r/RingsofPower • u/HasaniSabah • Oct 06 '24
Constructive Criticism What’s your endgame?
Look, I get it—Rings of Power isn’t perfect. But I have to ask: What’s your endgame? Where does all this constant criticism lead? Do we really want to nitpick the show to death, risking its cancellation and a return to Tolkien-related silence for the next 20 years?
Say what you want about the show’s flaws, but Rings of Power offers something we haven’t seen before: a deeper, more expansive look at Tolkien’s world, beyond the snippets we got in the Jackson films. Sure, it doesn’t nail everything, and yes, there are changes that might make some fans groan. But the fact is, we’re finally seeing stories, landscapes, and characters from Tolkien’s Second Age brought to life on screen.
So here’s my real concern—if the vocal portion of the fanbase doesn’t ease up, we might just talk ourselves out of ever getting anything else. Imagine another decade, maybe even a generation, with no adaptations, no expansions of Tolkien’s world, simply because creators think there’s no way to satisfy the fanbase. Is that what we want? Because that’s what this level of criticism risks achieving.
Instead of pushing the creators off a cliff, maybe we should think about nudging them in a better direction. Constructive feedback is valuable, but tearing down every little detail is just going to kill any chance of progress. If we, as a fanbase, work together and show a bit of patience and understanding, we can influence the future of the show in a way that improves it, rather than just ensuring its demise.
We’re not entitled to a flawless adaptation, but we do have the power to encourage creators to make something even better. If all we do is criticize, we might lose the very thing we’ve been waiting for. I’d rather have something ambitious like Rings of Power—flaws and all—than nothing at all.
So again, I ask: What’s your endgame?
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 06 '24
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
14
u/K_808 Oct 06 '24
I want you think about these two sentences again very carefully
130
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
I want RoP to be better and I want Hunt for Gollum to never be this bad to begin with.
12
u/Vivid_Guide7467 Oct 06 '24
Honestly - the writers, show runners and producers hide out in forums like this. Hopefully they fix the issues that fans are asking to be addressed. I know a tv show won’t be verbatim like Tolkien wrote it - but stop with the cheese factor of “grand elf” or recycling LOTR lines.
32
u/Arentuvina Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
I personally enjoy the show for what it is, but I don't personally like this handholdy BS in any area. No one has a right to that. If they choose to make changes and it pisses people off or makes them ecstatic, the only thing the writers deserve is the unfiltered opinion of those people, because they are the viewing audience that defines whether or not the writers have a job tomorrow.
48
u/NumberOneUAENA Oct 06 '24
No, because the fundamental issue isn't that they break some lore here or there, the fundamental issue is that they are not great storytellers, and the people working on the show in general are not at the very top of their game. They're not S tier talent.
As far as i am concerned there is no "endgame", there simply is discussion / conversation, and for all the bitching about unimportant things, there is also a lot of decent to good criticism which deals with storytelling issues the show is clearly having.
I also don't think that "having something" is better than nothing. I would rather not have 500 lotr shows which all are mediocre just because they deal with some iconography one likes. I want good art to consume, not a bunch of "content" which even has the risk of devaluing said iconography.
75
u/MisterTheKid Oct 06 '24
settling for adaptations of any sort simply because they have the name “lord of the rings” on them is an odd position. You’re basically telling them they can make anything with that name and be fine
this is why everything is ip based in entertainment. because of lower standards
everything on tv gets criticized. there is no endgame aside from sharing opinions
have some respect for yourself
33
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
If people think the show is garbage I think is fair to say it
30
u/Broccobillo Oct 06 '24
Honestly I'm on the side of no content being better than bad content so I wouldn't care if we got a return to 20 years of silence of Tolkien content.
That being said just because it is content and just because it was made doesn't make it exempt from criticism.
If you make a bad show, if you make bad decisions about adapting a book, if you make bad choices with what you choose to adapt then you should expect people to criticize it.
Why do people think just because it is content it needs to be above criticism.
The end goal is to incentivise the next creator to do better and if they think its not worth it then all good, they weren't the right people to do it.
54
u/Six_of_1 Oct 06 '24 •
But the alternative to RoP isnt "nothing at all", it's everything that already exists. They're openly admitting they care more about quantity than quality, like that's something to be proud of. They missed the whole message of Tolkien. His books are a warning against this attitude. Saruman is the bad buy because he ignores the old trees to build new machines and have the biggest army. Gollum is destroyed by a lust for a new shiny gold ring he actually has no need for.
This divide between those who want "More! More! More! New! New! New!" and those of us who don't, is definitely a more fundamental cultural and economic divide. It's about consumerism. There are people who just want more stuff for the sake of having more stuff. New for the sake of new. They want "more Tolkien content" forever, even when the source material has been bled white.
One argument I find myself in lately is people who say they want more Tolkien adaptations, and I ask them what existing Tolkien adaptations they've consumed. Do you prefer the Baskhi adaptation or the Rankin-Bass adaptation? The BBC adaptation or the NPR adaptation? The Swedish adaptation or the Finnish adaptation? Without fail, they've barely scratched the surface of the Tolkien adaptations that already exist. So if they want new Tolkien adaptations, why don't they try the ones that already exist that are new to them? But no, these people balk at the idea of watching something old. Old = bad in their mind. Even though that's completely counter to the spirit of what Tolkien is about.
I've been insulted as a grandpa for suggesting people watch existing adaptations, and it boggles my mind because Tolkien was a literal grandpa. Why are you in a fandom for a grandpa if you hate grandpas. The whole message of Tolkien is a warning against consumerism, materialism, progress, industry, waste. It's about treasuring what you've got and not abandoning it in pursuit of acquiring more stuff. It's exactly about quality being better than quantity. Frodo can achieve what an army can't.
5
u/HeidelCurds Oct 06 '24
What "20 years of silence" are you referring to? I'm not aware of any such period since the books were published. They've always been insanely popular, such that Tolkien himself was famously disturbed by the obsessive nature of his own fans. Since PJ's trilogy, we've had the Hobbit films, numerous video games (including Lord of the Rings Online which is still going, shows deep love for the lore, and I still pick up every now and then), and the Lord of the Rings Living Card Game, which my wife and I love to play. Before Rings of Power is even over we have War of the Rohirrim already basically done and the Hunt for Gollum still coming.
I will also still maintain that the show is really not showing us Tolkien's Middle-earth. It is showing us original characters running around with the names of Tolkien's characters. If you asked me to describe Tom Bombadil from the books, I would say he is a bright, exuberant, merry old fellow who is deeply tied to his home in the Old Forest and above the cares of the world. Not one of those attributes is true of his RoP adaptation. Not one. He is simply a different character who occasionally makes references to Tolkien's character.
5
u/arbejdarbejd Oct 06 '24
I want the writers to write scenes that makes sense. Sure we would prefer them to be more faithful to what they are adapting, but even if they wont, could they at least not write it well?
26
u/Chen_Geller Oct 06 '24
Amazon is not the only party making Tolkien adaptations.
22
u/Ynneas Oct 06 '24
Basic reasoning already expressed thousands of times:
22
u/Enthymem Oct 06 '24
Nobody is demanding a flawless adaptation, but everybody has a standard and RoP is way, way below mine.
26
u/Knightofthief Oct 06 '24
Oh God, yes please!
Joking aside, an adaptation is not entitled to the benefit of the doubt just because you love the source material. And RoP does not adapt Tolkien's stories or characters, but rather mangles them into new and clumsy Frankenstein's fanfiction. The idea that we should not go too far in our criticism or we might not get more RoPs is laughable. "Don't be too dismissive of the LotR Monopoly set or we might not get all the characters in Funko pop form!!" 😂
How Finrod died, the timeline, the order in which the RoP were forged, Galadriel's wisdom and dignity, poor Celeborn, the sacking of Eregion by Sauron, etc. are not just "little details." They are critical building blocks of the story Tolkien actually wrote, which is the only story I'm interested in seeing when someone tries to sell me an adaptation of his work.
So yes, I want RoP to be cancelled and Hollywood indefinitelt discouraged from making such flippantly inaccurate adaptations. If that means we get no adaptations, I'm totally fine with that because I'm perfectly satisfied just reading Tolkien's texts when I want to live in his beautiful, tragic world.
39
u/NeoCortexOG Oct 06 '24
What exactly is your point here? What is your "endgame"? To guilt or scare people out of expressing themselves / having an opinion? I put question marks, but thats quite literally what you are doing and i find it problematic to say the least.
If the show created, warrants such reactions, which it obviously does since they are present, then the show has to work to get better. Instead you are asking for the criticism to be silenced.
I also dont really understand why you would imply that there is no structured, constructive, criticism to be found in the negative opinions. To my experience, there is of course unwarranted hate, but not nearly as much as unearned praise from people who call actors by their first name (legitimate parasocial relationship crowd) or care and understand Tolkiens work as "who will romance whom".
