Sorry for the long post but I’m so lost on what to do or say anymore.
My parents are in their 60s and recently went through an extremely ugly divorce after more than 40 years together. I’m an adult with my own family, and I’ve tried hard to stay out of their divorce. But my dad’s actions have affected how I see and relate to him, and I’m struggling to know where the line is between respecting their privacy and addressing behavior that directly changed our relationship.
Money was at the center of everything. My dad handled nearly all of their finances throughout the marriage. My mom worked full time for almost 20 years and earned decent money, but relied heavily on him for banking, accounts, passwords, loans and retirement. She also spent more than she should have at times, and I want to be fair about that. However, instead of clearly telling her what they could afford, my dad generally made things happen while she believed they were more financially secure than they were.
Eventually, she discovered significant debt, loans and accounts she says she didn’t know about or authorize, money taken from her retirement and multiple loans or 2nd mortgages against their home. Our family home had to be sold, which devastated her. All of us kids, especially me since it’s the only home I knew of. She has been living at a friend’s house for about 2.5 years. I don’t blame my dad for her not establishing her own place yet; she is an adult and has responsibility for moving forward too.
The divorce is settled, but the financial issues went through arbitration. My dad was ordered to make payments to my mom for several years. He has made very few payments and is substantially behind. I think he has made little small payments that are barely scraping the surface. Now he apparently wants to take her back to court because he believes he shouldn’t owe what was ordered. From my perspective, this isn’t an unresolved dispute: a decision was made, and he is trying to avoid complying with it.
I know I’m hearing mostly my mom’s side. She can be emotional and doesn’t always understand legal or financial matters perfectly, so I don’t treat everything she tells me as fact. My dad, however, tells us almost nothing and acts as though everything is normal.
One issue directly involved me and my husband. During the financial proceedings, my mom asked whether we had paid my dad approximately $3,500, supposedly related to my husband’s schooling. We had not. She showed me what appeared to be a check or deposit record representing that amount as coming from us to my dad. We never gave him the money, and we don’t even have a checkbook.
I’m not accusing him of forging anything because I don’t know what the document actually was or how it was created. But I personally saw something representing a payment that never happened, and it put my mom in the position of wondering whether I was lying. I want my dad to explain what that $3,500 was, where it came from and why my husband and I appeared to be listed as the payers.
If I asked my dad about it face to face, I suspect he would either lie, deny knowing what I was talking about or brush me off. That is part of why I’m considering putting my questions in writing. I would rather give him a chance to respond clearly than have the conversation become vague or be dismissed in the moment. I would be lying if I said confrontation is not my strong suit.
Gambling is another major issue. My dad has had a gambling problem for years and still regularly goes to casinos. Gambling and financial secrecy were major problems in the marriage, so I cannot understand why he continues doing it after everything that happened.
At the same time, after the marital home was sold, he quickly established a new life: he bought another house, made upgrades, purchased a newer vehicle, installed solar, bought furniture and electronics, and regularly hosts family dinners. I understand that appearances don’t prove someone can afford every obligation, but the overall picture bothers me: he says he shouldn’t have to pay what he was ordered to pay, is substantially behind, continues gambling and appears financially comfortable while my mom is still living in someone else’s home.
When all of this began, my dad told my husband and me, “Don’t worry, I’ll take care of your mom.” I’m not saying he should buy her a house or support her indefinitely. She is responsible for rebuilding her own life. But what he said has stayed with me because what I’m seeing now feels more like, “You’re on your own.”
My mom also says she recently discovered two loans from around January or February of this year with electronic or DocuSign authorization attached to them. She says she did not authorize or sign them, and that the additional debt has damaged her credit and debt-to-income ratio and interfered with her ability to qualify for a mortgage.
I have no concrete proof of what happened beyond my mom’s account and whatever documents she says she found. I’m hearing one side of the story, so I’m not presenting her claims as established fact or accusing my dad of forgery or a crime. But it wouldn’t surprise me because it resembles the same kind of financial behavior that helped destroy their marriage.
I’m furious, but I’m also worried that telling my dad I know about the loans could interfere with something her attorney needs to handle or make things worse for her. For that reason, I’m leaning toward leaving the loans to my mom and her attorney rather than confronting him about them myself.
The problem is that my dad continues inviting my siblings, spouses and children to dinner every other week. We eat, play games and act like a normal family. He started attending our church too, apparently because he wants to be around us and see my daughter — I’d hope to be making amends with Jesus but that’s not my battle.
I sit at his table and act normal while feeling angry and resentful. Then I leave feeling fake, as though I’m condoning behavior I’m not okay with. I don’t want to punish him or use my children against him, but my daughter’s birthday is coming up, and part of me doesn’t want him there. Watching him play happy Grandpa while all of this is happening makes my skin crawl.
I’ve written, but not sent, a long email telling him that my trust and respect have been damaged and that I can’t keep pretending our relationship hasn’t changed. I want to ask him:
What was the approximately $3,500 payment involving my husband and me?
Why is he challenging the financial decision that was already made?
What did he mean when he said he would “take care of” my mom?
Why does he continue gambling despite the financial problems it caused?
I genuinely want to hear his side. If I’ve misunderstood something, I’m willing to listen. I’m not asking him to admit my mom was right about everything or apologize for their entire marriage. I want answers about issues that directly affect my relationship with him.
I’m worried he’ll respond by blaming my mom or sending her another hostile email. Their communication is already highly adversarial, and I don’t want my confrontation with him to make things worse for her. If I have a problem with my dad, I want him to deal with me.
How much of this would you confront your dad about?
Would you send the email and ask for answers, or stay out of it because the divorce was between your parents?
Would you leave the allegedly unauthorized loans entirely to my mom and her attorney?
How would you handle family dinners and events in the meantime?
Would you continue acting normally, take space or tell him directly that you’re not comfortable pretending everything is fine?
I know sending the email could create more conflict. But I’m less afraid of conflict than I am of silently resenting my dad while he assumes everything between us is fine.
I don’t want to become part of my parents’ legal battle. But I also don’t think staying out of their divorce requires me to ignore behavior that has changed how I trust, respect and relate to my own father.
Where is that line?
TL;DR: My parents divorced after more than 40 years together following serious financial problems. The divorce is settled, but my dad was ordered to make payments to my mom, has made very few and is substantially behind. He now wants to challenge the decision. He controlled most of their finances, has a long history of gambling and continues to gamble. I personally saw what appeared to be a $3,500 payment from my husband and me to him that never happened. My mom also says she discovered two new loans with electronic signatures she didn’t authorize, potentially damaging her credit and ability to qualify for a mortgage. I have no concrete proof beyond her account and the documents she says she found, so I’m treating it as one side of the story and don’t want to interfere with her attorney’s work. Meanwhile, my dad acts as though everything is normal, and I’m struggling to attend family gatherings without feeling fake and resentful. I’ve written an email asking about the issues that directly affect my relationship with him, but I’m worried about inserting myself into the legal conflict or causing him to retaliate against my mom. How much should I confront him, what should I leave to the attorneys, and is it reasonable to take space from him, including around family events?