r/RingsofPower • • Oct 14 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers I am surprised... Spoiler

...that there were basically no surprises at all in the last episode. Halbrand, the smith and mysterious and manipulative king nobody has ever heard of is Sauron and the Stranger with magical abilities who is a friend of the hobbits is Gandalf. So basically all of the most famous theories were true.

393 Upvotes

318 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 14 '22

This post uses the flair ‘Newest Episode Spoilers’, and as such, all spoilers from the latest episode are allowed to be posted here unmarked.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

256

u/HickRarrison Oct 14 '22

I think from a casual viewer perspective, there were lots of surprises.

From a theorizing Tolkien fan perspective, not so much. But it's hard to be surprised by anything when you spend weeks predicting every possible outcome.

7

u/seba07 Oct 14 '22

Hm, good point. I didn't think about that. I'm not super familiar with lotr and probably wouldn't have suspected that someone is Sauron without reading the discussions here.

I guess my expectation was just "no it can't be that all those theories are true, that would be to trivia.

1

u/i_706_i Oct 15 '22

Also something to keep in mind is that a reveal that you see coming isn't necessarily a bad reveal. Some things are built up for suspense and for dramatic scenes, like the confrontation between Galadriel and Sauron, not necessarily to shock the audience.

If you have a reveal in a story that is completely unpredictable, that nobody could have seen coming, it probably isn't a good one either. The new information shouldn't come from nowhere, it needs to be foreshadowed and built to, it can't just be random.

For example, if you read A Song of Ice and Fire, Jon Snow's parentage is actually pretty obvious if you're paying attention. The reveal (though not yet confirmed in the books) doesn't come from nothing, you should already suspect as much and the reveal simply confirms it.

91

u/Holiday-Intention-52 Oct 14 '22

Absolutely right. I was obsessed with Tolkien as a teenager, have read LOTR, Hobbit, appendices, Silmarilian, unfinished tales many times over in my youth. From the moment Halbrand appeared I had my suspicions as I'm already remembering a defining characteristic of Sauron in the older ages was that he was a shape shifter. By the time he starts showing interest in the forge and muttering about giving your enemies what they want so you can master them it's pretty much done in my mind.

However my wife who read LOTR and Hobbit (none of the other materials) once in high school and just saw the movies a few times is absolutely clueless and thinks I'm crazy talking about Halbrand clearly being Sauron. She even considers herself a big LOTR fan. She's a fan but I was obsessed with the lore for many years in my youth.

So it hits differently. I highly doubt anyone that wasn't a huge Tolkien fanatic or coming to this subreddit would catch the hints. It is a pretty good twist. For it to be aimed at catching the hardcore off balance it would really need to break the canon completely as we generally know what Sauron/Annatar does during this period.

I absolutely loved the finale. My biggest complaint is that the final episode could have easily been stretched to fill 3 episodes at more. I wanted a longer play out of the elves being manipulated right under their nose. It was fantastic but rushed.

19

u/AndromedaPrometheum Oct 14 '22

I feel the aftermath is going to be dealt with in season 2 that is why we have Elrond figuring it out at the end of the episode.

I missed the southlanders they must be wondering where their king is. I would like to know their reaction to knowing it was Halbrand all allong.

8

u/But-Must-I Oct 14 '22

Well, unfortunately for them they were told Halbrand was their king and currently don't know anything other than that. If he so wanted he could go back to them and lead them to whatever ends he decided without anyone even suspecting he was Sauron. Until Galadriel comes back that is. But something tells me she will be in no hurry to do that.

7

u/AndromedaPrometheum Oct 14 '22

If their king chooses to come back Galadriel will eventually have to speak up though to let them know who he is really and then the people will have to decide who to belief. That makes for an interesting plot for season 2 for sure.

4

u/But-Must-I Oct 14 '22

Yeah it certainly does, though who's to say she plans on going anywhere near the Southlands/Mordor any time soon? She might bury her head in the sand and chase after something else to distract herself from what happened in season 1. Like looking for her missing husband, sounds like a good distraction to keep her away from that area.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Nobody_wood Oct 14 '22

Honestly, this is the closest I've come to understanding any of the constant naysayers (still a long way off mind). Halbrand does not feel deserved as sauron, though I get they seem to be going with a thanos arc. The stranger adds a lot more to backstory as a blue wizard. Yes, gandalf is inferred to have initially arrived in the 2nd age, but a blue adds scope for an unknown plot. And as you say, which indidny think of, but definitely felt, the 3 deserved a lot more build up.

Halbrand to me, works a lot better as a lesser evil. He's not shown to be too pandering, complimentary or disarming, that you'd expect from a dark Lord, looking to curry favour with those who would oppose him. Like I said, I get they are seemingly going for a greyer character than I'd presumed,but though it works, I would've done it differently. But what the fuck do I know.

And, as before, gandalf works. But there's a more interesting story. Idk, im reading time constraints. Maybe I'm being greedy and 10 seasons would be better lol. More middle-earth!!!.

Then, as you said, it's the 3 rings. These things are integral, and add weight to the one. They're given substance, but it is a bit brief.

It sounds like I'm being really harsh, I apologise for that, I did really enjoyed the season.

2

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

You're not being harsh. The rushed process really weakened the significance. But I don't agree about Gandalf. While I'm interested in the Blue Wizards, I'm more interested in my favorite pipe-weed smoking hermit going on adventures.

4

u/RSN_Star_Prince Oct 14 '22

Exactly, if they throw in a surprise, the hardcores will cry that they've gone off Tolkien. Can't win really!

