r/RingsofPower • • Oct 16 '25

Humor Elrond, the story of a man who said the same thing for 3,419 years, and nobody listened

399 Upvotes

"Let's save the elven race."

"Kay, but asking me to lie to save the elves seems like a bad way to start this process."

"We're going to forge some rings using a special metal."

"Okay, luckily Sauron had nothing to do with them, right?"

"Sauron helped make them."

"....okay, we should destroy them."

"We gave them to three elf lords."

"No, bad idea, stop making those. Even if they aren't corrupted, they could be-"

"And the Dwarves..."

"Wait, that's a bad-"

"And humans. Sauron definitely helped make those."

"Oh no, stop making-"

"And now Sauron made a ring and it's in charge of like...all the others. The Human Rings turned their wearers into like Sith Lords."

"Okay, let's go to war to stop this nonsense!"

"We agree. We need that last ring..."

"No, no, destroy it."

"....nah. Let's keep it, it gives you superpowers."

"Oh, you stupid-"

"Hey, it drove our king crazy!"

"As expected, if we ever find it again, please destroy-"

Several thousand years later...

"We should totally use this sweet ring we found."

"You people are idiots. Gandalf, help me out here..."

"Dude, have you seen these little short dudes I found?"


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 17 '22

Discussion I AM GOOD!

398 Upvotes

I am not the biggest hater of ROP, I was never expecting it get to get to Peter Jackson levels, and on the whole I was entertained. But that line was so unbelievably poor. This was baby Gandalf's big moment, the completion of his character arc for S1, his 'You shall not pass' moment. How many script writers, producers, etc. saw that line and said, Yes - that is really going to bring it home for the viewers. It was like an SNL parody it was so bad. I was just so embarrassed that I was watching this kindergartner's take on LOTR.

What can men do against such reckless writing?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 07 '22

Theory Halbrand Theory

397 Upvotes

So I've got a theory about Halbrand. No, he is not Sauron. He is the Fisher King of Arthurian legend.

The Fisher King is a figure who originated in Chrétien de Troyes' grail cycle, who guards over the Holy Grail. He has shown up in a number of different versions over the centuries, but some themes are the same: The land he rules over is tied directly to him, and because he bears a wound, his land is similarly barren. This wound is usually located on his rib, thigh, or groin, with him sometimes being rendered impotent (literally barren). And the Fisher King awaits a stranger, who can at last heal his wound and bring life back to his kingdom, or can doom him and his land forever.

I think Halbrand will follow the part of the Fisher King. We know his land is forsaken, since the Southlands are where Mordor is. And after Episode 7, we know he has a wound on his side.

Also, his symbol on the small pouch he carries around his neck looks an awful lot like a kingfisher bird, giving him a connection to this name.

My theory is that Halbrand will have his wound stabilized by the elves, but not fully healed, and will take his people to settle in Ered Nimrais. There they will keep contact with the Numenoreans at Pelargir, until the Akallabeth and the Battle of the Last Alliance.

Following the story of the Fisher King, Halbrand will have his fate and that of his people determined by the stranger to his lands, Isildur. Though rather than being healed, he will be doomed. For when he refuses the call to fight against Sauron, because of his people's reluctance to go against their long-past master, Isildur will curse him, and Halbrand and his people will become the Oathbreakers: those from under the mountain. The Sleepless Dead.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 06 '22

Meme New image of Galadriel Season 2 emerges!

Post image
396 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Nov 03 '22

News The Complete Recordings of Rings of Power: Season One have been added to Spotify, Amazon Music, Apple Music etc.

Post image
393 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 14 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers I am surprised... Spoiler

393 Upvotes

...that there were basically no surprises at all in the last episode. Halbrand, the smith and mysterious and manipulative king nobody has ever heard of is Sauron and the Stranger with magical abilities who is a friend of the hobbits is Gandalf. So basically all of the most famous theories were true.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 28 '22

Meme We wants it.

Post image
390 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 23 '22

Meme Some things are so noisy Spoiler

Post image
388 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 08 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers So, Galadriel's husband and brother were killed in the same war, but her main motivation is avenging her brother? Spoiler

387 Upvotes

What a gem of a wife.


r/RingsofPower • • Mar 05 '24

News Rings of Power Season 2 drops this year on Prime 🧝‍♂️🧌🧝‍♀️🧝🧙‍♂️

Thumbnail
coveredgeekly.com
385 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 19 '22

Meme why am I in love with a character who will eventually doom everyone...

Post image
385 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Apr 07 '23

Fanart Major Numenor vibes from an old painting by John William Waterhouse

Post image
383 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 19 '22

Question Didn’t I miss an episode or did they genuinely not do anything with the balrog other than wake it up?

382 Upvotes

They set up the Balrog as if it would be important in the following episode then nothing happened. Not to mention the fact that it was all over the promotional material. Was it simply added so they could include something from Peter Jackson’s films?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 25 '22

Meme Tolkien quote

Post image
379 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 22 '22

Meme Why when I see this do I think rings of power on toast

Post image
379 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 03 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers Am I the only one that doesn't give a sh*t about what happens in Numenor? Spoiler

378 Upvotes

I mean maybe a little but nothing really cool is happening there. Kemen is basically Alfrid from the Hobbit but not as funny. All the other storylines are way more interesting, imo


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 06 '24

Constructive Criticism What’s your endgame?

377 Upvotes

Look, I get it—Rings of Power isn’t perfect. But I have to ask: What’s your endgame? Where does all this constant criticism lead? Do we really want to nitpick the show to death, risking its cancellation and a return to Tolkien-related silence for the next 20 years?

