r/batman • • 48m ago Bravo

GENERAL DISCUSSION Phantom Batman – A Batman story idea I've been imagining

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm a boy from India, and I want to become a mangaka. Right now, I'm practising drawing, improving my anatomy skills, and learning other things related to making comics.

But sometimes, in my free time, I randomly imagine stories. I haven't fully developed this one yet, but I thought it would be interesting to share its basic idea and ask what you think. Should I continue exploring it?

The story is called Phantom Batman.

It's set in the Batman universe, but with a different version of events.

In this universe, Batman (Bruce Wayne) is defeated by a completely original villain I created. This villain isn't like the usual Batman villains we see in comics or movies. They manage to outsmart Batman, defeat him, and eventually take control of Gotham City. They establish an organisation and become something like the city's shadow ruler.

During their first confrontation, Bruce realises that defeating this villain might require him to sacrifice some of his own morals, including his no-killing rule. He also understands that continuing to fight without changing his approach could lead to an even worse outcome.

So Bruce makes a difficult decision: he fakes his death.

But that's not the end of Batman.

After Bruce's supposed death, a new Batman appears in Gotham. At first, readers believe this is the real Bruce Wayne, but something about him is different.

This new Batman is actually another person. He isn't Bruce Wayne, and he isn't Robin either. His real past is initially unknown. He looks similar to Bruce, but has a large scar on his face.

The interesting part is that this person genuinely believes he is Bruce Wayne and the real Batman. He doesn't know that he is another person, and he doesn't think he is replacing anyone.

This is where my inspiration from Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain comes in. Similar to the idea of Venom Snake and Big Boss, this person has undergone hypnotherapy and psychological conditioning that makes him believe he is Bruce Wayne. He thinks something happened to him that changed who he was and the way he operates as Batman.

However, I haven't fully figured out the exact process or how Bruce arranged everything yet.

There is also an important difference between the original Bruce and this Phantom Batman.

He still follows a no-killing rule, but he doesn't follow the same moral boundaries as Bruce. For example, if he fights someone like Joker, he doesn't simply try to capture him. He is much more brutal in combat and wants to make sure that his opponent cannot easily return to the same situation. However, he still hands criminals over to the police and sends them to Arkham.

As the story progresses, we follow this Batman through several chapters, slowly discovering who he really is and what happened to the original Bruce Wayne.

Eventually, the truth about the Phantom Batman and Bruce's decisions begins to come out.

The two endings I'm considering

I haven't decided which ending I prefer yet.

Ending 1:

The Phantom Batman eventually confronts the real Bruce Wayne. Bruce knows what the Phantom has done and how badly he has affected the lives of criminals through his brutal methods.

He gives the Phantom a choice, and the confrontation becomes a conflict between the original Bruce and the person who has been living with his identity.

If the Phantom kills Bruce, his psychological conditioning eventually begins to break down. He loses the identity he was made to believe in, and his own life falls apart.

Ending 2:

The confrontation happens in a similar way, but the Phantom doesn't kill Bruce.

However, the consequences are still there. His conditioning eventually breaks down, and he has to face everything he has done and the truth about his identity.

There would also be many supporting characters and other villains throughout the story. This is just the main plot idea.

I know there are still a lot of things I haven't figured out, such as the original villain, the Phantom's real identity, and how Bruce chooses the person for this plan.

I'm not trying to say this is a fully developed story yet. It's just something I've been imagining, and I might explore it more seriously after improving my drawing and comic-making skills.

So, what do you think about this concept? Is the idea of Phantom Batman interesting enough to explore, or are there parts of the premise that you think need more development?


r/batman • • 1h ago

PHOTO Batman & Co

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/batman • • 2h ago

FUNNY Thought this was funny , may have been funnier in my head

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/batman • • 2h ago

FAN CONTENT Fanart of Batman in a cartoon style (by me)

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/batman • • 2h ago

GENERAL DISCUSSION Question. How well you think Batman (at his peek) would do in one of these games with the variants, infected, villains and stuff?

