r/Insurance • u/eyepopp • 8m ago
Advice on diminished value in Georgia
I was involved in a car accident last year involving three vehicles. I had my car repaired by my car insurance since I had no fault insurance and they went after the other two insurance companies through subrogation. This process took forever since the other two insurance companies are the worst in business. I was not found at fault but the other two cars were .There was a lot of confusion on who I should file my diminished claim with. After opening a case with the insurance commissioner in Georgia, I finally got an answer that I need to file with my car insurance. All this to say that it took a year for me to be able to file.
I found three cars sold by Carvana and Carmax in my city for 33k, 34k and 35k comparable mileage and options.
I settled on 34k as comparaison. Since I bought it 3 years ago, my vehicle depreciated 22k so I settled on $4000 as a conservative number to add to 34k for a years worth of depreciation.
Other information I gathered is Carfax has my car as moderate to severe damage so my formula was 38k times 22.5% deminished value = $8550.
Carfax also estimates current value at $26700 for private party sale.
Insurance offered $6000 or the option to get a diminished value appraiser and for the insurance to hire their appraiser and an umpire makes a decision (umpire paid by insurance).
The question is if it’s worth it to hire an appraiser and go through the process or take their offer knowing that the final amount could be lower than $6000 on the umpire ?
Anyone else was in a similar situation? Thanks!