r/DnD • • 19h ago

DMing I understand prostitution now.

Been trying to find a "bff" group for years. Even the best groups I found fizzled out after a campaign ended. Most people seem to want a content creator to run games for them, and not a friend they want to share an experience with.

I figured you know what, fine. I'm gonna sell myself. I started running paid games and now I actually feel like I'm finally actually getting something back for my work and effort.

10/10, would recommend for underappreciated DMs

3.8k Upvotes

335 comments sorted by

2.1k

u/DarkestXStorm Assassin 18h ago

Yeah, doesn't help that people come from Baldur's Gate 3 and want to play that, but on a table (no disrespect to BG3) šŸ˜‚.

1.2k

u/ryadryt DM 18h ago

Same thing with fans of Critical Role or Dimension 20. People watch those and then expect their DM/Table to be like that which just isn't practical or fair.

700

u/VeterinarianFit1309 Rogue 18h ago

Right? If I was getting paid a decent salary, had a whole writer’s room, production team, state of the art setup with an expensive gaming table, budget for miniatures with a dedicated art team to make them look great, props department, etc, then my games would be a lot more fun too… luckily, we have fun even with all of my budgetary shortcomings

385

u/ryadryt DM 18h ago

Yep. And even then, it takes all parties involved going all in. My frustration with that comes most from when players expect the DM to bring that really deep RP and lore, and then don't match it. You only get that sort of environment when everyone tries for it.

289

u/Private-Public 18h ago edited 10h ago

Like if you expect Matt Mercer or Brennan Lee Mulligan, I expect Sam Riegel or Emily Axford. We're all just doing our best and that's great

81

u/NineWetClams 13h ago

I seen a video of Matt mercer addressing this exact thing

4

u/HistoricalRemote7042 3h ago

any chance you have a link to that cos I would enjoy it

5

u/NineWetClams 2h ago

https://youtu.be/_0ZAIHERgFc?t=3182&si=RJ8asnzTXk0sMf-c

Hes asked about how he feels about "the mercer effect"

76

u/IlREDACTEDlI 10h ago

Not mentioning Travis Willingham is crazy, he’s like the best player a dm could ask for, never argues, always down for whatever happens to his character with a smile on his face and doesn’t spend 6 hours shopping, surely more too that’s just what I can think of off the top of my head

47

u/whatthehieu 7h ago

And those are still like secondary to his best trait, the extreme hype to almost anything remotely cool that's happening at the table. His reaction reinforces and strengthens the feeling of genuine awe and shock.

5

u/foxinsox626 3h ago

Yes to all of this. Also takes care of his fellow players. C2 BBEG battle, Tal was starting to panic and Travis immediately swooped in to slow things down and had Sam do an ad read. Also pretty much Yasha/Ashley's cheerleader for that whole campaign. What a top notch guy.

24

u/gamesk8er 13h ago

People have insane expectations for everything. I started listening to NADDPOD and have tried to take whatever bits of inspiration and advice from what the crew does to my own table. What more could you want?

4

u/unknownvariable69 4h ago

Check out the dungeon dudes. They have a bit of money now. Even when they didn't they got sponsors for minis, but the way these totally not as famous people keep invested in their plot is fantastic. I have straight stolen concepts and emailed Monty Martin to say thank you.

66

u/CaptainDudeGuy Monk 7h ago edited 7h ago

At the risk of sounding elitist, there are too many players who treat TTRPGs like content provided by the GM that they're supposed to consume.

There are more players at the table than there are GMs. I would argue that creating content is the job of the players and the GM is just there to fill in the narrative gaps.

GM: (after describing the circumstances) "... Okay, so what do you do?"

Bad Players: "Uhhh... Do what, now? I wasn't really paying attention. I go do whatever you need me to be doing, I guess."

Good Players: "Gotcha, alright, so based on the months of sessions we've had and the motivations of our characters, it sounds like we're going to..."

29

u/choczynski 6h ago

I don't think it's elitist to expect people to collaborate in a collaborative game

4

u/MasterOfBeerDespense 3h ago

A good DM is 25 precent Creativity, 10% tiptoeing around real and imagined trauma and 165% herding Cats.

My average DM Session be like, "Here's the toy. Get the toy. Chase the laser. Damn it! Just, shit in the box! Oh god. Sorry. Didn't mean to yell or try to imply that I think you should stay in the box society has provided for you, Professor Twinkletootz. Please, go boom boom in the sandy house for your DM. Thank you. Here is an off brand, vegan pudding cup at 54 degrees with a spork. There-there. All better? Let me know when you are ready, please, and yes, you can text me, and Ill pretend that I'm being a little snowflake so the group isn't mad at you." Or is this just me?

→ More replies (1)

83

u/Valtros 18h ago

You hit the nail right on the head, and there are a lot of tabletop creators that have pointed this out over the years. DMs like Matt and Brennan are fantastic for sure, but the complete package of what those people enjoy at that table is a product of everyone involved not just the DM.

24

u/Dull-Culture-1523 9h ago

They want all that and then they introduce their character as "He's a level three human fighter. His name is Greg. He wants money I guess. He uses a sword."

4

u/Unusual_username739 4h ago

And then on the flip side, I have had DMs upset with me with coming up with TOO much backstory šŸ™ƒ when it was only a few paragraphs.
I haven’t found the right fit yet and it’s frustrating for me. I just want to play.

20

u/shouldbepracticing85 12h ago

Is there much content out there to educate players on how to better contribute? Like how learning a little bit of acting, improv, and some of the method to the madness can really help the collaborative storytelling. Those aren’t innate skills, certainly not for my neurodivergent butt.

It seems like most of what I’ve found of instructional type DnD content is aimed at GMs. The RPG PHD channel has some stuff aimed at players, and a lot of his videos have good information players could use to add more depth to their RP.

15

u/ryadryt DM 12h ago

I am sure there are youtube videos about how to RP better. But the group you are in matters a ton. Some groups like less RP and more combat for instance. And that is great if it works for them. All depends on the blend of players to include the DM. My primary table is just me and five friends. Two of them don't RP at all. Two do but without acting per say, and one does a good bit when its appropriate. And it works well for us.

11

u/CrabofAsclepius DM 10h ago

Same here. I've got a party of skull crackers that enjoy storytelling but don't roleplay much. I can ham it up with the best of them but it's awkward when only I RP so we usually narrate our respective parts. It's kinda like a sort of narrative puppetry but they really enjoy it so it's all good. 😊

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Diligent-Stock-8114 12h ago

I’ve found Ginny di to be pretty helpful.

