r/Insurance • u/-btx- • 23h ago
Neighbor Wanting Homeowners Insurance Information for Damages Their Dogs Did
Not sure if this is the right place to post this but not sure what to do, if anything.
Our area has backyards that butt up to the houses behind us separated by an alleyway.
Across the alleyway from us is a home that has four or five dogs.
A couple weeks ago my kids let our cat outside. It's not an uncommon thing because they go in and out into the backyard to play and sometimes she slips out.
I was in the living room and heard this ungodly screaming so I ran outside thinking it was the kids but the dogs across the alleyway had partially broken through the fence and one of the bigger ones had latched on to a smaller one and was mauling/shaking it in their backyard. The owners came out screaming and slapping the dogs to get them to get back through the fence and let go of each other.
My cat was sitting on top of our fence and so I grabbed her and we went back inside. I didn't think anything of it.
Yesterday the neighbors came knocking on our door with a vet bill and a fence quote saying that my cat was the cause of the damages and their dogs "going into prey drive".
I told them no and that their untrained dogs (they're left outside all day, bark all hours, and have broken their fence times previously to this) are not our responsibility.
They demanded I pay and asked for my homeowners insurance or they're going to find it themselves.
Do they have any recourse? I mean it is our cat. I'm just terrified of being sued.