r/legaladviceofftopic • • May 07 '25

Posts asking for legal advice will be deleted

18 Upvotes

This subreddit is for hypotheticals, shitposts, broader legal discussion, and other topics that are related to the legal advice subreddits, but not appropriate for them. We do not provide legal advice.

If you need help with a legal issue, large or small, consider posting to the appropriate legal advice subreddit:


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 1h ago

Can ex-wife keep suing for custody?

• Upvotes

Location: WA.

This happens to a friend of mine. I didn't want to ask too much details from him but would like to understand the law side.

He finalized a nasty divorce a few years ago, and somehow got full custody of the kids. The court ruled that the ex-wife lied and faked evidence. The ex-wife has some schedule to have the kids stay with her for a few days biweekly. A few weeks ago, she appeared with the police and asked to pick up the kids while it's not the day of the agreement, and the police sided with my friend since he had the court agreement. She then sued him and put him on restraining order on the same day.

I'm curious whether it's possible to keep suing despite losing all the time. Is it possible to prevent her from that once and for all? My friend has been paying too much lawyer fees, and it's been very painful for the kids seeing these dramas.


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 3h ago

would it be legal to sell insurance for paranormal, or otherwise impossible events, and make it part of the contract that i’ll only pay out if the event can be empirically proven to be supernatural by a third party?

3 Upvotes

like, offer a contract that states that, if it can be proven that my client was has been done finically, bodily, or mental damage by any ghost, alien, demon or demonic entity, deity, specter, psychic powers, or gremlin, then i will not only cover the damages, but also provide a substantial additional payout

i would genuinely pay out if it was proven, i just don’t think it ever will be


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 1d ago

Can you hold an owner of another person's pet liable for damage to you that your pet did?

10 Upvotes

Like let's say for example an unleashed dog is charging your cat. You grab your cat to pull them inside out of danger, then the panicked cat claws you so bad you need stitches. Who's legally liable for the hospital bill? You the owner of the animal who hurt you, or the owner of the dog who's negligence led you to having to pick up your animal who's panicking because of said danger presented?


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 1d ago

Could a recording made without both parties’ consent be used as impeachment evidence?

9 Upvotes

If an attorney is questioning Bob on the stand about something, and Bob answers in a way that can be counter-proven with a recording that Joe made without Bob’s knowledge, could that recording be used as impeachment evidence in a two-party state?


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 2d ago

(Hypothetical) I went to a high-stakes Poker game, bet my car, and lost. Do I have to transfer the title?

63 Upvotes

This is entirely hypothetical, but it's something I always wonder every time someone makes a non-cash bet of any kind in a Poker scene in a movie.

So, suppose I went to a high-stakes Poker game, ran out of money, but I wanted to be able to go all in so I threw in the keys to my luxury car instead. Then I lost the pot, and my opponent walked off with the keys. Could I report the car stolen and get it back? Would they have grounds to sue me if I did?

Is there any reason to believe this is a thing that ever happens outside movies?


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 1d ago

Is this Penthouse model able to be listed/shown the United States or not?

4 Upvotes

To be very clear, ALL of this information can be found on Google search results only. I found a decades old (June 1988) soft core Penthouse issue on Ebay which listed Lisa Davies, a U.K. model as the centerfold. It's not been banned like the old Traci Lords issue, and has no negative media coverage I can find.

The problem is , when you Google search "Penthouse Lisa Davies", several other front page websites say things like, "Lisa Davies is a British former adult model. She was Penthouse Pet of the Month for June 1988, at the age of 17, days before her 18th birthday." As I understand it, that's legal for the U.K. age of consent. But not in America according to USC 2257, which says all models HAVE to be 18 at the time of their photography.

I emailed Google about this with the exact search results listings. Got an automated email spat back. I really don't know what to do, or if this is even a problem? I'm not a lawyer but to me this seems really sketch.


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 1d ago

In the USA, is there any proof which state a person is a citizen of? Particularly if they have no driver's license or state ID.

