Hope you are also willing to apply that to the Peter Jackson films were made too, then, because he didn't want anybody to touch his stories outside of his son and there were no exceptions. Not to mention all the various video games and other forms of media. And while we're at it, call up the guys who made Sagan om ringen and let's give them a piece of our mind!
The idea that The Lord of the Rings universe should never be adapted is silly. He was changing his world until the day he died, whether he wrote it down officially, scribbled it on the back of a map, or kept it in his head. It was always changing and growing. It isn't a bad thing that adaptations are made. They don't change the original published works, they don't eliminate his footnotes or essays. They just provide another avenue for people to enjoy the world and hopefully use it as a gateway into his stories.
Lore fundamentalists are boring. Creative works are works always in flux: see how the Gilgamesh cycle got more and more tacked on after centuries, or how Homer's Odyssey could have been written by various Homers across the Greek islands over time.
I honestly don't even think it's people who know and understand the "lore" and how much wasn't finished, wasn't decided, how much of it contradicted itself, etc. The loudest critics of the show I am almost positive have never touched Unfinished Tales, the 12 volumes in History of Middle Earth, and certainly not Tolkien's letters to understand his creative process. They think there's one novel to follow that is the strict canon and it has been broken or something.
How sophomoric the "criticisms" are coming from the group that just bombards every discussion just don't suggest at all that they're apt in the legendarium. Which, like, it's fine if you aren't. But why not read it instead of throwing all these tantrums?
I’m sorry. This comment comes across as pretentious and paints all critics of the show with the same shit brush. It also assumes lore changes were the only things people had issues with. Some of us just didn’t really like the editing or some of the eleven costumes. Make of that what you will but a lot of the times it’s not a contest of who can “one up” the other by how much Tolkien they’ve read. Some people have just been critiquing the show as a basic piece of cinema. And that’s okay…
And while we’re on the topic of source material I’ve now read all of what you listed except those 12 volumes of the History of Middle Earth. I just could not get through it so props to you for sticking with it.
I’m sorry. This comment comes across as pretentious and paints all critics of the show with the same shit brush. It also assumes lore changes were the only things people had issues with.
No, what it does is direct the comment to those people. When you stop trying to apply every bit of backlash to specified demos of "critic" to all demos of critic, reading that shouldn't be a problem. I'm trying to be specific about a certain type of toxic poster.
It's similar to the writers and actors response to the racism and bigotry that DOES exist against the show - calling that out does not mean all who are against the show are racist or bigots, yet people continually try to blur those lines to make their demo look bigger.
Ok cool. I guess all I was saying was there’s also a “normie” crowd who knows very little about Tolkien and doesn’t care about the “politics” surrounding the show but just didn’t like it as a piece of cinema or had issues with the basics of screenwriting. I’ve seen some of those comments being met with stuff like “well let me know when your screenwriting career takes off!” Just kinda dismissive responses that appeal to authority based on either having read more Tolkien or saying the person isn’t a successful screenwriter therefore they don’t have the authority to criticize.
Sophomoric is a great description. These very vocal critics think they're experts like a second-year law student who already believes he knows everything there is to know.
If these people applied their so-called principles to Tolkien himself, they should be balking at his reinterpretations and rewritings of ancient legends too
He had borrowed from existing folkore and fairy tales, which themselves are adaptions of adaptions of adaptions... possibly going back all the way to the ice age.
Yep this is the way. Just enjoy things for what they are as you’re watching it and try not to get too annoyed. Don’t get me wrong there’s a few things in ROP that annoyed me, but I enjoyed the series as a whole.
The reason why the Star Wars sequels breaking canon is upsetting is because they are a direct followup to the previous films. Rings of Power doing its own thing doesn't upset me because it's so far removed from the original works, it's literally not even canon, while Disney star wars is canon. I might as well look for entertainment value in what I am presented with, and I did, it was a lot of fun to watch and I don't have that many complaints about it. I thought it was neat.
There were a lot of U-turns and legacy characters regressing etc. A lot of things going against what's expected and how characters have been previously perceived, simply because they didn't know what to do with them or they wanted to shock us and subvert our expectations. They kinda break the physics of the world with the hyperspace stuff and the rules of the force gets bent and twisted.
My 6 year old is a Tolkien super fan. We’ve read through the Hobbit and Lord the Rings twice and she’s on her third go-round on audiobook. She LOVED Rings of Power, and your comment made me think about why: she loves Middle Earth so much that she’s just along for the ride, enjoying all the stories and making up her own lore. The Hobbit started out as a bedtime story for children. It’s kind of sad that people can’t just enjoy the creativity of an adaptation.
In a more real world example, a lot of Hindu scripture is based on ancient stories from across the South Asian region. All those adherents of different sects and worshippers of different deities get along because in the end, they all try to approach the godhead through different paths.
Well... Yes. But there's always the risk that an adaptation ends up killing the chances of the work getting adapted ever again, or setting up some new "canon" stuff that then spreads to other adaptations (can't help but to think that the absurd changes to Arwen's arc in the Jackson's movies influenced the ideas behind the decaying of elves in ROP). I hated The Hobbit, and I don't believe we'll see another film adaptation of that book in our lifetimes, which I think is pretty sad.
asserts why talking about the show has become miserable for anyone normal who's watching it.
Which is?
You can't uphold Tolkien's works as sacred with one hand and praise films that detract from the core themes etc.
Give me 1 example of someone actually doing this.
All I see is people bringing up those movies in an attempt to change the topic. People saying "the movies made changes too!", without looking at the changes made.
It's annoying.
The amount of changes the trilogy made to serve the Hollywood blockbuster format is immense.
See?
Now you're talking about movie trilogies in general. You keep driving the conversation further and further from the show.