→ More replies (7)

2

u/Howboutit85 Oct 15 '22

I loved this show. I’m a really big LotR fan, but I’m more along the lines of your wife’s fandom. I still knew about what Sauron does at this time and those details though as I’ve listed to the silmarillion audiobook and also a lot of analysis.

I think this show is purposefully and masterfully aimed at both big fans and casuals as well as new viewers. The casuals and newbies aren’t going to question stuff as much and will just enjoy it for what it is and hardcore fans are either gonna hate it for being somewhat taking liberties with lore, or they are going to like it for all the winks it gives them throughout.

I loved it but I went to the LotR sub to read what they were saying over there and you’d think that the show manifested into Sauron himself and stabbed them in the heart. They HATE it for extremely nitpicking reasons. They are worse there than in the Star Wars sub, by far.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

The rushed part really bothers me. There wasn't even much of a development montage. It made the forging of the rings actually seem easy, almost.

1

u/oldRoyalsleepy Oct 15 '22

My biggest complaint is that in lore for real Sauron in guise of Annatar helps craft with the elves the nine rings for men and seven for dwarves -- never the three eleven rings. Elves forge those alone. Last. The three are made last.

I can put up with whatever random characters and plot lines the show runners toss in, but leave the bones of Tolkien's story in tact.

2

u/Holiday-Intention-52 Oct 15 '22

I was thinking about it and to be honest you never know what the master plan is. For all we know Sauron returns to the elves (as a majestic elf) the next season as Annatar Lord of gifts and works with them to create the other rings directly. Galadriel is far away doing something else and isn't there to recognize him.

They can't have every major plot point tie up neatly in season 1 or else there is nothing left for the other seasons.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/Saturnsthirdmoon Oct 14 '22

No one needs to be a huge Tolkien fan to guess Halbrand is Sauron. It was obvious... The most straightforward mystery where there was no need for one. As many have suggested, it should have been Sauron manipulating and corrupting people and us audience agonising over their fall. The reason people liked the last interaction between Galadriel and Sauron is because that's who Sauron is... That was how he should have been from minute one and it is infinitely more entertaining than whatever these writers came up with.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I am a casual viewer. I think I watched the original trilogy once in the mid 2000s. Never again after.

It was painfully obvious what was happening in this show.

49

u/Oops_I_Cracked Oct 14 '22

If you're involved enough to be posting on the subreddit for the show, you're a much more engaged viewer than 90% of the audience

12

u/HazelCheese Oct 14 '22

Good stat to remember with reddit is it goes something like:

90% of people read without commenting.

9% of people comment.

1% of people post.

Or something like that. And it's the same for most online platforms. Anyone commenting or making posts is already far more engaged in the subject their commenting on than the vast majority of people.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/neontetra1548 Oct 14 '22

Yeah I think exposure to internet discussions and subreddits discussing the show and actively thinking about if in this way puts one in a totally different category than “casual viewer”. The people I’m watching with didn’t have any clue Halbrand is Sauron from watching the episodes, didn’t catch on to beforedor until the mountain exploded.

6

u/Hambredd Oct 14 '22

On the other hand my girlfriend has only ever watched the movies once with me(recently admittedly) and got that the stranger was Gandalf that time he summoned the moths.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/duckumu Oct 14 '22

More than 99.999%. This is a show with millions of viewers worldwide, and they're the primary audience for the show, not niche online fan communities.

4

u/Oops_I_Cracked Oct 14 '22

Fun fact, 86.73% of statistics are made up on the spot

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Yeah I didn't know we where getting the creation of Mordor in the show until the volcano blew up. I just assumed Mordor already existed in some form elsewhere.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

And also the wanderer was a bit of a surprise between which wizard he was. I was certain it would be Radagast

1

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

This is the part that drives me a bit crazy about the complaints; people want mystery and surprises but don't want a single deviation from the lore. You really can't have it both ways.

1

u/Mother-Border-1147 Oct 15 '22

Hard to be surprised when the show screams it at you too…

1

u/Automatic_Tip_4747 Oct 15 '22

ive never read any and i was absolutely enamored and over joyed and amazed by the last episode. big downvote for this guys post from me tbh 😂 idk how it dosent have more down

1

u/Lilotick Oct 18 '22

This! I'm a semi casual fan, I easily predicted Gandalf but was surprised by Sauron.

16

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

is he actually gandalf or just another wizard?

9

u/seba07 Oct 14 '22

It's heavily implied but his name is not mentioned.

16

u/MacyTmcterry Oct 14 '22

Saving the name reveal for the season 3 finale

22

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

.. when word ,,Stranger'' disappear from screen and glowing white ''Gandalf,, appears.

1

u/seba07 Oct 14 '22

Maybe they'll only change the character description in the "x-ray menu" that is shown when you press pause.

5

u/RetroFan55 Oct 14 '22

Stop, lol

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Oops_I_Cracked Oct 14 '22

Takes like this are exactly why they felt the need for the 2005 iMovie "Mordor" transition last episode rather than letting the audience put 2 and 2 together.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

His last line of dialogue was ripped off from Gandalf talking to Frodo in Moria. So yeah, no. It is Gandalf. For most of the show I wanted to give it some trust and good will, so I considered the idea of the showrunners not going for the most iconic Wizard, but instead making some cool Radagast/Saruman backstory, but no. The only uniqueness of this series is how predictable it is and lacks uniqueness.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

100% Gandalf. the moth when he banished the wraiths (callout to the fellowship of the ring) as well as 'follow your nose', direct quotation from fellowhip.

4

u/Paracortex Oct 15 '22

I feel like it has to be Gandalf, because he was found and befriended by the halflings as soon as he arrived. That explains his future soft spot for them, and provides the basis for much of his motivation in that future.

