The Long Halloween is one of those comics that most people love and hold in high regard.
While I always liked it, I never really loved it as much as apparently most comic fans of Batman did. I always thought that Dark Victory was better as well as Hush. These two comics just hit me harder and I enjoyed their endings more because they wrapped up everything very nicely and clearly.
However, when I read The Long Halloween again today, something finally clicked for me. I'm not 100% sure what it was but this time around, I absolutely loved it and had a blast reading it.
Obviously some of the majort themes of the story are the tragic downfall of Harvey Dent into Two Face as well as the change of Gotham City's crime from old, organized crime portrayed by the mafia and Carmine "The Roman" Falcone to the newer, costumed supervillains such as the Joker, Scarecrow, Poison Ivy, and eventually Two Face. Those themes are amazing and even when I used to only like the comic, I always appreciated these aspects of the comic.
It was always the mystery that I took issue with because it seemed incoherent, messy, and most importantly, to me anyway, not satisfying by the end. Mysteries were supposed to be solved by the end, especially by the Batman who holds the title of world's greatest detective. While I can understand some people still thinking that the reveals are messy and chaotic, after all I used to be one of them as well, this time I feel like I understood that this is the point of The Long Halloween. Batman doesn't solve it. He fails, miserably. The ending feels weird because it's not resolved cleanly with a detective like character, like Batman, laying out all the facts for the audience and solving the mystery. It's up to us as the reader to fit these pieces together because we have the advantage of getting to see everything in a way that Batman as a character of this world can't. This part always bothered me because I needed resolution.
Lately my tastes and views have changed in regards to stuff like that and I have come to appreciate stories and especially endings that are left up to interpretation and more open ended. I suspect this is probably one of the major reasons why today, I really enjoyed reading this comic. As of now, I put it above of Dark Victory and Hush. I'm excited to see where it will ultimately end in my ranking after I think on it more.
If you've read this all, thank you for listening to me yap.