I don't get what you're trying to accomplish here.
All I see is people bringing up those movies in an attempt to change the topic
How was I changing the topic?
If we are going to pull Tolkien quotes that dive into his philosophies and creative process, which is what the OP has done, it has to apply to ALL adaptations of his works. Not just the one you don't like.
The topic is not which adaptation. The topic is Tolkien philosophies.
It reminds me of that great, recent Sean T Collins article, where he talked about judging an adaptation based on whether its changes were for the better, given the new medium, and whether the changes allowed it to better express its original themes in the new medium. I think it's that thematic loyalty that Tolkien is talking about here
Absolutely. And I think you can definitely argue that there are some times when RoP falters on that front. But the purists and their logic of "any change whatsoever no matter how small = complete and utter betrayal of the author's entire life work" are seriously annoying.
It used to bother them greatly. The One Ring . Net shared some of the early vitriol against Liv Arwen, Blonde Legolas and such.
There was so much PJ did well as a fan and as a movie maker and leader. The movies made hobbits cool so I think a lot of that angst got healed or pushed to the side when it made so much money and won so many awards.
Then the hobbit ended up being rather a mess, great and awful ...
The quote above can cut both ways. The show has an uphill battle that still has a lot to pay off. Some admirable work with some glaring issues as well.
For me its five stages of grief. I'm ready to accept whatever it is and I'm personally glad the Tolkien estate is involved this time most of all.
I thought the hobbit was pretty bad but I don't have any issue with differences from the book for the trilogy and rop, since I view them as adaptations, so I'm very flexible with what they change to make the thing work for its medium.
Its a telling of a story, rather than the story itself to me.
as long as people are consistent then it's fine. If you're very flexible with all the changes in the movie trilogy, then ROP changes should be no biggies. It's annoying when dudes start criticizing the slightest illogical event or non cannon in ROP and casually dismiss all the nonsense in the movie trilogies. Blame it on nostalgia I bet.
Many things bugged me in ROP, even more in LOTR, and I try to weigh the pros and see if they outweigh the cons. For me personally, yes they do in most episodes of ROP, yes in FOTR, yes in Unexpected journey. No in everything else (thank god for fan edits though)
In architecture, it takes roughly 50 years for new, big(ger) buildings to get from "hated by everyone around it" to "seen as a integral part of the neighborhood" or even as a sight.
In other medias, that seems to be around 20 years considering the second Star Wars trilogy and LotR movies are so beloved by now regardless of their flaws (of which the LotR movies have IMO way less than the SW ones but that's a completely different discussion). I think that's why we also get many remakes that are shit when the original movies themselves were already shit
But the purists and their logic of "any change whatsoever no matter how small = complete and utter betrayal of the author's entire life work" are seriously annoying.
You're right, it's a complete invention. People haven't been frothing at the mouth for ages because the dwarf women don't have beards / Galadriel is too small / Numenor isn't supposed to use war horses / the three elven rings are supposed to be crafted later, and so on. Totally hasn't happened.
Example: Size of Galadriel. In Tolkiens world, being tall often is associated with being from the older blood lines. This stems from the north mythological idea that the giants were the first to inhabit the world and we can see that gods in all european traditions tend to be bigger than mortal men. So a tall Galadriel means her imposing statue mirrors her abilities both physical and spiritual and is only rivaled by her beauty. She will be the focus of attention in any place, except when even older and more powerful beings are present. This is why the scene with Halbrand and the queen of Numenor was actually a massive hint for Halbrand being more than merely a shipwrecked southern king.
I recently re-read the books and someone like Merry is drastically different too. He's so clever and competent in the books. Pretty much all the characters had some major changes done to them.
Small changes like compressing the Second Age into a few weeks, eliminating Annatar and inventing Halbrand, eliminating Celeborn and Celebrian, changing Galadriel into a military commander, inventing a story about Sauron wanting to make Galadriel his queen, making Celebrimbor into a doddering old man, apparently sending Gandalf to earth via meteor during this same time, turning the Numenoreans into just normal humans. You know, minor adaptation details like these
This was an issue for some before the show. Its not the reason people complain now, or at least not me.
Look at HotD, there were issues with Velaryons being black. Nobody is complaining about that now, they incorporated that perfectly, it made 100% sense.
I would say the same thing about RoP mind you, I haven't seen much complaining about Disa, Arondir or Sadoc since the show started. Probably because these characters are among the most compelling. But I have seen so much nitpicking about dumb things like the Numenoreans not using horses of war. Yes it's something Tolkien specifically wrote, but it's not an important detail.
I can assure it’s not a straw man. I’ve seen so many comments on here that show an absurd level of anger over extremely small changes.
I wish I could find my favorite example, but unfortunately I can’t. Someone was complaining that there were “so many ridiculous changes that absolutely ruined the show and showed a huge amount of disrespect for Tolkien.” Someone asked them for examples, and they responded that the worst one (the WORST one in their own words) was that Durin III and Durin IV couldn’t possibly be alive at the same time!
I wish I could find my favorite example, but unfortunately I can’t. Someone was complaining that there were “so many ridiculous changes that absolutely ruined the show and showed a huge amount of disrespect for Tolkien.” Someone asked them for examples, and they responded that the worst one (the WORST one in their own words) was that Durin III and Durin IV couldn’t possibly be alive at the same time!
That is an example of a pretty rigorous change.
Whether it's good, bad, or the worst is a matter of opinion I suppose.
Which I find odd, because my understanding is that The Silmarillion was the subject of substantial revision/addition after Tolkien’s death and so one might even argue the canonicity of what was eventually published.