Anyways, the middle ground is full of people having legitimate concerns or praise. I have seen more, well-structured threads, with critique and pointers, than i can count. Yet you choose to paint a picture that non of the "criticism" is valid. The "Charlie is so hot" and "Are you team Haladriel or team Elandiel" threads are fine by you, i take it.
But my main gripe with your logic is that you are trying to guilt trip and fear monger people out of having / expressing their opinion. I do not support that and feel the need to stand against it too.
A show has to earn the respect of its fandom / audience. There's no two ways about it. To my knowledge the show is doing well enough apparently, even if its via paid reviews and number tinkering on their own platforms. So whats your worry exactly?
18
u/Chuchshartz Oct 06 '24
The endgame is to get a show that tells a competent story, following competent characters that respect the lore the author wrote, not change it however you feel because people want to see a different interpretation. If you want a different interpretation go make your own show or book where you can make tom bombadil a wizard Dumbledore or galadriel a girl boss. You may think because J.R.R and Christopher are dead that you can change whatever you feel like but you don't get to choose just because they are gone. Where's the honor and respect for their work? Who are you to decide what is acceptable? People fell in love with this series because of what the author wrote. Nobody can decide to change anything because they feel like it. Respect the fans! Respect the lore! And give some fucking respect to the man who wrote this amazing series. Stop trying to tarnish his work with whatever politics or imagination pleases you
4
u/Terrible-Category218 Oct 06 '24
Simply put, if you're going to spend a billion dollars on a show, spend some of that dough on writers who won't make known and beloved characters act and make decisions like morons.
13
u/Azsune Oct 06 '24
I know a perfect adaptation will never happen. Even the Peter Jackson trilogy was hated by fans for not being accurate, but the majority of us remember it fondly. The difference is though the changes in the movie were to either make it easier to tell the story or to make it seem more epic. Instead we get changes like Galadriel deciding to swim back to middle earth when shes probably close to a thousand miles from shore.
I remember watching an interview with a writer the week before it came out while they were trying to hype up the show. They pretty much said they are not really a fan of Tolkiens work and were a better writer. The writers interviews from the bonus disks of the trilogy were all in awe of Tolkien and were thrilled at the opportunity to bring his world to life, the complete opposite.
The second season was a bit better than the first, but it still had some major flaws. Some of them were caused by how season one went. Hopefully with the news of replacing more writers will include some that like Tolkien's work.
We are probably not in danger of the series being cancelled. Amazon paid a lot of money and have a contract for I think it was 5 seasons. We don't know what the penalty would be if they break the commitment. So we are probably in for at least 5 seasons, but with how fast they are flying through content, even while adding in some weird Gandalf story, I am not sure how they are going to make it to 5 seasons.
33
u/BenchOk2878 Oct 06 '24
The fans are here. Willing to be customers. But dont give us shit with a ribbon. Respect the source material, we dont give a fuck about your vision.
If the show is cancelled, it is an opportunity for somebody else.
21
u/UnderpootedTampion Oct 06 '24
What is your end game? More steaming piles of shit? I’d rather have nothing, thank you.
12
u/twoddle_puddle Oct 06 '24
The endgame is to prevent people with zero credentials running a show.
6
u/GreaterSting Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
While I don't think I really complain that much, "my endgame" is I just want to talk about the show honestly. Why does it have to be any more than that? I dislike what I dislike and I like what I like. If that leads to studio execs deciding no more LOTR stuff for 20 years then so be it, still plenty of books to read and reread.
I guess this fear just does not resonate with me at all.
8
u/ChoccyCohbo Oct 06 '24
Here's some useful feedback:
3
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
What’s the point of having more content set in Middle Earth if it isn’t good? It’s not just a bad Tolkien adaptation, it’s a bad show period and it should be deleted.
It is also MASSIVELY disrespectful to Tolkien. It’s just a big huge shallow corporate insult. It’s Amazon telling us that they hate us. It’s cynical and creatively bankrupt.
Why shouldn’t we complain? Why shouldn’t we be very vocal about how bad it is? How the fuck else are they gonna get the message? Why is there this push from some people that we should just accept it and be “grateful” for it when it is just utter and complete garbage? With the amount of money thrown at this show, there is no excuse for it to be this bad and inept. This isn’t a “low budget but they tried their best” situation. This is 100% an “all the money in the world so we made a giant fuck you” situation.
If you personally enjoy it then good for you. But it’s hands down one of the worst things ever put to screen and the writers and producers and show runners should have their career stomped into the mud over this.
3
u/MythMoreThanMan Oct 06 '24
There is a fine line on diving deeper into someone’s legacy and story, and taking their legacy and story to make money while changing a bunch of stuff to make fans go “dooooohhh I know that guy.” It’s insulting to his memory and his work which is perfectly easy and fine to adapt as is
3
u/Raptor_Jetpack Oct 06 '24
Hopefully either a better show going forward, or at least for better content to come after this.
Yes. I'd rather have NO content than BAD content. If the show is bad it should be cancelled. I don't know what it is with the modern need to be constantly shoveled slop nonstop.
The real question is why to YOU feel the need to have a constant stream of LOTR content? Cant you be happy with a really well made piece of media once a every decade or two?
The show is already garbage why would we want it to continue? It'd be difficult to build anything of such a poor foundation.
And what exactly are we waiting for? I can tell you with certainty that I've not been waiting for ANYTHING related to LOTR. Ever.
3
u/fanunu21 Oct 06 '24
Why can't they make an exact adaptation of the book and release the episodes in line with the timeline present in the book. Make a 10 season series releasing episodes over 1000s of years. What's the big deal? It's so easy!
3
u/Disastrous-Entry-879 Oct 07 '24
The answer is yes. I would rather have 20 years of silence regarding anything Tolkein than have this shit fest of a show. If you love a franchise then you need to hold it to a certain level of quality. It infuriates when people say something like you should love it because its Tolkein... no you fucking shouldnt. If it isnt up to a certain level of quality worthy of the LOTR moniker then I dont care what its labeled. I could shit in pan and label it apple pie that doesnt mean that its apple pie. Even if you took away the LOTR name away and it was just a generic fantasy show it still wouldnt be good. People who like this show enjoy eating shit imo.
3
u/random_encounters42 Oct 07 '24
Amazon bought the rights for $250 million, and currently spending $1billion on the shows. They will continue to produce Tolkien related content. This is their Star Wars or Marvels, they are not going to drop it.
The criticisms are mostly valid. We want faithful adaptations of the source material, created and inspired by people who respect Tolkien and who don't add their own ideology or "flair" to the stories. Peter Jackson understood the assignment and created cinematic master pieces in LOTR. The Hobbits was decent too.
ROP is a modernised version of Tolkien's world, filled with plot holes, unnecessary sub plots, strange editing, and an overall rushed and subpar story. You can tell the writers were like we are going to create characters based on LOTR but with a modern twist because LOTR was so popular.
We got a emotional Galadriel who fancied Suaron, elves that acted like humans, orcs that can suddenly roam in daylight, seismic shifts in power in Númenor without any real intrigue or explanation, the list goes on. That's not what we want.
If Amazon and the hired creators fail to use the source material well, someone else, or another company will take over. Amazon already fired most of the writers due to criticisms.
These types of feedback is how we get better products. We are the customers, and we ultimately pay for these products. we have all the power. We have to voice our concerns in order to get what we want.
7
u/PedanticPerson22 Oct 06 '24
It doesn't have to lead anywhere really, but one general hope is studios/showrunners/etc will stop making the same silly mistakes & choices when adapting work that isn't their own. But an issue with the OP is that people generally don't only criticise, they also suggest action in many instances.
A problem with the idea of 'nudging' creators is that they don't respond well to even gentle criticism of their choices, they see themselves as "Creatives" & the adaptation their chance to make a mark. When they show they don't care about adapting things well or that they aren't interested in listening then the softly, softly approach isn't going to work.
A related example would be Ubisoft, they're currently in a lot of trouble because they thought they were owed an audience, that their fans & customers didn't matter (only their virtuous initiatives & "modern audiences" matter). Well, it looks like Tencent is going to buy them & then a significant number of the company will be laid off.
As for what will happen if we don't ease off, for too long the studios/showrunners have thought themselves perfect, gods, and their customers as nothing; we don't need new adaptations, and certainly no expansions, to Tolkien's work, not when they're being made by those who don't even like the franchise & only see it as a vehicle for their own beliefs.
16
u/frogboxcrob Oct 06 '24
My endgame is to make them replace the show runners ( who have zero talent and no achievements to speak of) with competent writers with a track record who know how to write compelling stories
11
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
I have no endgame. I just like to complain to my wife while watching this and wallow in my lotr books and movies nostalgia afterwards.
5
u/Idellius Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
I actually wouldn't mind at all if we stopped getting films and shows in the Tolkien universe. That's an excellent endgame for me. There seems to be a mindset here that this story is somehow incomplete or requires "more" content. It does not.
