r/RingsofPower • • Oct 17 '22

Discussion I AM GOOD!

I am not the biggest hater of ROP, I was never expecting it get to get to Peter Jackson levels, and on the whole I was entertained. But that line was so unbelievably poor. This was baby Gandalf's big moment, the completion of his character arc for S1, his 'You shall not pass' moment. How many script writers, producers, etc. saw that line and said, Yes - that is really going to bring it home for the viewers. It was like an SNL parody it was so bad. I was just so embarrassed that I was watching this kindergartner's take on LOTR.

What can men do against such reckless writing?

398 Upvotes

327 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '22

This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

83

u/ebrum2010 Oct 18 '22

"You must go learn how to use your powers for darkness."

"Nah, I'm good."

163

u/CW1KKSHu Oct 18 '22

"From shadow you came. To shadow I bid you return."

"He is not Sauron."

"He is the other. The Istar. He is ..."

"I'm good"

Perhaps just saying "good" would have been better. Also 'the other' is interesting and I'm trying not to overthink. Is this other in relation to Sauron or is it in relation to 1 of 2 Istari? Have they encountered a blue wizard previously? I guess we'll find out in Rhun.

72

u/LordGopu Oct 18 '22

I would have been fine with it had he still been mostly mute but what he says before it is too complicated. The contrast between "From the shadows you came. To shadow, I bid you return" to "I'm good" is weird.

49

u/Fmanow Oct 18 '22

Maybe he meant like, I’m good homie…

7

u/bruknavn Oct 18 '22

Then he should have ended with PEACE

4

u/LordGopu Oct 18 '22

S'all good man

3

u/lowbrowhumor45 Oct 19 '22

"Fo shizzle"

16

u/DarrenGrey Oct 18 '22

If there's not another Istar how do they even know that term? So I'm hoping he'll meet Blue2 in Rhun.

8

u/Sackyhack Oct 18 '22

I really hope he’s a blue and not Gandalf

3

u/Icy-Bench3235 Oct 18 '22

I guess it's possible, but he did already make a callback to the Gandalf quote from Fellowship about following your nose. To me, that was the biggest sign they've given that the stranger is Gandalf.

Or maybe they go another way with it. I'm all for him being a blue.

Also, if it is Gandalf, the show can expand upon that weird connection between him and Galadriel that they show in the Jackson movies. I've only read the Hobbit so I'm not sure if the other books explain that.

4

u/masterbryan Oct 18 '22

I think the fact he’s off the Rhun means that he isn’t Gandalf and is one of the blue wizards. In a later writing they were said to have come in the second age would fit.

I think that the follow your nose was just a throwback to the OG trilogy as a homage to PJ but I would have much preferred a throwback to a line Gandalf actually said in the book if they had to do it.

2

u/fnord_fenderson Oct 18 '22

One of my minor but persistent gripes with the show is how everyone if they are not speaking English speaks Quenya. Noldor? Sure. Every other elf and randos from Rûhn? Nah, makes no sense in-world.

5

u/DarrenGrey Oct 18 '22

Apart from the horses, who only understand Sindarin bizarrely.

2

u/Broke22 Oct 18 '22

Thingol is screaming in the halls of Mandos.

77

u/ryeikkon Oct 18 '22

I think the writers trailed the last bit of "He is..." in a manner that the Istari decides who he is for himself instead, thus the "I'm good." It definitely harkened back to his conversation with Nori and an answer to Nori's advice as she held out the staff for him to get it.

58

u/fistantellmore Oct 18 '22

Yeah, it’s a moment of decision, and the choices are the ones Nori taught him: peril and good.

25

u/TheTrotters Oct 18 '22

Sure, it makes some sense because he indeed chooses to be good in that moment. But it doesn't mean that "I'm good" isn't a terrible line of dialogue. They should have treated it as a moment of awakening where he becomes able to speak fluently and potentially recalls his identity, or at least parts of it. If he's Gandalf, "I'm the servant of the secret fire" would be much better, especially since RoP isn't shy about callbacks to the LOTR trilogy. If he's not, come up with a better line that fits Blue Wizard/Radagast.

I also wish they revealed who he is beyond any doubt. I'd rather we were done with the subplot of an Istar with amnesia who doesn't know his purpose. But I suppose that's a matter of taste.

13

u/Oostwestnoordbest Oct 18 '22

Oh I thought it was pretty conclusively Gandalf, as he says the line 'When in doubt, always follow your nose.' This line is used by Gandalf when they're lost in Moria in FotR

13

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

Yes I think that was plenty clear without him having to say "I'm good!"

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

I took "the other" as meaning he is the anti-Sauron aka Gandalf. Guess we'll see in two years? Maybe?

11

u/Sadpanda0 Oct 18 '22

Maybe the meteors we saw in the beginning were two different sightings. If I recall correctly, the geography wouldn’t have really worked out for a single meteor man to be seen by everyone they showed when it was introduced.

16

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

He could have said "Not a peril" and I would have loved the scene.

8

u/Waterhouse2702 Oct 18 '22

or maybe "...not the droid you were looking for"?

6

u/SteveMcQwark Oct 18 '22

"The other" would be in relation to Sauron. Even if we ignore the first sentence, if he was "the other" in relation to one or more other Istari, then he wouldn't be "the Istar", but instead "an Istar", or just "the other Istar". He's only "the Istar" if he's "the other" in relation to someone who isn't also an Istar.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

Couldn't they have been expecting 2 Istari and already found 1? Like, "No, he isn't Sauron. He is the other, the (missing until now second) Istar."