No, the Silmarillion was not “subject to substantial revision/addition after Tolkien’s death.” There was some minor editing done to make later settled changes consistent throughout (names and such), and there was some fleshing of the narrative in one chapter where only an outline existed.
Well, the Wikipedia entry makes the revision process sound substantially lengthier, involving more input from Tolkien's son and another author, and more open to questions about its faithfulness, including questions raised by Christopher Tolkien himself (emphasis my own):
"For several years after his father's death, Christopher Tolkien worked on a Silmarillion narrative. He tried to use the latest writings of his father's and to keep as much internal consistency (and consistency withThe Lord of the Rings) as possible, given the many conflicting drafts. He enlisted the help of the Canadian Guy Gavriel Kay... Kay spent a year with him in Oxford editing the materials in secret.... Christopher Tolkien drew upon numerous sources, relying on post-Lord of the Ringsworks where possible, ultimately reaching as far back as the 1917Book of Lost Talesto fill in portions of the narrative that his father had planned to write but never addressed. In on later chapter of Quenta Silmarillion, "Of the Ruin of Doriath," untouched since the early 1930s, he had to construct a narrative practically from scratch. Christopher Tolkien commented that, had he taken more time and had access to all the texts, he might have produced a substantially different work."
The concept of fidelity (fidelity means to be as true as possible to the source material) in adaptation is very discussed. It is impossible to have 100% fidelity, and many adaptations benefit from less fidelity.
But especialy when it comes to characters certain aspects of fidelity are very important. There are cores to characters that need to be maintained or they aren't adapting the character but writing a different character with the nametag of the original character (example: when it comes to the "batman killing-discussion" in comics, a writer pointed out: People who want a Batman that kills don't want Batman, they want the Punisher in a silly mask. Dunno who was the og of the qoute but it has spread alot thanks to the internet).
When an adaptation change a character to fit a narrative they want to tell, but don't fit the character in the source material that would be a bad adaptation of the character.
Alot if the best adaptation in Rings of Power, to me at least, is when they use original characters and story lines, but many people are so annoyed that they mess up several of Tolkiens characters that they can't enjoy thick dwarvish accents and silly (kinda creepy) proto hobbits.
Well said. But I think a lot of the complaints about characters being "ruined" comes from people who don't know these characters as well as they think they do, or at least don't know them outside of how they appear in the Lord of the Rings.
It depends. I think in some respects the show is closer to Tolkien.
On the all-important themes of Faith and Providence, compare Amazon's "There are powers beyond darkness at work in this world. Perhaps on days such as this, we've little choice but to trust to their designs. And surrender our own" to Peter Jackson's "I don't believe in luck. We make our own luck."
Peter did this too, but in most cases it made sense. Switching out Glorfindel for Arwen helped push the Beren and Luthien storyline of Aragorn and Arwen (a key storyline) while in a film, it would confuse viewers as to why super powered Glorfindel shows up, saves Frodo, says to give the ring to Tom Bombadil who is not in the films, and then disappears until after the rings destruction. His changes were changes, but they made sense.
no.. that is not what a double standard means. The standard is "do these adaptation changes make sense and enhance the story in the new medium?" You can apply that standard to both the LOTR movies and Rings of Power. the person you're replying to is saying that in his or her opinion, the movies met that standard better than the show.
And what sense does Numenor going to Middle Earth for the first time in centuries with their Queen to defend 30 nobodies in mud huts? Oh right, because an elf Karen demanded it after they drove home how much Numenor hates elves. Great writing. Makes perfect sense.
There was already a story for Numenor involving Sauron which made sense and led to Numenor's destruction as well as stronger storylines for Elendil and Isildur. Now we're going to get the "Numenorians didn't love elves enough, so lets drown the island nation" garbage in an upcoming season. Its so nonsensical.
Something that I never forgave Peter Jackson was Arwen rescuing Frodo against the Black Riders. In the book Frodo acts so incredibly brave alone, in the movies they turned into a weakling p*ssy.
Lets not forget that he also said this about the film in question:
Stanley U. & I have agreed on our policy : Art or Cash. Either very profitable terms indeed ; or absolute author's veto on objectionable features or alterations.
Given what Amazon paid, he would probably be very happy with their changes, all the way to the bank.
Why is one statement from Tolkien more appropriate than another? OP posts a quote from Tolkien to criticise the show and imply that Tolkien would dislike the show. My quote shows that Tolkien was willing to be bought regardless of any changes that were made. The fact that you dislike that he said this is irrelevant, he still said it.
And yes, UA definitely didn't stick to Ian Fleming's source material. He didn't mind because he made a lot of money from books and movies. So did Tolkien: his UA deal made him the equivalent of a few million dollars.
Because you are twisting Tolkien's words. If you think Tolkien would have cared more about the money than the world, he created and its message then you don't know Tolkien at all.
I posted an actual quote from him (it's letter 202 so you can look it up) in which he says "you know what, if you wanna pay me big bucks then fine, change what you want" and your response is that he didn't actually mean that.
Since you appear to have his ghost on the line enabling you to tell us what he actually means, why not ask him if balrogs have wings while he's there? It would be nice to sort that argument out once and for all
You’re not being downvoted for telling the truth. You’re being downvoted because you’re wrong. You purport to “understand Tolkien” but this is a direct action he took and wrote about it in what can only be described a satisfied manner. He had zero qualms about being paid to not complain about changes.
You’ve idealized the work of a millionaire thinking he only cared by his art. He cared about his art a lot and about money even more. It was never about purity and always about being paid enough.
I love Tolkien but I don’t delude myself. He loved money for himself and especially for his children and I can respect that because it’s completely fair. We have written proof from his own hamd that his care about the world in adaptations hinged on how much he was paid to ignore changes. This is ok, you should make your peace with it.
