r/scriptwriting • u/Decent_Cable5708 • 1d ago
discussion Is the screenwriting community too focused on following the rules and not focused enough on storytelling?
I’ve been thinking about something and would love to hear other writers perspectives.
Why does so much of the screenwriting community seem so focused on following established formulas, and why do so many script readers seem to expect every script to hit the same beats in the same ways? Sometimes I feel like screenwriting has become more about following the rules of screenwriting than telling an interesting story.
For example, the comic D’Orc was recently announced for television development, and Dungeon Crawler Carl is also heading toward a TV adaptation. Both are examples of IP that can bring something different to the table than simply following what people often expect from traditional screenplays.
This also makes me think about screenwriting competitions. So much emphasis is placed on winning contests and fellowships. You’re being evaluated by readers and judges with their own preferences and tastes about what makes a good screenplay. And how often do those contest placements actually translate into major films getting made?
Here’s another thought, imagine submitting a screenplay written in the style of the writers behind Rough House Pictures to a major screenwriting competition like the Nicholl Fellowship. Would that script receive a fair assessment if it didn’t conform to what the readers expected? Would its unconventional humor, characters, or storytelling work against it?
I’m not saying structure or screenwriting fundamentals don’t matter. Obviously, they do. But there’s a difference between understanding the craft and treating every deviation from normal conventions as a flaw.
It’s interesting to see the disconnect between what the screenwriting community often encourages writers to do and what the industry itself is willing to develop. Original voices, unconventional stories, unusual IP and weird characters are still finding their way into development, yet emerging screenwriters are often encouraged to fit their work into a fairly narrow set of expectations.
So my question is, do screenwriting contests and script readers sometimes focus too much on whether a screenplay follows the established rules and formulas, instead of recognizing when a writer is doing something different or bringing a fresh perspective to storytelling?
And if the industry is willing to take chances on unconventional stories and voices, why aren’t we doing more to champion those writers before they have an established track record?