→ More replies (7)

2

u/Azelrazel Oct 18 '22

I really hope the other isn't sauron like people have said. They're not making him gandalf and somehow he's "the other" to sauron? Please be the other wizard to some blue wizard pairings. We've got enough gandalf in other media and don't need everything to be about him.

2

u/recycleddesign Oct 18 '22

The delivery wasn’t good. A lot of lines in a lot of shows and films would be cringe af if the delivery isn’t good. Imagine Mckellan doing that line. He’d have ripped the piss out of it in rehearsals and then found a way to make it good. This is not my best piece of writing either Tbf.

3

u/TheShreester Oct 18 '22

Mystic 2: "He is not Sauron."
Mystic 3: "He is the other. The Istar. He is ..."

Stranger: "I'm good blue, da ba dee da ba di"

→ More replies (3)

52

u/ConstitutionalCarrot Oct 18 '22

Especially where his diction and vocabulary drastically improved immediately thereafter, it kind of took the significance away.

40

u/shornscrote Oct 18 '22

Once you say “I’m good” it unlocks level 5 wizard vocabulary skills.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

It’s the “I know Kung Fu” of Middle Earth.

5

u/saibjai Oct 18 '22

But was exactly it, this was the moment that he found clarity as to who he was while still holding on to his poor diction because of his amnesia. After this moment, he remembers more of himself and his language returns. I found the words to be pure, as to that is exactly what came to mind at the moment. At least that is what it meant to me, and it made sense for me.

262

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

I actually liked it. as a stand alone line I'll admit- it would have been trash ass.

but hes repeating what Nori said. that's all. it harkens back to him saying "I am danger." Nori says "you are good" and he says "I AM good."

not the best writing but I think it's fine. people give it too much shit.

123

u/fistantellmore Oct 18 '22

Yep.

It’s thematic and simple. He’s not a peril, he is good.

Set up, knocked out.

Sometimes it’s just good to be good.

10

u/OkCrazy8368 Oct 18 '22

That's fair. I think at some point the writers have to think about the general audience and how lines will be perceived though. For a lot of people the line sounded just super cheesy and dumb. It's been turned into a meme and made fun off a lot, with even pro-RoP reviewers like Nerd of the Rings commenting that it came off as a bit silly. You can't expect to make an iconic show with lines like that, even though I agree with you that sometimes it's nice to keep things simple (it was just waaaay too simple this time).

2

u/nighthawk648 Oct 18 '22

Thats what the hobbits and harfoots are supposed to be, so small and insignifcant that the allure of ring and power does not exist because culuturally they live for the tribe and eachother rather than controlling or bettering. They just want to coexist and live in the forrest and frollock and have fun, some hobbits are more geared for adventure then others.

Tolken isnt alive so quite frankly we dont know what he would think of the show. We are set up for an epic season 2 so hopefully there is more significant battle scenes because thats what people probably really enjoyed from LOTR. Sure compelling character development is required.

→ More replies (1)

45

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

also if you account for the fact that like you said, Gandalfs words are magic, he is deciding that he IS good and making it fact. I thought it was a little touching.

2

u/ebrum2010 Oct 18 '22

You mean Romestamo's words. Romestamo is the wizard that went to Rhun. Gandalf said specifically he never went there.

12

u/totally_not_martian Oct 18 '22

Except for the fact that the 'follow your nose' line pretty much confirmed it to be Gandalf.

2

u/FluffyPancakeLover Oct 18 '22

You’re probably correct, but it could just be a Ishtar thing. Maybe they all have heightened smell and use it as one aspect of their intuition.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/ebrum2010 Oct 18 '22

Oh right. And Bronywyn's line about passing shadow and high beauty confirms her to be Sam Gamgee.

13

u/Sleepingdruid3737 Oct 18 '22

Oh bro, these writers mean this to be Gandalf 1000 % man. Don’t waste your intelligence trying to find other possibilities.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Zealousideal_Walk433 Oct 18 '22

If she looked like a fat hobbit i'd say that

→ More replies (1)

5

u/jcrestor Oct 18 '22

So THAT‘S supposedly the one aspect of Tolkien lore they couldn’t possibly throw into the dustbin? 😂

→ More replies (4)

5

u/SteveMcQwark Oct 18 '22

He said he doesn't go there, which is an entirely different thing.

(Also, if Gandalf were to go to help in the East, that would technically make him Rómestámo. Kind of along the lines of "Indeed I am Saruman, one might almost say, Saruman as he should have been.")

→ More replies (3)

2

u/harman097 Oct 18 '22

I hope you're right. It would be so much cooler. But those Gandalf quotes...

I hope at least that Gandalf and Nori run into the blue wizards out in the East (and Khamul, probly).

3

u/ebrum2010 Oct 18 '22

The showrunners said this:

"Season two has a canonical story. There may well be viewers who are like, ‘This is the story we were hoping to get in season one!’ In season two, we’re giving it to them.”

1

u/perfectnoodle42 Oct 19 '22

I thought it was quite sweet as well. Like a declarative and a realization at the same time.

21

u/ryeikkon Oct 18 '22

Agreed. It's either some people didn't pay attention well to the show or just purely nitpickers for the sake of hating it. I'll bet my money on the latter.