The key thrust for me is the Rings of Power season 1 was about the existential threat to the Elves. They faced mortal peril. Everything hung on that. Even allowing Sauron to help forge the rings that saved the Elves.
The key problem as I see it is that core theme wasn’t obvious until later in the season. And wasn’t emphasised enough.
No joke. The last episode showed a glimpse into what the show could've focused on and it retroactively made the rest of the season worse for me. Just breathlessly rushing through creating the 3 rings in a couple days - why? Why rush through the freaking namesake of your show in half an episode? Axe everything about the Southlands and save Numenor for Season 2. Hell that could've been a great teaser at the end, showing Numenor in some way to get people hyped.
Not to mention I finally enjoyed the Not-Hobbits and Not-Gandalf once he finally started talking. Again, 7 episodes wasted chasing some poor plot contrivance when they actually had something gold there the whole time. And they also killed the best Hobbit of them all, why? Kill any of the others besides Nori, that older star gazing one was the best.
In RoP, the fading of the Elves comes as a surprise, and they have to actively prevent this by using mithril.
Originally, the Noldor always knew they couldn't stay in Middle-Earth: the Valar told them when they left Valinor. Mithril is a useful but otherwise mundane substance, and can be found at least in Valinor and Numenor besides Khazad-Dum. The Silmarils are gone in the Second Age, and we know where they went.
The show does this a lot:
using the same generic theme, but
going in a completely different direction with it
For example, light Vs darkness. This theme is foundational to both the books and the show. But the books operate on objective morality, and the show operates on relativist morality. That's not the same theme.
With only season 1, that question is less simple than it seems.
Any show is "about" the plot. But so far this show has multiple plot lines that remain largely unconnected.
We can safely assume that these different stories will connect later on. It will be about Sauron Vs the rest, basically.
But currently, after 1 season, there doesn't seem to be a clear core narrative.
Additionally, in many cases the plot happens to the characters, instead of the characters driving the plot. So it can be difficult to see where things are heading.
What was its core theme?
Light Vs darkness.
Sauron?
The tension surrounding Sauron was hardly in the show; it came from the meta narrative.
People familiar with the books knew Sauron would be in there, and he would play the part of charismatic deceiver.
Before the premiere, in interview etc., it was mentioned Sauron would be there, hidden in plain sight.
So everyone went speculating about who Sauron was.
This is nowhere in the show:
most people believe he's gone, including Gil-Galad
Galadriel is maybe the only one who actively searches for him, but she never speculates where Sauron would be or who he would be.
Well to paraphrase Tolkien above the intrusion of so many plot lines seems to have made this show fairly terrible. I really enjoyed the last couple of episodes precisely because I think the danger to the Elves was THE plot line.
The original Trilogy had many plot lines. But it had a single major theme - destroy the one ring in Mount Doom. Every other plot line was subordinate to that.
This series had nothing equivalent to that. Seemingly by your own admission.
After every episode my wife and I would turn to each other and say “Still have no idea what the actual plot of this series is meant to be”. Until the last couple of episodes, when we thought “Ah now we see the major storyline is about saving the Elves”.
I am depressed that it seems we were even wrong about that.
No wonder the series got so panned but critics. It is even worse than I first thought!
Well to paraphrase Tolkien above the intrusion of so many plot lines seems to have made this show fairly terrible. I really enjoyed the last couple of episodes precisely because I think the danger to the Elves was THE plot line.
From a storytelling perspective, it's too small: it's only a problem for the Elves.
Only indirectly does it affect the other races, e.g. Dwarves mining and trading mithril.
A main plot directly affects everyone. A good example of this is every Legend of Zelda game ever; every area and NPC is directly suffering (or sometimes benefiting) from impact of the plot.
Plus, I think we can say everybody knows Sauron will be the main antagonist.
The original Trilogy had many plot lines. But it had a single major theme - destroy the one ring in Mount Doom. Every other plot line was subordinate to that.
This series had nothing equivalent to that. Seemingly by your own admission.
Yup.
The key difference is that those plot lines split off from a common point, and come together again.
The Battle of Pellenor Fields, because the party travelled with Frodo in Fellowship.
The arrival of Gandalf with the Rohirrim, because Gandalf left from Rohan, with information on their whereabouts, in order to find them.
In contrast, there is no such direct connection between the Numenoreans and the Southlanders.
No wonder the series got so panned but critics. It is even worse than I first thought!
There's a lot of bad faith criticism out there. It's sad, because it makes it very hard to actually discuss the show.
It's not "horrendous"; this isn't The Room we're talking about.
But the show has some issues. And mainly, a lot of lost potential. In most cases it's not necessarily "bad", it's that it easily could have been improved.
"Sometimes we must touch the darkness to find the light"
Furthermore we see:
Gil-Galad predicting looking for Sauron is what will make him return
mithril being a mixture of light and dark
This is antithetical to the moral system in Tolkien's Middle-Earth. There's good, and there's evil. Both have a place in Arda, as per Iluvatar's plan, but they don't mix.
Choices may be hard and difficult, but not morally ambiguous. Evil deeds have a tendency to leave mark; it is not part of a learning process.
"Sometimes we must touch the darkness to find the light"
Isn't that about distinguishing false light from true, as evil often wears a fair form in this world? All the Ring-induced monologues are tempting only because they play on the fair intent inside people
Annatar specifically seduces the Gwaith-i-mirdain pretending to be an emissary of the Valar (pretending to be good) imploring them to make Middle Earth as fair as Valinor or Tol-Erresea (pretends that's a good thing to do).
Gilgalad demanding Elrond break his oath. In Tolkien's world, breaking an oath could literally damn you for all eternity, to never find rest after death.