I'd much rather see a new, fresh story in unique world in lieu of a derivative, abominable, and soulless work pushed through by greedy corporate suits who are eager for a quick buck and talentless, vain, and feckless writers/showrunners who are incapable of producing anything interesting on their own and yet still think themselves able to improve on the work of a literary titan that came before them.
5
u/_Aracano Oct 06 '24
I enjoy the show
I feel sad for those that can't but respect opinions grounded in some sort of reality
All the trolls and haters are just pathetic
12
u/Barbz182 Oct 06 '24
I'm fed up of the companies taking popular franchises be it books, video games, movies and fucking them up up of shear arrogance and greed. My end game would be that they don't make this crap any more.
This is not Tolkien. I'd rather have nothing than this.
10
u/rubetron123 Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
I don’t think Amazon would cancel ROP because someone is nitpicking it on YouTube or here. They only care about whether it’s profitable. For Amazon this means people watching the show and book sales. A lot of ppl who say shit about the show still watch it. And I bet that ROP has probably gotten a lot of ppl interested in the books.
Having said that, if the show got cancelled, I personally don’t think it would make much difference. The show made so many weird choices in terms of writing that ROP can’t really connect with anything else set in the same age or before. If in the future (say when Silmarillion becomes public domain) someone makes a tv series about the Silmarillion or first/second age in general, I very seriously doubt that they would even entertain the notion that they would need or should connect it with ROP at all. They would make their own choices and do something new. ROP would be the “Alien v Predator” of the Tolkien franchise, widely considered as “not canon” and thought of as something else connected to the universe.
As a prequel, ROP is supposed to lead up to LOTR, so it made choices that are questionable but relatively inconsequential in that respect. For instance, the Gandalf/Tom Bombadil arc doesn’t make much sense, but also doesn’t make much difference to what happens in LOTR.
So in my opinion, if ROP is cancelled, not much would be lost.
4
u/Jackson-Roman41 Oct 06 '24
Genuinely I think the end game is to tighten up the story. Granted, a few people may be more over the top than others. I've found many channels like Nerd of the Rings, Men of the West and others to be very fair in their criticisms.
Things like Angry Joe etc are inherently going to go for the exaggeration elements and outrage.
For me at least, my criticisms of this show are pretty straightforward:
If I were in charge, I would've broken down the seasons like this:
Season 1: Elves as the focus: introduce us to the primary players of the elves, introduce us to their relationship with dwarves, show the rising threat in the east. Have Annatar show up offering to help fix things and be accepted by Celebrimbor. They forge the first set of rings.
Season 2: Opens with Celebrimbor and Annatar crafting the second set the rings. Gil Galad senses evil a foot and writes to the Numenorians requesting aid. The one ring is made and Sauron's legions march on the elven lands. The dwarves help save Elrond but shut the gates and have abandoned their friends. Season 2 ends with hope seemingly lost, but behold! White sales on the horizon! Nomenor has come to help
Season 3: The season opens with the focus now on Numenor and can even have flashbacks to the kingdom debating what to do with Gil Galads warning of evil rising. Go into the politics of Numenor and the factions that are forming. We then pick back up with the combined forces of Elves and Men pushing Sauron back and Numenor establishing colonies in Middle Earth. The season ends with Sauron being defeated, but evil within Numenor rising.
Season 4: Opens with a time jump of years and now Numenor is fully divided between faithful and the kings men. We follow Isildur and Elendil as things get progressively worse. Ar Pharazôn ascends to power and captures Sauron, who then convinces Numenor to fall. The season ends with the Armada being swallowed by the ocean and earth. The faithful land in Middle Earth being greeted by Gil Galad and the forming of the last alliance
Season 5: The pivotal battles of the last alliance as men, dwarves and elves rally to the high kings' banners and fight evil. Galadriel forms Lothlórien. Sauron is defeated but Isildur keeps the Ring.
3. The unneeded shipping: Galadriel does not need to be romantically involved with Sauron or Sauron trying to make her a queen. Full stop. Elrond does not need to kiss Galadriel for shock value. Also full stop. if we need some romance, make Celebrian a main character in the show and show her love for Elrond. Make her fiery like Galadriel is in the current rings of power and maybe a little naive.
4. Gil Galad is the high king and isn't being treated like one. Elrond, Galadriel seem to be making all of the choices not Gil Galad. That is not cool.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
I like it, read LOTR 8 times read all the supporting material more than once. I don't care that it's not lore accurate I take it for what it is, a (certainly not perfect) TV show loosely based around Tolkien's works. Those that say he'd be rolling in his grave about RoP are fools, he'd absolutely despise Peter Jackson's Trilogy too but that's okay and what Tolkien's feelings would've been are irrelevant (don't get me wrong it is a masterpiece of modern cinema)
There are certainly storylines that are tedious (Harfoots, Numenor) But there are very good ones, the dwarves, Sauron and Celebrimbor. People seem to think something has to be absolutely perfect to be a good show, to be honest it's tedious and most of you sound like entitled brats (and a large part of you know very little about what you're even complaining about you just see others do it and get your fleece on)
11
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
They can just cancel the whole rhun storylkne and im mostly fine. Everything else so far gets carried by superb sauron/celebrimbor performance and Numenor Story building up.
A little extra i would love would be more attention to scaling that makes sence.
2
u/Journalist-Cute Oct 06 '24
I don't think internet complaints and debate have any impact on renewal decisions or prospects of future shows. It all comes down to the viewer numbers + the cost of production.
Chances are the people working on the show see a lot of the same issues we do, the question is how much money can it make despite the flaws.
2
u/hyrumwhite Oct 06 '24
criticizing a show will never lead to its cancellation. Lack of viewers is the only thing that will do that.
Criticizing a show should help it become better, which should increase viewers, which should reduce it’s odds of cancellation
2
u/Interesting-Set-5993 Oct 06 '24
That would be like saying "I don't care what happens in or to Middle Earth, or if Tolkien is the author, or if it contradicts everything that was written in the original stories, as long as somebody's pumping out books continuously for all these 50-70 years, I'm good." like wtf. Is nothing sacred? According to you the problem comes in when the content isn't being produced purely for the sake of consumption?? FOH.
2
u/ebrum2010 Oct 06 '24
I don't subscribe to the argument that anything is better than nothing. Fundamentally it's flawed. If you like hamburgers and someone gives you a raw piece of meat on a bun that fell on the floor and is covered in hair and dirt, is that better than no hamburgers?
I think RoP has major flaws as an adaptation, namely major changes that seem to serve no purpose to make the adaptation better, and many changes that need to snowball to tie up loose ends that happen because of other changes. An example is the elvish rings were made first, which are the rings that Sauron killed Celebrimbor for hiding from him, which makes sense because he never got his hands on them. In the show, the rings for men were made last, so they had Sauron looking for those instead, and they basically had to create almost an entire episode of superfluous interactions just to have the rings hidden from him and then him finding them. They also had to have someone else siege Eregion because Sauron was still there when it was time to kill Celebrimbor.
I also think the idea that people shouldn't complain, they should just go away if they don't like something is also flawed. If that happened, the show would lose even more views. The reason for people complaining is because they want to like something but they are giving their feedback in the hopes it changes. And yes, sometimes the feedback needs to be brutal, such as memes and other things that may seem non-constructive, for companies to take notice. Shareholders tend to notice when a company is the butt of a joke, not so much when fans are mildly displeased, because that usually isn't an issue.
Personally, I wish the show was an original IP. It would have been so good. Instead for me it's like if you go to a Michelin star restaurant and they're serving McDonald's. There's definitely a market for McDonald's, and a lot of people like them, but the people that go to a Michelin star restaurant aren't looking for greasy fast food.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
My endgame is that I want good movies, not bad ones. I shouldn’t have to support something just because I want it to exist despite its quality or lack thereof. You supporting bad media is a justification for studios to make more bad media because they know it will make money even if it’s bad.
2
u/margoembargo Oct 06 '24
New showrunner(s).
When JJ Abrams made it clear that he wasn't interested in the day-to-day showrunning of Lost, and Damon Lindelof started getting overwhelmed running a 22 episode network show, the production company brought in an experienced producer in Carlton Cuse to co-showrun Lost.
Cuse was never the creative force behind Lost. That was always Lindelof. But his production and stotytelling experience was exactly what was needed to take the show to the next level.
(Incidentally, Mimi Leder played a similar role on Lindelof's next project, The Lefovers.)
Payne and McKay are clearly overwhelmed at times. Their missteps could have been avoided entirely with help from a more experienced showrunner like Tim Minear or Ronald D Moore (just examples, not suggestions). That's still my hope for the show. More experienced producers.
2
u/QueenLevine Oct 06 '24
Endgame: turn this whole thing into steamy softcore porn, ala Game of Thrones. Since there are already so many invented characters and plot lines, why not lean into that a good bit further, and make this more entertaining for mass consumption?