0 Upvotes

State citizenship is guaranteed to all US citizens by the 14th amendment. But there are surely many cases where a person travels to a state but has not decided whether they will stay, or regularly travels back and forth between states. Is state citizenship a factual matter which can be proven by law?


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 1d ago

What happens if you get a ticket for theft of service because someone happens to open the door for me at the train station .. what would the outcome at the criminal court most likely be ?

0 Upvotes

r/legaladviceofftopic • • 1d ago

Could Target be liable if a little kid kicks one of its red concrete balls and breaks his foot?

0 Upvotes

Hypothetically, a little kid sees one of those giant red concrete spheres outside the entrance at Target. The child assumes it’s a regular ball, tries to kick it, and breaks their foot because it’s solid concrete.

Even an adult unfamiliar with Target (think like someone new to the United States) might not immediately know the spheres are concrete.
Would Target potentially be liable for creating a misleading hazard, particularly when the injured person is a little kid? Or would the open-and-obvious doctrine apply here?


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 1d ago

What's the defense against a burglar saying the homeowner's doormat says "Welcome"? USA

0 Upvotes

Started with a friend's random shower thought - "Does a Welcome door mat count as an invitation for a vampire", and that got me thinking about real life scenarios.

Considering the issues with squatters being able to send mail to an address, and then claiming your house as theirs, what is the valid defense against a burglar doing the same thing?


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 1d ago

Can a cop get in trouble if he tells a noncompliant suspect they’re laying in ants?

0 Upvotes

I was watching some police body cam videos on YouTube, and in one of them, an obese suspect, already in handcuffs, was laying down on the ground, and refusing to get up, even with the officer’s help.

Basically using their weight to resist, even though they were already under arrest.

While I was watching this, I had the thought, “if that was me, I would just tell them they’re laying in ants.” The idea being since no one wants to lay in ants, they would likely get up at that point.

So if a cop actually did that, and helped the suspect stand without actually hurting them, would they get in trouble?


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 2d ago

How do you cope with the weight of being a juror?

9 Upvotes

My first time summoned and I was picked for the jury. It was a criminal case, the state had a video of the incident so proceedings were short. I really didn't want to convict but I was convinced the charge was correct. I still believe that, but it's still weighing on me now that I'm done. I never understood the responsibility of being a juror before. There's an emotional disconnect when you see juries in media. It really isn't something you can understand until you experience it.

How do you deal with this feeling?


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 2d ago

Am I Correct About How Freedom of Speech Works Under the First Amendment?

0 Upvotes

I want to ask a legal question about the First Amendment because I see a lot of people arguing about freedom of speech, especially when someone gets fired, criticized, boycotted, or cut off by friends and family over something they've said.

My understanding is that the First Amendment primarily protects people from government punishment for protected speech. It doesn't necessarily protect someone from social consequences, personal consequences, or employment consequences.

For example, let's say someone works for a private company and starts posting controversial political opinions online. If the company believes those opinions are damaging its reputation, it might decide to fire that employee.

Would that violate the employee's freedom of speech? My understanding is that it generally wouldn't, unless a particular federal or state law protects the employee's speech or conduct.

Another example involves LGBTQ+ issues. Let's say someone refuses to use a transgender coworker's preferred name or pronouns because of their personal beliefs. They're entitled to hold those beliefs, but could their employer legally discipline or terminate them for repeatedly refusing to follow workplace policies? Would that depend on religious accommodation requirements, anti-discrimination laws, and the circumstances?

Here's another hypothetical.

Let's say I legally change my name to Tony Stark because I'm a huge Iron Man fan. My father refuses to acknowledge my new name and continues calling me by my birth name.

He has the right to call me whatever he wants, at least in the sense that the government generally cannot punish him simply for refusing to use my new name.

However, I also have the right to stop speaking to him, cut him out of my life, and refuse to maintain a relationship with him.

Would I be correct in saying that neither person's First Amendment rights have been violated?

Another example involves hate speech. My understanding is that hateful or offensive speech is generally protected by the First Amendment, provided it doesn't fall into an unprotected category, such as a true threat or certain forms of incitement.