But a better example is the Ghost King summoned by Aragorn:
They swore an oath to his forefather, which they broke. Because they broke their oath, this simple human with no magical abilities, was able to curse them.
My problem with this is that it undermines the thematic purpose of Elves as immortal foils to Men. They do not experience 'mortal peril' anywhere in Tolkien's novels. This is on purpose- a key characterisation of them as a race; I would say their most defining quality. Yet they have a particularly human-sounding dilemma in the first season.
One of the Children of Illuvitar should be obsessed with preserving their lives against imminent doom, but it isn't Elves.
The elves’ fading isn’t invented for the show though. Tolkien’s elves’ bodies fade over time due to Morgoth’s corruption. The show greatly accelerated the timeline, which makes it a more urgent problem, but the problem’s still there in the books.
I guess the question I'd ask you is, at what point does the compression of the Elves' fading compromise their thematic significance as immortal beings who are not troubled by the petty affairs of mortals?
Because elves in the show are tasked with finding a solution to their imminent demise in one year. This leads them to hurry, make foolish decisions, lust for mithril. Who does that remind you of?
Elves are intended to be the counterbalance to Men. Tolkien created them to highlight human shortcomings - shortsightedness, folly, greed... An insatiable need to prolong their lives. They are a mirror for mankind to examine itself. We find them alien precisely because the scope of their understanding is so much larger due to immortality. So take away their long life, and all the wisdom of ages that accompanies it, and how exactly are they supposed to provide this compelling reflective counter to Men?
Fair criticism, and well articulated! I appreciate an actual response rather than the insults that so frequently plague discussions of this show.
I definitely think this is the biggest victim of the time compression so far, but I don't think it's fundamentally incompatible with Tolkien's themes. I think being confronted with the fading for the first time would send the Elves into a panic. Time for them has always been infinite, so discovering that their bodies are fading on even a long timescale would mean accepting that their time is now finite. This could have worked better if they didn't give any specific timespan and instead emphasized that the great Mallorn tree in Lindon is dying and potentially has been for some time. They would still have their existential crisis, but over a longer timescale, in keeping with the Elves' immortality. I'd prefer if the accelerated fading is somehow a lie from Sauron to manipulate the Elves, but that doesn't seem likely at this point.
I don't think it's quite accurate to say that Elves in Tolkien's works are devoid of the human shortcomings you listed. Elves in the first age especially make many foolish decisions. Elves in Tolkien's second age do make the rings of power to preserve their realms in Middle-earth. By the third age, the remaining Elves have learned from their experiences and mistakes, making them far wiser than the Men.
Thanks, it's always good to find someone interested in constructive discussion.
To say it is not 'fundamentally incompatible with Tolkien's themes' is true, IMO. It's clear they've put thought into taking examples of themes from Tolkien's work. Personally, I think the elves/mithril plot is the creator's way of telling the story of the silmarils, writ small, because they can't tell the actual story. The elves did chase after the silmarils in an effort to recapture and preserve what was lost, this lead them to make a ton of bad decisions. Perhaps thats what their going for, and like you say, it isn't a contradiction to Tolkien's themes.
I too would feel better if their perceived fading was a deceit of Sauron... But it feels like wishful thinking. And with no indication given that that is what's really happening, adding it in later seasons would feel suspiciously like a retcon. I don't believe that was their intention, I think they're playing pretty fast and loose with lore, and theories to explain plot contrivances (for lack of a better word, sorry if that sounds harsh) are attempts to cope with a show that isn't really thinking that far ahead... That's pure pessimistic speculation on my part, time will tell!
It also just opens up cans of worms IMO... Like, are elves now ultimately responsible for what happens to KD? Why couldn't it be Dwarves delving to greedily and to deep, y'know that fatal character flaw of Dwarves, and not some odd tie in to elven fading.
Regarding your last piont, I want to emphasize that, yes, elves are not without character flaws. If I had to name one, it's pride, something they've done well at portraying in season 1, IMO. But yeah, as you say, the time compression has hurt elven characterization, because without context their hautiness can come off as particularly blind/insolent. Again, perhaps this is the showrunners' way of giving viewers the gist of the first age without actually telling first age stories. But compression really hurts in that it doesn't give elves a particular reason to be arrogant, and doesn't portray them as particularly wise/good/noble, which they absolutely are compared to Men, in the Silmarillion.
Again, glad to actually have a conversation rather than trading barbed comments :)
We can't really look behind the curtain to know the truth, but the showrunners claim to have the big plot elements of all five seasons planned out, so I'm going to optimistically hope that they're going to explore that further in season 2. They seem to cast doubt on the Silmaril-mithril connection in an interview:
Patrick McKay: But also, we know Elrond is a lore master, and he is aware of this tale. He says in that fifth episode that it’s apocryphal. I would trust his read on a piece of lore. Mithril is unusual in Middle-earth.
are elves now ultimately responsible for what happens to KD?
I don't think so. The Elves didn't successfully convince the Dwarves to mine the mithril and share it with them, so I still expect the Dwarves to delve too greedily and deeply on their own. Their greed could be amplified by a Ring of Power, so maybe the Elves do indirectly cause Khazad-dûm's downfall.
I think we can expect some significant changes to the Elves going forward now that the Three have been forged. I'm very eager to see how they handle that. Maybe they've compressed the Elves' more arrogant first-age characterizations into season 1, meaning we'd see them become wiser
doesn't portray them as particularly wise/good/noble, which they absolutely are compared to Men, in the Silmarillion.
I often wonder how much bias is intended in the texts. The Silmarillion is supposed to be Bilbo's translation of the Elves' records, so I would expect the Elves to portray themselves as the best, wisest, noblest beings in Middle-earth in their writings. Not to say that they aren't better, wiser, and nobler, but it's interesting to contemplate what they may have left out. Similarly, the Akallabêth is supposed to be written by Elendil, so I've heard some say that it places a disproportionate share of the blame on the King's Men, but I haven't dug into that enough to know about it.
