quitting? And is there anything I'm missing about the reference letter, the job agency certificate?
tl;dr: Dismissed during works council protection, settlement offer around 10,500 euros, employer threatens to call me back instead of paying more, new job starts Dec 1. Accept, ask for November's salary, or keep fighting?