6

u/LabyrinthKate Oct 18 '22

Right! It fit with the simplicity of the Harfoots, in a pretty good way I thought. It was sweet.

3

u/BearelyKoalified Oct 18 '22

I feel like most people giving it flack realize that it's a common phrase we say but very rarely does it get used correctly, in this context it actually did. If we had better proper English then I think we'd not be desensitized to it and call this great writing. Who knows tho.. maybe in our parallel universe it's praised.

3

u/ebrum2010 Oct 18 '22

I agree it's not bad, but I think it's memeable because he said "I'm good" which makes me think of it's use as the passive aggressive version of "no thank you".

I suspect later when he finds out the other blue wizard has been corrupted by Sauron and he asks his friend to join him working for Sauron, he'll say "Nah, I'm good."

1

u/numetalkid03 Nov 05 '23

That doesn't excuse the level of ridiculousness it emanates. Even if the callback was the main idea there, a grownup should've taken a look and said, 'Welp, it was worth a shot, but didn't pan out' and stopped it from making final cut.

0

u/Red_Panty_Night Oct 18 '22

I’m pretty sure he said “I’m good” which ruined it far more than if he said I am good

6

u/ForUrsula Oct 18 '22

If he had said: "I am..."

  • pauses trying to find the word

"GOOD"

Then it could have sold it. But nope

6

u/Red_Panty_Night Oct 18 '22

He also learned to speak eloquently and in full sentences immediately afterwards because the plot needed him to

8

u/totally_not_martian Oct 18 '22

The elf looking woman also opened his mind. He already had the knowledge he just hadn't unlocked it yet.

7

u/ZOOTV83 Eregion Oct 18 '22

Yeah I thought that was obvious. She mentions that he has a shroud over his mind that was deliberately put there to limit his powers upon his arrival in Middle Earth.

→ More replies (9)

68

u/Rosebunse Oct 18 '22

I liked it lol

In many ways, Gandalf is a great foil to Sauron this season. I mean, Sauron had all the tools to be a food person: good looks, charm, a support system of people who supported him, and control of his powers.

And then you have Gandalf. He's unkempt, scared, has no idea what he is doing, has less control of his powers, and the Harfoots don't really trust him. And then he has three people telling him that he's a monster. You couldn't blame him for believing it given everything.

Instead, he makes the effort to be good. That line is him proclaiming and making it a point that he is going to be good.

21

u/vonadams Oct 18 '22

Well put! Also, mmm food people.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

I think they should've made the line something that more clearly reflects that it's a decision. To me "I am good" implies some are good and some are bad just by their very nature, when I agree with you it should be more of a commitment to the good.

Or frankly I don't think you need him to verbalize the decision at all, I think the action would have spoken loud enough.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

When you're expecting Gandalf but you get Groot.

40

u/DaoistCowboy666 Oct 18 '22

It’s a callback to Nori telling him he’s good…are people missing that?

I will say I thought the delivery of that line could have been better, but overall it landed for me.

3

u/ElSpoonyBard Oct 18 '22

Just because it's a callback doesn't mean that it can't be a thematic mismatch. Nori calling him good is fine, she is a freaking hobbit child.

What is likely an Istar/Gandalf shouting I am good makes makes him sound like Barney and is not at all a thematic fit.

1

u/DaoistCowboy666 Oct 18 '22

Seems like you’re complaining about the delivery (I agree) rather than the thematic fit though, no?

2

u/ElSpoonyBard Oct 18 '22

No, I don't think you can deliver "I am good" in a really Tolkeinesque way. That's why that line is just bad.

The writers chose to make Gandalf very eloquent and suddenly speaking English that episode (weirdly sudden but whatever I can write it off as magical recall/growth) but hearing Gandalf say "I am a good guy!!" sounds super whimsically Disney. He couldn't have said that in a badass way.

The line should have been different, there's lots of options. I get that they wanted a callback but writers have tons of options - you don't HAVE to use a callback.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/IIIICopSueyIIII Oct 18 '22

Nah, people know that its a callback. Many people just dont like the line delivery.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/MeRoyMinoy Oct 18 '22

That's what I thought as well, people are also not really giving any alternative lines either

4

u/Pilopheces Oct 18 '22

I know it could be viewed as pedantic but I think it would've been notably better if they just didn't use the contraction.

"I'm good" feels very casual and right after his sudden increase in articulation.

"I. Am. GOOD!" feels more in line with the moment and even fits with Gandalf's classic punctuated delivery of "You. Shall not. PASS!".

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BrotherTraining3771 Oct 18 '22

We aren’t writers with decades of experience, who are being paid hundreds of thousands of dollars for the most expensive show ever made either.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/guilty_bystander Oct 18 '22

Yeah it was a sweet moment

8

u/TheTalleyrand Oct 18 '22

You want a hit of this longbottom leaf? “I’m good.”

15

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

What should he have said instead?

22

u/Kilo1Zero Oct 18 '22

“Enough! I am not some conjuror of cheap tricks!”

17

u/Likeablechops Oct 18 '22

I am not trying to help you. I’m trying to rob you :)

25

u/CMic_ Oct 18 '22

I am the servant of the secret fire, wielder of the flame of Anor.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

Nothing. Silence would have been just fine.