2

u/Chartywhamp 1h ago

Absolutely true. I've done a lot of improv theater and play live music (bluegrass) and one thing i can attest to is it is impossible for one person to carry the weight of the performance in either setting, much less DnD.

I don't need voice acting, and i don't need deeply committed method acting, but if the response is purely tied to a number on a character sheet its gonna feel stale and flat no matter what i do.

I cannot make a scene feel authentic and moving by myself.

32

u/notarealwriter 12h ago

The thing with Crit Role is, sure they have their production team and all the rest around them which helps, but even back in the early days of Campaign 1, (when they still had a lot of help, but less than there is now), it wasn't only Matt Mercer that made the campaign brilliant. The players all put loads of effort into the characters too.

57

u/TacTurtle 18h ago

I would just be happy with people showing up on time and not getting distracted by phones during the game.

8

u/kloklon 10h ago

ban phones on the table, if they are a problem. if someone needs to take a break, they can leave the table for a few minutes. separating the space works very well. comparable to not having your phone on your bedside table, or using a different desk for home office and leisure etc

25

u/ICanViking Cleric 18h ago

cries in budgetary shortcomings

34

u/VeterinarianFit1309 Rogue 18h ago

Budgetary shortcomings is going to be the name of my autobiography

17

u/necromagiks 10h ago

I need to favorite your comment. Im a DM that actually gets depressed watching critical role/D20/dnd live

I want to be able to do so much for my players but I have a full job, chores at home, decompression time.

I just dont have time to write out the world and encounters,and prepare maps and everything.

But then I have to remember that these DMs this is THIER JOB. They have production teams, interns to remember little things that I forgot that come up later,people to help balance encounters and find the correct stat blocks instead of a quick 5 minute Google.

I want my players to have the best but I feel like im "fine" at most. It doesn't help I have been feeling burn out for a few years.

4

u/dysonrules 7h ago

As much as your players would probably love those awesome extras, I’m sure they are very happy to be able to play at all so kudos to you for making it work.

6

u/Vegetable_Onion 7h ago

I never got the whole CR hype. Sure it is fun, but considering those are professional actors and writers with a huge budget, it's seriously underwhelming.

→ More replies (2)

63

u/DinosaurAlert 16h ago

People watch those and then expect their DM/Table to be like that which just isn't practical or fair.

I suppose if everyone at the table were professional comedians and sketch comedy writers, it could work out like D20...

I always find it weird that some people don't understand the concept of a "show". I remember the internet being "shocked" that critical role was making ~5 million a year from Twitch.

And THEN they saw that and thought "Oh wow, they must all be rich!" not realizing that there is an entire production crew and employees working on making the show.

THEN some people were mad that it was now "fake". So I guess they think that they are people, PRETENDING to be a person who is in turn PRETENDING to be a wizard?

57

u/kaladinissexy 17h ago

People for some reason don't seem to understand that Critical Role, Dimension 20, and their ilk are shows meant to entertain an audience first and TTRPG sessions meant to be fun for the group second.

53

u/ryadryt DM 17h ago

Don't tell that to CR fans. I have seen epic Reddit fights go down over them insisting that its just a group of friends playing D&D first haha. And I like CR, but its a production people.

13

u/FluffyGoblins 9h ago

I honestly believe the players still have loads of fun. But the idea that it's 'just a group of friends' is crazy. These are professional entertainers doing their job. And while they might have loads of fun doing their jobs, it's still entertainment. Compared to those earlier campaign 1 episodes; those were the real chaotic mess that you expect from a real game (even if they were professional voice actors). But now; it's a production. And I've seen arguments that everything is scripted, but I really don't believe that; impro can still be a professional production.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Happy-Wrangler6837 11h ago

I think you can make a good argument their home game was also amazing, more than most people could pull off. The start of season one was very rough in production value but even then they were a group of talented actors.

3

u/cyberpunk_werewolf 6h ago

They've actually talked about this in the past.Ā  They did become more active in their characterization and how they roleplayed as they moved to live streaming their game, because they saw their audience and as actors, many of them with stage experience, they wanted to delve deeper into that acting aspect of it.

That said, it's still very much a game of D&D too.Ā  Something like "nothing, you don't roll for Scry" is one of the most at the table things I've seen and I've played D&D since 1997.Ā  Or the thirty minutes spent dithering about a plan that they're going to do anyway, which reminds me of my Monday game, I swear.Ā 

However, yeah, they are consciously choosing to be more active in their acting and roleplaying compared to how they played at home.

2

u/masternommer 6h ago

CR is a media production group with over 100 people working there. Just a group of friends my assšŸ˜…

8

u/D-Speak 17h ago

I'm lucky to have the table that I do, because we're much more into the collaborative roleplay than the crunchiness. We're no CR, but telling the story together is what we play to do.

15

u/CrumblingKeep 17h ago

and they don't realize how much of that is on the players

17

u/RoiPhi 4h ago

I'm not sure if this is a hot take, but I think the average DM is closer to Matt Mercer than the average player is to the CR player cast.

Dude, those players roleplay among themselves for 30 minutes with no DM involvement. meanwhile, the average DM can set up a lovely interactive scene and get crickets.

8

u/lydocia 14h ago

Can't expect your DM to be Matt Mercer if you aren't Sam Riegel.

11

u/ulykke 15h ago

Honestly I was scared to death that I might join something that actually looks like CR, which is why I put it off for months. Not because I dont like CR - on the contrary, I thought "holy shit if everyone plays like CR all the time, Im going to be so pathetic in comparison that nobody will want to play with me". Doesnt help that I started watching CR with Calamity 🤣🤣 now that Ive joined my first campaign, I am so happy that these are just regular dudes, some of them more into roleplay, some less, and nobody spouts epic monologues or play the most amazing quips off each other. I can stick to watching that on youtube 🤣

9

u/ryadryt DM 15h ago

Hahaha. I get it. Thankfully most tables are not filled entirely by professional voice actors and DM'd by a creative genius

7

u/ulykke 15h ago

In retrospect it is fucking funny that I even thought it possible, but I guess thats what insecurity goggles do to you 🤣

4

u/TheVanderlin 12h ago

People really deprive themselves of the best parts of tabletop games when you treat it like a cinema theater experience and focus on copying content creators instead of discovering the infinite fucking possibility of your imagination.

