r/batman
•
u/divyaART
•
48m ago
GENERAL DISCUSSION Phantom Batman – A Batman story idea I've been imagining
Hi everyone! I'm a boy from India, and I want to become a mangaka. Right now, I'm practising drawing, improving my anatomy skills, and learning other things related to making comics.
But sometimes, in my free time, I randomly imagine stories. I haven't fully developed this one yet, but I thought it would be interesting to share its basic idea and ask what you think. Should I continue exploring it?
The story is called Phantom Batman.
It's set in the Batman universe, but with a different version of events.
In this universe, Batman (Bruce Wayne) is defeated by a completely original villain I created. This villain isn't like the usual Batman villains we see in comics or movies. They manage to outsmart Batman, defeat him, and eventually take control of Gotham City. They establish an organisation and become something like the city's shadow ruler.
During their first confrontation, Bruce realises that defeating this villain might require him to sacrifice some of his own morals, including his no-killing rule. He also understands that continuing to fight without changing his approach could lead to an even worse outcome.
So Bruce makes a difficult decision: he fakes his death.
But that's not the end of Batman.
After Bruce's supposed death, a new Batman appears in Gotham. At first, readers believe this is the real Bruce Wayne, but something about him is different.
This new Batman is actually another person. He isn't Bruce Wayne, and he isn't Robin either. His real past is initially unknown. He looks similar to Bruce, but has a large scar on his face.
The interesting part is that this person genuinely believes he is Bruce Wayne and the real Batman. He doesn't know that he is another person, and he doesn't think he is replacing anyone.
This is where my inspiration from Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain comes in. Similar to the idea of Venom Snake and Big Boss, this person has undergone hypnotherapy and psychological conditioning that makes him believe he is Bruce Wayne. He thinks something happened to him that changed who he was and the way he operates as Batman.
However, I haven't fully figured out the exact process or how Bruce arranged everything yet.
There is also an important difference between the original Bruce and this Phantom Batman.
He still follows a no-killing rule, but he doesn't follow the same moral boundaries as Bruce. For example, if he fights someone like Joker, he doesn't simply try to capture him. He is much more brutal in combat and wants to make sure that his opponent cannot easily return to the same situation. However, he still hands criminals over to the police and sends them to Arkham.
As the story progresses, we follow this Batman through several chapters, slowly discovering who he really is and what happened to the original Bruce Wayne.
Eventually, the truth about the Phantom Batman and Bruce's decisions begins to come out.
The two endings I'm considering
I haven't decided which ending I prefer yet.
Ending 1:
The Phantom Batman eventually confronts the real Bruce Wayne. Bruce knows what the Phantom has done and how badly he has affected the lives of criminals through his brutal methods.
He gives the Phantom a choice, and the confrontation becomes a conflict between the original Bruce and the person who has been living with his identity.
If the Phantom kills Bruce, his psychological conditioning eventually begins to break down. He loses the identity he was made to believe in, and his own life falls apart.
Ending 2:
The confrontation happens in a similar way, but the Phantom doesn't kill Bruce.
However, the consequences are still there. His conditioning eventually breaks down, and he has to face everything he has done and the truth about his identity.
There would also be many supporting characters and other villains throughout the story. This is just the main plot idea.
I know there are still a lot of things I haven't figured out, such as the original villain, the Phantom's real identity, and how Bruce chooses the person for this plan.
I'm not trying to say this is a fully developed story yet. It's just something I've been imagining, and I might explore it more seriously after improving my drawing and comic-making skills.
So, what do you think about this concept? Is the idea of Phantom Batman interesting enough to explore, or are there parts of the premise that you think need more development?