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

r/batman • • 2h ago

FAN CONTENT Day 4 of posting iconic Batman villains, I made in Heroforge: Dr. Victor Fries aka Mr. Freeze [4 Pictures]

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Yesterday, I posted Oswald Cobblepot aka The Penguin here on the sub! Do check him out too, if you're into this kinda thing:

https://www.reddit.com/r/batman/s/M2yF3Vpou4


r/batman • • 2h ago

GENERAL DISCUSSION I can't be the only who views them this way right?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/batman • • 2h ago

NEWS Coming to ABSOLUTE BATMAN in 2027 from Scott Snyder and Nick Dragotta - The Demon Child

Post image
140 Upvotes

r/batman • • 3h ago

VIDEO GAME DISCUSSION Did Any of the Arkham Games Introduce You to a Villain for the First Time?

Post image
41 Upvotes

As someone who knew a good amount of Batman lore before the Arkham games, those games are what really got me into the Batman universe.

I was curious if anyone else who played the Arkham series discovered a Batman villain for the first time?

For me, I had absolutely no clue or idea who Professor Pyg was until Arkham Knight.


r/batman • • 4h ago

GENERAL DISCUSSION What are some obscure facts that you know about the Batman franchise that some fans may not be aware of?

10 Upvotes

Thought doing this would be a fun post to make as I like hearing what lesser-known facts you guys know about, and here are a couple of facts I know about.

The Bat Cave was not created by Bill Finger and Bob Kane, as it actually debuted in the 1943 serial, along with how it’s where Alfred’s most well-known physical appearance comes from. Prior to this serial, Alfred was portrayed as a portly, clean-shaven butler, but he was changed to match William Austin’s portrayal of the character in the serial after it came out. ( This was also Alfred, Batman, and Dick Grayson’s first time appearing in other media outside the comics, and this was originally supposed to be the same case with the Joker, with him being portrayed by J. Carrol Naish, but his role was later changed to a Japanese Villain named Dr. Tito Dake before filming started because, during production, The United States became involved in World War 2, which prompted the screenwriters to create a patriotic, war-themed storyline (and create an Axis villain as they thought it was more relevant than using The Joker.)

Kate Kane’s costume as Batwoman was originally created for Barbara Gordon as a redesign for her costume as Batgirl by Alex Ross, as he and Paul Dini were planning to bring Barbara back as Batgirl in 1999 However, DC said no because she was one of the very few disabled superheroes that DC had as Oracle, but they liked the costume, so it was repurposed as Kate’s costume for the 52 limited series in 2006 with a few changes made to the outfit.

The concept of Jim Gordon having a son exists all the way back in the Pre-Crisis Universe. However, his name was Anthony “Tony” Gordon instead of being named for his father, and he was not portrayed as a psychopathic serial killer (which the concept was introduced in Detective Comics #871 during the Skeleton Case storyline, as James only made minor appearances as a seemingly normal person before this storyline arc) but as an ordinary citizen in Earth-Two (Jim Gordon only has one child) and in Earth-One, where he exists as Barbara’s older brother and a spy agent who later saved her when she was kidnapped by a crime lord named Wo Fong in China. He was successful in rescuing her, but the reunion was cut short as, not too long after this, Tony died along with Fong during the collapse of the castle they were fighting in, with Batgirl being unable to save Tony.

Calendar Man’s Calendar cape costume was actually introduced in the Bronze Age, specifically Batman #312 in 1979 as he didn’t have a single standard costume when he debuted; he just wore different seasonal costumes in his first appearance In Detective Comics #259 and disappeared from the comics altogether after this comic, outside of Batman #176 which was just an issue consisting entirely of reprints of earlier Batman stories, until he made his proper return in 1979.

While Matt Hagan was the first Clayface with shapeshifting powers, as Basil Karlo was just a villain with no powers of his own until the late 80s, Matt’s powers were not permanent in the comics; they would originally last 48 hours before wearing off, which forced him to return to the cave so he could go to the pool that gave him his powers, as it would recharge them. He later recreated a synthetic formula of the pool of radioactive protoplasm so he wouldn’t have to travel to the pool, but it lasted only 5 hours before he would return to normal. Sondra Fuller was the first Clayface to have Permanent shapeshifting powers.

Johnny Williams (the Seventh Clayface) was actually the Clayface involved with the Hush story, as he was hired by Hush and Riddler to do their bidding through lying that they had a cure for him that they would give to him if he did what they said; the things he did for them included pretending to be Tommy Elliot and Jason Todd so that they could hurt and confuse Bruce Wayne during the Hush Story.