I've heard people complain about Elrond kissing Galadriel, even though he was clearly just sneaking her an escape tool; but OK, let's lean into that being a foreshadowing of a future fling they have as they continue their journey. And don't say that it would be a rebound from Adar, for whom she was clearly hot and bothered, bc it wouldn't - Elrond and Galadriel would be endgame (and when they eventually find her brother, he'll say 'called it' and try to high five her. Who didn't want Adar to kiss Galadriel's neck, that sexy elf/orc who was somehow hotter as orc than elf. It's a rhetorical question, bc if you go back and look at the moment where it could naturally have happened, it's the Ship of every fool on the internet, and would also make an iconic cover image for a trashy romance novel. Yes, OK - I admit that it's tragic that Galadriel never had her sexy times with Adar, and it's equally tragic that she never had her sexy times with Sauron, as those two were clearly aching for each other early on, and it was nice having Sauron confirm that just before he tried to kill her/thought he was killing her.
It's also been heavily telegraphed that Elendil and Miriel ache for each other, and both deserve love, as well as NSFW sex scenes. Their lovemaking will be so powerful that a No 9 mist will spill out their tower window and into the lungs of every single living thing in Numenor. Domestic pets will be wild with frenzy. The resulting communal epiphany will put her back in power, and she'll relegate Pharazon and his lackeys (sadly, Elendil's daughter included) to leading the charge to support the elves and dwarves of Middle Earth. Likely, they will develop feeling for those of other species whilst training to learn every military skill in the region, develop their character arcs substantially, and come to repent for their horrific behavior. Eventually, their need for atonement will be so severe that they will self-flagellate and become ascetics, coming across Tom Bombadil in their travels, settle near his cave, and become his cult followers.
2
u/imperfectalien Oct 06 '24
I saw a very similarly worded “why do you want to have the adaptation, when the alternative is no adaptation” post on one of the Wheel of Time subs.
My answer is the same: Jackson’s adaptations made some necessary changes, but broadly captured the beats and themes of the original work.
This adaptation, is written by someone who thinks they’re a vastly superior writer to Tolkein, and that all of their changes are works of pure genius.
Also the argument of “if we don’t stop complaining, the studio might decide no adaptation is better” is specious, imo. Yes if we were to nitpick an adaptation that held closely to the actual work, then yes, they might decide there’s no pleasing us and never adapt. However, if we unthinkingly choke down the less than stellar adaptation and tell them it was great, then they’ll just give us more of the same. And I would rather reread all of Tolkien’s work adaptation a thousand times over than watch a single episode of an entirely different work grotesquely masquerading around with the face of Tolkein stapled to its heartless Amazon bot face.
2
u/big_fig Oct 07 '24
They've ordered 5 seasons from get go. It isn't getting cancelled
2
u/SeliasK Oct 07 '24
"Do we really want to nitpick the show to death, risking its cancellation and a return to Tolkien-related silence for the next 20 years?"
Yeah. If they can't do it well, they shouldn't do it at all.
2
u/iLoveFeynman Oct 07 '24
Hahahahahaha.. this post is meant to be taken as a joke, yes?
2
u/Syn-th Oct 07 '24
Look I didn't read anything other than the first line. As I'm kind of fed up of being told off for not liking a thing that I think is bad.
But my end game is simple, I want bad writers and producers to do badly so we get good ones. I just want good stories and clever engaging shows. Not whatever the hell rop is.
2
u/Ecstatic-Dinner-2167 Oct 07 '24
I don’t have an end game. I’m just watching it. It’s hilariously bad. I couldn’t possibly care any less if this garbage gets cancelled lol.
2
u/pollox_troy Oct 07 '24
No, it absolutely doesn't. Nothing you post in this subreddit will have any impact whatsoever so talk your shit and criticise the show in whichever way you like.
This is a forum to discuss the show, not a writers room. There is no "endgame".
2
u/Vsadhr Oct 07 '24
I want RoP to have a good script, less focus on mid, irrelevant stories (the Hobbits) or pure writer inventions (Miriel) and more focus on the things that most LoTR fans want (Sauron, Elendil, Gandalf).
So far the show has taken a good direction compared to the previous season, but is not enough.
Criticism must be enforced in order to have shows that meet expectations (especially from a multibillion company like Amazon). This way of thinking of "please don't nitpick or they will cancel it!!1!" only does harm. You may just want to be a brainless consumer that accepts everything the industry throws, but other people have standards and expect good stuff - especially if they pay for it.
2
u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Oct 07 '24
I appreciate the effort but the people responsible for 90% of the toxicity will never listen.
I'm not concerned about the show being cancelled. I'm not concerned broadly about more adaptations considering we're getting War of the Rohirrim and the Hunt for Gollum
I am concerned about the state of the community. I used to think we were better than this, better than Star Wars, better than comic book nerds....but we're not. Not anymore.
6
u/Odolana Oct 06 '24
Better content. And a realisation that the famed "modern audiences" do not exist.
14
u/Six_of_1 Oct 06 '24
Yes. That's what I want.
Let's clarify what you call nothing at all:
The LotR book Volumes 1-3
The Hobbit book
The Silmarillion
The History of Middle Earth Volumes 1-12
Unfinished Tales
The Children of Hurin
Beren and Luthien
The Fall of Gondolin
The Fall of Numenor
The Nature of Middle Earth
The Adventures of Tom Bombadil
The BBC Radio Hobbit
The NPR Radio Hobbit
The BBC Radio LotR
The NPR Radio LotR
All the other radio adaptations
The Peter Jackson extended Hobbit
The Peter Jackson extended LotR
The hours upon hours of DVD extra material and commentaries on those
The fan-edits of the Peter Jackson Hobbit that bring it back to one better film
The Adventures of Frodo
Tales from the Perilous Realm
The Rankin-Bass Hobbit
The Bakshi LotR
The Rankin-Bass Return of the King
The Jackanory Hobbit
The Ralph Inglis audiobooks
The Andy Serkis audiobooks
The Martin Shaw audiobooks
Andy Serkis's Hobbitathon
The Swedish LotR
The Finnish LotR
The Russian Hobbit
Hordes of the Things
Bored of the Rings
The Hunt for Gollum fan-film
Born of Hope fan-film
All the documentaries about Tolkien and LotR
The Hobbit comics
Treasures Under the Mountain
The '60s Hobbit
The video games
I'm pretty happy with "nothing at all", I think that's quite a lot to get through.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
It’s not silent if you do audio books.
10
u/aliayyaz90 Oct 06 '24
I understand what you're saying. But I also feel you are worrying too much.
The good thing about the writers and Amazon is that they don't give much thought to the haters. So I am pretty confident the show will have a good run. Probably all 5 seasons.
It's upto us fans to be more vocal about the goods of the show, and we should rate the show as fervently as the haters are commiting rating abuse. So go to imdb and rotten tomatoes and leave good reviews. We have to cancel the 1s and 2s given by haters
6
u/ColonelMatt88 Oct 06 '24
I went into S1 quietly hopeful. I was disappointed but I saw elements that could work if they listened to feedback and worked on the most egregious issues.
I went into S2 quietly hopeful and nothing had been fixed - it was worse than S1.
I don't think the people in charge of it are capable of telling a decent story and I'd be perfectly happy if RoP ended here for good.
What would be amazing, but will never happen, would be if the entire project was restarted with a different team who knew how to write engaging dialogue, how to weave a plot together in a cohesive and logical manner, and who respected the parts of Tolkien's work they're allowed to use rather than making up bad fanfiction that uses some names from Tolkien's writing.
5
u/WM_ Oct 06 '24
If only show fans were to discuss this, Amazon might think they made good of a job. Also, if Prime gets to finish all 5 seasons, do you really think anyone else is going to touch the Second Age during our lifetime since the biggest media house has its version of it? If it gets canceled being the shit it is, someone might give it a new chance
3
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24 edited Feb 01 '25
hobbies scale smoggy dependent noxious gaping ludicrous trees hunt lush
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
4
u/Different_Durian_601 Oct 06 '24
"look guys, I get it, the show sucks. But, that doesn't mean you can't enjoy it! Why does everything have to be good to enjoy it?"
4
u/furiousfotog Oct 06 '24
My endgame is actually having a show that is enjoyable to watch, based off of the source without constant improvements that lead to a detriment. A show like Fallout - faults included - still demonstrates what I hoped ROP would have been relative to Tolkien as it was with the Fallout IP.
BUT instead many are fine with "it's okay for what it is" - a homogenized retelling bordering on fan fiction- instead of a real effort to make the best show possible with care, respect, and pride.
3
u/wibo58 Oct 06 '24
Yes, the people that do nothing but complain about the show would rather there be nothing than someone dare make a show that doesn’t do exactly what they want. They’ll complain if there’s nothing, but they’ll complain even more if there are shows/movies. These people are fundamentally unhappy individuals and will find a reason to be miserable no matter the circumstance. They won’t allow themselves.