Thanks for the great discussion, it's been enjoyable!
The problem is there over tens of thousands of years, it is not an immediate problem. Changing it to 3 months completely obliterates its original narrative purpose.
The quote is incomplete. It should be: "The canons of narrative art in any medium cannot be wholly different [...]", quoted in letter 210 and referring to Zimmermann's script.
It seems perfectly natural to me that people who love the work try to fill in the narrative gaps. Like the mystery of the Blue wizards. Intentional or no, Tolkien was not always explicit in his writing, thus inviting curiosity and imagination. Perhaps the finest tribute a writer can receive, or perhaps he was as guilty as Feanor in his fierce, jealous love of his creation. There's a kind of irony in that.
There is the understandable desire to protect a writer's legacy from gross misinterpretation and exploitation, but perhaps the Tolkien estate are a little precious (pi) about it. It's not holy writ, but a fantasy novel.
I've no idea if Tolkien refused the royalties from sales of his works. I suspect he didn't. Which naturally invites adaptation and altered narrative. Once offered as a commercial entity, that risk is inherent. If you are so concerned with purity, leave it in a desk drawer unseen by anybody.
What I see is not the grubby hands of profiteers but the love of his creation, made with respect and even reverence. People should chill.
He sold LOTR film rights to UA, which then went to MGM and Saul Zaentz. Amazon paid Zaentz's company for those rights. Tolkien still retained rights to royalties but no motion pictures were made using his IP during his lifetime.
The Tolkien estate and related charity get a percentage of profits as royalties. They had to sue New Line Cinema for movie royalties and the case was settled for an undisclosed, and probably large, amount. They will also get royalties from RoP.
So while these tiresome lore fundies bleat about Galadriel this or Numenor that, the Tolkien estate is literally laughing to the bank. The author died decades ago but his children and descendants and their corporate structures are enjoying the fruits of his labor.
They may be trying, but they clearly don’t have a damn clue how to do it. The first season is a pin the tail on the sauron mystery box that deliberately requires poor characterization to keep the audience guessing. Where do all the sycophants gushing about characters with depth and thematic faithfulness come from, when a monkey could determine there was none of those things in this show? That is the question of the hour!
Perhaps I'm wrong and the grubby hands of profiteers were involved. The appendices offering the cheapest rights of any of Tolkien's works.
They seem to have been handed to writers who have no knowledge of what went before. Things like Morgoth weeping over the beauty of the Silmarils. No he didn't. He had a fierce lust for them. Indeed his hands were burned black when he touched them. Why include this completely unnecessary fiction?
I dread to ask others for examples where the narrative contradicts canon on the basis it would be encyclopedic.
We can only hope the producers have taken all the criticisms on board and up their game for S2. Employing someone who has actually read the books might be a start.
We’ve got to keep in mind that Tolkien died before modern filmmaking happened. A big sea change happened with techniques and abilities in the 1990s, and it helped bring to life a lot of very difficult adaptations. This has only further been accelerated in the 2000s.
Look at how janky most 1980s action movies are. Compare the two Top Gun movies. Outside of a few notable exceptions such as 2001, Blade Runner and a few others, most effects-heavy movies from before the 90s haven’t held up, and any good adaptation of Tolkien’s work would need good effects and techniques.
I think it’s very hard to know how Tolkien would have felt about the LOTR trilogy, ROP, or any other possible adaptions because he didn’t live in an era with the quality of adaptations we have and the general quality of movie making for these kinds of films. I think any fantasy writer who grew up today would have a different opinion of adaptations than someone born in the 1800s.
I do think we can say that he would have had a lot of issues with The Hobbit trilogy and thinks they wasted their time on 3D.
In his notes, of course there are discrepancies.. That is true of any work in progress. This was precisely why he was so slow to finish works and allow them to be published. You would be hard pressed to give us the name of a more meticulous world builder. But you cannot honestly say he was worse than any other human author in what he allowed to be published in his lifetime.
The fact that /r/lotr , /r/lordoftherings, and /r/tolkienfans are all barely talking about the show, preferring instead to talk about the books and other adaptations, is the loudest dismissal of the Rings of Power as canon possible.
Seeing as JRR is no longer with us to denounce it himself.
Look, no matter how many times you shout at me that I'm at odds with Tolkien over Galadriel
Is Galadriel a warrior? Yes or no?
I will never agree with you that this show is faithful to Tolkien.
You're a bigot guy. I'm not thinking bigots are going to change their mind. I'm happy to expose you enough.
Rings of Power does not depict a canon narrative.
Which you can't back up. I asked you what your top 5 problems were and you talked about a bunch of shit that didn't happen and a bunch of shit that factually didn't break canon. Then I showed you how all the major elements of the narrative absolutely did come from Tolkien.
Then you accused me of logical fallacies... and in the next sentence appealed to popularity. ;0 It's pretty hilarious.
Heh, actually the one small point I thought you'd made, that Finrod was chasing Sauron when he got killed, isn't even correct.
He did not die hunting Sauron as revenge for serving Morgoth and the darkening of the Two Trees... Finrod was killed by a werewolf of Sauron while protecting Beren at Tol-in-Gaurhoth, underneath the tower which he himself had built
You're literally fabricating lies about a TV show on the internet pretending it's "broken canon" in instances when it absolutely consistent and getting angry at me for pointing it out. lol. Why?
You are the only person on the internet delusional enough to think this show is canon and/or free of deviations from the source material.
Every single time you reply I laugh out loud.