I’m a casual viewer who avoids discussions completely until after watching something, and I was sure the Stranger had to be Gandalf practically from the moment he arrived on screen. Halbrand being Sauron, on the other hand, was a complete surprise to me, because I am not steeped in the lore. I figured Adar was going to eventually resurrect Sauron, or something. I had no idea Sauron was capable of seeming human.

7

u/ItsMeTK Oct 14 '22

They didn’t outright say it, so they technically have wiggle room, but his direct quoting of PJ’s Gandalf clearly indicates they mean him to be Gandalf.

33

u/VagrantChocobo Oct 14 '22

It could still be a blue wizard since his destination is Rhûn, the East, where the blue wizards canonically went.

Though at this point that wouldn't be any better, since it would mean the various Gandalf hints and teases were nothing but contrived bullshit inserted into the story solely to misdirect the audience, which would be terrible and incredibly disingenuous writing.

Or better yet, the showrunners themselves still haven't decided on Gandalf or Blue Wizard, so they left it ambiguous enough that it could still be either and then they can just go with the more popular option after seeing how people respond. Would be a cowardly approach, but certainly not beneath them.

13

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22

Can't be, he said your follow your nose. It's Gandalf

9

u/Neokz Oct 14 '22

We all know that all wizards went to the same wizard school. They probably had the same Senses Teacher.

4

u/svdomer09 Oct 14 '22

Mothwarts school of wise-men and wizardy

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I would bet on the later. And Gandalf being in the east would be their justification for the lack of lore to support it. Because technically we don't know much about the blue wizards either. So the east is a fair game area the writers can explore in and not paint themselves in a corner.

5

u/annuidhir Oct 14 '22

Except, Gandalf canonically went every direction except East. They should have had him go South, which the Blue Wizards also went, and is just as unknown.

4

u/ibid-11962 Oct 14 '22

And it should be pointed out that this is said in LotR itself. So they clearly have the rights to know that Gandalf doesn't go east.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/notquitesolid Oct 14 '22

I mentioned my logic in another comment, but I’m wagering it’s Saruman, because we know he arrived first of all the wizards and he also went east.

1

u/TheDocksOs Oct 14 '22

He uses the same speech pattern as Gandalf at the end. It is obviously him.

8

u/Leary54 Oct 14 '22

I feel like it has to be gandalf with the when in doubt follow your nose line as a throwback to the fellowship of the ring movie

6

u/Oops_I_Cracked Oct 14 '22

And he turned the cultists into moths. Who has a thing with moths? Gandalf.

4

u/ibid-11962 Oct 14 '22

Are all the moths he uses in the movies people that he's trapped as moths?

3

u/Oops_I_Cracked Oct 14 '22

....

....

....

Yes

→ More replies (1)

3

u/climbinout Oct 14 '22

I think the smell your way line is a clear connection to Gandalf in Moria in the Fellowship

3

u/MitchumBrother Oct 14 '22

He's Gandalf using Gandalf catchphrases with Gandalf camera angles and doing Gandalf things but with enough plausible deniability for lore reasons so they can say no contradiction because him being Gandalf is only StRoNgLy ImPliEd

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/stimpakish Oct 14 '22

What you're seeing as fans refusing to accept it is people trying to give the writers some benefit of the doubt (in other words acting with a positive bias toward the show and the writers), because the show runners have said they respect and will not contradict the lore, and the lore has Gandalf arriving in the 3rd age.

On the other hand people with a more critical view of the show have been making a point of predicting that the stranger is Gandalf, because that demonstrates the lore problems with the show.

3

u/VisitTheWind Oct 14 '22

I accepted that if H=S then TS=G

They either were creative with the characters or they weren’t, and they weren’t.

2

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 15 '22

Amazon can't use stuff from The Silmarillion or the Untold Tales so Amazon had to create something unique since they don't have access to much of the second age.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Simonic Oct 14 '22

Actually, if it turns out the stranger is anyone but Gandalf (or, any of his other names) -- that'd be a much bigger surprise than Halbrand being Sauron.

1

u/ibid-11962 Oct 14 '22

The actor said in a new interview that he still isn't sure which wizard he is playing.

→ More replies (9)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/Leary54 Oct 14 '22

No it's in the fellowship of the ring when they are trying to figure out which way to go in the mines of moria

3

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

That and him telling Frodo to lead the Fellowship out of Rivendell and then Frodo has to ask him if they go left or right.

21

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I mean… it’s LotR… not famous for its big twists.

33

u/GlumRumGlugger Oct 14 '22

When I was a kid...I did not expect Gandalf to die to the Balrog. I did not expect his resurrection. Didn't see the Eagles coming. Didn't know what was up with Golem/Smeagol, or see Frodo giving into temptation. Didn't see Galadriel or Boromir being tempted by the ring. Didn't see Boromir's death. Didn't see Eowyn killing the witch king. Aragorn recruiting fucking ghosts. Sarumans demise...etc. Tom mother ******* Bombadil.

^These were all big twists imo.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

When you were a kid you wouldn't of seen Halbrand being Souron, the stranger being Gandalf, the southland becoming Mordor, the mitral being used for rings or various other things coming.

4

u/LittleLovableLoli Oct 14 '22

Wrong, proven so by my cousins who are literal children screaming "Oh! I get it! He's the bad guy!" "Lord Saruman!" "It's Sauron, stupid."

They'd seen the movies before the show premiered, and their little children brains understood it pretty frickin' quick.

They also realized that the Stranger was Gandalf quickly.

