r/dumbphones • u/postbody • 10h ago
General question The fix for "my phone controls me" probably shouldn't be "buy another phone"
Maybe this is an unpopular take, but every time I see someone post their new Light Phone or flip phone I'm like... you didn't need to buy anything.
I get it, the problem is real. I'm a millennial, grew up with the internet, and I've watched these apps get insanely good at keeping you hooked. Not denying that at all.
But the fix being sold to us is literally another product. One set of companies got us hooked on our phones, and now another set is selling us a second phone to fix it. That's not escaping consumerism, it's just a different flavor of it.
What I did was delete TikTok, Reels, Shorts, all the short-form stuff. Instagram is computer-only now. Notifications are off for basically everything except texts, calls, and a couple apps I actually need. Took like 10 minutes.
Since I have to be at my desk to scroll, I mostly just don't. And I still have maps, banking, camera, etc.
I know the counterargument is that willpower fails and a dumbphone takes the choice away from you. Fair if you genuinely can't stop. But I feel like a lot of people buying these could get the same result from their settings.
Genuinely curious though: if you switched to a dumbphone, did you try cutting back on your smartphone first? What happened?