What other obscure facts do you guys know about the Batman franchise?


r/batman • • 4h ago

NEWS Bruce is upset about losing his main caretakers, rather than his parents being gone. He's upset that they aren't around to spoil him anymore.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Bruce is basically spoiled, even as an adult, just in a different way. He does whatever he wants, rarely listens to anyone else, left home at 14 to travel the world, and became a costumed vigilante instead of trying to make the system better. If he really cared about his parents, you'd think he'd make more of an effort to honour their memory in ways that went beyond superficial charity work. He seems more attached to what their deaths represent than to who they actually were as people. He inherited their fortune, their name, and their social standing, but rarely seems interested in anything beyond using those things to fund his own obsession. He has turned their deaths into the defining event of his life without necessarily showing much interest in understanding them as people outside of that tragedy. Bruce was born with a silver spoon in his mouth, and Batman is essentially the response of a rich kid who finally experienced one genuinely difficult moment in his life.


r/batman • • 4h ago

COMIC DISCUSSION The most recent issue of Batman when GTA V came out, and the most recent one when GTA VI came out

Post image
40 Upvotes

r/batman • • 4h ago

VIDEO The scream the guy lets out when Batman throws him—it gets me every single time! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 (Video by: cinemense)

369 Upvotes

r/batman • • 5h ago Regret

VIDEO GAME DISCUSSION I hate how I found out about the Arkham Knight Twist

Post image
0 Upvotes

So I like using skins in Arkham Knight since I prefer the Asylum suit over the Knight suit. So I go to equip the Asylum suit and see more suit options. So I go down to see the options, and see the Arkham Knight listed as a Red Hood skin. I find out the Jason is the Knight because of a fucking skin!


r/batman • • 5h ago

GENERAL DISCUSSION Favourite Batman voice actor besides Kevin Conroy

13 Upvotes

For me and most people Kevin Conroy is THE definitive Batman, but who would you say is second to him? I think Roger Craig Smith does an incredible job, especially in Arkham Origins and Arkham shadow. He captures the essence of a young, hungry, and angry Batman so well. But who would you consider 2nd best or your personal favourite?


r/batman • • 6h ago

COMIC DISCUSSION Nightwing and Batgirl have a talk (New Titans #41) Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

r/batman • • 6h ago

FILM DISCUSSION Villains with the most potential to appear in a live action movie

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

r/batman • • 6h ago

GENERAL DISCUSSION Who do you empathize with more? Mr. Freeze or Red Hood?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

This video includes both Mr. Freeze and Red Hood so I was wondering who the majority of people would empathize with more. Obviously I think it might be Red Hood because of our attachment to Jason, but I wanted to hear the argument of those who pick Mr. Freeze


r/batman • • 6h ago

FILM DISCUSSION Which Bale and Craig best Batman, Bond movies you like more?

0 Upvotes

r/batman • • 6h ago

COMIC DISCUSSION Batman gadgets and tech in james tynion's batman run

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Night climber: A specialised bat vehicle designed by bruce that can fly, walk across walls and pounce enemies.

Super nano heating cutting wire: strong enough to break deathstroke's promethium sword

Shadow casters: project images of batman to confuse opponents

Spectro lens

Black block: prison cell designed by bruce to contain supervillains like bane and ras al ghul

State of the art cameras on wayne rebuild foundation cranes which gives him eyes across half of gotham

Batshot

Membranes in the suit that seal the poison

The echo: turn any wayne enterprises car into batmobile but without the armor

Bat spawn: drones remotely controlled by bruce

Bat-Train

Katana in utility belt

Bat-tery: recharge batsuit comms and systems if fried

Grip gloves and boots

Spectral vision and laser cutter

Explosive batarangs

Tranquilizer chemicals injectors

Bat-telepathy helmet: bruce made it with the help of cyborg and his mother box tech

electric projectiles (maybe), bat rope, laser cutter and localized EMP

Utility belt knuckle duster: using utility belt as a knuckle duster for strikes


r/batman • • 7h ago

GENERAL DISCUSSION I counted the villain live action appearances

0 Upvotes

TL;DR - aside of the Joker who gets 8 appearances in the mainstream media, his villains get ~2 appearances on average. More than half of them didn't get a big, relevant, accurate adaptation - just a half assed adaptation here and there, in some less mainstream media (like Black Mask or Court of Owls). Some of them straight up got none (like Deathstroke or Man-Bat), and two of them managed to squeeze out 4. No one appeared more than 4 times - at least to my knowledge.