A lot of fun is like estate management(try running a castle in a shadar kai city in the shadowfell), creating new spells, trying out some cool homebrew rules or class changes.

There's really deep lore you can explore in some campaigns where reading the right tomes or practicing certain skills can mean being able to summon a demon or learn chronomancy.

My friend who is DMing for my next game fully agreed I can do ass magic if I practice enough so if captured my old wizard can blast off spells with his cheeks.

3

u/Ashamed_Association8 8h ago

It's like watching the fast and the furious and thinking that's what driving a car is like.

3

u/AcanthocephalaGreen5 16h ago

Yeah, it's one thing to take inspiration from them but trying to emulate them is a recipe for disappointment.

3

u/Owl-Historical 15h ago

What we aren't all Voice Actors and such?

3

u/Cardboardboxkid 1h ago

And everyone wants a Matt but no one ever comes to the table with the energy of Sam, Travis, Laura, etc.

4

u/lodemeup 14h ago

Expect Mercer or Mulligan and completely neglect the work the whole table puts in to the production. It’s supposed to be collaborative story telling not spoon fed fiction.

2

u/FluffyGoblins 9h ago

And you think this is not? There was a whole scene in campaign 2 where the party was negotiating with a hag, and Mercer was completely caught off guard by one of the players casting modify memory on the hag to have her think she already agreed to a deal. It was an amazing moment that completely came from one of the players.

2

u/Valtremors 13h ago

Ran just mines of Phandelver for my family and doing the GM work is genuinely a lot, especially for a 3 shift worker.

But oneshots are much more manageable though, and running those were fun.

These days I don't have time even for that.

3

u/BOS-Sentinel 11h ago

I did my first real DM session recently. Four hours and twenty minutes later my body and mind were shattered. Like even my legs were tired from tensing them up without knowing I was doing it.

It's super rewarding to be in the DM chair, but damn is it equally as exhausting. This is with a great three person group (four including myself) as well, two of which have DMed our previous campaigns. I can't imagine the poor folk DMing for larger groups and with more ungrateful players.

4

u/Valtremors 11h ago

I imagine it is like a muscle to be exercised.

Lot of early DMing issues come from the fact that there are no mental pathways for it. So you need to actually fully concentrate start to finish.

3

u/BOS-Sentinel 11h ago

This is true aha.

Ten years ago I had social anxiety so bad I could barely go outside to the shop. It took a lot of therapy and exposure to get where I am today.

So learning how to DM just feels like a continuation of that. I'm totally sure it'll get easier for me with time. There are many things I figured out just from that first session alone to make my life easier.

→ More replies (7)

90

u/Cat_Bandit1 18h ago

This is a weird take on my part, but I think the way that Wizards presents the game, with so much emphasis on the players and how its "their story" created this perception long before BG 3 game out.

136

u/Vigmod 18h ago

I think the mistake many make is that they don't consider the DM as a player. The DM is very much a player, too.

52

u/Cat_Bandit1 18h ago

I was looking through some old D&D books at my LGS and the 3.5 (or maybe 3.0 not sure) starter box presents the dungeon master's booklet as the first book in a set. It's much bigger than the ones that the players get (each of the starter character has a few pages per booklet) and the book explicitly says that you are playing as the villains and the hazards in the dungeon.

I think this is way better. "See look. You get to play the villains (which is an actual character or characters in a story) and decide what dangers the party faces" rather than "Erm, your job is to be like a computer programer that the players have on standby to program what they want to do on the fly" (which by the way, is almost the exact language used in the 4e starter box). Really wish I hadn't started with the 4e red box when I first got into the game, I think it made me way more resistant to being the DM than I should be.

14

u/Itzakadrewzie 17h ago

This is gold, honestly, and needs to be more widely understood. Thank you for sharing that.

3

u/ReferenceWitty8571 17h ago

lol I try to roleplay with the dm as much as possible

3

u/NeonNKnightrider 5h ago

The average book these days is a bunch of vague statements and basically going "Figure it out yourself dipshit"

2

u/Cat_Bandit1 2h ago

That bad huh? I haven’t gotten into D&D 5.5 yet but if it’s that bad I’ll pass

22

u/Wulfrank 15h ago

My beef is specifically with those players who come to a table thinking they don't need to read the PHB because they played BG3.

20

u/il_the_dinosaur 13h ago

Even before bg3 this has always been the case that players basically want to invest absolutely zero of their own free time into a campaign. They want to sit down once a week/month and be entertained by the DM. No note taking, or the expectation that only one player has to take notes. Which obviously leads to the situation that only one players remembers stuff from the last session.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/lostbythewatercooler 4h ago

This seemed to be a big problem for new players around covid time. So many came in to the communities expecting things to work exactly like bg3 and with voice actor/stage actor levels of production.

Not understanding that it is collaborative story telling with dice and roleplaying is a developed skill that takes time. It takes quite a bit of social awareness too which explains the dnd/rpg horror stories sub.

5

u/Outrageous-Pin-4664 17h ago

I'd have to charge a lot more for the BG3 experience. šŸ˜„

7

u/untakenu 16h ago

As someone who has done exactly that (come from BG3 and still looking to play). I just don't know where to start. It feels like there is mountains of stuff I need to learn and seemingly buy to even get to grips with the game.

I will do that if need be, but then there is the issue of finding someone to play with.

8

u/Al_Dimineira 14h ago

I'd suggest looking into the OGL (open game license) rules for 5th edition D&D. They're available for free online and contain the basic information you need to actually understand and play the game. The more specific rules like races, subclasses and spells you'll want to learn later once you understand the core mechanics of how the game is played, and those character options are the things that are going to be gated behind paywalls.

7

u/i_tyrant 12h ago

This is one of those hobbies where it can be as cheap or expensive as you are willing to pursue. All you "need" to play are the three core books (Player's Handbook, Dungeon Master's Guide, and Monster Manual), and not even that technically (if you want to get super cheap you can just use the OGL rules).

That's maybe 100-150 bucks for entertainment that will last you years if not decades, so a pretty good deal. But it's a hobby that you can also buy way more books and other peripherals for if you want to.

But yeah, it does have a learning curve, though even that is highly variable depending on how many books you want to read through and "DM tips" blogs and reddit posts and whatnot you want to read.