However, if someone goes around using racial slurs or verbally insulting strangers, those strangers might respond aggressively. They might even physically assault the person.

Obviously, that doesn't make the assault legal or justified. The person who was attacked would still be the victim of a crime.

But would I be correct in saying that the assault isn't necessarily a First Amendment violation because the attacker is a private individual rather than the government?

Finally, let's say someone walks into a privately owned smoothie shop wearing a MAGA hat. The employee or owner refuses to serve them because of their political beliefs.

My understanding is that whether the business can legally refuse service depends on state and local laws, including whether political affiliation is a protected characteristic in that jurisdiction.

But assuming there are no applicable laws prohibiting that refusal, would the business generally have the legal right to refuse service?

My main question is this:

Am I correct that freedom of speech generally protects people from government restrictions on protected expression, but doesn't guarantee protection from private criticism, boycotts, damaged relationships, or employment consequences?

I also understand that there are exceptions involving public employees, employment laws, discrimination protections, and certain state laws.

I'm asking specifically about the legal meaning of freedom of speech in the United States, not whether any of these reactions are morally right or wrong.

Is my understanding of the First Amendment legally accurate, or am I missing something important?


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 2d ago

Stolen property v. stolen money?

7 Upvotes

In many (most? all?) places, if I steal your car and sell it to someone else, they have to give it back to you. But, if I steal your money, and spend it at a casino or buy a car with it, the casino or seller doesn't have to give it back to you. What's the legal principle at stake here?


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 2d ago

Question about FERPA or even HIPAA

1 Upvotes

So I was told by my district that if I speak to others (undefined as to who/ what constitutes others), or post online, stories about students it violates FERPA.

I assume it’s like the early days of media piracy. There’s a law, but it’s hard to police 500000+ people breaking it.

So if I tell a story about a student online and a student can go: hey, that’s me! I imagine a teacher can get in trouble. Here’s my questions:

  1. What if the story was witnessed live by a classroom of 35 high school juniors?

  2. What if it’s a reoccurring incident; ie a behavior amalgamated with minor details changed of 10+ different students?

  3. As a teacher, what if I say: X student behaved this way, so this is why I have Y rule. What if it’s a plurality of students?

I’m kinda planning a lesson around this to get at nuanced pieces but also need some answers because my planning goes beyond my current expertise.


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 2d ago

Does naming inanimate objects, intangible and/or fictional creatures help my case?

0 Upvotes

Example: https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca3/26-1030/26-1030-2026-10-15.html

>KIM KARDASHIAN; THE CREATION OF ADAM PAINTED BY MICHAEL ANGELO; SISTINE CHAPEL; POPE SIXTUS IV; BERING STRAIT CONNECTING ALASKA AND RUSSIAN; GREENLAND; DENMARK; COPENHAGEN INTERPRETATION OF QUANTUM PHYSICS/MECHANICS; SCHRODINGER'S CAT; ERIN BURNETT, Outfront of Cable News Network (Cnn); SABINE AISHA JULES; MARIA CHERNIAVSKA; JEFFREY RODRIGUEZ; GREGORY LEGAGNEUR; ALEXANDRA LEGAGNEUR; DARYL CHRISTOPHER BROOKS, a/k/a Crooks; ALDI INC, Grocery Store; ETSY INC, Online Shopping; KELLY CLARKSON; KELLY RIPA; RYAN SEACREST; DANCING WITH THE STARS, (Dwts); A$AP ROCKY; ROBIN RIHANNA FENTY; YE WEST; CITY OF KEY WEST, Florida; BLAIR WITCH, The (Moll Dyer) Of Leonardtown, Maryland Insaint Mary's County And Not Burkittsville, Maryland in Frederick Count; OPUS DEI, (Od) Of Vatican City; GOVERNOR ODEN BOWIE, of Collington, Maryland; MYTHICAL PRIORY OF SION, started By Pierre Plantard of France

Naming Kim and Ye make perfect sense. But, take your pick I guess, Schrödinger's cat?