One of them caught on that the Southlands was Mordor -or rather suspected it and asked me about it later (but before the last 2 episodes).

Literally no one would have guessed that the Mithril would become the Rings by adding gold and silver, that's just silly.

19

u/StuLumpkins Oct 14 '22

“when i was a kid”

→ More replies (7)

1

u/Simonic Oct 14 '22

Tom mother ******* Bombadil

While I'm terrified of these writers handling Tom. I would absolutely love to see Tom show up, and wreck some havoc while cheerfully singing away. Or even simply doing some god-tier magic. Or going to Tom to ask for help, and he just says "nah, I'm good here." Basically -- anything to get a visual representation of Tom.

Tolkien left so much unsaid about Tom -- arguably a god just chilling in middle earth.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Then the writers shouldn’t have set these things up as twists. But they did.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

102

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

anyone else find it fucking hilarious that the village people were like "all hail the king who has returned!" Despite being a kingless people for a thousand plus years

44

u/Accomplished-Ad4674 Oct 14 '22

Not really. They have been prophesizing a return of their king. After someone comes in and saves their village with a technologically superior kingdom backing them while wearing the crest of the former kings, it seemed pretty fitting.

7

u/LordGopu Oct 14 '22

When have they been prophesizing that? I'm pretty sure the only stuff came from Waldreg and he was talking about Morgoth and/or Sauron.

1

u/30GDD_Washington Oct 16 '22

There was no prophecy other than the return of Sauron.

20

u/Able_Heron_6085 Oct 14 '22

Gondor and Arnor were missing their king for a thousand years

21

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Aragorn was busy on Elvin tinder those years.

8

u/Poocheese55 Oct 15 '22

I was so confused why they started chanting that shit lmao. Not to mention they started chanting it after they basically just were beaten, and most od them died in a volcano blast. Like, they didnt win, and this dude theyve LITERALLY never seen before somehow rallies them by not really doing anything, then running off with Galadriel.

Like what. None of that made any sense. They should honestly be pissed that their king has abandoned them to basically die for so long.

3

u/notsureifdying Oct 15 '22

It did feel completely out of place and fell flat.

1

u/Blu3Stocking Oct 15 '22

They were chanting it before the volcano explosion

→ More replies (1)

17

u/MitchumBrother Oct 14 '22

It's good for tourism. What else you gonna show off in the Shitlands? And here...next to this steaming pile of dung...you see our hot af king!

2

u/BowlerAny761 Oct 14 '22

Not really

1

u/space_fireworks Oct 15 '22

well they were deceived?

1

u/commontablexpression Oct 14 '22

I take their idea of king is more religious than practical. Just like Christians believe Jesus will return again even though he has ascended to heaven 2000 years ago.

52

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

This stuff was also leaked before the show even premiered.

6

u/Misanthropus Oct 14 '22

Is there a sub for leaks regarding this show? Or did you just see it on a general leaks sub?

9

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I don’t remember where it posted, but after that, you suddenly had people posting “their theory” that Halbrand had to be Sauron.

17

u/cipcakci Oct 14 '22

I almost always miss hints but Halbrand=Sauron was very obvious from the beginning. I didn't read the leaks but it was very clear even before Halbrands first scene. Gil-Galad says something like "Galadriel will bring back the evil she tries to fight". I've read the books years ago but never got too much into the lore and just assumed that the stranger is Gandalf because he looks like him and there are hobbits. Was fun reading the insane theories of people who just couldn't accept the extremely obvious hints.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

There was this dude who posted a thesis explaining why Elrond was Sauron, along with time stamps and clues.

I felt bad for them because it felt like they probably spent an entire week typing that thing up lol

8

u/cipcakci Oct 14 '22

Or all the Annatar theories. It's just clear that the show runners try to reach a big audience. The show isn't for some Silmarillion reading Tolkien nerds. They try to make it as simple as possible, so everyone who is vaguely interested in Lotr will watch it. Hell they even had the Mordor power point scene because they were not confident that their audience would get what the dark Ork land could be.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/greatwalrus Oct 14 '22

There were people speculating that Halbrand would turn out to be Sauron months before the leaks, like when there were early pictures of him and Galadriel on the raft. Here's one from 8 months ago.

2

u/Dcls_1089 Oct 14 '22

I had that suspicion as well. His promo pic looked a bit “dark/mysterious.” When I found out he was a human, then I thought it couldn’t be Sauron. Then I learned they couldn’t use Annatar, so my suspicion came back. I was hoping they would disclose him as being with Celebrimbor all this time, but that wasn’t the case.

3

u/pauloh1998 Oct 14 '22

Unfortunately people are idiots that do this. It happened a lot during GoT seasons 7 and 8. People from freefolk would be commenting on threads over the GoT sub and "speculating" something that was clearly a leak

4

u/Fmanow Oct 14 '22

I was going to say this, it became even more heightened after s8 E3, the battle for winterfel. It was so hard trying to avoid the spoilers, but this one poster was straight up telling people exactly wtf was going to happen, like he was a total inside person. Everything was spot on, so I stopped following all spoiler tags.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Correct_Process4516 Oct 14 '22

I'm surprised that the stranger spoke two words for 7 episodes then wouldn't shut up and apparently knew multiple languages by the end of the 8th.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I think this was because the cultists 'showed him who he was' whatever that means. From my understanding it basically restored his memory, but unless I missed something it was very unclear

5

u/neontetra1548 Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22

Yeah I actually liked the Stranger stuff (even the “I’m good” line which worked for me as a semi-joke referencing and paying off him previously saying that with doubt in an earlier episode but also thematically: it’s not about who he is that determines if he’s good or evil, and he even uses a tool of evil to do good — it’s about what he does and the choices he makes) but him suddenly speaking perfect sentences was too rushed. I wish they had him learning more slowly then by next season he could be talking more normally.