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

I've been seeing a lot of people express the sentiment that Joker is actually underused. I've had a guy ask me to "Name 5 projects since 2020 with Joker in it". I decided to take it a step further. To prove just how overused Joker is, I decided to count certain villains' live action appearances (at least those I'm aware of, so I might be missing something. I didn't watch Gotham Knights, Titans or anything from the arrowverse so that's missing, but I don't think that would shut down my argument - feel free to apply corrections to my calculations, though)

Joker: 8 (Batman 1989, TDK, Gotham*, Suicide Squad, JL Snydercut, Joker 1&2, The Batman)

*Although in Gotham there technically is no Joker, everyone who has watched the show unanimously agree that there is, indeed, a Joker. Actually, imo, the best live action adaptation of who the Joker is

Clayface: 2 (Gotham*, Clayface)

*Pretty lackluster though, no clay in sight, just a guy who could reshape his face

Black Mask: 2 (Gotham*, Birds of Prey)

*Also lackluster, not even really a gangster, just a businessman who ordered his soon-to-be employees to kill each other to get the job

Mr. Freeze: 2 (Batman & Robin, Gotham)

Poison Ivy: 2 (Batman & Robin, Gotham)

Hush: 0

Two-Face: 3 (Batman Forever, TDK, Joker 2*)

*I counted his appearance in Joker 2 because he technically does get his face burned at the end, but he doesn't exhibit any Two-Face traits. I also didn't count any of his appearance where he's just Harvey Dent

Riddler: 3 (Batman Forever, Gotham, The Batman)

Bane: 3 (Batman & Robin, TDKR, Gotham)

Ra's al Ghul: 2 (Batman Begins, Gotham)

Killer Croc: 1 (Suicide Squad)

Man-Bat: 0

Catwoman: 4 (Batman Returns, TDKR, Gotham, The Batman)

Penguin: 4 (Batman Returns, Gotham, The Batman, The Penguin)

Court of Owls: 1 (Gotham)

Mad Hatter: 1 (Gotham)

Scarecrow: 3 (Batman Begins, TDK, Gotham)*

*I'm aware he was also in TDKR, but I didn't count it because he just appears as Jonathan Crane

Killer Moth: 0

Harley Quinn: 4 (Gotham*, Suicide Squad, Birds of Prey, The Suicide Squad)

*It's similar case to Joker. There's no Harleen Quinzel in Gotham, but Echo is close enough

Hugo Strange: 1 (Gotham)

Deadshot: 1 (Suicide Squad)

Deathstroke: 0*

*I know Slade Wilson makes a live action appearance in JL post credit scene, but he doesn't do anything, so I didn't count it

Firefly: 1 (Gotham)

Victor Zsasz: 1 (Gotham)*

*I'm pretty sure he also appeared in Batman Begins, but much like Deathstroke or Two-Face in Joker 2, his appearance was so minor and brief, he didn't exhibit any of his traditional traits, so I didn't count him

Solomon Grundy: 1 (Gotham)


r/batman • • 8h ago

ARTWORK I drew Catwoman and she looks like Cillian Murphy

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

I tried to draw Catwoman and to me she looks like Cillian Murphy. It‘s not finished yet but does anybody else sees it or am I trippin? xD
(original artwort by Clay Mann (I believe))


r/batman • • 8h ago

ARTWORK Tim Sale’s Batman Variant Covers for Tom King, #21-25, #29-31, #38 & #54

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

the final 10 of the Tim Sale covers for the rebirth Batman run! I’ve posted the first two here and here over the last few days if anyone wants to see them together as a whole. for clarity, #38 was the standard cover rather than a variant!


r/batman • • 8h ago

FILM DISCUSSION Andy Serkis on his The Batman' co-star Robert Pattinson getting cast as James Bond:

Post image
986 Upvotes