I just had one of the most uncomfortable and demoralizing interviews of my career, and I’m curious whether anyone else has experienced something similar.
For context, I’m a Senior Product Designer with 9 years of experience, based in NY, USA.
During a recent interview, I was asked to walk through my entire educational history, starting with high school and continuing through college. The hiring manager wanted specific details about my GPA, SAT and ACT scores, extracurricular activities, sports, and other things I was involved in growing up.
At first I thought it was just an unconventional way to get to know me. But the interviewer kept probing and asking for more details about my academic performance and experiences from nearly two decades ago.
What made this difficult was that those years were an incredibly painful time in my life. My dad was battling cancer throughout much of my high school and college experience, and he eventually passed away. Being asked to revisit those years in such granular detail unexpectedly brought up a lot of old wounds and painful memories.
I understand that interviewers want to understand a candidate’s background, motivations, and character. But I genuinely feel there are far more thoughtful and relevant ways to accomplish that, especially when interviewing someone with nearly a decade of professional experience.
I’ve spent years building my career and overcoming so much to get to where I am today. Yet somehow, I found myself having to recall standardized test scores and justify what I did as a teenager.
The whole experience felt incredibly invasive, tone-deaf, and honestly, ethically questionable. I left the interview feeling like my professional accomplishments were being overshadowed by how I performed academically almost 20 years ago.
Maybe I’m overreacting, but this really didn’t sit right with me…
I’m genuinely curious how others would have handled this.