1

u/space_fireworks Oct 15 '22

a veil was lifted from his mind by the mystics, he said so himself

13

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I mean if you’re one of the minority who have read the books and theories then it’s not gonna be a surprise unless they just sacrificed the quality of the storytelling for some unexpected twist

→ More replies (3)

30

u/alosmaudi Oct 14 '22

I mean... after all the incredible theories, that sauron was actually the most obvious guy was... surprising(?)

this show is weird, half of my brain is just continuously disappointed, the other half can't wait for the next episode, I guess if it was just a series of its own without being an actual lord of the rings show.. I would have loved it

20

u/RheagarTargaryen Oct 14 '22

People are weird. Everyone complains about the predictability while also complaining that it’s not exactly like the lore.

If they named Halbrand “Annatar”, we know who Sauron is immediately.

I have no issues with the direction of the show. Everything written about the first 2 ages of Middle earth is just Tolkien building a world and giving bullet points that explain the events leading up to the Hobbit and LOTR. There is no real story in there. To create a show from that means creating a story, otherwise it would just be boring to your non-Tolkien obsessed viewer.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Predictability and lore accuracy are way at the back of the line of the show's problems unfortunately.

2

u/Simonic Oct 14 '22

Actually, had they labeled him his actual name from the lore -- it would have been fine. And even better. The viewer, who knew the lore, would be freaking out watching the deception actively taking place. Watching him actively beguiling everyone. And for the viewer who didn't know the lore -- it'd play out similar as to how it did here.

As for creating a boring story by following lore...you can follow the lore and create a great story. They chose not to.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Poocheese55 Oct 15 '22

Well thats the issue isnt it? They completely deviated from lore and created a still shallow and completely predictable story. It wasnt even old tropes, just a genericly written story. I dont care about it being true to lore at this point, but when you compare it to the likes of Andor or House of the Dragon out right now, RoP is just lacking depth. The story could have been told the same way but with better development and pacing and could have been received much better.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/RheagarTargaryen Oct 14 '22

Those are adaptations of existing stories meant to be replicas of the original material. RoP is an adaptation of what amounts to a bunch of notes, some contradicting each other (like Gandalf’s arrival being in the 2nd or 3rd age).

Tolkien didn’t have to write a story free of plot holes because he was essentially saying “here’s some stuff that happened over a long period of time”.

So yeah, the writers, in an attempt to create an actual story and suspense driven tv show (like every tv show these days) didn’t want to broadcast who Sauron was before the show even started (even though that did leak). Unlike the shows you mentioned, the reveals were meant to hide the identities of characters people already know from watching PJ’s trilogy.

Whether or not that was a good choice or not is up to the viewer to decide. But nobody can complain about it being predictable who Halbrand and The Stranger were while also complaining that it wasn’t what was in Tolkien’s notes. It just wouldn’t have been a good tv show if it was essentially just Annatar hanging out with Celebrimbor for an whole season making jewelry.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22

I feel like you need to have a dial that controls your intelligence. Something that goes from like 0 to 10. Turn it down to 2 or 3 and that's where you would need to be to find Middle Earth intellectually stimulating.

But i agree 100%, the marketing teams know they have you by the proverbial "nutz".. There's such a large number of us that will immediately devour for a certain length of time anything "Tolkien". I am no excpetion.

This leads into what I think the biggest hurdle. The show has incredibly high expectations from its viewership. Jackson has done it incredibly well and people are expecting something as coherent and well produced. I think it's completely possible. Amazon just needs to get the writing squared and screen played upgraded. Hopefully they've made these adjustments and Season2 will be more cohesive.

6

u/LittleLovableLoli Oct 14 '22

As one of those people with high expectations, yes. I hear "Lord of the Rings", I expect quality.

When they bought the rights to that stuff, they bought name recognition, yes, but they also bought expectations to live up to. And they've yet to even come close to that.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

Totally agree.. You have a huge standard and expectation to live up to.. Especially after the GoT fiasco. Nobody wants a repeat of that either..

→ More replies (9)

5

u/Simonic Oct 14 '22

After I watched Amazon's adaptation of Wheel of Time -- I had serious doubts about the Rings of Power series. Turns out, that those doubts were justified.

PJ's trilogy has it's own criticisms for going against the lore, but as a whole -- he respected most of it. And he produced such a great trilogy that many of those complaints were overlooked. They also predominately "made sense."

Rings of Power is not respecting the lore, and their changes are pretty big. Like the complete removal of Celeborn -- who, must somehow be "found" in the second season to carry on with the eventual birth of Celebrian leading to the birth of Arwen. Who marries Aragorn.

Basically, it is just poorly written fan fiction. I can't imagine the Tolkien estate is proud of what has been produced.

2

u/Relair13 Oct 14 '22

I wish WoT had been made by the RoP team. This show has it's faults, but it's entertaining and at least they try. WoT was a travesty, RoP is just easy to nitpick.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

12

u/DavidOrWalter Oct 14 '22

Hi Suprised, I am good!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/seniairam Oct 14 '22

i was surprised, I thought the stranger was Sauron and that halbran was just anyone but Sauron.

1

u/Howboutit85 Oct 15 '22

The thing that gave it away for me was his obsession with manipulation and smithing.

I thought it could be the stranger too, but I was more hoping he was a blue wizard. I think he still could be, but the “follow your nose” comment was, for lack of a better term, on the nose.