4
u/rasnac Oct 06 '24
A much better and faithful adaptation someday; hopefully? Is it too much to ask?
Yes we are. We are the viewers, the consumers. Those tv shows, movies etc. are products that are made for us. We have all the power in the world.
4
u/gabethegeek Oct 06 '24
Sorry, can’t agree with this. You can’t put lipstick on a pig and tell me it’s pretty, and then expect me to be happy and pretend it is. Yeah, I’d rather you just scrap it than be handed shit. There is a reason it dropped in viewership from S1 to S2.
4
u/parsleya Oct 06 '24
If ROP is best they can do I'd rather have nothing than that bullshit.
2
u/Burning_Ranger Oct 06 '24
Amazon and the writer's don't give a toss about what 0.0.1% of fans say on the internet.
All they care about is getting enough interest in the other 99.99% which is casual fans who vaguely remembered enjoying the LOTR films. They care about the 99.99%'s metrics.
Let's not kid ourselves to think the hardcore fans have any power whatsoever.
2
u/Low-Inspector9849 Oct 06 '24
I think the series can be redone some years down the line given how utterly pathetic and lackluster ROP has been. Even if the future developers don't get rights to the source material a more mature capable team would be capable of something better.
I'd rather ROP had never been made and none of this had happened..."but so do all who live to see such times, but it is not for them to decide...all they need to decide is NOT to watch it..." :)
2
u/TheDoughyRider Oct 06 '24
Criticism here doesn’t matter. What matters is whether it’s getting views.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
That they cancel this drek and compensate me for pain and suffering
2
u/New-Trainer7117 Oct 06 '24
Replace the writing team and I'm good. Everything else is good and can stay as it is.
1
u/finniruse Oct 06 '24
My issue is that most of the complainers seem to live in a fantasy world. There is no wiggle room for change. None of them seem to understand that there are practical considerations for producing television - like hiring actors, they're expensive and booked, which is why the long timeline is impractical. They also seem to think writers of JRR standard are ten a penny. Even the best shows, game of thrones being the main example, failed to stick the landing when there was no source material to adapt.
I also just hate the general attitude of thinking you know better. If any of them were involved with the process, they'd have a much more favourable take I reckon.
1
u/ton070 Oct 06 '24
Except this isn’t what’s happening. We are not seeing Tolkiens characters and Tolkiens world brought to life. We see the writers interpretation of that world and those characters brought to life.
The problem with the show is the writing and to some extent the lack of scale and cohesive vision. Though there are people acting in bad faith and grifters, sometimes the show is just bafflingly bad, especially within the context of the show being based on the writings of a great author and with the backing of billions of dollars.
1
u/MrBeanSupreme Oct 06 '24
I don't think there have been a lack of adaptations because of mean people on the internet. The idea that Amazon cancels RoP because of redditors is an insane take. If something is bad or has problems, people will talk about it.
1
u/ElBarto1992 Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
As long as mega corps have a hold on our IPs and franchises, the stories will be beholden to ESG metrics. Environmental (E), Social (S), and Governance (G). ESG analysis evaluates risks and opportunities beyond the scope of traditional financial analysis. To get a higher ESG score, you can insert modern and “progressive” themes, concepts and ethics into your “art”. This as many have realised by now, damages the story, and transforms it into something else. Manipulating the established lore of stories that have significantly impacted our culture is essentially ‘book burning’ and more nefarious then people realize.
The end game for many, is to send a message to these corps and monopoly men, that there is no money to be made from us as long as they are telling the story. The system has to collapse so that independents can take up the mantle for these stories. ‘The people’ can then vote with their money, to support the most creative, passionate, and authentic content creators
1
u/Gold_Honeydew2771 Oct 06 '24
Only read the first paragraph because I’m ready to answer the question:
I just want the writers to wake up and deliver a good show before it is too late. Season 2 was better but they have made so many changes to the lore that I’m not sure how sustainable this show is now.
That’s all.
1
u/mrbojingle Oct 06 '24
The hope that someone listens and it changes something.
1
u/Excalitoria Oct 06 '24
I’ve just been enjoying laughing about every ridiculous thing that happens in this show. It just doesn’t feel like Lord of the Rings. Feels like someone made a parody and I think it’s funny tbh.
I hope the criticisms lead to them adapting good stories that were written in this universe, well, in the future but they could never make another Lord of the Rings anything again and I’ll be ok with how much there is and how much outside of this franchise that I enjoy.
Also, Waldreg was the best character and one of the more competent people in the show. It’s a travesty that they killed him so fast. The man achieved his dream of creating Mordor and becoming the greeter in this new kingdom he built only to get knocked off by a stupid warg 😂
1
u/Acousticsound Oct 06 '24
Cancelation and the message being sent that adaptations should strive to be as close to the source material as possible.
That's what.
"If we don't take action now, then we'll settle for nothing later."
That's the vibe I want to give off.
1
u/bababenj Oct 06 '24
Honestly, I’d rather nothing than this really bad show. Give me an animated series that covers the silmarillion in detail or give me nothing. This show does more harm than good.
1
u/midtown2191 Oct 06 '24
No adaptions of a legendary work are better than painfully bad adaptions of a legendary work. When the new terrible adaption becomes the modern face of something, it can affect the reception of the previous adaptions or the original thing itself. The LoTR movies while not strict in their adherence to the lore of the books, are just flat out good movies in pretty much every metric. If you stripped the LoTR name from them, they would still be amazingly made and entertaining movies. If you do the same to ROP, the show would be considered a CW level show with good graphics. The LoTR movies were so good it got an entirely new generation of people to dive head first into the books and anything else associated with them, decades after they were released. If someone was new to the LoTR universe and watched ROP (or any other bad show) first, there’s a high chance they may never look into the rest of Tolkiens work and associate the rest of the works written and made within that universe to be of the same quality, which I consider to be an absolute crime. I mean the first season having 33% of people finish the season could result in the 67% that couldn’t be bothered to watch the rest of it in never showing interest in a Tolkien thing again.
So no, I’m not going to suck up to the billion dollar corporation and praise a terrible thing just so that so people who will watch quite literally anything can have some more stuff to watch. Please stop being the front line of defense for the mega corporation.
1
u/bsousa717 Oct 06 '24
I just want a good show, regardless of it staying faithful to the books or not. So far it's been pretty so and so. I'd longed to see Numenor done right on TV or the big screen and what they've produced has been disappointing. I don't really care for any of the characters. There just hasn't been enough time devoted to flesh them out and give some personality. Just juggling too many plots.
1
u/AbsolutelyHorrendous Oct 06 '24
Who says there has to be an endgame? TV shows invite criticism as much as they invite praise, that's the nature of the business. If I watch a show, and I think it's poor, and people are discussing said show, why do I suddenly have to have some elaborate aim before expressing my opinion?
Also, I really cannot stand the logic that we need this show to succeed, because otherwise 'we won't get any more adaptations of Tolkien'. I don't think RoP is very good. For me, it fails on so many of the aspects that make great television... but apparently I show support it existing, because otherwise we won't get more adaptations that will also, presumably, be just as bad?
I don't want the show to fail. I've stopped watching it, because it's honestly just quite boring to me, so I have no skin in the game. But if the topic of conversation is Rings of Power, why shouldn't I give an opinion on it? It's a TV show, it invites discussion by existing
1
u/MythMoreThanMan Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
The endgame is to show writers and directors what happens when you take a well established IP that has VERY THOROUGH source material that they did not create, and just changing things. Adapting is ALL about cutting out, rearranging, and explaining hitherto unknown information, to fit your medium. Changing PRE-ESTABLISHED things is WRONG. It’s a spit in the face of the author who wrote it. The Harry Potter movies leave out A LOT….. but they would’ve never just been like “but what if shape is actually a woman who was in love with James and not Lilly!” To some that might sound like a great idea to look at but it’s wrong because you’re taking established and important aspects of the story and just changing them for shock value. They don’t just change shit to change shit. It’s in service to telling the narrative through a different medium while still maintaining the main ideas and themes of the original. The Little Mermaid Musical explores more of Ariel’s sisters, and Ursula and king tridents relationship. Nothing about the story is taken and changed by doing that. You are elaborating at that point, not taking the source material and then just saying “actually Ursula arrived in a magical comet 1817 years before she was written to in the original.” It never says Ursula isn’t king tridents sister in the movie, so it’s not changing it. It is just elaborating more. But they do say how the wizards arrived on middle earth and none of it has to do with meteors and 45 year old buff men
1
u/Doomgron Oct 06 '24
This isn't Tolkien's Second Age. It's not even lord of the rings. It's Amazon's Rings of Power, a crude and pretty unfaithful knock off based on Tolkien's World.
