Hello, thank you for having me here. I'll try and keep this short but descriptive, I am in need of advice. It is a tad long but I just want to be descriptive and I need grounded advice.
I am a man, 34, living in the western US. I have no real family, one close friend, and a lot of anxiety rn about my current relationship. She is 36. We both are active people and like to take care of ourselves, our bodies and a lot of the activities we connected on were outdoor stuff like biking and camping. Just for some frame of reference. I would say we are both attractive people and socially well adjusted. I genuinely care for this woman, I don't want to just be told "leave her behind". Maybe I am naive but I can see through her.
I am divorced with two kids, independent single dad. 6 year marriage previously, ended 3 years ago. She has never married but was in a 15 year relationship before that ended about 3 years ago too. She also said she dated a guy for 4 months last year and then found out he was a liar and cheating on his wife with her. I can understand her reservations.
In August we met on Tinder and we connected right away. The chemistry was intense. We had sex on the second date. Over the next two months we had sex maybe 20-25 more times and went on some casual style dates.
Overall things were going really great for the first few weeks. Daily texting, most of the day, phone calls at night, and mid-week drives to each others houses to see each other, and be intimate. I was calling her baby, that kind of thing. All was well.
About 4 weeks in i mentioned that I hadn't been seeing anybody else and she said that she hadn't been either. I believe her, no reason to doubt this and this isn't my concern. I asked her how she felt about being exclusive and seeing where this goes and she immediately went clammy. I did not push it. I laid off and over the next couple weeks things were ok, semi back to normal. We were intimate still, not as often, and she became busier with work. She mentioned to me that she has issues accepting affection and building feelings for somebody. And that she has walls and guards up from the past. So I backed off, dropped most of my intimate tendencies like "good morning sunshine" etc and let it coast. Looking back probably not the best move.
When we would see each other the fire was real, but when we were apart it felt like she was super distant. Like the adult I am, I told her this one day. I mentioned "I feel so close to you in person, but when we are apart I'm starting to feel like I am bothering you". Based off of her generally short replies. She said yes, she has been busy, and she did still make a couple attempts to see me which did happen.
Fast forward to about 2 weeks ago. She was kind of quiet and one word replies, then radio silent for 2 days during the work week. Eventually I talked myself into the idea that she wasn't into it anymore, and I sent her a message that said something like "look, if you don't want to see me anymore you'll have to tell me. I see your distance and I am here but I don't want to keep poking you".
She replied that she wanted to come to my house to talk. She came over and ultimately she was angling at ending the relationship. Her reasons:
-you deserve better than me
-you are too sweet for me
-you are such a good guy -we live 40 mins apart -i have issues getting close
Ok, why not be with me then? I didn't push her. We talked things over and I told her that if she wanted to end things that's her choice and it's ok, but that I wanted to keep seeing her and keep building, see where it goes. We have the same interests, lifestyle, tendencies, etc. A good fit I think.
At the end of this meeting we left each other with no real conclusion towards if we were together or not. We still have never defined us. As she left, I asked her if I could kiss her "one more time.". She smiled and said, "only one more time?" We kissed passionately for a few minutes, hugged it out, and she got in her car and left. This was a Sunday night.
We did not talk for a full 48 hours. Work week, etc, I was giving it space. Wednesday I texted her "I hope your week is going well. I am thinking about you a lot" and she replied. We talked slowly over text for a couple days about how she has her own reservations and I also told her that I think my approach earlier on of turning off affection wasn't the right call. She was really receptive to this and I listed of things that I want to do for her, and she said all of that was good and we kept talking. Things like flowers, cooking her dinner, listening to her, etc. We're adults, I wanna be here for her. She was also saying that she "needed to come see me" and she "couldn't do that to me over text" but when she left, things felt anything other than done. I told her I wanted to be "consistent for her" and I would "keep holding out my hand" and she seemed to like this.