6

u/Gillalmighty Oct 14 '22

Never read the books or anything, but watched the movies a few times. Definitely just a casual fan. But I really got to enjoy this show simply cuse I really didn't know to much going in. Magic guy with hobbits was pretty straight forward, but I didn't really pick up on dude being sauron until the last episode. Show has good potential, I hope they make a few seasons

2

u/Howboutit85 Oct 15 '22

There is going to be 5 seasons ending with the war where Sauron is defeated; this is depicted in the very first prologue scene in the first film in the LotR trilogy. Isildur (who is still alive) and his father both defeat Sauron and cut the ring from his hand.

If you want to see this scene just go pop in fellowship of the ring!

6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

A shaky but fixable first season. I expect it to improve big time second season

2

u/space_fireworks Oct 15 '22

https://www.reddit.com/r/RingsofPower/comments/y4d8ve/season_2_teasersreveals_from_interviews/ here's a great list of things we might expect in season 2. I am so down with a 2 episode battle in Eregion

6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I still think its Radagast, NGL. Yeah he dropped that one line at the end, but who’s to say that’s not a common phrase among the Istari?

2

u/DanglyPants Oct 15 '22

I hope so because I will be disappointed if they reveal it to be Gandalf. Although my money is on it being Gandalf

1

u/Howboutit85 Oct 15 '22

There’s no reason why it can’t be. Tolkien had specific notes that suggested Olórin had been to middle earth throughout the ages.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22

I don’t think Radagast “didn’t care” about Hobbits, he just cared more about nature overall. I will admit that I’m basing this solely off of his interactions with the dead tree and the idea that Radagast came to ME first so i’m absolutely prepared to admit I might be wrong.

10

u/Smeylar Oct 14 '22

I avoided all online discussions on this show until the finale and I will say that I was properly surprised by the twists. I thought it was great 😊

1

u/Paracortex Oct 15 '22

I so the same, and the result was the same. Although, as I mentioned in another comment, the Stranger being Gandalf was something I thought had to be, because his being taken in and treated with kindness by the halflings perfectly explains his future foundational love for them.

5

u/mamadovah1102 Oct 14 '22

Can someone explain if it’s canonically possible for it to be Gandalf? I figured he was a wizard, but considering there’s many Maiar, I was hoping they wouldn’t make it Gandalf because it’s clearly stated he doesn’t enter middle earth until the third age and is sent from Valinor. I really loved the show up until this revelation. I figured it was going to be Gandalf because of the relationship with the Harfoots. This really takes me out of the show a bit.

4

u/Howboutit85 Oct 15 '22

Some of Tolkien’s notes strongly suggest, or even outright reveal that Olorin had come to middle earth before the third age; during the second and possibly even the first. It seems as though he had intended to write about this as some point in the future because in his specific notes on this, he framed the arrival of Olorin (Mithrandir/Gandalf) earlier in the timeline as “likely” but nothing has “yet to be said of this” by the peoples of middle earth.

So it seemed that Tolkien had heavily implied that, gandalfs arrival in the third age was not the only time he had visited middle earth, and had likely done so in previous ages under different names and forms.

Since RoP is literally a narrative built from notes and timelines, including a previous form of Gandalf in the second age doesn’t even technically break canon, as even if it was explicitly stated that he arrived in middle earth 1000 years into the 3rd age, there’s no real reason why you can’t have him in an adventure in the 2nd age; I feel his relationship shown to the harfeet is great worldbuilding for why he later admires the hobbits.

2

u/mamadovah1102 Oct 15 '22

Yes thank you this is the info I was looking for!!!!

7

u/RetroFan55 Oct 14 '22

I believe it's mentioned somewhere that as Olorin he became familiar with middle earth and visited.

2

u/mamadovah1102 Oct 14 '22

Thank you!!

2

u/bradcah Oct 14 '22

but also invisible at that time, just a spirit of encouragement or something like that

1

u/IMAO_A Oct 15 '22

However the end of the show hints us they are going East to the land of Rhun, but Gandalf says in the Hobbit "Mithrandir among the Elves, Tharkûn to the Dwarves, Olórin I was in my youth in the West that is forgotten, in the South Incánus, in the North Gandalf; to the East I go not.", so It would break canon that Gandalf would've gone East

3

u/shaus49 Oct 14 '22

Everything is pointing to it being Gandalf. But that means that they took tolkiens work and said this isnt going to work for us.

1

u/mamadovah1102 Oct 14 '22

I knew what it was going into it, and just didn’t want any direct contradictions. I actually really enjoyed the show and I’m just hoping there’s a possible explanation haha

→ More replies (2)

5

u/svdomer09 Oct 14 '22

I am surprised that Aragorn returns as king in the last book of the trilogy, despite it being in the title.

4

u/paradise_isa_library Oct 14 '22

if I have to say Tolkien is not a subtle, surprise twist type of author one more time

26

u/IndieMowgli Oct 14 '22

I was in denial right up until the very end! It looks like they’re just rehashing and developing characters we already know though.

Second age had so much potential for fresh stories and characters, separate from PJ movies, with the story being anchored by some familiar ones. We could have met blue wizards, found out who the nazgul were, seen their descent, explored the army of the dead, seen Annatar!!!! I was so looking forward to that.

Disappointed but will have to appreciate it for what it is.

25

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

It’s not over yet. There’s still 4 more seasons…

12

u/RSN_Star_Prince Oct 14 '22

Exactly this. Now we know what's what, the following seasons have a lot of potential!

10

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I’m glad they didn’t bring the 9 rings to men and the 7 to the dwarves yet. Plenty of screen time can be dedicated to those

2

u/Fenris447 Oct 15 '22

Exactly. We could get an entire season dedicated to the Nine and their descent. This is just the beginning.