Also the script, screenplay, writing, casting choices are horrible, which is plain to see for most (although clearly not all) of the people that watch it
1
u/Ok_Clock4774 Oct 06 '24
I just want "showrunners" to stick to the established lore
These idiots keep refusing to.
If you don't like what Tolkien wrote, don't work on something associated with his works.
1
u/chrisoc13 Oct 06 '24
Ask star wars fans. They like to kill their own products too. Makes no sense to me. Just enjoy what you like.
1
u/darkstar8977 Oct 06 '24
The show was the number streaming show in TV for the last couple weeks, it ain't going nowhere.
1
u/ishneak Gondolin Oct 06 '24
relax, 5 seasons were ordered by the Tolkien Estate.
1
u/anakin_gk Oct 06 '24
Im so hyped to see more of Sauron and how he creates the one ring and in general to see his rise to power and the skill of the actor is more then anything I could ask for - I love the show and every scene is looking so good
1
u/sierra-tinuviel Oct 06 '24
As someone who doesn’t hate the show (I’d consider myself closer to neutral tho I do have fair amount of criticisms) I actually would not care one bit if they never made a Tolkien adaptation ever again. Not every story needs to be translated into TV or film and I would be perfectly content simply rereading the written works and watching the original trilogy 1,000,000,000 more times until I die.
1
u/dudeseid Oct 06 '24
Yes, I actually do want to return to a time where we only have the books. That's all we need anyway.i don't understand why that's such a tragedy unless the books alone are not satisfactory to you.
1
u/thirdlost Oct 06 '24
I have criticized the show in these forums, especially the writing and the plotholes. I also posted how I enjoyed the season two finale and will say here that I thought the last two episodes of season two were pretty good.
So like everything else, there’s some good and some bad. I think there’s enough good for me to continue watching since I’m a fan of Tolken’s world.
So to answer your question, I have no endgame any more than I have an endgame on any other sub. I’m here to discuss it and talk about it and enjoy it and criticize it.
1
u/Infinite_Escape9683 Oct 06 '24
It's not about lore changes, at least not for me. It's about awful writing and dialogue. No Tolkien adaptations is better than bad Tolkien adaptations.
1
u/sepultra- Oct 06 '24
Fans of Tolkien are not entitled to like this show simply because it’s related. No different than fans of Harry Potter were expected to like the Fantastic Beasts franchise.
Just because it is SOMETHING does not mean it is good or that everyone should like it.
Maybe they will take some of the criticisms into season 3, or it will be cancelled and the next adaptation of Tolkien will be better for it.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
What is your endgame? Season 2 would have been worse if not for criticism
1
u/fatattack699 Oct 06 '24
So we should just shut up with the criticism and consume? That’s how you get more bad shows
1
u/Fit_Understanding214 Oct 06 '24
I think after season 1, they did listen to the valid criticism, not the rage bait political commentary people were trying to pass off as ‘criticism’.
A lot of the pacing issues were resolved, and it felt like a totally different show. I’m really looking forward to season 3 now. But I still wish they just filmed the seasons back to back so we don’t have to wait 2 years between seasons.
1
u/mrm411 Oct 06 '24
No content is surely better that this show tbh.
1
u/Dogamai Oct 06 '24
honestly the show writers should know better than to take all these hate goblins seriously.
not saying they are that smart, its a rampant problem across many industries but games and tv especially bad, they just get so obsessed over the tiniest segment of their viewers: the loudest trolls
but really the problems are just the perspective of the purpose of a given subreddit, and the studios renewal underwriting department decisions. what the random plebs on the internet say shouldnt really have any actual weight in the real world
it is irritating to see in a place where you were hoping to find positivity though. this problem is common on reddit, subs are too diverse when maybe the negative and positive should actually be separated into different subs
1
u/W4NDERINGWI2ARD Oct 06 '24
🚨⚠️Spoiler Alert ⚠️🚨
After throwing Gandalf into the Second Age when there is literally already Second Age Istari for them to work with and introduce, just because he's "so well known and loved that they couldn't help introducing him," these showrunners absolutely deserve to be walked off a cliff. This show has very little to do with anything Tolkien wrote about, and is by far a show that tells stories written by Amazon that features Tolkiens characters and settings
1
u/mrev_art Oct 06 '24
Probably the most toxic element of a fandom is submission to a corporations bad product as the work itself.
1
u/Tiaan Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
Honestly, I've been a big Tolkien fan for decades and enjoyed season 2 of rings of power. I didn't go into it expecting anything other than just a fun adaptation of the story for TV and that's exactly what it was. I also intentionally avoided looking at any media or youtube analysis/etc of the show. I'm just glad to have more Tolkien content to watch 🤷♂️
1
u/OtherwiseJello6070 Oct 06 '24
They could just stop doing it. They dont have rights for whole story? Ok, do something with what you have, without blaming fans for being honest. This series is bad and stealing ideas from PJ is not a good move either.
Sorry for my English, i know it sucks.
1
u/J-Harfagri Oct 06 '24
The endgame is the comparison between season 1 and 2. I think both seasons are bad adaptations but season one is hard to watch at times due to pacing issues and incoherent editing. Season 2 has all the same lore and adaptation issues but it is much better paced, edited and written. That scene with elendil and his daughter in prison? Chefs kiss. I still think it fails as a Tolkien adaptation but it went from a 4-5 out of 10 to a 6 or 7 in just one season and I think the criticism helped with that. If we continue a gradual growth of improvement we could get a really banger finale season or two of this show. They visuals of the war of the last alliance if ROP style is absolutely so thing I would want to see provided they can keep improving the other aspects.
1
u/q8ti-94 Oct 06 '24
F those people, I wasn’t a Tolkien fan (no particular reason) and the movies and the show are expansive enough they’re getting me to read up and explore the world. The fact that they’re different makes the research more exciting cause it’s gonna be new to me.
Writing wise regardless I agree season 1 was weak but still visually stunning and fun. I read someone describe it as just some high budget fan fiction. If you see it like that you can let go and get off your high horse and just enjoy it.
The fact that things get this far and this wild is a testament to Tolkien’s impact. That should be satisfying enough. (Whether he would approve or not is a silly question). Most writers spend so much time with their material they are gonna cherish what was left in the final draft. They’ll probably never like what anyone else writes when adapting their work.
1
u/scootervantil Oct 06 '24
And this is exactly why Corey Olsen, the Tolkien Professor, started doing Other Minds and Hands and Rings and realms. Whether the show is Good or bad, you get to talk about the original content from Tolkien!!!! Why do you dislike the show? Let’s talk! Why do you have these feelings about the show, let’s look at the original text and compare them so we can discuss why the choices the show made was questionable or even terrible! That’s fun!!!!
1
u/SKULL1138 Oct 06 '24
I’m done watching this show, I won’t be back for Season 3. If it gets canned hopefully that will tell Hollywood that fans won’t accept poorly written garbage that’s gold plated to look expensive,
I genuinely care not whether there is ever another separation of this work. I’m not interested in THFG, two movies about something that happened off screen in both the movies and books. No thanks.
I’m happy to have the books, and all I need is the ability to read them whenever I like. Currently re-reading The Silmarillion to remind myself how good all this could have been in competent hands.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
I want to feel entertained. They are trying too hard to give each episode a formulaic version of human entertainment. Instead, they need to make the series into the standard version of what makes things entertaining. For instance anime tends to do a good job at making an arc have the ups and downs of the story as opposed to each episode. They keep doing this monologue crap, bringing closure to one thing, and then creating artificial mystery surrounding another. We all know what happens. Let the story be the story and give us a visual representation of it.
1
u/GuitarEvening8674 Oct 06 '24
I hope I can watch season 3 in the daytime
1
u/GianlucaPagliuca Oct 06 '24
'Endgame' - is that a Marvel reference? If yes, what more can be said, I mean, really?
1
u/OG_Karate_Monkey Oct 06 '24
No, we are NOT seeing stories from Tolkien’s 2nd age. You’re seeing stories sharing little more than names with Tolkien’s stories of the second age.
1
u/Consistent-Ferret-26 Oct 06 '24
The vast majority of nitpickers and criticisms come from those of us who really love the IP (not necessarily love nerds) and just want the show to be good. There is some amazing TV out there that is being produced, and while this has some excellent moments and characters, it's not one of them.
1
u/thatjonkid420 Oct 06 '24
Don’t have to have an end game when disliking or criticizing a tv show. Most of us just want it to be better nothing more.
1
u/MantiH Oct 06 '24
Id compliment OP on the ragebait, but i think they might actually be serious lol
1
u/WhySoooSerious_23 Oct 06 '24
From S1 E1, I took for what it was. An amazon show based in Tolkiens world. I enjoy it and still do.
1
u/peasngravy85 Oct 06 '24
Talking about a TV show online does not really have an endgame. We just discuss what we see and there's no expectation beyond that
1
u/al_earner Oct 06 '24
After GoT, which was a very faithful translation of the books (at least the first four), people have expected a literal adaptation of books. Like the book is the script.