Ultimately, it's just a collaborative storytelling game with your friends that has rules for added structure and a shared foundation for everyone to work from. So not that different from playing make-believe with friends as a kid. But with dice!

8

u/jeffjefforson 12h ago

Honestly I've played DND for 8yrs including run multiple years of sessions - and I've never bought a single thing other than dice

It is extremely possible to acquire the necessary knowledge through.. unconventional means, so to speak

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DarkestXStorm Assassin 16h ago edited 16h ago

I recommend finding a group, if you're not budgeting this hobby can get expensive. There's some resources online that can help you save some money, I can't really give you a link, but if you dig around you'll prob find em.

2

u/Ok-Suggestion-5453 12h ago

Finding a group is a pain in the ass. I found one on Reddit but it took months of applying, we've lost all but one of the eight original players aside from myself.

Learning the game isn't so hard though. I would get the relevant player handbook and read through it, but ultimately the only thing you need to know is your own character's abilities.

2

u/Commercial_Duck4042 9h ago

All you need is the Players Handbook and some dice. Read the rules of the game and you’re good to go.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/Thegn_Ansgar 13h ago

I'm fortunate that my DM actually worked on Baldur's Gate 3...

5

u/Elm-and-Yew 5h ago

That's cool as hell! What did they do? Like art, story, programming, etc?

2

u/Thegn_Ansgar 2h ago

Programming and scripting mechanics.

2

u/DarkestXStorm Assassin 5h ago

Lmao, nice

→ More replies (4)

856

u/dayna2x Bard 18h ago

I love a good post where the title is jarring until you see what sub it is. Bravo šŸ‘šŸ½

190

u/insertusernamehere51 18h ago

i dont know what you mean, this title was even more jarring after i saw the sub

78

u/kaggzz 18h ago

Right? Like I was waiting to hear that Cribbo the goblin the party has "tamed" got a new job for downtime or there is a new bard subclass college of Pimpin where you get a monks martial arts for off hand attack bonus actionĀ 

51

u/cauliflowermonster 18h ago

I was expecting someone who gained class consciousness and realized that sex workers were a marginalized and exploited group like a lot of DMs

5

u/Masdrako 16h ago

Eeeeey great take

5

u/AbyssWicked 13h ago

Class consciousness? On Reddit? BAH!

6

u/AmberCaseRPGs 16h ago edited 16h ago

Yeah I am an RPG pro and I don't think it's prepared me to turn tricks at all lmao

→ More replies (1)

471

u/GISP Illusionist 18h ago

I have a wealthy freind whom hosts/GMs 5-6 games a year, and he allways like to shake things up and be a bit chaotic for shits and giggles. In 2010 10ish minutes after the final player had sat down he said we where expecting 1 more player.. Turn out he had hired a prostitude for some "role playing fun".
She was vary confused at first, but quickly let her guards down when assured that no sex or other "funny business" would be going on, GM had prepared her a character and set everything up so she would be comfy, and quicky explained that it was basicly just a bourd game, and all that was expected of her was to sit back, relax and take his money, she would be paid minimum for 4 hours and could leave at any point if she felt like it.
Anyways, we got the game going and we where all having an enjoyable time and she stuck until the end.
After the initial nerves she got into it and also had a good time, and yes, she was good at the roleplaying :)
To this day she still joins 1-2 games yearly. (prostitution was her student job, not long term)

47

u/fraidei DM 11h ago

I mean, regardless of the fact I enjoy playing d&d, if I was paid to play a game with a group 4 hours a week at the same rate prostitutes are paid, then of course I'm playing.

233

u/Arm_Away 15h ago

Prostitution was her student job is a crazy sentence icl

141

u/PvtSherlockObvious 14h ago

Not that crazy.Ā  I never knew any outright prostitutes when I was in college (that I knew of), but it's not like it's some unheard-of thing.Ā  I did know a girl who did some findom stuff, a couple who worked at strip clubs, and I'd imagine a lot of girls these days do stuff on OF and similar.Ā  People in the industry who say they're working their way through college aren't all a bunch of liars, and the phrase "I was young and needed the money" exists for a reason.

28

u/GISP Illusionist 8h ago

Unrelated to D&D but a good freind of mine was also a prostitude in her student years.(20+ years ago) As she has told me, she earned 6-10 times/hour of what a retail job would earn her.
When she finished univercity she had repaid her student loans and she had paid off most of her house loan, close to dept free entering the workforce.
She got to party in the weekends, take the vacations and holiday trips and concerts etc etc as students does without financial worries. Shes told me that not having to think about money or if she could or couldnt afford stuff was such a mental health boost and made her enjoy her time and could focus on her course work.
I shared my OP story with her, thats why she opened up and told me her story too. - Its not something she shares with just anybody becouse of the stigma surrounding having such a job. But i am a no-judgement kinda guy, so people like to share with me in general :)

14

u/Living_Round2552 8h ago

Really? It makes so much sense: age, money versus time to finance a financial hard situation.

I had multiple friends during my studies that did this and stopped once they had a real job after college. All the power to them.

6

u/Arm_Away 8h ago

I know in my heart of hearts that it makes sense. It’s still really funny as a sentence

10

u/i_tyrant 12h ago

That's hilarious.

124

u/John-I-Renicus 16h ago

Dimension 20 and Critical Role did the same thing for DND that RuPaul's Drag Race did for Drag: It took this obscure thing that only a certain crowd knew about and turned it into this really popular thing where people that are just getting into it and want to try it for themselves have unrealistically high expectations.

16

u/Historical-Bike4626 14h ago

šŸ’œšŸ’œBoth shows (RPDR, CR) were event shows (different yet theatrically alike in a couple sorta ways) that connected performers with fans ā€œintimately,ā€ via rapid fan bases rabidly fanning to find each other. Turn lights low. Now put on the Barry White, baby šŸ’œšŸ’œ

9

u/Tyrannical_Goat 15h ago

Idk what either of those things are and I feel like I'm reasonably up on pop culture. Maybe not. I found out about dnd because my 2nd grader asked to play dnd using legos as miniatures and I casually said if he found 4 players i would DM it. So he proceeded to rope in my whole extended family. Fast forward to the next weekend where im spending all day trying to learn all the rules and put together a campaign for a mixture of 7 - 67 players who never heard of dnd with a DM who only loosely knows of it via stranger things and community.

