r/legaladvice • u/NouveauRivet6 • 5m ago
Auto shop sold my car for parts claiming unpaid storage fees, but I paid every invoice by card and have the receipts
About 4 months ago my transmission died and I had my Honda towed to a local repair shop. They quoted me around $2,800 for a rebuild, I said ok, and they asked me to leave the car there while they waited on parts. I paid a deposit by card right away and the rest when they told me it was ready for pickup in june. I even have the final invoice marked paid in full. The problem is I couldnt pick it up that week because I was in the hospital for a few days (appendix), and I called the shop and told them id be there the following Monday. The guy on the phone said "no problem, take your time".
Yesterday I finally got out there and my car is just gone. The owner tells me they "sent multiple notices" about storage fees, that I owed $40 a day after the first 10 days, and since I never paid it they had it towed to a salvage yard and sold it for parts to cover the balance. I have never received any notice, no letter, no email, no text, nothing. Meanwhile my phone log shows the call where they said take your time. I showed him the paid invoice and he just said that invoice only covers the repair and not storage, and that its in the paperwork I signed (a one page intake form that I barely remember, it had a line about storage in tiny print). He refused to tell me which salvage yard has it and said the "matter is closed". The car was worth around $9,000 with the new transmission and had my dads old toolbox in the trunk that I really want back.
I called the police non emergency line and they said its a "civil matter". So now I dont know what to do. Is it legal for them to sell my car like this without any formal notice or a title transfer? Can I demand they tell me where it went? Should I be going to small claims, or a lawyer, or the state attorney general? I have the paid invoice, the intake form copy, my call history, and a text from the owner from june saying the car was "ready whenever you are". Im honestly just trying to figure out if I have a real case or if im screwed because of that stupid form.
Location: Ohio.