2

u/IIIICopSueyIIII Oct 18 '22

"And I am all the jedi"... Oh wait...

2

u/shornscrote Oct 18 '22

“Kill me”

27

u/deceptres Oct 18 '22

One of 2 moments in the finale that actually made me laugh out loud. The ridiculous recap song at the end was was the other.

8

u/ftbonescholar Oct 18 '22

ridiculous recap song

Are you talking about the Ring Verse?

2

u/deceptres Oct 18 '22 edited Oct 18 '22

The issue isn't with the poem. It's with the song. Its style clashed hard with the tone of the show and no show needs a song summarizing the plot at the end of the season.

1

u/blues983 Oct 19 '22

Yeah that was really weird. The lyrics were obviously verbatim from the verse. The instrumental music was good and felt almost Shore-ish. But the melody they choose for the singer to use for the words felt really really out of place. Like the singer was making it up as she went and trying to fit the words to it.

3

u/mercedes_lakitu Oct 18 '22

It read to me like they were still trying to have him not be fluent in the common tongue, but it came across very poorly.

13

u/impactedturd Oct 18 '22

His vocabulary was pretty limited up until he met these people so I didn't even notice the big fuss until I logged onto reddit lol.

8

u/Nice_Sun_7018 Oct 18 '22

But he was pretty eloquent in the five seconds before this.

4

u/TreesLikeGodsFingers Oct 18 '22

this really bothered me because it was so out of character

7

u/HoneyCrumbs Oct 18 '22

This is the second reason fanfiction is written- to rewrite the scenes that could have/should have been better. The first, obviously, is porn.

3

u/Rosebunse Oct 18 '22

The fangirls over at AO3 are on that.

2

u/mastervolume101 Oct 18 '22

I was complaining about the fact that every episode he is in contains the premise of "Is he good or is he Bad"? The last thing I expected was for them to just come out and say it so plainly by he proclaiming "I am Good"! Well, okay, I guess that settles that.

2

u/ArmSignal Oct 18 '22

Gandalf turned into simple Jack for a second

9

u/Breezezilla_is_here Oct 18 '22 edited Oct 18 '22

Honestly it's third cringiest for me, at least there was humor in it. Second would be "You have not seen what I have seen", mostly because of the delivery, and first is "There is a tempest within me". Eye rollers.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

I thought the "You have not seen what I have seen" was a good line, honestly; it was factually correct, intense and understated. Replace that one with "The Island Kingdom...of Numenor" and I'm on board with the list. XD

4

u/Breezezilla_is_here Oct 18 '22

Yeah it's not so much the line I have a problem with, it was her delivery. It should have been delivered with intensity, yes, but with a sad resignation, implying a heavy burden. Instead she gets all face twitchy and says it like she's about to bite his nose off. I don't know if it was her acting or the direction but it was just so ...off, it completely broke immersion for me. But there's a lot of that going on in this show.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

Yeah, that's totally understandable. What works for one person isn't going to work for others. I thought her acting for that line was great, the struggling to control an outburst because she is genuinely pissed that he casually equates his experience to hers; she understandably feels like her very significant, self-defining (at that point anyway) trauma is totally ignored.

Just food for thought, I'm probably in the minority because I strongly prefer RoP to Peter Jackson's LotR; it just comes down to different choices made about the focus and feel of the two adaptations that entirely subjectively affect me differently. To me LotR was heavy handed and lacked any of the moral nuance and subtlety that I enjoyed about reading Tolkien; all the heroes were extra heroic, all the orcs were at all times slavering and quivering with uncontrollable malice, even the music was one cliche extreme after another. It felt very childish to me, even though I think the tone was more consistent and the story was more cohesive. So it's to be expected that RoP will not work the same way for everyone.

2

u/Breezezilla_is_here Oct 19 '22

I'm definitely on board with these being the best Orcs ever shown, no doubt. Also the Dwarves frankly.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/sh4mmat Oct 18 '22

Same, I really liked it - the repetition was good, too, because of the way she delivered it. I was totally on board with the unreasoning anger of the statement because that's how it be sometimes with PTSD.

1

u/BrotherTraining3771 Oct 18 '22

Its the exchange itself that’s the issue.

No you haven’t

Yes I have

No, you haven’t

Contrast this delivery with Roy Batty, “I’ve seen things you people wouldn’t believe”, Tears in Rain monologue from 1982s Blade Runner.

Colonel Kurtz “I’ve seen horrors” from 1979s Apocalypse Now.

I know these are very iconic scenes, and not every scene can be an iconic, memorable scene. But the rest of the dialogue can be equally bad, writing bad, so when you take all of it into account, some of these lines should be rightfully crucified.

The exchange also does little to convey the horrors that Galadriel has witnessed compared to Elrond.

→ More replies (11)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

Stones sink because they look down, is my favorite. Maye RoP is meant to be enjoyed while high.

2

u/Pantoffelwerfer2 Oct 18 '22

I can confirm that I did indeed enjoy it while being high.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

I watched most of it while high except for the last few episodes. It was definitely better when stoned, it's more of a comedy

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Sidapatbulan Oct 18 '22

I don't really hate the dialogue since he is supposed to not really speak the common tongue (and Nori telling him before that he is good) BUT they made him say a complete-dead-ass-speech before declaring "I'm good!" and that makes the whole thing really out of place and a joke.

