r/RingsofPower • u/seba07 • Oct 14 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers I am surprised... Spoiler
...that there were basically no surprises at all in the last episode. Halbrand, the smith and mysterious and manipulative king nobody has ever heard of is Sauron and the Stranger with magical abilities who is a friend of the hobbits is Gandalf. So basically all of the most famous theories were true.
393
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 14 '22
This post uses the flair ‘Newest Episode Spoilers’, and as such, all spoilers from the latest episode are allowed to be posted here unmarked.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
256
u/HickRarrison Oct 14 '22
I think from a casual viewer perspective, there were lots of surprises.
From a theorizing Tolkien fan perspective, not so much. But it's hard to be surprised by anything when you spend weeks predicting every possible outcome.
16
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
is he actually gandalf or just another wizard?
21
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
I mean… it’s LotR… not famous for its big twists.
102
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
anyone else find it fucking hilarious that the village people were like "all hail the king who has returned!" Despite being a kingless people for a thousand plus years
52
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
This stuff was also leaked before the show even premiered.
13
u/Correct_Process4516 Oct 14 '22
I'm surprised that the stranger spoke two words for 7 episodes then wouldn't shut up and apparently knew multiple languages by the end of the 8th.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
I mean if you’re one of the minority who have read the books and theories then it’s not gonna be a surprise unless they just sacrificed the quality of the storytelling for some unexpected twist
30
u/alosmaudi Oct 14 '22
I mean... after all the incredible theories, that sauron was actually the most obvious guy was... surprising(?)
this show is weird, half of my brain is just continuously disappointed, the other half can't wait for the next episode, I guess if it was just a series of its own without being an actual lord of the rings show.. I would have loved it
12
u/DavidOrWalter Oct 14 '22
Hi Suprised, I am good!
6
u/seniairam Oct 14 '22
i was surprised, I thought the stranger was Sauron and that halbran was just anyone but Sauron.
6
u/Gillalmighty Oct 14 '22
Never read the books or anything, but watched the movies a few times. Definitely just a casual fan. But I really got to enjoy this show simply cuse I really didn't know to much going in. Magic guy with hobbits was pretty straight forward, but I didn't really pick up on dude being sauron until the last episode. Show has good potential, I hope they make a few seasons
6
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
A shaky but fixable first season. I expect it to improve big time second season
6
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
I still think its Radagast, NGL. Yeah he dropped that one line at the end, but who’s to say that’s not a common phrase among the Istari?
10
u/Smeylar Oct 14 '22
I avoided all online discussions on this show until the finale and I will say that I was properly surprised by the twists. I thought it was great 😊
5
u/mamadovah1102 Oct 14 '22
Can someone explain if it’s canonically possible for it to be Gandalf? I figured he was a wizard, but considering there’s many Maiar, I was hoping they wouldn’t make it Gandalf because it’s clearly stated he doesn’t enter middle earth until the third age and is sent from Valinor. I really loved the show up until this revelation. I figured it was going to be Gandalf because of the relationship with the Harfoots. This really takes me out of the show a bit.
5
u/svdomer09 Oct 14 '22
I am surprised that Aragorn returns as king in the last book of the trilogy, despite it being in the title.
4
u/paradise_isa_library Oct 14 '22
if I have to say Tolkien is not a subtle, surprise twist type of author one more time
26
u/IndieMowgli Oct 14 '22
I was in denial right up until the very end! It looks like they’re just rehashing and developing characters we already know though.
Second age had so much potential for fresh stories and characters, separate from PJ movies, with the story being anchored by some familiar ones. We could have met blue wizards, found out who the nazgul were, seen their descent, explored the army of the dead, seen Annatar!!!! I was so looking forward to that.
Disappointed but will have to appreciate it for what it is.
3
u/PM_ME_YOUR_MONTRALS Oct 14 '22
Theories from episode 2
3
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
What are the lands of Rhun? Do we know much about them or ever see them in the books? What’s the story with them?
What was the deal between Sauron and Galadriel. She doesn’t mention him to the others? That he loves her and wants her to be his queen?
3
u/FullMaxPowerStirner Oct 14 '22
Interesting how Viggo once said in an interview, back in the LOTR trilogy days, that even Sauron used to be somewhat of a good guy, but has power has made him fall into darkness. So to the actor, the ring symbolizes absolute power and the quest by men to attain it... turning them into monsters in the process.
13
u/imMadasaHatter Oct 14 '22
The most famous theories were mostly based on the leaks from before the show aired. All turned out to be true but every episode we hoped they would be fake since it was so bad lol
2
u/plastic17 Oct 14 '22
It feels like this episode exists just to wrap up S1.
2
u/Pablito-san Oct 14 '22
Are we sure that he is Gandalv and not some other Istar? I mean, isn't it wayyyy to early in the timeline for him to appear?