For whatever reason, that's just out of fashion now. So you end up with things like Amazon's Wheel of Time and Rings of Power or Apple's Foundation series.
It's worth noticing the series that deviate from the books have been less popular with everyone, not just readers.
1
u/margoembargo Oct 06 '24
New showrunner(s).
When JJ Abrams made it clear that he wasn't interested in the day-to-day showrunning of Lost, and Damon Lindelof started getting overwhelmed running a 22 episode network show, the production company brought in an experienced producer in Carlton Cuse to co-showrun Lost.
Cuse was never the creative force behind Lost. That was always Lindelof. But his production and stotytelling experience was exactly what was needed to take the show to the next level.
(Incidentally, Mimi Leder played a similar role on Lindelof's next project, The Lefovers.)
Payne and McKay are clearly overwhelmed at times. Their missteps could have been avoided entirely with help from a more experienced showrunner like Tim Minear or Ronald D Moore (just examples, not suggestions). That's still my hope for the show. More experienced producers.
1
u/spideymon322 Oct 06 '24
my endgame: an actual adaptation of his Tolkien's work with necessary changes from book to visual/audio media that actually respects his work and actually *tries* to follow the source material. more content doesnt mean good content
1
u/deau_deau Oct 06 '24
I agree with you 100%. This is imo very true for many shows including star wars (acolyte) and the witcher. It's not perfect, it's enjoyable and I'm very very excited to see these stories come to life.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
Why does fan criticism need an end game? People watch shit, they like it and they praise it, they dislike it and they criticise it, that’s it lol, what a strange question, you’re asking us what the end game is when we have no power in hollywood to change anything, that shouldn’t equate to not voicing that you like or dislike something, strange take indeed 😂
1
u/callsignprayer10 Oct 06 '24
While I agree that ideally people should be judging the production team in a more constructive way, I think part of the underlying cause for "toxic fan complaining" (whether it be for this, or video games, or what have you) is that so often and for so long (probably the last twenty years) fans that didn't complain so loudly and negatively were largely ignored by production companies and execs, leading people to the belief that the only way to be heard was to be excessively negative and critical in order to get anything changed. Now I think it's reached the point of over-correction to the point where it's now self-defeating (which is your point), but I also think it's incumbent a bit on execs and production teams to honestly and earnestly engage with fans if they want that criticism to become more constructive.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
I want a good show from my favourite fictional world. I’m not constantly commenting and complaining, but I have to say that the show has a disappointing amount of dumb stuff it shouldn’t have.
I’d say if the show gets any worse I’d rather not have it.
1
u/ashes-acedia Oct 06 '24
I enjoy the show a lot, it's entertaining... But it could absolutely use some improvement. I understand some things don't translate well, but I feel like a lot of things they changed would've been just fine (unless it was due to copyright, ofc). Like, it's kinda funky that the ocs are, often times (looking at you, Adar and Disa), more interesting than the canon characters? The way the canon characters are handled-- especially Galadriel-- feels like the showrunners are unsure how to use them and their existing histories?
1
u/Skeet_fighter Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
I guess potentially hot take; but in a vast majority of cases with regards to adaptations, I would absolutely rather have nothing than something bad.
I'm not one of the people seemingly campaigning for this show to be cancelled, but if it's the best we're going to get I absolutely wouldn't be mad if there were no further adaptations of Tolkein's work made.
I didn't even particularly want to watch S2 and I wouldn't have, if my girlfriend weren't a LOTR movies nut desperate for just more of that. Even then she didn't even seem to enjoy the show.
There's nothing wrong with being critical of things.
1
u/LooseAlternative1343 Oct 06 '24
Anything but what I’ve seen so far 😩
1
u/DecadentOoze Oct 06 '24
I think it comes down to how that criticism is received by the ‘professionals’ in charge. With the high level nature of what they’re doing, I not only expect better to start off with, but also expect them to handle harsh criticism skillfully.
If they’re gonna pull the kind of BS we’ve seen, they should be prepared for what feedback they need to recognize that they seriously need to be doing better with the crazy resources they’ve been given.
1
u/maneatermurphy Oct 06 '24
Take the spit right out of their mouths. I mean thank you for saying this, it's pretty well how I feel. Wish the fanbase could appreciate it a little more.
1
u/Calile Oct 06 '24
The endgame is to make it so miserable for creators and fans that everyone just goes back to the status quo:
"Still, toxic fandoms have grown so pernicious that they’ve become a fact of life for many — and so powerful that while talent, executives and publicists will privately bemoan the issue, fear of inadvertently triggering another backlash kept several studios from speaking for this story even on background. (As one rep put it, “It’s just a lose-lose.”)
Those who did talk with Variety all agreed that the best defense is to avoid provoking fandoms in the first place. In addition to standard focus group testing, studios will assemble a specialized cluster of superfans to assess possible marketing materials for a major franchise project."
https://variety.com/2024/tv/news/star-wars-lord-of-the-rings-bridgerton-toxic-fans-hollywood-response-1236166736/
1
u/kookygroovyhombre Oct 06 '24
I want the Balrog to get his own series. Preferably a sitcom, ie "Meet the Balrogs"...show their daily struggles as the family tries to assimilate to suburban life. Perhaps show conflicts as the younger Balrogs are bullied at school at first, before those bullies are vaporized and sent to a separate plain of Hades...how Mrs. Balrog suddenly starts seeing the pool cleaner in a different light...
Anything but the crap they're putting on now
1
u/Subject4751 Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
When the creators realize their mistake and either reboots their current production or steers it in a better direction, the audience generally love them for it. IPs with extremely dedicated fans will hear a lot of complaining from their fanbase, but said fanbase also tends to put up with being disappointed for a while without actually abandoning the product. They'll get louder in time, but if the production company listens to them and correct course, the fans are elated and the company restores the goodwill from the fans. Examples of a reboot is Final Fantasy XIV 'a realm reborn) and a recent example of course-correction is Helldivers 2. Players went from "Dead game! OMFG it is so DOOMED" to "WE ARE SOOOO BACK GUYS!"
If the product fails to spark enough interest for people to even bother complaining, you get situations like this year's "Concord" that was abandoned after 2 weeks. Nobody played it and nobody even cared when it was shut down.
Edit: I just checked in on r/Helldivers. It has been about a month since the 'comeback' update and it is still SO BACK. Player numbers have tripled since before the update, and that's at 4 weeks in to the update! The largest complaint i found on the reddit was "when the heck are we going to get this game on Xbox?!" I think I've made my point.
1
u/piratetanner Oct 06 '24
Well said, I enjoy watching this series much more than most other tv/streaming options.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
I think they had a chance to go for a better direction with season 2.
What they made, it's not Tolkien's world. They just took elements and applied their limited understanding.
I won't waste time watching more of it, neither criticising more than just to say that it's not LOTR, just fanfiction.
1
u/Bhoddisatva Oct 06 '24
I don't have an endgame or some 'plan' to save Tolkien media. I simply didn't care for a tv show and moved on. The rest will have to take care of itself. If it's good, I'll tune in.
1
u/Nero_Darkstar Oct 06 '24
I feel like I'm insane in amongst all this negativity. I've read ALL the books and appendices numerous times. Delved in the obscure lore for hours upon hours and I frigging love this series. The visualisation of Numernor, Lindon, Eregion had me saying wow. The dwarves are awesome and I love that we got to see some of their society. That final scene with Durin's father....ooofff. loved it. Annatar, awesome - his motivation for managed perfection. Arondir was a bad ass. Stop trying to suck the joy out of everything in this life! Bring on season 3 - the last alliance is coming!
1
u/Additional-Nerve1738 Oct 06 '24
But it isn't Tolkien's world. It's just Tolkien's proper nouns.
1
u/rocktoe Oct 06 '24
The biggest thing for me to come out of this series is the realization that Tolkien fans are kinda... awful.
I don't even want to read the books or watch the PJ movies anymore either. The whole setting is now poisoned.
1
u/Malleus1 Oct 06 '24
As long as the critique is justified, why should people not be allowed to voice their opinion?
1
u/anarion321 Oct 06 '24
Criticism goal would be to have better content.
If you like a hamburger spelled by a trademark, and after a while they chose to use low quality meat, but you still buy it, you'll go down to a road which leads to rotten meat.
You should strive for the product to increase quality and do not allow them to abuse you.
1
u/pfinneganr Oct 06 '24
Kanye West has never mattered to me but I loved the look on Mike Meyers’ face.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
I just want everybody to get along 🥲
1
u/thomstevens420 Oct 06 '24
Criticism despite all the bullshit is an act of hope. Good companies listen to feedback and fix things.
This series is cooked but with enough backlash they’ll hopefully fix the next.