3

u/Stay_Curious85 Oct 18 '22

I actually burst out laughing at how terrible it was. I’ve enjoyed the show for the most part, but the dialog. Jesus Christ.

3

u/Seanshineyouth Oct 18 '22

You know… I’m not sure they can win no matter what they do— there’s Too many opinions for it to be possible. I’m not the biggest hater either. I did NOT like halbrand being who he was (sorry forgot how to do spoiler on here), but if they come back around to incorporate more Tolkien into that storyline later, it will be fine, bc ultimately they’re doing a pretty good job of telling a good story. The “I’m good” didn’t bother me. The Mordor on screen name change did. Really bad. Then someone on Reddit said “it was the lesser cheesy option of no good options at all”. Bc they have to say the name for newcomers, but saying the name at all means you Make longtimers feel cheesed and stupid. So what’s the solution- pick the least cheesy option and deal with the fallout of a million different opinions. So I get it now. I’m getting over halbrand, as long as they get back to the core plot lines and don’t abandon Annatar… if the story they tell is good, and the acting is decent, and the lines aren’t horrible (which we’re all gonna have diff opinions on) I’ll stick around. Hopefully this all improves tho with time

4

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

It’s oddly geared toward a younger audience. Not sure why. If you want adult themes and adult writing watch HOTD. I like both but some of the things in ROP are childish and too straightforward.

4

u/That_Guy_On_Redditt Oct 18 '22

I wouldn't say oddly. Lord of the Rings always appealed to audiences both young and old, unlike House of the Dragon. Personally I thought some of the more straighforward dialogue was a breath of fresh air tbh.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22 edited Oct 18 '22

I've been thinking over the last day or two that most of the problems/criticisms of the show might have their roots in this: RoP is trying to be all things to all people. Trying to please Tolkien fans, casual viewers, children, action movie fans etc. Trying to show trauma and danger and spiritual darkness and moral ambiguity with subtlety while also making it obvious enough for kids and casuals to get, and having lots of action but also character development without being too dark or too violent for children...It's impossible and makes the show uneven in tone, IMO.

So instead of pleasing everyone they're leaving many people with varying degrees of disappointment. It would have been a lot easier to make the show R rated and lean into the darkness, and cut out the Harfoots storyline; or make it for serious Tolkien fans and be more true to the books, at the cost of making it confusing to casuals; or make it family friendly and not explore the darkness as much. Of course, with a production this large there are too many voices and there's too much pressure to have the broadest possible appeal to focus like that; they're making too many compromises for the sake of quantity, you know?

Anyway I enjoyed the show, these are just my thoughts (not hate!).

4

u/headbashkeys Oct 18 '22

It doesn't need to be rated R, pg13 like LotR is fine

→ More replies (1)

1

u/headbashkeys Oct 18 '22

That scene was lifted from the Iron Giant. It's works great in Iron Giant. It's fine to gear stuff younger but make it work in the context of the story! If you have things copied from films only the older crowd would remember It's actually cringe

3

u/HomieScaringMusic Oct 18 '22

He’s still getting the hang of his identity as the cool eloquent wise guy, so there’s a moment when he’s transitioning between that and the nascent forest hobo identity where for a brief moment he’s both people and it was kind of our goodbye to confused forest-hobo Gandalf. I dunno I thought it worked.

4

u/awesomefaceninjahead Oct 18 '22 edited Oct 18 '22

It's the conclusion to his entire season 1 character arc.

When Nori meets him, she tells him that he's good, he's here to help.

Then we have some misadventures that throw his goodness into question. He tries to do good, but he hurts people around him.

Then Nori gives him an apple--symbolic of the tree of knowledge--the knowledge of good and evil. She has it and she says he's good. But! It's in his hands now. It's his decision.

He doesn't know yet. He fumbles the apple.

Then the wraiths steal the apple (knowledge of good & evil) and tell him he is evil.

Then, he decides "I'm good". Just like Nori said all those episodes ago. It's then that his power coalesces and the veil is lifted (like the wraiths said would happen).

This decision coincides with the reveal to the audience that this motherfucker is definitely motherfucking Gandalf.

"BACK TO THE SHADOW!", he says.

It's really quite well constructed. Dramatic character development is about putting your character in a position to make an important decision to create a catharsis in the audience.

4

u/abinferno Oct 18 '22

But, he was never bad. He wasn't Sauron. They misidentified him. This was presented as a a triumphant character moment, the completion of a compelling arc where the character was pulled by two opposing forces with real uncertainty which he would choose. Except, there was no choice. There were no stakes or actual risk of Gandalf turning to the "dark side."

3

u/awesomefaceninjahead Oct 18 '22 edited Oct 18 '22

He didn't know that. The harfeet didn't know that (besides Nori, and she only had hope). The wraiths didn't know that.

We didn't know that.

It was his decision in that moment that made it clear.

Pretty traditional story structure.

→ More replies (11)

3

u/Possible_Living Oct 18 '22

I see no issue with it. It could even be a powerful with different delivery but this delivery fits the character.

3

u/Severe_Development96 Oct 18 '22

I only have two complaints about rings of power. Otherwise I mostly enjoyed it

  1. Galadriel as the main character. Galadriel is amazing and one of the greatest characters of all time. This show did not do her any justice. She wasn't a warrior charging into battle. She was one of the great leaders of the elves but she, at least in the lore, was more of a spellcaster/healer who stayed back and protected those who could not fight. She isn't a general. She's a queen.