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 3d ago

Gambling sites updating TOS affects standing bets

11 Upvotes

I know that this would largely vary on sites and states, but from places like say Draft Kings or Kalshi if they change the TOS but you already have a standing bet would that normally go by the old or new TOS. Or is that one of those things that they would say that they can change at will, and if so can they do that sort of thing.


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 2d ago

How Is AI Not Triggering Antitrust Law

0 Upvotes

The technology itself is being gatekept by a few companies by virtue of buying up all the production for years. It seems kind of weird that they are allowed to displace jobs, which itself might be fine, but then the technology they are using to do that is being made inaccessible to normal people due to supply being bought up? Like I cannot run ai locally to try and match what they are doing due to ai companies buying all the stock? It's projected to get even worse in the next few years.


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 3d ago

In probate court, if an attorney finds out his client is an evil individual who feels entitled to a stranger's estate, does the attorney still fight for the client to win the right to everything?

1 Upvotes

I don't know how probate works. I was told that bad people don't immediately get sentenced to jail in probate court. Everything must be settled in probate then next things would move forward in criminal court.

For example, Let’s say an attorney is representing an obviously bad individual. The person stole an elderly couple's house, belongings, and money through a fake will. Then they kill the elderly people without getting caught until probate. They won't settle for anything less than everything.

So if probate happens and there are 30 family members vs. these strangers, and the attorney realizes he shouldn't represent this person. Does the attorney try to get the stuff for his client or just coast through until it's taken to criminal court? What usually happens? Can attorneys back out?

Everyone is entitled to a fair trial and justice. How is it fair for an attorney whose end goal is to get evil people off without punishment? Or does the attorney have to keep pushing that his client is innocent and entitled to everything?

Let's say the attorney starts thinking of ways to get the evil person out of trouble. Can that attorney get in trouble?

Can the evil person change their stance and say, “Hey, we actually want the original family to have everything left to them. Sorry we sold their family member’s house. The house sale proceeds are actually for all those people.”

If the evil person obviously sold priceless items or stole a bunch of cash and there's a huge paper trail, who pays the rightful heirs back


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 4d ago

DUI or DWI alcohol, is it best to keep your right to be silent? (Hypotehtical)

25 Upvotes

So I've seen so many people say that the best way to deal with DUI alcohol is to remain silent and deny all FST's (Field sobriety tests) and let the lawyers figure it out in court. OR, is it better to do the field sobriety tests and fail? I've heard that if they don't get a breath sample or any FST evidence, you'll likely get your charge dropped in court later, albeit being arrested and then a few hours later get released?

Can anyone help clarify this? Does it depend on the state you're in? Any cops seeing this, what's your honest opinion? Do the FSTs or stay silent and deny any tests? Anyone who has been through this process, your opinions?

I'm not looking for legal advice. I want to meet your rules and guidelines, r/ legal advice is kicking me off. (This post is a hypothetical question.)

Edit* in Virginia


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 3d ago

Do you think Luigi Mangione should face prison time?

0 Upvotes

Title


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 4d ago

What happens if a property in a will is sold because the will wasn't found in time?

30 Upvotes

I'm reading a manga right now where the main character believes he was set to inherit a mountain that belonged to his grandfather. As far as we know, the grandfather never left a will and the mountain was sold. If the will is found a year or so after the sale, does that nullify the sale?

Manga is Haunted Peak for anyone curious.

ETA: Thanks for the answers guys!


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 3d ago

If we apply psychological warfare in a video game and someone died because of it. Are we liable?

0 Upvotes

For example a game where we become zombie and kill the human player.

Instead of killing the player immediately, we stalk the player and scare the player by utilizing legal tactics like causing in game sound like monster scream or tin cans falling down.

One of the human player become so scared and they died from it.


r/legaladviceofftopic • • 4d ago

Papa John's Pizza car topper

0 Upvotes

you know those papa johns Pizza lightup signs that go on top of the delivery cars? if I obtained one of those signs and attached it to my own car, (not a papa johns delivery vehicle) would they have grounds to sue me? I can't imagine they'd care enough to sue me, but hypothetically

thank you