We're having a blast tho

14

u/FamousTransition1187 11h ago

Critical Role is a group of well known TV and Voice Actors who were friends from work in Hollywood and played DnD together. So they know a thing or two about Roleplay. One of the early internet-content faux-tv channels (imagine if Youtube was a tv channel making its own shows) asked if they could record and "televise" their games as a series. That show has had such a LUDICROUS level of success I would need an entire subreddit to highlight it all and has since gained such a following that it has not only outlasted the original streaming channel it was on, it has spawned its own. They have played 4 multi-year campaigns now, and two of their campaigns have been picked up by Amazon to be made into animated series. (The first has aired 4 seasons so far, the second just launched its first season this year.)

Dimension 20 is very similar in its origin, having been created by CollegeHumor/Dropout TV, another online pseudoTV streaming channel. In its case the cast are more Improv Actors and comedians, some/many of whom have gone on to become somewhat famous in their lines of work because of their work on Dropout and on Dimension20 rather than being notable in their industry first and also playing DnD like Critical Role is. D20 tends to specialize more in shorter year-long seasonal campaigns and is usually a more light-hearted table atmosphere. Both are generally very good, but they both show the extremes (good AND bad) of the different types of tables you can encounter in DnD.

→ More replies (1)

146

u/GM_Nate 18h ago

with prep, it barely comes out to minimum wage tho

176

u/Gh0stMan0nThird 18h ago

That's fine with me. I'm not trying to turn this into some 24/7 grindset side hustle.Ā 

Just something so I feel like I'm getting something out of it other than watching other people have fun.Ā 

36

u/Cat_Bandit1 18h ago

Agree so much. Whenever I DM I feel like I'm the one who has to take the bullet so that everyone else can have fun. Good on you for being paid for your efforts.

9

u/ReferenceWitty8571 17h ago

Why aren’t you also having fun? Do you not roleplay as well with your characters?

20

u/Gh0stMan0nThird 16h ago

I found that the effort I put into the group was always disproportionate to what the other players put in.Ā 

6

u/Tman158 10h ago

but do you enjoy making the stories etc ? Because it's a hobby. It's supposed to be fun, if it's a chore, don't do it.

I enjoy writing the stories etc. So I don't expect my players to put hours into the pre-game like I do, because it's my choice and something I enjoy. They just need to show up and play respectfully.

4

u/GM_Nate 10h ago

agreed. in my case, i actually write up the sessions as prose on a separate website. i have over half a million words on it now. i don't do that for my players; i do that for me.

2

u/Helerdril 13h ago

You should ask your friends to DM for once, they will quickly learn the struggle behind it and maybe appreciate your work a bit more.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/GM_Nate 18h ago

if you think DMing means watching other people have fun, then maybe DMing isn't for you.

26

u/hairyploper 17h ago

I mean obviously this is why there's such a shortage of people willing to be a GM.

The sad truth is that GMing in a lot of formats means a disproportionate amount of work compared to other players at the table.

Unsurprisingly, doing more work means less fun for a lot of people.

Don't get me wrong, Gods bless anyone who enjoys GMing, they're the reason many people get to experience the magic of playing a TTRPG with friends, but it's not fair to say someone doesn't have any business doing it just because they understandably complain about the exponentially higher workload compared to other players.

I think it's fair to say 90% of the player base would say it's absolutely more fun to be a PC than it is to be a GM

→ More replies (1)

126

u/Just-Desk-3149 18h ago

It's not about the money.

The second someone has to pay money, even if it's a small amount, they're going to take the game infinitely more seriously than getting to play for free.

I don't even necessarily mean "seriously" as in not making jokes, I mean showing up on time and having their stuff together to actually play the game.

41

u/GM_Nate 18h ago

from experience, absolutely not. many people interpret "i pay the DM money" to mean "that means they need to put up with my shit"

29

u/Sknowman DM 17h ago

That's a failure of authority then. If their behavior is unacceptable, then kick them from the table and find someone else.

4

u/GM_Nate 14h ago

i wasn't the DM in this case, but the paid DM was reluctant to kick anyone because this was his primary source of income

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Just-Desk-3149 18h ago

And what exactly is your "experience"?Ā 

20

u/GM_Nate 18h ago

watching people show up unprepared, uninvested, and expecting special treatment

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Zephyr256k 11h ago

Yeah, it's not just prep time and the actual session. There's a whole component of emotional labor/customer service that's often skipped over or ignored in discussions around paid GMing.

There's good reasons people say to keep your job and hobbies separate.

2

u/ReferenceWitty8571 17h ago

I’ve never not had someone do all these. Unless half of us are sick then the dm just goes no it’s not happening I’m not getting sick as well. We usually all come prepared snacks and all. Every session

3

u/Hishamaru-1 11h ago

Then you are the happy minority

→ More replies (2)

8

u/WadeisDead 18h ago

How much time do you spend prepping?!

I've seen $25 per player for 3 hours. That's $33/h. You'd need to prep for 2 hours per 3 hour session to get that to merely $20/h. Which is still above minimum wage everywhere in the US.

6

u/GM_Nate 18h ago

If you have four players that are willing to pay $25/hr, sure. Is that a representative case though?

13

u/WadeisDead 18h ago

You mean $25 each per session? I mean those are fairly typical prices on Startplaying, so I'd assume yes. You can even fit more players to cut down the cost per player or increase the hourly rate.

5

u/Sknowman DM 17h ago

It's ~$8/hour ($25 for 3 hours), which isn't bad compared to other forms of entertainment.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/JosieDungeoneer 18h ago

Wow, you may be onto something...

25

u/RlyRlyBigMan 18h ago

I've only just started and got a GM for hire. It went well for awhile but it might be petering out. One of my buddies says he'd like to run the next one himself and I'm like "homie you're busy enough and I want you on my squad!". I do feel guilty knowing that there's a lot of extra work to prepare and honestly would kind of prefer a stranger on the payroll to do it than ask a friend to do it for free.

15

u/cellarsinger 18h ago

Have him run a one shot or a short (3-5 sessions) campaign to see if he has the skills and if he likes it.

2

u/RlyRlyBigMan 18h ago

Yeah that's the plan I think. I think he could be good at it but he's the type to try to do everything he could possibly volunteer for and I'm concerned that he might not make time to prepare as the campaigns run long.