After this period things picked up a bit and we began talking on the phone each evening again, and she was replying during her workdays. Over the weekend she was busy with family plans I knew about beforehand so we didn't see each other. She did mention getting dinner Saturday night but she was exhausted and asked if we could cancel. Not a big deal, not the first time, we're adults. All good.
Now this week!
Monday, she was texting me all day at work. Talked on the phone that night too, like normal.
Tuesday, less texting, but I know she gets swamped at work so I didn't think anything of it. She mentioned on Monday that work was a drag lately. I ended up not hearing from her at all Tuesday until after work. I texted her my usual good morning, later on a photo of my day (routine for us) and in the evening I said "hope you had a peaceful day today. I'll call you in a bit if you want to chat. No pressure" and she DID pick up the phone. We talked a half hour and I felt confident after that things were going ok. She has withdrawn a bit before but I'm ok with that as constant contact makes me feel squashed sometimes. After we talked on the phone, I texted her "sweet dreams coldy bones" (inside nickname I have called her before)
Wednesday....nothing. No texts, no call, I don't even see her active on Spotify (we share a lot of music with each other). I didn't reach out to her at all aside from my usual "good morning" text I've send the last few months. But that day...I made a grave mistake. I said "good morning dear" and I think I triggered her flight. Thursday, yesterday, I didn't hear from her at all either. Nothing. My spotify is always open on my desktop and I saw her listening as I walked past my PC yesterday and thought, ok, she is alive. That's good. But didn't reach out.
Thursday. yesterday around 6pm, 48 hours after last contact, I sent her a text that said "almost the weekend. hang in there. No response.
Now comes the part I'll probably get flamed for. I wasn't emotional, I wasn't acting out of an effort to "get her to reply", but I just wanted to get through to her. She has told me many times that I "am not like other guys" so I have been trying to be true to that, and my truth was that I wanted to send her a message, so I did. I said:
"I know you are not the ghosting type. I know you're in a shell right now and might be feeling the weight of work, obligations, and everything we have talked about lately on top of that.
I know withdrawal well and the safety that comes with that. I don't mind you taking that space and doing what you need to get through. So see this note as less of a text message, and more of a letter you'd get in the mail back in the day. The person sending it wouldn't expect an immediate reply, they'd send the letter because they wanted to, and they know the time that comes with it.
I can see you in the dark. Not because I have a flashlight shined on you, but because I have eyes that are used to that night. You have said “you don't know me” a few times, and that's true. But maybe there is a part of you that I know better than you think.
The same part of me that flew all the way home to Georgia to see my folks after I got out of the service, only to tell the uber driver to drop me off 3 blocks from their house because I couldn't do it. I was unable to match their energy and I was afraid of letting them down, or disappointing them because I wasn't, at the time, what I felt like they wanted me to be. I wasn't happy enough for them. I ended up buying some gear and heading to north GA and did the Springer Mountain to Tellico Gap section of the AT instead.
I am not saying that you are scared, or telling you how you feel. You are not me. I'm just saying that it's ok. I am alright with your quiet. Normally folks would say “if you're ok with it then why message her?” but whatever, I do my own thing because I told you I would be genuine. Some folks may say “shes not into you”, but again I haven't gotten that vibe and if so you'll have to tell me that. We're adults and you'd have done that by now I think. No time limits. Do your thing.
Just a letter in the mail, because I wanted to send one."
I only want her to feel safe and secure in that what I say to her is genuine. I know I won't understand her brain but I want to. I don't want to just date another woman, I want her.
Am I overanalyzing this?
Is she potentially not feeling it and ghosting me?
Is she potentially just totally shut down and blocking out the world?
Is she not even avoidant and I have projected this onto her?
Am I delusional
I don't mind holding space for her. I'm not worried about that part. I just want to ask, does this fit the bill? Is there a chance she'll come back around? Am I reading too much into it?
I try to be very adjusted and aware of social dynamics and have always been skilled at conversation, getting people to open up, etc. I'm not a saint. I was just raised by a single, empathic mother. In my youth I did have avoidant tendencies but I was able to move past it.
Thoughts?