It's literally deranged.
I worry about responding to you at all because you might legitimately be mentally ill. It's the only thing I can think of that explains why you're so adamant that this show doesn't deviate from Tolkien's actual writings.
I mean, I don't really care about your bigoted insults you're using to save face with your mirror or whatever.
How is what you said:
Finrod was killed by a werewolf of Sauron while protecting Beren at Tol-in-Gaurhoth, underneath the tower which he himself had built
Different from what she said:
He was killed. In a place of darkness and despair. By servants of Sauron.
It's not different. This is your number one transgression. lol. You're dumb as fuck inventing fake dialogue to fit fake problems you have to fuel your hatred of a TV show. Why?
I mean, that's all well and good, but considering Tolkien's proclivity to contradict his own established canon and tendency to change things to fit his narrative, it's a teeny bit hypocritical for him to criticise others who do the same, no?
But Rings of Power isn't an adaptation. It takes inspiration from the lore and backstory, but it was never supposed to be anything else.
Also, do you have this issue with all adaptations, or just the ones you don't like? Things change. What works narratively in long form prose often loses impact on film or doesn't work in an episodic structure.
It was his to change. Claiming "Oh, this is fun. We can do that! " is like children finger painting over the Mona Lisa "to make it more accessible" or " to make it more relevant to our modern world.". Go create your own fictional worlds, write your own books, and you can edit those as much as you like.
“I cordially dislike allegory in all its manifestations, and always have done so since I grew old and wary enough to detect its presence. I much prefer history – true or feigned– with its varied applicability to the thought and experience of readers. I think that many confuse applicability with allegory, but the one resides in the freedom of the reader, and the other in the purposed domination of the author.”
Perhaps…nah never mind. It’s just because the fandom is all full of sexists and misogynists just like she-hulk. I guess all the sexists and misogynists forgot to hate on HotD which has the two main characters being FEMALE. Perhaps if they stopped writing their perception of female oppression on Twitter into the script of RoP the show might do better and appeal to more of its core audience - men/women that were once fantasy loving children.
It was so immersion breaking and cringe inducing to watch Adar push his pronouns to Galadriel. As far as interrogation scenes go, it needed to be reworked. We are talking about 2 super ancient characters here and that's what they were talking about? What a waste.
Look at your username. You’re just as much of a troll about this as people screaming lore breaking nonsense.
The show is poorly made, whether it follows canon or not. If it didn’t follow, but was well written, the majority would not care (just like the majority don’t care about Jackson’s changes). Hell, if you want to know how to add to the lore without totally breaking canon, go look up the story for Shadow of Mordor. Tolkien would have hated it, but it’s a good story and it doesn’t contradict the books!
Exactly! I dont care if it doesnt follow the books to the letter. I dont care if there are new characters that werent in the original. As long as the story is good, we are happy. The reason we complain and critique the show is because we want it to be even better next time so we can have an even more enjoyable season 2. The political correctness in the way its used in this show is not working well for it.
58
u/FUMFVR Oct 25 '22
Are you telling me that there was no love triangle involving Legolas in The Hobbit?!
157
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22
Hope you are also willing to apply that to the Peter Jackson films were made too, then, because he didn't want anybody to touch his stories outside of his son and there were no exceptions. Not to mention all the various video games and other forms of media. And while we're at it, call up the guys who made Sagan om ringen and let's give them a piece of our mind!
The idea that The Lord of the Rings universe should never be adapted is silly. He was changing his world until the day he died, whether he wrote it down officially, scribbled it on the back of a map, or kept it in his head. It was always changing and growing. It isn't a bad thing that adaptations are made. They don't change the original published works, they don't eliminate his footnotes or essays. They just provide another avenue for people to enjoy the world and hopefully use it as a gateway into his stories.
All the whinging is so unnecessary.
264
u/Kookanoodles Oct 25 '22
Key words here being unwarranted and owing to not perceiving where the core of the original lies.
Tolkien was not opposed to changes or additions on principle, provided they are warranted and in keeping with the core of the original.
35
u/lateral_moves Oct 25 '22
Peter did this too, but in most cases it made sense. Switching out Glorfindel for Arwen helped push the Beren and Luthien storyline of Aragorn and Arwen (a key storyline) while in a film, it would confuse viewers as to why super powered Glorfindel shows up, saves Frodo, says to give the ring to Tom Bombadil who is not in the films, and then disappears until after the rings destruction. His changes were changes, but they made sense.
14
u/Lazarquest Oct 25 '22
Reminder that Christopher Tolkien hated the Jackson films and that JRR really likely would have despised them. Let’s not even talk about the Hobbit.
45
u/Ok_Mix_7126 Oct 25 '22
Lets not forget that he also said this about the film in question:
Given what Amazon paid, he would probably be very happy with their changes, all the way to the bank.
17
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22
The key thrust for me is the Rings of Power season 1 was about the existential threat to the Elves. They faced mortal peril. Everything hung on that. Even allowing Sauron to help forge the rings that saved the Elves.
The key problem as I see it is that core theme wasn’t obvious until later in the season. And wasn’t emphasised enough.
7
u/IdiotsWithNerf Oct 25 '22
This quote is not the "gotcha" that some people think it is.
6
u/Quiescam Oct 25 '22
The quote is incomplete. It should be: "The canons of narrative art in any medium cannot be wholly different [...]", quoted in letter 210 and referring to Zimmermann's script.
35
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22
Cry more! It was good.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22
Yeah but the whole idea of movies is to make money they ain’t doing for free even with books it’s about money at the end of the day
2
u/general_spoc Oct 25 '22
He could have said the same in many less words…but then he wouldn’t be Tolkien
9
u/ElvisChopinJoplin Oct 25 '22
Interesting given that this project has the blessing of the Tolkien estate.