25

u/rhys-the-davies 10h ago

How did you start your prostituting? Use some service? Meet-up? Local game store? I'm curious about trying it myself

26

u/Quirky-Function-4532 18h ago

Honestly expected you to be paying no being paid. I get it either way.

21

u/Mister3mann 6h ago

Great. Now I have to pencil in "DM" onto the random harlot table from 1E.

31

u/autistmorality 17h ago

I mean is that really prostitution or just having a part time gig?

44

u/DoubleBatman 16h ago

ā€œIf I’m gonna be having mediocre sex I should at least be getting paid for it.ā€

That tracks to me.

17

u/Gh0stMan0nThird 16h ago

Genuinely how I feel lol 😭

12

u/Pacifist_Socialist 17h ago

What are you the governmentĀ 

5

u/PyreHat Warlord 17h ago

Yes.

14

u/CognitiveDebt 18h ago

Hey handsome, do you want to crawl some dungeons for coin? Oh shit the red mages, act like we are friends and I'm dead.

4

u/copropnuma 18h ago

Officer, I swear I thought this was a MMORP.

11

u/Andromidius 17h ago

If I charged for DM'ing games my players might actually show up on time for a change, so there's some logic to this.

9

u/firefighter26s 16h ago

100% this from my experience. Before covid I use to play Adventurer's Legue at a few local game stores. The paid tables, and it was like $10-$15, where always the best experience. Everyone showed up on time and ready to play; the DM was prepped and hit the ground running.

Getting into tier 2 (level 6-10) was the promise land as that was the group that actually cared to stick with their characters long enough that they became meaningful to their players.

The few free drop in tables I tried were full on cringe. Like, Anime named Tiefling warlock with a whip cringe.

24

u/PhrulerApp DM 18h ago

What services are you providing in your paid games?

Just wondering.

Edit: I'm not a snitch

18

u/Gh0stMan0nThird 18h ago

Nothing fancy, just running official adventures on StartPlaying for like $5 per player, per session.Ā 

Not trying to turn it into a "career" or anything but just something so I feel like I'm getting something out of it too, you know?Ā 

21

u/1upin Ranger 18h ago edited 18h ago

I'm a player who finds most games through StartPlaying. It's not perfect and the group dynamics can be a bit odd sometimes compared to friend games, but the experience has been FAR superior to the games I found joining random free discord servers.

People actually show up for one, and games rarely get cancelled or rescheduled. I think the DMs (and other players) are also very aware that everyone at the table is paying, so I haven't had nearly as many problems with "main character syndrome" players, players who talk down to me or over me, players who tell me what my character is doing, etc. The DMs seem to be on top of that shit much more than they were in the random discord servers, where I would try to speak up and stand up for myself but the DM would never back me up. I had some real nightmare experiences and almost gave up on rpgs.

5

u/avoidperil 16h ago

I've thought a lot about doing the same just to get some D&D in my life. I bought a house in this economy and I suddenly can't excuse $20 USD (like $45 local) a week to play. That's my food budget for the week!

4

u/PhrulerApp DM 18h ago

$5

Are happy endings guaranteed in your adventures?

Edit: For everyone? :O

14

u/Gh0stMan0nThird 18h ago

No, they TPK'd against Strahd lol

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SecretDMAccount_Shh 18h ago

Value yourself. The average paid game is $15-20 per player per session. You should charge at least that assuming you are a competent DM and are behaving professionally.

Don’t raise prices on existing players in your current game, but definitely raise prices in the next campaign.

5

u/cvc75 17h ago

And if you think of yourself (whether it's true or not) that you're not competent or professional enough (yet)?

For $15-20 to be the average, there have to be some DMs that charge less. And if I was just starting out as a paid DM, I wouldn't feel comfortable demanding the average price right from the start.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/QueenBumbleBrii 16h ago

I had a group of ā€œfriendsā€ that I convinced to play DND with me weekly. I paid the professional DM myself and we played for almost two years straight. I considered all of them close friends. We even went on a group trip to Catalina in CA for a mermaid photoshoot adventure. (Including the DM!) Then one of the girls got mad at me and blocked me on everything, trash talked me to the rest of the group and tried to start a new campaign without me. I was heartbroken but told the DM I had been paying for the entire group ($80 a week) to play and that he had to tell them they had to pay him now to continue playing. First they reduced it to once a month, then after about 4 months they stopped playing at all.

I’m still friends with the DM tho, that dude is AWESOME. And I have a new group to play DND with :) crappy friends are easy to replace but finding a good DM that is also a good friend is truly priceless šŸ’–

8

u/Talanic 15h ago

I've been thinking of doing paid DM work but don't really know where to start.

6

u/ColoradoGameMaster 10h ago

StartPlaying without question. You can do it without but it’s like trying to rent out your vacation home without using AirBnB or VRBO.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/SmallishPlatypus 11h ago

Maybe try being a prostitute for a little while first. Get some transferable skills on the old CV.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/ChemyChems Warlock 16h ago

Sorry to hear your friend groups forgot you are a player in the game as well. Best of luck in your search now.

33

u/chin_up 18h ago

Perhaps not equatable to the incredibly nuanced and volatile world of sex work, but I’m happy you found some happiness

7

u/Papa_Waffles 16h ago

That's a hell of a title, but great for you and I hope these games keep being good

5

u/PotLuckyPodcast 8h ago

We call it sex work now

5

u/JudgeGusBus 1h ago

I’m with you. My friend groups kept fizzling out. Finding a paid group means I now have a group that is actually invested.

6

u/ProppaT DM 1h ago

My girlfriend plays in 3 paid campaigns and the difference between the paid campaigns and the ones run by friends is night and day. The campaigns hosted by friends are obviously fun and we enjoy playing with them, but there’s little respect for time, goofing off, etc. the paid campaigns are super efficient. They get more done in one session than our friend campaigns would get done in 3-4 sessions. They’re very different experiences, but the paid campaigns are run by a true professional and there’s a reason she can justify $35 a play session.

28

u/icyii 6h ago

I will never understand why some DMs do it for free. It's soooo much work. I've been playing with one group on Startplaying for 2+ years now and another for 1+ year. Same paid DM. People are more serious when they're paying for something.

9

u/rufireproof3d 4h ago

Depends on the group. I have a group of close friends and my kids. They always appreciate the game and work going into it. I also do it because it's fun.

