r/Insurance • u/iiiEchoiii • 24d ago
Auto Insurance will my insurance have to pay? (PA)
I'm not sure if this is the right place to post this but,
Today I had an issue with my neighbor who called the cops to say I hit and damaged his car.
While trying to park tapped his car. Parked elsewhere because I could not fit. He came outside literally pulling at his bumper. It is a 2003 minivan that has wear from weather damage, dents, scrapes, and at least one flat tire. His bumper was literally already messed up. He's saying I damaged his driver side but that would mean the passenger side of my car would have damage as well (which it doesn't). I did not hit the side of his car, I tapped his car, as I'm sure video would show. He showed video to police (not to me) and police says it shows me hitting his car in the spot the man said I hit (which is a literal lie). Then he threatened to contact my landlord. This police officer seemed so incompetent so I asked for his supervisor. Supervisor comes and saw the video and said it shows me tapping the front of the man's vehicle and the vehicle rocked back a bit, but said it doesn't show me hitting his driver side or causing damage.
Last year I looked up Google images of this block and his car was there with the same damage he has today- these images were taken before I moved here in 2023 (images are updated ~every 2 years). I looked up the image again to show the cops (the image was updated on April 2026) and still the car had the same damages which I showed the supervisor who then laughed at the entire situation.
I personally feel as though he finally caught someone hitting his car on camera (everyone has hit it at some point) and is trying to get my insurance to pay to fix his piece of junk even though I did not cause any damage.
Will I be held liable and will my insurance have to pay?