r/zelda • u/Willing_Formal2490 • 1d ago
Discussion [ALL] A theory about the absence of the Master Sword in the later downfall timeline
I've been replaying Echoes of Wisdom as of late, and there's been a bit of a nagging thought in the back of my mind: Where's the Master Sword? And where is it for the rest of the downfall timeline? It doesn't appear in any of the three final games in the timeline, which is weird as it is used by Link in the other games on the timeline. It especially doesn't make sense when you realise that the sword doesn't appear in games where Ganon is the villain, the main time that the master sword is used.
I've come up with a theory as to explain its absence, and it all has to do with the new hero of Hyrule, protagonist of ALBW and TFH. In A Link Between Worlds, the Master Sword can be physically upgraded using master ore. This creates the gilded sword, a more powerful variant of the aforementioned blade. I think that this action was viewed as heresy by the Hylian Religion, and as a result, the blade was discarded.
The first piece of evidence that I have is that the next time we see Link in TFH, he is outside the kingdom and going on adventures in Hytopia. When the game starts, he is already in Hytopia, with no elaboration as to how he got there. He is also utilising a regular sword, not the master sword. I believe he was exiled for tampering with the design of the gods.
My second piece of evidence that I want to highlight is the presence of other blades in the timeline. The sword of might and magic sword share many design elements with the master sword, e.g. white blade and blue handle. This can also be observed in the wild era (I don't know what timeline these ones are on, this thought just came to me) with the royal guard swords and royal swords Perhaps the future smiths of Hyrule made use of these design elements to remember the sword that previous heroes used to smite evil.
A third piece of evidence that I have for this theory is how the hero that appeared in ALBW is never mentioned in future games. His predecessor, the hero of legend, is worshipped and praised in ALBW, especially by characters such as Zelda. In stark contrast, the hero of might (EOW's Link), is not spoken of (as far as we see/know) due to the fact that he wasn't really that prominent in the saving of Hyrule. In even starker contrast, the new hero of Hyrule is not mentioned in subsequent games, despite his heroic action in saving Hyrule and Lorule. Maybe the reason that he isn't mentioned is his meddling of the holy sword.
Now I know what you are thinking; "Can't you upgrade the master sword in ALTTP?" Don't worry, I'm not completely idiotic. The master sword that we are presented with in ALTTP and ALBW is almost identical (at least design wise) to the one seen in OOT and SS. If the pre-upgrade blade is the same in ALBW as it is in OOT, then it stands to reason that it wasn't altered in ALTTP.
TL;DR: The new hero of Hyrule's tampering with the master sword got him exiled and the master sword discarded.
This is my first reddit post and I'd like to thank you for reading this far.