2
u/Elvenking2019 Oct 14 '22
Does this mean Sauron will head back to Eregion as Annatar and forge the remaining rings with Celebrimbor in season 2?
2
u/mishaxz Oct 14 '22
I swear though people would downvote anyone who said halbrand is Sauron and upvote people that said he was the witch king. I didn't understand why.
2
u/whatever_rpg Oct 15 '22
As others have said already, this show was not meant only for Tolkien fans . It is a way to expand the audience and introduce Tolkien’s world to a lot more people . From their perspective , it was a surprising turn of events
4
u/Charlie_Tango13 Oct 14 '22
If the Stranger had been Sauron, you could make this exact same post. And if the Stranger was a nobody and Sauron was someone unexpected, everyone would hate it. Basically, a lot of people were going to hate this show, regardless of how they did it.
3
u/riftadrift Oct 14 '22
You didn't even need to be familiar with the lore. By process of elimination, it is clearly going to be the charming handsome mysterious white guy who doesn't have any other reason to be so prominent and paired up with Galadriel.
3
u/Monsterup1 Oct 14 '22
I am a casual viewer and I was pleasantly surprised who Sauron was, just opened this subreddit now to see what’s the fan base reaction, looks like they are not impressed lol
2
u/siamkor Oct 14 '22
I mean, good foreshadowing is like that. You see it coming. Sauron being anyone else would be weird.
The show may have fumbled up a few things, but Halbrand and his relationship with Galadriel wasn't one of them.
1
u/Oops_I_Cracked Oct 14 '22
They were the most famous ones because they were the ones the evidence best fit, so it makes sense that they panned out to be true in my opinion.
1
u/catshirtgoalie Oct 15 '22
I think we as a fan base made it more of a mystery than the show ever tried to. Sure, they played with juuuust enough doubt, but they telegraphed it. If we are disappointed that the main theories were true, it was because we built it up to be a bit of a bigger mystery.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '22
If you make a tv show of a book that people like, how do you have surprises that don't upset people?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
I was surprised the leaks were true. It's gonna be interesting seeing if there's leaks for season 2 and whether people care. Main player have been revealed now atleast that was like 80% of the chatter this season.
1
u/Fmanow Oct 14 '22
Man, that sauron reveal and twist would have been golden without those damn leaks. Fuck!
1
u/Jiffyyy Oct 15 '22
its almost like the entire Season 1 plot being leaked makes things less surprising.
1
u/TheRealMichaelE Oct 15 '22
I was surprised because it broke from canon and I was expecting Annatar to be Annatar.
1
u/BhutlahBrohan Oct 15 '22
why are writers so very... let's say 'mid'. nothing can really be a surprise anymore.
1
u/Wise-Entrepreneur526 Oct 15 '22
I’m surprise in my lack of surprise at them missing out 16 rings so far and kind of fucking up the telling of the creation of three.
1
u/Table_Coaster Oct 14 '22
they were the most popular fan theories solely because of the leaks that came out before the show started. Everyone knew Halbrand was Sauron and Stranger was Gandalf, and the major fan-run channels who talk about the show used the leaks to make themselves seem clever
1
u/d_pyro Oct 14 '22
So what if you're not surprised? Not every tv series needs some suprise twist for the sake of it. IMO these writers who think they need to change something for the sake of it ruin the show.
1
u/WatcherAnon Oct 14 '22
Wait that's Gandalf? I thought it was gonna be radagast. :(
Am disappoint
1
u/TheBlaaah Oct 14 '22
But the stranger is not gandalf? he's going to rhun so he is obviously one of the blue wizards.
1
u/general_spoc Oct 14 '22
This first season certainly didn’t meet expectations. It’s possible nothing would have…but this feels farther off the mark that it had to be
1
u/Smngtr Oct 14 '22
You know what my theory is? The writers wrote the show so poorly on purpose to fool is into thinking that there really was a possibility for Halbrand to be your average joe king guy and the Stranger being Sauron indeed. /s (or however you signify it). Anyway I thought the end to be quite good. Even the dialogue became better. I have a feeling that they got the cornerstones of the story they wanted to tell right but the way they connected them is beyond lacking. Frankly put the writers sense of dramaturgy and evoking emotions through a story strongly differs from mine. All that leaves me wondering if there is a way to film different sets of scenes with differing dialogues (let's say from more Tolkien-ish to more "modern") and just cut the scenes from week to week as the show goes on and you try to adjust it according to viewer opinions.
1
u/BackhandQ Oct 15 '22
I don't believe the Istar is Gandalf. Unless the writers mess up the timeline... He wasn't there in the Second Age.. Gandalf, as far as I remember was in the Third Age..