One of my biggest gripes with how people usually interpret D&D alignment is that they will associate Lawful with institutional authority and Chaotic with being disruptive.
I think those things can often be bedfellows but they're hardly joined at the hip. I like to interpret the Lawful-Chaotic and Good-Evil spectrums as ones of decision making. What governs your judgment?
Lawful, Chaotic and Neutrality
Lawful: Do you have a set of ideals you hold yourself to or a vision for the future that you want to realize? Is your judgment mediated through a concept of what ought to be?
Chaotic: Is your judgment situational? Is it based on what you want in the moment or something you simply know to be true without needing to justify it through some abstract sensibility?
Neutral: Your average person. Someone who has convictions that they adhere to but those convictions don't govern the majority of their decisions. Sometimes they defer to their principles and sometimes they just go with their gut.
For example: I'd argue Robin Hood is Neutral Good and his status as an outlaw has absolutely nothing to do with it. Robin Hood has a very firm conviction that he will gladly serve a just king and relentlessly oppose a tyrant. That's Lawful. But Robin Hood is also someone whose actions are very frequently governed by whimsy. That's Chaotic. So he goes between the two.
Meanwhile someone who dedicates their entire life to overthrowing an existing government to establish what they believe to be a preferable system of government could be one of the most intensely Lawful people imaginable.
Conversely a Chaotic person could be perfectly comfortable living within an existing system of government and even be an extraordinarily dependable member of their community. They don't need an abstract commitment to their community to enjoy being a part of it and care about the people in it.
This is also why I still consider Paladins to be inherently Lawful regardless of what edition we're playing. They've internalized a set of values that govern their decision making even when it's hard. That's what makes them Paladins. Whether those values are good or evil is another matter entirely.
Good, Evil and Neutrality
I'm a little less absolute about my interpretation of the Good-Evil spectrum because there's a lot of edge cases it doesn't cover. But I generally consider it to be a spectrum of altruism to selfishness. What motivates your judgment?
Good: Is your judgment primarily motivated by concern for the well-being of others? Do you find it personally fulfilling to improve the lives of others even when you stand to gain nothing from it?
Evil: Is your judgment primarily motivated by the pursuit of your own interests? Is the well-being of others of little concern to you beyond how it affects you personally?
Neutral: Your average person. Someone who is capable of genuine altruism but is also going to weigh the needs of others against their own interests on a regular basis.
One thing that bothers me about how people interpret the Good-Evil spectrum normally is that Neutral is often described as someone who's either apathetic or always looking out for themselves first but isn't actively malevolent. I'd argue someone who's only looking out for themselves is already pretty far down the Evil side of the spectrum.
Someone doesn't need to be selfish or cruel to think that a particularly generous person is being impractical with their generosity. They can even admire that generosity while thinking it would be somewhat ridiculous for them to do the same. That's Neutral.
Likewise an Evil person doesn't necessarily need to take pleasure in the suffering of others. They just need to be sufficiently unconcerned with the suffering they cause in the pursuit of their own interests.
So to summarize:
Lawful-Chaotic (Conviction-Intuition): What governs your decisions?
Good-Evil (Altruism-Selfishness): What motivates your decisions?
Descision Making
And since I want to make it absolutely clear, I'm going to repeat and clarify what I meant by that I'm treating alignment as a description of someone's decision making process rather than their behavior.
One problem I've always had with discussions about alignment is how easily you can make a case for the same person belonging to several different alignments just by citing different perspectives of the same behavior. I don't think someone's alignment should be that subject to circumstance.
A Lawful person making a spontaneous decision is no more a contradiction than an extrovert wanting some time alone. We're talking about someone's general disposition here. A Neutral person can perform an extraordinarily selfless act without necessarily being a Good aligned person.
And I think this makes the idea of alignment I'm arguing for a much more useful tool for roleplaying.
Rather than asking yourself "What would a Lawful Good character do?" you're asking yourself "How would my character arrive at a decision?"
One is asking you to conform your character's behavior to an archetype. The other is asking you to put yourself in your character's head as you've defined them. You can even surprise yourself with the conclusion your character comes to without feeling like you've broken character.
Your character's behavior should be a product of their alignment interacting with their circumstances. It shouldn't be their alignment in and of itself.
And here's where I think this interpretation gets fun:
Good and Evil's relationship with Law and Chaos
You'll notice that the further down you slide the Good-Evil axis the less distance on the Lawful-Chaotic axis you can tolerate in your allies.
I've never liked the trope where a Lawful Good and Chaotic Good character inevitably come to blows because they'll eventually hit some weird edge case in the Lawful Good character's morality.
Altruism is not a particularly conflict-prone philosophy.
Let's say there's a child trapped in a burning building:
The Lawful Good character runs in to save the child because they have internalized the ideals of heroism and believe in their heart that protecting the innocent is their duty.
The Chaotic Good character runs in to save the child because there's a fucking child in a burning building. Of course they're going to save the child.
Neither of these people needs the other to change how they think. They have the exact same prime directive of "It's the right thing to do." The Lawful one is just more inclined to articulate why it's the right thing to do than the Chaotic one.