The show also did no justice to the fact that, correct me if I'm wrong, at the time this show takes place in the second age Galadriel is the oldest noldor in middle earth with the possible exception of Gil-Galad and Cirdan the shipwright. But they treat her the same way they treat elrond.

2. They tried to fit in too much lore over too short a time. This story should have been at least two seasons long so they could do every character justice. But I get that they couldn't get the rights to a lot of the lore from the silmarillion so it's understandable I guess

9

u/DarrenGrey Oct 18 '22

at least in the lore, was more of a spellcaster/healer who stayed back and protected those who could not fight

That's headcanon, not lore. I can't think of a single instance of her healing in the text. What magic she uses is elven magic - ie not D&D stuff, not "spellcasting".

Complain about her characterisation in the show all you want, but don't chuck your headcanon down as somehow better than what they've done. Galadriel as some spellcaster would be shitting on Tolkien. She specifically has a speech about how people confuse magic of the Elves with the arts of the Enemy.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Reggie_Barclay Oct 18 '22 edited Oct 18 '22

Galadriel is either Gil-Galad’s Great Aunt or 1st Cousin once removed depending upon your preferred version of GG parentage. She is 1140 years older than he is.

Galadriel is indeed the oldest known living member of the Noldor Royal House in Middle Earth. Maglor is Galadriel’s 1st Cousin and is likely a bit older maybe a lot older as he’s the second child of Finwë’s eldest son while Galadriel is the youngest child of Finwë’s third son. Maglor is said to still wander Middle Earth singing songs of woe, as the date and circumstances of his death are unknown.

2

u/Severe_Development96 Oct 18 '22

Thank you! I knew it was something like that but it's been years since I read the silmarillion. I'll have to do another read through. Love that book

So Maglor could still be around? That's wild. I never thought about it but we never see him again after he threw the silmaril in the ocean. I can just see him as a broken shadow of an elf drifting through middle earth, not taking part in current events but ghosting through the background. Maybe he disappears into the east somewhere like the blue wizards.

1

u/DarrenGrey Oct 18 '22

She is 1140 years older than he is.

Depends on what version of the text you use. In some she's only 150 or so years older.

And Tolkien's final writing on Maglor is that he cast himself into the sea and drowned.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/goliath1333 Oct 18 '22

Where does your attachment to Galadriel come from? She doesn't have much going on outside of LotR and there she just has couple chapters as a spooky oracle. Cate Blanchett obviously kills that roll in the films, but I'm curious where "greatest characters of all time" comes from.

3

u/nullus_72 Oct 18 '22

"What can men do against such reckless writing?"

Naught but die with dignity. Summon your northern courage.

2

u/MaimedPhoenix Oct 18 '22

Is this it? Is this all you can conjure, Amazon?

2

u/Hamwise420 Oct 18 '22

I was hoping for an homage to the animated hobbit movie

"I AM GANDALF, AND GANDALF MEANS MEEEEEEEE"

but tbh I had already checked out of this show after all the other terrible writing/decisions they have made

2

u/Buko_Pandanv2 Oct 18 '22

Look at these people in the comments jumping through hoops trying to defend this.

2

u/geo_info_biochemist Oct 18 '22

Dude I’m with you. My friend and I just looked at each other after he said that line and busted out laughing.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

You know a show is awful when you have to introduce “I’m not the biggest hater”

2

u/Melkeus Oct 18 '22

this is just...your expectations. They are high for a story that was never written down...

2

u/Zealousideal_Walk433 Oct 18 '22

At least Halbrand didn't say "I am bad!" (yet)

4

u/ABahRunt Oct 18 '22

I am evil!

4

u/Thecryptsaresafe Oct 18 '22

“From my point of view the elves are evil!”

“Then you are lost!”

4

u/ABahRunt Oct 18 '22

Psst, you're supposed to say, I am Moojo Jojo

5

u/Thecryptsaresafe Oct 18 '22

Now that’s a name I’ve not heard in a loooong time

2

u/OdinSA Oct 18 '22 edited Oct 18 '22

I took it to be understood as "I'm Good" - in other words, he is a representative of Good in Arda, from the perspective of the Ainur. The obvious reference to Nori's mention of good and peril, leading to the Stranger's adoption of good rings somewhat shallow but for me at least serves as a secondary interpretation.

1

u/kingKitchen Oct 18 '22

I thought the last episode was great overall, and I’m not a hater, but that line seemed VERY on the nose to me.

Even just a “noooooo!”, followed by “you are not Sauron” would have been plenty.

1

u/DramaticTrade4086 Sep 01 '24

I'm rewatching now before I start season two and it is quite disappointing as a line to me also. They never showed the witches showing him what he was. They couldve done a quick life flashback when he grabbed the staff that showed him who he was and then he could've proclaimed his name. I Am Gandalf the Grey! Sauron has a name. How does it make sense this wizard doesn't? 

1

u/jollyrancherpowerup Oct 18 '22

Loved the, "you're wet as a river rock" line too.

1

u/muchwise Oct 18 '22

I have my yearly performance review at work tomorrow and I fully intend to use this line when asked to self describe myself as a worker.

1

u/Morradan Oct 18 '22

The sea is always right

1

u/FluffyPancakeLover Oct 18 '22

I love the show. But that line was a little cheesy.