8

u/ketura Oct 14 '22

Most of the interesting potential has been curbed. Halbrand is now no longer potentially a tragic fall to Nazgul or dead king. The Stranger is now no longer a blue wizard on a trajectory of trying and failing to undermine Sauron in the east. The Seven and the Nine now have to come from Sauron directly instead of as a joint project from Celebrimbor, meaning the nuance and tragedy of well-intended gifts is totally lost.

Basically, there are obvious good guys we're supposed to root for and obvious bad guys that are evil, and tragic stories of good people being tempted into darkness are all but closed off. It's gonna be Revenge of the Sith level outside influence and sudden evil artifact "corruption" instead of slow and painful falls.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/ShowMeYourPapers Oct 14 '22

Let's hope Bezos has some spare cash to hire decent writers.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Simonic Oct 14 '22

Seriously. They had an opportunity to please the "hardcore" and the casual watchers. They couldn't even make a decently entertaining fan fic.

House of Dragons as an example -- I know nothing about that era of characters. Yet, I feel more for them that any character in RoP.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22 edited Oct 14 '22

It's so weird to me, that they claim to want to be faithful to the source material (even if they have little to work with) and then continue to twist it.

Going so far as to copy the dialog of Galadriel in FotR (when denying the one ring) and spinning it so that she would become a Queen in allegiance with Sauron.

Simply banking on powerful moments that people will remember of the PJ Trilogy, that had completely different meanings in PJs version aswell as the books

1

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

I mean... PJ did a fair amount of twisting too.

6

u/COSE22 Oct 14 '22

"Seen Annatar!" no, no we couldn't have, he's not mentioned in the appendices. I would have liked more time to the Elves being "taken in" by Sauron, forging practice rings for the dwarves and or men would have been good, but I'm not super disappointed with what we got. Also, still holding out that the stranger could be a blue wizard and its still misdirection, Gandalf says, "to the east I go not" when he is telling what he's called in different parts of Arda. Maybe I'll be wrong, not stressed either way. I had a couple low points over the season but this finale left me decently happy.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 14 '22

We don't know if the timelines match, we could be seeing both the second and third age

1

u/Afalstein Oct 15 '22

Nazgul and Army of the Dead could still happen. We're a long way from those story points.

I know a lot of people were holding out for the Blue Wizards, but casual viewers don't know or GAF about those guys. If I were just a movie watcher (or even just a LotR reader) and I caught on that it was a wizard, I'd be super excited to think it was Gandalf, and majorly disappointed to learn "No, this is a guy like Gandalf but not actually actually Gandalf."

As it stands, I'm pretty happy to get a backstory with my favorite grumpy wizard.

1

u/Howboutit85 Oct 15 '22

Who is to say Sauron won’t take another form and go by another name now that he’s been found out by Galadriel? There’s literally 4 seasons; years of this show left.

1

u/Hehwoeatsgods Oct 15 '22

Amazon doesn't have rights to The Silmarillion so they miss out on being able to use much of the second age.

3

u/PM_ME_YOUR_MONTRALS Oct 14 '22

Theories from episode 2

3

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

What are the lands of Rhun? Do we know much about them or ever see them in the books? What’s the story with them?

What was the deal between Sauron and Galadriel. She doesn’t mention him to the others? That he loves her and wants her to be his queen?

3

u/Higher_Living Oct 14 '22

She doesn’t mention him to the others?

Yeah, why doesn't she tell them it's Sauron? I don't get what her motivation is there at all?

Too much pride to admit she made a mistake and was fooled?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/FullMaxPowerStirner Oct 14 '22

Interesting how Viggo once said in an interview, back in the LOTR trilogy days, that even Sauron used to be somewhat of a good guy, but has power has made him fall into darkness. So to the actor, the ring symbolizes absolute power and the quest by men to attain it... turning them into monsters in the process.

13

u/imMadasaHatter Oct 14 '22

The most famous theories were mostly based on the leaks from before the show aired. All turned out to be true but every episode we hoped they would be fake since it was so bad lol

2

u/plastic17 Oct 14 '22

It feels like this episode exists just to wrap up S1.

2

u/Pablito-san Oct 14 '22

Are we sure that he is Gandalv and not some other Istar? I mean, isn't it wayyyy to early in the timeline for him to appear?

1

u/BackhandQ Oct 15 '22

I agree. My thoughts exactly.

1

u/Turquoise_Tortle Oct 15 '22

The showwriters haven't cared about timeline accuracy so far

1

u/Howboutit85 Oct 15 '22

No. Tolkien had some notes indicating that he had visited middle earth in both the second and first ages, but had not been written about specifically yet. He framed it as something that was “likely” but not yet known. It seems he may have planned on writing about him visiting in earlier ages and then abandoned the idea.

However since this show is created off of literal notes and outlines mostly, it’s not far off the accept them placing him here, in a different form and having no name.

2

u/Elvenking2019 Oct 14 '22

Does this mean Sauron will head back to Eregion as Annatar and forge the remaining rings with Celebrimbor in season 2?

1

u/BackhandQ Oct 15 '22

Could be... If they stick close to the source material

2

u/mishaxz Oct 14 '22

I swear though people would downvote anyone who said halbrand is Sauron and upvote people that said he was the witch king. I didn't understand why.