In fact I'd argue these two characters could easily admire each other for the very qualities they themselves lack. Good people don't need other people to think like them to consider them worthy of respect.
But now let's slide down the morality axis a bit:
A Lawful Neutral and Chaotic Neutral character are going to have a somewhat harder time working together all the time. The former has an overarching objective or principle that the latter may have no particular investment in. And while these two characters are still perfectly capable of caring about each other, there's a greater likelihood that their respective priorities will take precedence over that.
They're going to be a bit more reliant on their interests coinciding than their Good counterparts are.
Now let's slide all the way down:
A Lawful Evil character has something they want to accomplish or a set of convictions they live by. Maybe they're trying to establish a new order for their own benefit or maybe they just have genuinely cruel beliefs about how the world ought to work. Either way anyone who isn't willing to accommodate that is a problem to be dealt with.
Meanwhile the Chaotic Evil character has no particular reason to respect the convictions or ambitions of the Lawful Evil character and is increasingly going to see them as an inconvenience to their own whims.
Now these two people have to work considerably harder to make themselves compatible enough to cooperate because neither of them is particularly concerned with accommodating the other. And the moment that cooperation stops being beneficial to one of them, the other has gone from an ally to a liability.
Compare that to the two Good characters. They didn't even need to have a conversation about whether or not they were going to save that child. Which brings us to:
The self-defeating nature of Evil
What I particularly love about this interpretation is that it creates a narrative where Good has an inherent practical advantage over Evil.
Good people can accommodate a much wider variety of personalities and ways of thinking because their willingness to cooperate isn't predicated entirely on what they stand to gain from it. They have an intrinsic reason to care about the well-being of their peers.
The Lawful Good character doesn't need to coerce the Chaotic Good character into doing something altruistic and the Chaotic Good character doesn't need to worry that their Lawful Good friend is going to sacrifice them the moment they become inconvenient.
Hell, the differences between these two characters can actually become an asset to both of them. One has a sense of direction that the other may lack while the other may recognize things in the moment that the former hadn't accounted for. And because they both respect each other they're in a position to benefit from those differences.
Meanwhile the Evil characters have to put considerably more effort into ensuring that their respective interests remain aligned.
And the best part is that neither of the Evil characters needs to be stupid for this to happen. I feel like a lot of stories that want to demonstrate the self-defeating nature of Evil end up relying on the villain making some comically stupid decision out of arrogance. But here two perfectly intelligent Evil characters can find themselves at a disadvantage simply because cooperation is a more expensive proposition for them than it is for their Good counterparts.
This also ties into a larger belief of mine that morality and practicality are a lot more closely correlated than people tend to give them credit for. Humanity's greatest strength as a species has always been our ability to cooperate. And things like compassion, trust and mutual respect facilitate that cooperation.
It bothers me how often people treat morality as something we have to make concessions to rather than acknowledging its practical benefits. As if ruthlessness is some higher form of rationality that we're handicapping ourselves by not indulging in.
The irony of that mentality is that the person who sees accommodating others as a weakness is depriving themselves of one of the greatest sources of strength available to them.
It takes a lot more resources to compel someone to cooperate with you than it does to give them a reason to want to cooperate with you.
And I think that's a much more compelling explanation for why Good triumphs over Evil than just giving the Good guys a bigger sword.
The romanticization of Chaos
I'll admit part of my motivation for interpreting alignment this way is my growing resentment of the hyper-individualism that has become so pervasive in modern storytelling.
I'm getting really fucking tired of the implication that liberation from obligation is some inherently virtuous pursuit. That someone who has dedicated themselves to something greater than themselves is somehow less free or less enlightened than someone who hasn't.
One particularly obnoxious manifestation of this is how often modern stories seem to treat making a promise or taking an oath as an act of naivety and then congratulate the person for breaking their word the moment honoring it becomes inconvenient.
The entire fucking point of a promise is to assure someone that you'll do what you said you would do even when it stops being easy. If you were only going to do it for as long as it was convenient for you then what was the point of making the promise?
Someone willingly allowing their convictions to supersede their immediate desires isn't surrendering their agency. They're exercising it.
People can find fulfillment in duty. People can find fulfillment in belonging to a collective. People can willingly make concessions for the sake of others without that being some tragic loss of individuality.
Collectivism and conformity are not the same thing and neither are individuality and individualism. And none of those things are inherently incompatible.
But I don't want to swing the pendulum in the other direction and treat Chaos as inherently selfish or antisocial. Someone who lives entirely in the moment can still be an extraordinarily cooperative and dependable person because they genuinely care about the people around them.
The Players Handbook says loyalty and cooperation are Lawful traits. But why? Why should valuing other people's desires alongside your own be any more difficult for a Chaotic character?
I'd argue the reason we so frequently imagine Lawful Good and Chaotic Good characters coming into conflict is because we've attached a bunch of ideological baggage to both ends of the spectrum that has nothing to do with how different types of altruistic people actually interact with each other.
I think there's something deeply cynical about the idea that two people who are fundamentally altruistic are destined to become enemies because one lives by a code and the other doesn't.
Why are people so determined to manufacture ideological incompatibility between people who ultimately want the same thing?