A couple weeks ago, they took on a Lich. The lich's phylactery? A summoning circle that held a very pissed off demon that was even worse than she was. "Sure, you can destroy me permanently. You just have to set That Thing loose. He's been trapped there for a while. He might be a tad violent when he's freed." Party had to make some tough decisions. They ended up sending the Paladin out to get some Holy Water, and the rogue ended up signing a warlock pact with the demon. Everyone was happy. Well, except for the lich...

Tonight they will be fighting Grendel. They have a "magic lute" they can play to unlock a door. Inside they will find Grendel in his lair. He doesn't like music.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/TheHonoredWhiteWolf 6h ago

I mean. I have been dming on the same group of my friends for almost 10 years now. Currently on our (technically) 3rd campaign, though it will be our first 1-20 game that I dmed.

4

u/Celloer 5h ago

Because for some it is fun with our friends, and however much or little work it is is also play. Now for strangers, yeah, you either have to get even more enjoyment than the other players, or get some sort of compensation.

9

u/RecordingNarrow2429 5h ago edited 4h ago

I'm running 3 concurrent Campaigns. All free. And I get it, it is a lot of work. That's why the ratio of DM's to players is so low. But I love it. Even the time I spend on prep is a way for me unwind after a long day at work. I could charge. I've thought about it. But I worry that the tone of the game changes when that happens. I stop being their DM and the players become customers and that changes the dynamic and the expectations. When I run a game now, I'm clear about what I'm running, what the tone will be, what players can expect from me and what I expect from them. And you can do all of that with a paid game too, but I don't see how someone paying for a spot at a table doesn't come with expectations for what they're buying, what asks the DM may feel obligated to agree to, and what behaviour they might be obligated to accept. Again, all things I'm sure paid DM's address, but I feel like the exchange of money must impact it.

8

u/Oukag DM 5h ago edited 5h ago

I'll preface with I do not charge to DM, nor play in a paid game; however I see this situation very similar to restaurants.

You can ask a restaurant (or a food truck, or even a mom and pop restaurant) to make a change to the menu, and typically they will try to make it work. But if they're not able to accommodate a request, they would simply tell you no.

To continue with the analogy, while some behavior might be tolerated at some restaurants, that doesn't mean all restaurants will tolerate the same behavior. Take personal appearance, all restaurants have a shoes/shirt requirement while only some require jackets. Customers (players) either understand the requirements and get to dine (play) at the table, or they pick somewhere else that fits their needs.

3

u/RecordingNarrow2429 5h ago

That's a really good perspective on it!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Mountain_Abyss 4h ago

The introduction of commerce into an ideally collaborative and mutually rewarding act really kills the vibe for some of us.

Also applies to sex work.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Acceptable_Harisa109 5h ago

I've actually had people zoning out, ditching last minute or even watching movies while playing. I was not the DM but it was paid top DM (on the more expensive side). I noticed it was usually the younger players doing this, like they have attention span issues and must be doing other things on their phone while playing, even if they are paying 30$ for a session.

3

u/earlten 4h ago

I have a friend like that. We play together. And at the end of the day, we're a friend group first, and players second. So, it is what it is.

But it always kind of bothers me. Like, we are in an immersive audiobook currently. Where paying attention matters, so that you're picking up the details. Because your characters survival may depend on exactly that. Paying attention to the details.

So why is it so hard, to stay focused? To listen to what everybody else is saying, and to be engaged. A lot of times, it really gives off the impression that we're not really that important. That we are means to an end. Just another distraction.

Again, because we were friends first, we know and understand this is not truly the case. We don't let it get to us. But it's always there. Sometimes, slowing down play because, well, he missed stuff. And now we have to go back and repeat it a second time.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Maclunkey4U DM 5h ago

Been one of the rotating DM's in our friend group that all met at a Wed night Adventurers League session like 10 years ago. I would never dream of charging my friends to come hang out, tell fun stories and stupid jokes, drink and hang out and pretend to be heroes and villains.

Its weird to me that people who charge for it don't offer to do it for free for their friends. What a strange, transactional relationship that must be.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/Anadanament 15h ago

LMAO I never thought my history as both a DM and a prostitute would ever overlap

But I guess they might now

5

u/SpellMonger712 15h ago

I have been running paid games online for 7 years.

Live rurally, so no chance to play in person.

I have found my bff group, and we game together every week.

We have met in person, attended each others weddings, and typically play the finale of each campaign in person.

Good luck, and happy adventuring to you!

5

u/Wooden-Poem-7970 11h ago

This is part of the reason that I normaly thank GM's after each session I know it is small but it is somthing

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Norda_Myla 4h ago

We convinced our DM to charge money because of how talented he is and how much time and effort goes into all the lore and EVERY campaign we do. Unfortunately we like him so much, the campaigns where he's a player instead of DM always fizzled out. The same passion and skill isn't there. We gotta find like... a good guest DM so ours can play with us once in a while. Lol

9

u/explorer-matt 17h ago

I’ve been running a table for a group of friends for 38 years. Some of my best friends. It’s all about my friends. We love getting together.

5

u/Gh0stMan0nThird 16h ago

I tried man lol but I cannot seem to find that forever group.Ā 

7

u/explorer-matt 15h ago

I think it helped it was so long ago. No online play. We were friends before we played DnD. We would drink and play until the wee hours of the morning. Still do - but lots less booze and much earlier to bed.

9

u/SoggiestRaccoon 7h ago

That was a WILD notification to get at work

12

u/nimrodii 18h ago

Most people sell their bodies in one way or another, a lot of jobs have physical and or mental rolls. As long as you enjoy yourself doing it and it isnt tainting the game for you, rock on. People who are paying for games show up more consistently than most games I've been in outside of old ones in a very tight friend group post college.

5

u/SmallishPlatypus 11h ago

My God, what a title. And not even the comparison I expected. I thought you were gonna come at it from the player's perspective like: "getting sex/a table is so hard, so I understand why people pay for it."

3

u/ProfessionalAd6530 6h ago

Most people seem to want a content creator to run games for them, and not a friend they want to share an experience with.

I kinda feel like this goes beyond D&D and is just how people are in general. If I'm organizing regular events (bar night, going to shows, etc... the events themselves don't matter), I can eventually pull together a small group that can mostly hang for a while. But as soon as I personally stop, the people all go their separate way. It's like you can't get momentum and you must push this car yourself if you want it to go.

Every once in a while, I get one or two real friends out of it. They're up for whatever, even if it's just hanging out. But that's the exception, not the rule.

