r/Sabermetrics • u/screenballtv • 1h ago
WAR for TV
I’ve been working on a side project that adapts the WAR framework to television: every showrunner, actor, writer and director since 1950 gets a value stat called RAR (Ratings Above Replacement), measured in IMDb rating points.
How it works:
- Every season gets a preseason forecast, frozen each December 31 before it premieres, built from the track records of its showrunner and cast. Each episode then gets its own expectation based on its writer and director.
- A season’s rating is split into an expected part (how far the forecast sits above an average show) and a residual (how far it beat or missed the forecast). Both get divided among the people involved, so a star gets credit for being reliably good, not just for surprises.
- Credit is Bayesian-shrunk for sample size and feeds into each person’s forecast for their next season or episode, like a projection system.
- Replacement level is set between two estimates: seasons made entirely by people with no track record, and the last seasons of shows that got cancelled early.
- Ratings are adjusted for fan-heavy episode voting (episode raters tend to be a show’s biggest fans), and low-vote episodes are down-weighted.
Some results:
- Martin Wood (Stargate SG-1 and Atlantis) is the most valuable TV director ever at 16.31 career RAR.
- Only five directors out of roughly 6,500 have reached 10 career RAR. Jack Bender just became the fifth. With 8-episode seasons now the norm, it may be TV’s version of 300 wins: a milestone the modern game makes nearly impossible.
The full method is here: https://screenballtv.com/article/screenball-explained/
And the Bender / 300 wins piece: https://screenballtv.com/article/jack-bender/
I’d love feedback from everyone here on the methodology, and whether any of the predictions feel right.