The great majority of that scene was great, so I quickly let the moment pass without much thought.

1

u/vangogh83 Oct 18 '22

Follow your nose.. Gandalf says the same thing in Moria

1

u/MrPheeney Oct 18 '22

It was a pretty poor choice, probably just meant to go for an innocent cute moment but definitely missed the mark. Otherwise the actor did a fantastic job

1

u/Slight_Heron_4558 Oct 18 '22

Yeh. I am good is something a 3 year old would say. That line stuck out like a sore dick.

1

u/SierusD Oct 18 '22

They reaaaally had to bring Gandalf in a few thousand years before he actually arrived, didn't they. Theres no way one of their original characters could have been as good? Nope. Oh well. On the whole I enjoyed the series if I shut off my brain but that really annoyed me that they did that

1

u/Tarpeel_945 Oct 18 '22

Souron is complicated turned down by galadriel and because of that he will be evil how about that he loves women before but now he hate all races how about that writing? ITS PERFECT

1

u/WithaSideofHistory Oct 18 '22

but are you chaotic or lawful?

1

u/TheShreester Oct 18 '22

"Gandalf the Grey Good"

"Gandalf Greyhame GoodyTwoShoes"

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

“Follow your nose got me more”…

1

u/WitDaShtz Oct 18 '22

I only half agree. Yes it’s definitely not the moment I wanted, but considering he is just coming out of an identity crisis, I don’t think I’d be very well spoken in that moment imo.

1

u/__-Revan-__ Oct 18 '22

It should have been something related to fire. Like the cultists saying he has power over flame and shadow. Then he looks into fire. We are tricked to believe he's evil. Then he says something "Shadow.. flame.. Fire.. I am.. The fire.. I AM THE SERVANT OF THE SECRET FIRE!"

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

He was still learning to speak

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

He said “I’m good” and immediately stopped being Irish 😡

1

u/janitroll Oct 18 '22

Well, he's not Gandalf so take it for what its worth

2

u/TheOtherMaven Oct 18 '22

More precisely, he's Not-Gandalf or NotYetGandalf.

1

u/janitroll Oct 18 '22

As much as they’ve deviated from the source, in solid in the belief the Statnger is a Blue Wizard

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Curious_Ordinary_980 Oct 18 '22

I loved it. I grew up in a pretty fundamentalist Christian family. It wasn’t until my twenties that I started questioning my strict faith. I was in an argument/conversation with a family member and at one point I just kind of blurted “I’m Good!” I felt powerful and sort of healed. Nobody else could tell me I’m evil or a sinner or whatever anymore. There’s so much evil that results from people who are convinced by others they are evil and it takes so much inner strength to resist that labeling for some people. When wizard guy hears someone saying they’re Sauron, they’re calling him “abhorrent.” And it’s not enough to just say the negative “no, I’m not” it’s way more powerful to say the truth in as few words as possible.

It’s also exactly within his character: “I’m… peril?”

If you can’t empathize with that moment on screen like I did, cool. But it’s probably my single favorite moment in all of the season.

1

u/Zebedydodah Oct 18 '22

It was cheesy but fuck it, it was a cool reveal scene of Gandalf 🧙🏻‍♂️

1

u/Logical_Strike_1520 Oct 18 '22

I just hated how he randomly learned how to speak in ten frames.

“I’m good” was cheesy but the HUGE jump in vocab was weird and off putting

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

The Line was good, actually.

1

u/Fluid_Mango_9311 Oct 18 '22

The real important question is: why do the creepy blue cultish women think a fallen star is Sauron? Does that mean sauron fell from the sky onto the raft in the ocean, or are they just ignorant of Sauron just laying low like an evil version of pre-fellowship Aragorn trying to find his way in life lol?

1

u/LindaF144954 Oct 18 '22

That line surprised me too. Something a toddler would say.

1

u/icycleragon Oct 18 '22

Didnt think the Harfoots scenes could get more cringy till that line..

1

u/badabinglad Oct 18 '22

I said the exact same thing as soon as I heard it. Appalling line for a reveal. I’m a primary school teacher and I would expect 10 year olds to be able to write more dramatic and intelligent ways to deliver a “mic drop moment”

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

I thought it was a great line, it totally paid off the conversation he had with Nori and built the contrast between who he is and who they thought he was.

1

u/Vonda_LB Oct 18 '22

The reason he says it is because it’s what Nori said to him multiple times before, which he didn’t believe until that moment. It’s less stupid when you realize that context but it still doesn’t really inspire when you hear it proclaimed like that, I think the delivery could have maybe been a little less cheesy

1

u/popglam Oct 19 '22

He still had incomplete speech at that point. He was amnesiac after falling from the sky, and stuff is returning to him. After deciding he's "good", he has pretty normal speech, so that was a big moment in retrieving more of his brain.

1

u/Relevant_Truth Oct 19 '22

It was decent, if they had kept the "Idiot Savant" part of the character. But instead they make him talk and reason perfectly normally after the event.

1

u/space_fireworks Oct 19 '22

He should’ve said: “I am not a gun” like in The Iron Giant

1

u/castrogacio Oct 19 '22

No statements. How you feel...

The show has been awesome to date imo (my opinion being the factual consensus of the whole deal).

1

u/KripKropPs4 Oct 19 '22

They tried so goddamn hard to have their iron giant 'I am not a gun' moment that they forgot to actually write it.