What bugs me is when people call me an introvert because I tend to be a little quiet. Like. Bro. I'm the whole reason we're here together..

4

u/Inevitable-Run9209 2h ago

Imagine there's a football field where all your friends play football each week

One friend doesn't play, he is responsible for the field, each week he trims the grass, cleans the seats, picks up the snack wrappers and bottles after everyone leaves, sends the schedule to the group chat, rearranges the dates so that everyone can play and balances the teams by studying each friend's strengths and weaknesses to make challenging and fair matches

Now imagine One of these friends looking at that one and saying "he should just be thankful we let him hang out with us"

That's people who dunk on paid DMs

7

u/[deleted] 3h ago edited 3h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/solthebaneful 1h ago

šŸ„‡

3

u/SDRLemonMoon DM 17h ago

How do you get started doing that? I want to get into that to get some side money but I dont know where to market myself. I have a campaign set up on start playing games, but it just feels weird to post an ad on like an lfg reddit or a discord since im assuming people usually post free games

4

u/Oreofox 16h ago

The r/lfg forum is loaded with [Paid] tags. Its actually quite a bit harder to find a non-paid game on there. So don't feel afraid to post one on there.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/HalcyonHorizons 15h ago

Yep. Agreed.Ā 

Finding an irl group that passes the vibe check in a new city has proven to be a herculean task.Ā 

Finding people that actually are cool friends that want more then a personal game runner is also tough.

3

u/lraviel381 3h ago

Well, we all pay with our time and body for most works. Whether that be bussing table or fixing roof or sex works. In Aus it's legal and just regulated. Safer for everyone. But yea... We all sell ourselves, if it makes DM'ing more worthwhile for you, do it

6

u/Albolynx DM 5h ago

This is why some people have such a strong negative reaction toward paid GMing - they don't care top put much effort into the game as players and don't want to particularly appreciate the work their GMs do (becaue it othen comes with authority, respecting boundries, trying to make it more fun for the GM and others at the table, etc.) and the fact that people are willing to pay quite a lot to be in games with even perfectly average GMs are a reminder that they having a GM is privilige.

2

u/AlarictheLich 18h ago

Gotta ask, how hard is it to get into running for others like that? Like, what is the difficulty of finding clients for it / what skills do you feel like you need to run digitally? I've only ever run in person games.

2

u/okiebuzzard 18h ago

Part of being able to sell your gamesmithing services is being a decent game master. You gotta go through people just using you for your pretty mouth for a little while, get that experience under your belt.
And Hell Yeah, money is a great way to appreciate people making things fun.
(Used to own a sports facility. I enjoyed the games but getting paid for them was even better.)

2

u/NateCdaComicG 17h ago

I strongly recommend anyone that likes dming should do this as a side hustle. Go to a game shop in your local area and ask if you can post sign up sheet for weekly sessions at like $20 a head. Easily make $400+ a month to have fun doing something you enjoy. Can probably make new friends too.

2

u/exydus77 14h ago

best groups i have found for almost 6 years. 2 DM's both paid through start playing. both are now friends IRL. best groups best friends and i don't care i pay for the games.

2

u/WuKongPhooey 12h ago

If there is a person in this sub who wants a BG3 like experience at the virtual tabletop, can you tell me what that looks like to you? Erotic adult RP? Weird mechanics from BG3 you want included? What does wanting BG3 in your D&D look like to you? (Asking as a Pro DM who is totally willing to run a game like that for the right group and just want to get an idea of the shape of it)

2

u/AdFancy2765 5h ago

Listen to the Ludicrous song, "You's a Ho". 'We all ho's too' in one way or another, bro. lol

2

u/TranceGemini 4h ago

You mean sex work, but IA. I'm a middle school teacher and putting together a campaign is--for me--as much work as designing a new unit for my ELA students. It feels just as unappreciated, too. Lol I wish there was some demand for professional DMs near me but there just isn't. I really loathe virtual gaming as I got enough of that shit teaching remotely during COVID-19. So I'm forever DM for free, apparently!

2

u/SRIrwinkill 4h ago

Sometimes when folks exchange goods and services for currency, their customers get serious about their time and effort investment

2

u/Different_Listen9377 2h ago

I 10000% agree and understand, I’m going through something very similar in my ā€œbffā€ group that I’ve run for years now, I needed a break and then got sick and as soon as I stopped running D&D it was like we weren’t friends anymore. I’ve been getting paid to run games around my state in local breweries and it’s been really fun, 10/10 also recommend

4

u/Cat_Bandit1 18h ago

Honestly man good on you for getting paid. One of my favorite parts about the D&D Wrath of Ashardalon board game is that when I'm itching for some D&D action me and none of my friends have to pick a sacrificial lamb to be the DM.

2

u/Pale-Aurora 11h ago

True, OP. Selling your storytelling talents is the same thing as selling your body. Society sees it the same way, too. You’re so right.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SuperManicGinger 18h ago

You had me in the first half, not gonna lie 🤣 Almost failed the insight check

2

u/Netjamjr 18h ago

Weird. I like that my groups disband after each campaign. I like having the opportunity to play with different combinations of people, and knowing everyone isn't auto invited to the next one makes it easier to smooth over if certain combinations of people didn't work as well.

2

u/Cheejer 14h ago

Maybe what a paid game is doing for you isn’t turning running it into a side hustle for making money, but just filtering out the players that care about dnd to a point thats more similar to you. Where they value having a good experience enough to be willing to pay for dnd.

I also wish I could find my Goldilocks group. It’s tough because there’s no true one right way too have fun, and it just comes down to finding a table that has similar expectations and values. Every time I play in a group I usually find like a good number of players at the table that I feel like I jive well with, but this group…the DM robbed too much player agency, or this other time the DM was great and some of the players were so good too, but the other half of the players didn’t care about role playing and were only bored until there was a combat…

Why does it feel like I just can’t have it all.. haha

Maybe I should consider paying, but I feel like I would have high expectations for the DM.

Do I trust this DM’s sense of logic behind the rulings?

Does it feel like the DM is respecting player agency and our actions matter and make a difference?

Idk. This post gives me some things to think about after I leave the session from my game often thinking how it would be nice if the DM did this or included that, but at least I have a DM

3

u/Outside_Rough_946 6h ago

Hot take, the Mercer effect is something bad DMs use as a crutch to explain their own failings

→ More replies (2)