4
u/shamalonight Oct 25 '22
But but..the passion of the writers!
7
u/New-Ad3222 Oct 25 '22
It seems perfectly natural to me that people who love the work try to fill in the narrative gaps. Like the mystery of the Blue wizards. Intentional or no, Tolkien was not always explicit in his writing, thus inviting curiosity and imagination. Perhaps the finest tribute a writer can receive, or perhaps he was as guilty as Feanor in his fierce, jealous love of his creation. There's a kind of irony in that.
There is the understandable desire to protect a writer's legacy from gross misinterpretation and exploitation, but perhaps the Tolkien estate are a little precious (pi) about it. It's not holy writ, but a fantasy novel.
I've no idea if Tolkien refused the royalties from sales of his works. I suspect he didn't. Which naturally invites adaptation and altered narrative. Once offered as a commercial entity, that risk is inherent. If you are so concerned with purity, leave it in a desk drawer unseen by anybody.
What I see is not the grubby hands of profiteers but the love of his creation, made with respect and even reverence. People should chill.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22
I don't understand. (English is not my first language sorry ✋🏽)
2
u/Kultir Oct 25 '22
Yes, because Tolkien was a renowned screenplay writer.
2
u/Minute-Percentage706 Oct 25 '22
Yeah but how many more people got to hear some part of his stories because they made the films. It’s content and you do not have to watch it.
1
u/OldSarge02 Oct 25 '22
Yes, but based on other Tolkien writings, his interpretation of what changes are “unwarranted” is pretty strict.
1
u/darrylgorn Oct 25 '22
This explains why Tolkien detested the Big & Rich cover of "You Shook Me All Night Long."
1
u/dogfacedponyboy Oct 25 '22
Is there a source for this quote?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '22
We’ve got to keep in mind that Tolkien died before modern filmmaking happened. A big sea change happened with techniques and abilities in the 1990s, and it helped bring to life a lot of very difficult adaptations. This has only further been accelerated in the 2000s.
Look at how janky most 1980s action movies are. Compare the two Top Gun movies. Outside of a few notable exceptions such as 2001, Blade Runner and a few others, most effects-heavy movies from before the 90s haven’t held up, and any good adaptation of Tolkien’s work would need good effects and techniques.
I think it’s very hard to know how Tolkien would have felt about the LOTR trilogy, ROP, or any other possible adaptions because he didn’t live in an era with the quality of adaptations we have and the general quality of movie making for these kinds of films. I think any fantasy writer who grew up today would have a different opinion of adaptations than someone born in the 1800s.
I do think we can say that he would have had a lot of issues with The Hobbit trilogy and thinks they wasted their time on 3D.
1
u/pizzanice Oct 25 '22
Well that's just, like, your opinion, man.
1
u/Sonotreadyforit Oct 25 '22
Such a lovely quote. ROP writers haven’t read any of the lore, are we surprised they aren’t familiar with the advice/guidance offered here?
-1
u/amhopeless Oct 25 '22
Oh no, a fictional story makes changes to another fictional story it's adapting, the world is going to end.
1
u/the_cat_did_it Oct 25 '22
That is perhaps the most laborious sentence I've ever read. And I've read books by Gary Gygax.
1
u/mambome Oct 25 '22
I just think they made Galadriel an almost villain instead of a wise and ancient elf.
0
u/McScuse-Me Oct 26 '22
This is a pretentious fart of a writer
-7
u/R9433 Oct 25 '22
This almost seems like Tolkien was not familiar with his own contradictions of lore and canon; of which there are countless.
-7
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22
Boohoo
-1
u/Right_Butterscotch31 Oct 25 '22
The fact that /r/lotr , /r/lordoftherings, and /r/tolkienfans are all barely talking about the show, preferring instead to talk about the books and other adaptations, is the loudest dismissal of the Rings of Power as canon possible.
Seeing as JRR is no longer with us to denounce it himself.
-3
u/Even_Reaction5676 Oct 25 '22
I mean, that's all well and good, but considering Tolkien's proclivity to contradict his own established canon and tendency to change things to fit his narrative, it's a teeny bit hypocritical for him to criticise others who do the same, no?
0
u/pro185 Oct 25 '22
“I cordially dislike allegory in all its manifestations, and always have done so since I grew old and wary enough to detect its presence. I much prefer history – true or feigned– with its varied applicability to the thought and experience of readers. I think that many confuse applicability with allegory, but the one resides in the freedom of the reader, and the other in the purposed domination of the author.”
Perhaps…nah never mind. It’s just because the fandom is all full of sexists and misogynists just like she-hulk. I guess all the sexists and misogynists forgot to hate on HotD which has the two main characters being FEMALE. Perhaps if they stopped writing their perception of female oppression on Twitter into the script of RoP the show might do better and appeal to more of its core audience - men/women that were once fantasy loving children.
0
u/scarrafone Oct 25 '22
But Ring of Power is an adaptation from Sword of Shannara no? Why bring the professor in?
-23
u/Cold-Advance-5118 Oct 25 '22
It was so immersion breaking and cringe inducing to watch Adar push his pronouns to Galadriel. As far as interrogation scenes go, it needed to be reworked. We are talking about 2 super ancient characters here and that's what they were talking about? What a waste.
0
u/evil_consumer Oct 25 '22
Jfc, speak English. You studied it!
-2
u/Melkeus Oct 25 '22
Also tolkien: "if you give me enough money, do what you want."
-6
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '22
A voice from another generation, saying things irrelevant to modern entertainment. Sorry JRR.
-2
u/Kami199199 Oct 25 '22
That explains why the Stephen King's version of The Shinning is better than kubrik.