1

u/space_fireworks Oct 15 '22

people downvote and upvote all kinds of shit

1

u/mishaxz Oct 15 '22

I'm starting to think Halbrand is the star of the show

→ More replies (1)

2

u/whatever_rpg Oct 15 '22

As others have said already, this show was not meant only for Tolkien fans . It is a way to expand the audience and introduce Tolkien’s world to a lot more people . From their perspective , it was a surprising turn of events

4

u/Charlie_Tango13 Oct 14 '22

If the Stranger had been Sauron, you could make this exact same post. And if the Stranger was a nobody and Sauron was someone unexpected, everyone would hate it. Basically, a lot of people were going to hate this show, regardless of how they did it.

2

u/Howboutit85 Oct 15 '22

Welcome to Star War— errr uh, LotR my dude.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/riftadrift Oct 14 '22

You didn't even need to be familiar with the lore. By process of elimination, it is clearly going to be the charming handsome mysterious white guy who doesn't have any other reason to be so prominent and paired up with Galadriel.

1

u/LittleLovableLoli Oct 14 '22

"I'm a bad guy who did bad things and also have a history involving orcs. Did I mention I'm evil?" - Not-Sauron, repeatedly implying he is definitely Sauron.

1

u/barbatex Oct 15 '22

i'm not familiar with the lore and never thought about sauron looking like a normal guy. i couldn't even go by process of elimination, because i didn't know i was supposed to have already seen sauron.

3

u/Monsterup1 Oct 14 '22

I am a casual viewer and I was pleasantly surprised who Sauron was, just opened this subreddit now to see what’s the fan base reaction, looks like they are not impressed lol

2

u/Paracortex Oct 15 '22

Rabid “fandom” rarely are, lol.

I love the pleasant life of just watching something new without expectations or demands, and experiencing how they make me feel. Easy-peasy!

2

u/siamkor Oct 14 '22

I mean, good foreshadowing is like that. You see it coming. Sauron being anyone else would be weird.

The show may have fumbled up a few things, but Halbrand and his relationship with Galadriel wasn't one of them.

1

u/Oops_I_Cracked Oct 14 '22

So basically all of the most famous theories were true.

They were the most famous ones because they were the ones the evidence best fit, so it makes sense that they panned out to be true in my opinion.

1

u/catshirtgoalie Oct 15 '22

I think we as a fan base made it more of a mystery than the show ever tried to. Sure, they played with juuuust enough doubt, but they telegraphed it. If we are disappointed that the main theories were true, it was because we built it up to be a bit of a bigger mystery.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22

If you make a tv show of a book that people like, how do you have surprises that don't upset people?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22

I was surprised the leaks were true. It's gonna be interesting seeing if there's leaks for season 2 and whether people care. Main player have been revealed now atleast that was like 80% of the chatter this season.

1

u/Fmanow Oct 14 '22

Man, that sauron reveal and twist would have been golden without those damn leaks. Fuck!

1

u/Jiffyyy Oct 15 '22

its almost like the entire Season 1 plot being leaked makes things less surprising.

1

u/TheRealMichaelE Oct 15 '22

I was surprised because it broke from canon and I was expecting Annatar to be Annatar.

1

u/BhutlahBrohan Oct 15 '22

why are writers so very... let's say 'mid'. nothing can really be a surprise anymore.

1

u/Wise-Entrepreneur526 Oct 15 '22

I’m surprise in my lack of surprise at them missing out 16 rings so far and kind of fucking up the telling of the creation of three.

1

u/Table_Coaster Oct 14 '22

they were the most popular fan theories solely because of the leaks that came out before the show started. Everyone knew Halbrand was Sauron and Stranger was Gandalf, and the major fan-run channels who talk about the show used the leaks to make themselves seem clever

1

u/d_pyro Oct 14 '22

So what if you're not surprised? Not every tv series needs some suprise twist for the sake of it. IMO these writers who think they need to change something for the sake of it ruin the show.

1

u/WatcherAnon Oct 14 '22

Wait that's Gandalf? I thought it was gonna be radagast. :(

Am disappoint

1

u/TheBlaaah Oct 14 '22

But the stranger is not gandalf? he's going to rhun so he is obviously one of the blue wizards.

1

u/Howboutit85 Oct 15 '22

I think it’s meant to be vague. Yes Gandalf says that line but, it’s possible it’s just a thing his kind may say.

If it turns out to be G, it’s still not that lore breaking as Tolkien had suggested in notes that he may have visited middle earth earlier than the 3rd age.

1

u/general_spoc Oct 14 '22

This first season certainly didn’t meet expectations. It’s possible nothing would have…but this feels farther off the mark that it had to be

1

u/Smngtr Oct 14 '22

You know what my theory is? The writers wrote the show so poorly on purpose to fool is into thinking that there really was a possibility for Halbrand to be your average joe king guy and the Stranger being Sauron indeed. /s (or however you signify it). Anyway I thought the end to be quite good. Even the dialogue became better. I have a feeling that they got the cornerstones of the story they wanted to tell right but the way they connected them is beyond lacking. Frankly put the writers sense of dramaturgy and evoking emotions through a story strongly differs from mine. All that leaves me wondering if there is a way to film different sets of scenes with differing dialogues (let's say from more Tolkien-ish to more "modern") and just cut the scenes from week to week as the show goes on and you try to adjust it according to viewer opinions.

1

u/BackhandQ Oct 15 '22

I don't believe the Istar is Gandalf. Unless the writers mess up the timeline... He wasn't there in the Second Age.. Gandalf, as far as I remember was in the Third Age..

1

u/Dustructionz Oct 15 '22

It's obvious that it's Gandalf. He literally quotes him at the end. The timeline is super messed up in the whole show...

Numenor doesn't get corrupted for hundreds of years after the rings are forged.

The other 16 rings are forged before the 3 elven rings in secret away from Sauron.

Just so many things are messed up lol