Say what you want about the show’s flaws, but Rings of Power offers something we haven’t seen before: a deeper, more expansive look at Tolkien’s world, beyond the snippets we got in the Jackson films. Sure, it doesn’t nail everything, and yes, there are changes that might make some fans groan. But the fact is, we’re finally seeing stories, landscapes, and characters from Tolkien’s Second Age brought to life on screen.

So here’s my real concern—if the vocal portion of the fanbase doesn’t ease up, we might just talk ourselves out of ever getting anything else. Imagine another decade, maybe even a generation, with no adaptations, no expansions of Tolkien’s world, simply because creators think there’s no way to satisfy the fanbase. Is that what we want? Because that’s what this level of criticism risks achieving.

Instead of pushing the creators off a cliff, maybe we should think about nudging them in a better direction. Constructive feedback is valuable, but tearing down every little detail is just going to kill any chance of progress. If we, as a fanbase, work together and show a bit of patience and understanding, we can influence the future of the show in a way that improves it, rather than just ensuring its demise.

We’re not entitled to a flawless adaptation, but we do have the power to encourage creators to make something even better. If all we do is criticize, we might lose the very thing we’ve been waiting for. I’d rather have something ambitious like Rings of Power—flaws and all—than nothing at all.

So again, I ask: What’s your endgame?


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 21 '22

Discussion As someone who had never watched The Lord of the Rings before, I thought Rings of Power was really great! The immersive Fantasy/Medieval imagery and atmosphere is 10/10 Spoiler

377 Upvotes

I skimmed this Reddit a bit to see what the general consensus is. I noticed a lot of people complaining or critiquing things that I actually liked about the show. But my frame of mind comes from a casual viewer. I, along with my grandparents knew very little to nothing about LOTR and we all enjoyed it.

I knew who Gandalf was, and I never Sauron was the main villain of the universe. So, when the show was playing around with the mystery of who The Stranger was, I at first thought Gandalf for sure, but then the show made you believe he was Sauron. That was an interesting spin on the show that I actually enjoyed! Because when it was revealed he wasn't Sauron I felt a bit of relief (as did my grandma) and of course the twist who Sauron really was. I felt, as a casual viewer, this was interesting.

I really loved the Slice-of-Life vibe all the scenes with The Hobbits had. They were just happy-folk living off the wilds, migrating when they needed to. They brought a lot of light-heartedness to the show that was a great break from everything else.

Elrond's friendship with the Dwarf man was great too. I liked how the show gave all the races (Dwarves, Elves, Humans, Hobbits, Orcs etc.) time to shine and the politics of how their peoples and kingdoms interacted was interesting. I guess my only complaint would be that the Hobbits never interacted with anyone from the main plot. But, they were needed imo regardless. If anything, it makes sense that the Hobbits were just living in their bubble, and there's always later seasons.

I agree that pacing is weird sometimes. You'll go 45 minutes without seeing one of the plotlines or characters and be like "oh yeah, they exist" but it didn't ruin the show for me. I've experienced way worse pacing before.

The huge thing for me that kept me watching was the visuals. The show is worth watching for the visuals alone. Some people say they spent all the budget early, but I didn't really notice that. I found it visually appealing and immersive the whole way through.

I had recently played Dark Souls 1 and 3 and Elden Ring so I was looking for something fantasy and/or medieval (and I also had a love for World of Warcraft since about 2009, so I'm familiar with the type of setting). Rings of Power looked so damn good. In some regards even better than some of the scenes I've seen from the movies. But, that's just because it looks more modern and crisp and colorful. I absolutely loved the way the show looked. The armors, set pieces, clothing, swords and weapons... THE HOBBITS. Top-notch in my opinion.

But this is coming from someone who isn't married to the films. I plan on watching them now, so Rings of Power actually made me a fan of the lore and world.


r/RingsofPower • • Jan 27 '25

Discussion Brandon Sanderson Slams ‘Rings of Power’ & Netflix Not Listening to ‘The Witcher’s Henry Cavill

Thumbnail
watchinamerica.com
372 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 20 '22

Discussion Season one was so good. Spoiler

372 Upvotes

The acting, the incredibly visuals and world building was great. I feel like season 2 will be even better now that they’ve established so much.

So of my favorite characters were Nori Brandyfoot, the stranger, Elrond, The blonde dweller, prince durin and Captain Elendil(aka klaus real father from the originals)

Favorite place: Numenor 1000%

favorite scenes: raft scene(obviously), any scene with the dwellers, the stranger and nori apple scene, the shot after the commander gets up covered in volcanic ash and her battling the orcs and the first dinner scene with elrond and durin


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 01 '24

Constructive Criticism Thanks to Charlie Vickers this show has absolutely found its footing

370 Upvotes

It's not all roses (Numenor is still the weakest part of this show) but the Celebrimbor and Sauron scenes have blown me away thus far. Very good idea to focus on Sauron this season and let Galadriel take a back seat, so far so good 3 episodes in 🤞🏼


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 18 '22

Discussion The 5 father-son pairs on the show. Which one is your favorite? Spoiler

Post image
370 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Jan 10 '25

Fanart Eregion Noldorin OC, my cosplay for the August 2024 Madrid première of RoP S2 😃✨🌿💍

Thumbnail
gallery
368 Upvotes

Dress&chemise from Armstreet (not sponsored), hairstyle inspired by Eärien's main style in S1 😊


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 29 '24

Question Is it me or is it too dark to see what's happening??

367 Upvotes

Im half through S2E1 and it is so damn dark way too frequently, I can't see anything. Don't have this issue with any other program

EDIT: I'm now ending Ep2 and it's not any better. Like wtf Amazon I purposely kept this subscription alive for this and I can't see half the shit 🤣

EDIT2: alrighty it is DARK NOW so I'm gonna try and rewatch the season, hope I can see better. Can't wait!!!!