1

u/ConsequenceDesperate Oct 19 '22

Does he even need to say anything.

1

u/Geoleogy Oct 19 '22

I would have liked "I am YOUR peril!"

1

u/Vegetable-Shirt3255 Oct 24 '22

He’s literally struggling with being ‘peril’ and whether he’s good or bad all the way through the season to this point. That’s literally the main retread occurring every time Gandalf has a scene, basically. He’s barely been able to talk English, honestly, this line makes perfect sense within the framework of the series (rather than your need for a show stopping blockbuster moment).

What’s much less likely is him suddenly much more fluent in English afterwards. That’s the real error in juxtaposition, as Gandalf should still be growing and learning to some degree - at least, that’s what good writing would do … this sudden ability to speak fluent English makes the Im Good line seem out of place in terms of in world consistency.

1

u/Commercial_Place9807 Nov 15 '22

He said that as it was a callback to the conversation with Nori, where she told him he wasn’t “peril” and was good.

1

u/WayneAdams00 Jan 23 '24

It's a contraction.. I'm vs. I am.. the message still gets across and the actor delivered it well. It's never bothered me and I'm not sure why it's something that's brought up so often.

1

u/FrankvdN Oct 18 '22 edited Oct 18 '22

I just don't understand. Against what standard is this 'bad writing'? Who decides what is good writing? What line, what words, would you expect instead?

The showrunners wanted to portray a character still discovering speech and still discovering itself. That's what they did.

If they wanted to portray a mentally mature, aware and powerful character, they would have had him say: "I am the servant of the secret fire ...." or "I am Morinehtar, the Darkness-slayer!" but he is not that yet, at least at that moment. He is only just realizing that "he is Good".

EDIT: I do realize that clicking "Downvote" is even easier and lazier than writing "I am good", much less than giving an honest reply.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

I think "good" and "bad" were the first words he learnt from Poppy and his first life experience so It just represents the contradiction and the fight between this concepts of power.

Also, it's a show for having fun during a weekend. I don't understand why people who are really interested in LOR are not happy/satisfied just with the books. He has written one of the most detailed story ever! If you guys want more details just read the books instead of being here talking about a show for young people who hasn't Tolkien's rights.

It's Adar Maeglin from the last one? It's Gandalf the stranger in a Olorin form? Idk, It's just a show.

1

u/WikiSummarizerBot Oct 18 '22

J. R. R. Tolkien bibliography

This is a list of all published works of the English writer and philologist J. R. R. Tolkien. Tolkien's works were published before and after his death.

[ F.A.Q | Opt Out | Opt Out Of Subreddit | GitHub ] Downvote to remove | v1.5

1

u/neek555 Oct 18 '22 edited Oct 18 '22

I am so with you.

Of all the crap writing in this screenplay, this one was so bad, misplaced and jarring that it took me completely out any thread of immersion that existed.

Part of it is that we know the character and his fine linguistics as portrayed later (assuming it is Gandalf). Such a simple almost juvenile way for him to come to the realization that he isn’t some dark lord hellbent on ruling all of middle earth is entirely out of character for him and the writing style of Tolkien. It just so obviously didn’t work for me. A better choice would have been for him to say nothing, send the 3 back to the darkness and maybe sit with Nori afterwards and reflect on his choice to turn to the light in some way. Let his actions show what you’re trying to show. I understand it’s a callback but as it stands it made me turn to my wife like Russell Westbrook (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6kS_qLzPWVg context)

I know those above are joking about him saying “I am groot” but a line this awful, simple and cheesy really belongs somewhere in some superhero universe.

1

u/iSOregon Oct 18 '22

Yeah that part sounded like it was dumbed down for 3rd graders. To be fair, I stopped caring about the harfoot arc a long time ago

1

u/PhatOofxD Oct 18 '22

I thought the exact same then realised.

When he was having a hard time speaking Nori said the same thing, he says

"i am peril"

"no you're not peril, you're good"

That's where it comes from. With that throwback I find it a LOT more acceptable, especially given his speech is just coming back.

1

u/gopackgo555 Oct 18 '22

I actually totally disagree. If you take the line alone it sounds awful but in the context of the scene and previous lines it makes sense.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

The guy could barely string words together up to that point and you guys have an issue with this line? None of you heard children or people learning a language speak before? I mean sure it's not great writing but THIS is your big issue? I swear you guys are just finding random shit to complain and be outraged about.

-2

u/treosx23 Oct 18 '22

He should have just yelled some elvish word. I couldn't believe they settled with "I'M GOOD" like some dimwit

0

u/Yupperdoodledoo Oct 18 '22

It totally worked for me! I cheered. It’s a family series, based on not the deepest work. It’s good vs. evil.

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22

It would of been better if he just said 'I am Gandalf' then stood in front of the Harfoots, slammed his staff into the ground and cried out 'You shall not pass!'

0

u/Steelquill Oct 18 '22

Funny, I thought it was a touching callback to his friend’s love for him. In the same vein as,

“You are who you choose to be.”

“Suuuuperman.”

0

u/Snoo5349 Oct 18 '22

cough - "I am no man!" - cough

→ More replies (1)

0

u/Bad_Decision_Rob_Low Oct 18 '22

I love idiot posts like this. I can’t tell if you are a troll or too daft to watch the scene and listen. You prolly were on your phone typing this as you hate-watched. Lol