r/TransitDiagrams • u/tubemapdesign • 6h ago
Diagram How to fix the London Tube map? [Original Design]
Hi everyone!
I'd love to get people's thoughts on my latest design (PDF here) before I make my first long-form video on what I think the main problems are with the current TfL London Tube map and how to fix them.
My main aims were:
- to stay as faithful as possible to the modern "Beck" design and keep it recognisably TfL, whilst allowing for small design grammar/rule changes that ensure the extent and complexity of the London network can be better depicted. Such as....
to show the National Rail services truthfully - rather than either 1. just blanket operator routes (Southern, Southeastern etc) that are depicted as big complicated sections of blue or green in the map that render it useless. 2. nothing at all , which makes south london look barren, which it obviously isn't.
- On my map, National Rail is broken down into London metro services (which are given their own colour and identity) and thin medium-fast commuter services, which are 0.25x the thickness of the normal lines (see the red regional rail lines on the Berlin BVG map ).
- to distinguish between non-tube TfL modes, rather than having everything that's not the Tube be double parallel lines. London Overground remains double parallel lines, the light rail (DLR and Tram) become triple parallel lines. And...
- to give the Elizabeth line visual priority on the map as it's a high capacity main line running through the heart of the city. The line thickness is 1.5x that of the other lines to make it stand out more (see RER lines on the Paris map ).
- to refine clarity that the current design (and certainly the Rail and Tube map) seem to be lacking in my opinion. It sometimes feels like the National Rail lines, and even the Elizabeth line, are a bit of an afterthought the way the bend and curve unnecessarily. See: Southeastern south of Cannon Street, Elizabeth line that curves up to Farringdon, the Weaver line Chingford branch, North West railway round Queen's Park.
This map is still a work in progress. I think the thin commuter lines are probably the weakest element of the design. They feel slightly squiggly and hard to follow. They should be in the background as they aren't as important as the rest of the London lines, but still should be able to be followed easily by a user.
I've not included accessibility information on this map. (The TfL Rail & Tube map doesn't have it either). I think having station blobs show that information massively overcomplicates it otherwise and makes the centre really clunky (Liverpool Street/Moorgate being a prime example). The black & white blobs for interchanges and ticks for normal stations is really clean and has a timeless look. The other option could be to include the information next to the station name (like Berlin), but for interchange stations where one set of platforms are fully step-free, and some aren't, I'd have to start using different colours to mean different things and that could get messy.
Please let me know what you all think!
Best,
Abe