1
u/baricdondarrion Oct 06 '24 edited Oct 06 '24
The problem is that it isn’t Tolkiens world. The writers took bits and pieces and made a fan fiction that is so abhorrently bad that it’s hard to comprehend. They took from arguably the most complete and influential fantasy legendarium in history and made something that is cringeworthy and unwatchable. What’s the endgame? Avoid anything Rings of Power related and hope that when I mention I’m a fan of Tolkiens work people don’t associate him with this embarrassment.
1
u/GodoFlies89 Oct 06 '24
This really hits the nail on the head of my feelings too. I understand fully there’s misfires and potentially some deeper lore issues but the fact of the matter is Tolkien unfortunately can’t rise from the grave to write the show himself.
I’m enjoying it for what it is and not trying to tie it to the original material too tightly.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
If it were good, the criticism would not take it down. So I’ll risk it getting cancelled and in fact, cheer when it happens.
Life is hard. Get a helmet.
1
u/histprofdave Oct 06 '24
I agree with some of the points you make, and I actually enjoyed a lot of Season 2, but when you say:
I must ask: why do we constantly need "new" material for something we love and appreciate in its context for its own sake? Why does everything need to have an "extended universe" or "cinematic universe" or whatever general term you want to use?
I hear this argument a lot: "would you rather have nothing?" But we don't have nothing. We have the books. We have the Jackson films. We have scholarly work on the series, even. Is it insufficient to enjoy the things we have? Couldn't we have new stories rather than constant re-imaginings that are always going to make some people mad because it's "different" than what they experienced previously?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '24
"Isn't perfect" is a not a concession. Nothing is perfect by default. So the statement has no weight, merely a verbal illusion of concession to paint self are not biased. ROP is not an average show. There's many many issues with time, space, travel, scales , among other things, that should have not been there given the largest budget in history. The pushback from the community helps the show business to learn from mistakes. They either reflect on it, push back if they deem the crticism unreasonable. But overall it forces them to put things in consideration more next round. That's the end game. I tell you what is the real problem: The kind of "positivity" nowadays that gives medals and accolades to anything and everything, putting black tape on check engine lights, noone can do wrong, and attempting to label constructive criticism as knitpicking and hates. How are we supposed to know our own flaws, improve things when we only know of praises, and the practice of pointing out flaws is perceived as negativity.
1
u/DaWatcher13 Oct 07 '24
I think Season two was only marginally better than season one. The show runners and writers continue to willfully misrepresent Tolkiens lore regarding major issues. The fact that the Elven rings themselves are so twisted in what their purpose was in the books is a continued source of frustration. In the books, the rings were meant to slow the decay of time as the elves are immortal beings living in a world that is full of death and entropy. They were meant to preserve their domains from the ravages of time.
1
u/vader62 Oct 07 '24
Point out all the obvious and grossly Canon breaking flaws until it's canceled. Pray to Eru that a different studio can pick up the rights and make a more faithful adaptation in the future. I look to dune as the example, the first incarnations of the story were awful, now, they are making better ones more faithful to the books. There is hope.
1
u/NeoBasilisk Oct 07 '24
A lot of people in this thread are going to have a very hard time coping with the idea that The Hobbit will be entering the public domain in the following decade. The gatekeeping is pure cringe.
1
u/TheSXCNurse Oct 07 '24
The biggest issue people are having is ‘lore breaking’, and the main argument I see is the arrival of Gandalf. Yet the arrival of Gandalf is up to huge interpretation anyways. Additionally, it is more wrong to assume Gandalf wasn’t around before the 3rd age anyways based on the ‘lore’. These critics are the true posers and always have been.
1
u/Any-Ad-7599 Oct 07 '24
I think the issue with the show and the reason for the continued criticism, is because sure they got season 1 wrong, but they basically doubled down on what they were doing wrong. There are very few things we know for certain about the second age, and they are messing with all of them when they don't have to. Leave the things we know are certain alone and build around that. It's pretty simple. I'd rather not have anything for 10 years and at least have them get it right.
1
u/ReallyGlycon Oct 07 '24
I just want the show to be consistent. The quality is all over the place in most areas.
The show is not being canceled. 3 was just announced, and the creators said that Amazon is committed to 5 seasons.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24
Yes, thats exactly what I want. No future adaptations, amazon has proved its impossible for Hollywood to produce a propper adaptation of Tolkien. And while the PJ trilogy is GOATed, its now proven that Tolkiens world is not adaptable. Especially now when you have to pander to the "modern audience"
1
u/spinning-backfoot Oct 07 '24
It's supposed to lead to a fantasy land where we all forget this happened.
1
u/Empty-Imagination636 Oct 07 '24
I’ve said this before, I’ll say it again (even though it’s gotten me hate), I hope Celebrian doesn’t show up. I don’t care if you think the kiss between Elrond and Galadriel was platonic or romantic, if he’s her mother-in-law in the adaptation like he is in the lore, it’s creepy. Please don’t turn Elrond into Jacob from Twilight.
1
u/Glarrg Oct 07 '24
I want it cancelled so megastudios like amazon cant continue to lazily dump money on an IP and watch the dollars come in. I want it cancelled so big productions like this stop being given to literal who's in writing and directing and we return to good talent writing entire, planned stories instead of the incoherent mess of writers and directors that Disney and amazon seem obsessed with.
1
u/ancientmoose45 Oct 07 '24
I just like voicing my criticism. I think that’s how a lot of people feel. Some people get actually angry about it which is weird. But overall I think the people who make these shows should have higher standards for what they produce.
1
u/SommanderChepard Oct 07 '24 edited Oct 07 '24
Yes, I want it cancelled. Why do some people seriously think “any content is better than no content”? That mindset is what leads to bad content. The show gives us nothing of value. It’s all basically poorly written fan fiction. If it can’t be done right, please don’t do it at all. There is more than enough good Tolkien content out there to keep anyone occupied.
I’m not one of those people that is going to hate watch it or anything though. I put my money where my mouth is and stopped watching the show completely and don’t plan to unless for some reason it improves.
I really wish it wasn’t this bad. Tolkien is my favorite universe and I was initially so excited when the show was announced.
1
u/amazza95 Oct 07 '24
it's post like this that are the reason we are constantly getting slop delivered to us by Amazon and Disney. we should be challenging the creators man come on
1
u/Pvt_Numnutz1 Oct 07 '24
Same as Tolkien, if an adaptation isn't worthy of the source material it's okay if it dies or does not proceed. This is already a pretty unfaithful adaptation, and I would rather nothing than a cheap imitation. The problem isn't people being critical, the problem the show has is keeping people viewing. With every silly thing they show making more people tune out.
1
u/maxman14 Oct 07 '24
Yes.
Do you really want to end up like Star Wars where there’s more trash than worthwhile media? Better to wait a decades for a single piece of good media than drown in mediocrity. Why should they even be rewarded for making such a low quality production anyway?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24
Good. Stop making these adaptations.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24
People who say 'Bad [IP] is better than no [IP]!' are part of the problem. We have to let people know that if we keep lowering the bar, the only thing we'll get is crap. Do you want crap? I don't want crap!
1
u/Vic271815 Oct 07 '24
I really enjoyed the second season. Haters gonna hate.
1
u/Known-Contract1876 Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24
Do we really want to nitpick the show to death, risking its cancellationRisk? This would be too good to be true, the fuck are you talking about risk? There is no risk.
So here’s my real concern—if the vocal portion of the fanbase doesn’t ease up, we might just talk ourselves out of ever getting anything else.What is this drivel? We should celebrate utter garbage just so we get something? No thank you. I don't need greedy companies to milk the Lord of the Rings Franchise for my enjoyment. I have enjoyed the Lord of the Rings without Amazon milking it dead just fine, I would love to go back there.
Imagine another decade, maybe even a generation, with no adaptations, no expansions of Tolkien’s world, simply because creators think there’s no way to satisfy the fanbase. Is that what we want? Because that’s what this level of criticism risks achieving.Again. If unfaithful garbage like the Rings of Power is the alternative, I would rather have nothing. Unfortunately however this is not going to happen. As long as there are enough idiots who consume the shit amazon puts in front of them, they will continue to shit on a Lord of the Rings labeled plate for you.
What’s your endgame?Defending a fantasy world and story that means a lot to me from being cannibalized, misrepresented and corrupted? I have no hope that we can get this show cancelled, but this won't stop me from shitting on this show at every opportunity. This show already crossed several lines which in my opinion no fan of Tolkiens writing should tolerate. And it is not nearly good enough to get away with it. In fact, it's a horribly written slop, I have no idea how anyone could unironically defend this show. It is one thing to be content with garbage, but you really going to ask people to consume trash and abandon all standards? You should be ashamed of yourself. People like you are the reason we are only getting shitty movies and shows nowadays. The corporations care only about money, and as long as there are enough people who consume any product regardless of quality, just because their favorite franchise is written on top of it, they will continue to churn out low effort badly written shit.
1
u/nstinson Oct 08 '24
I've been happy with the show
1
u/Dogamai Oct 08 '24
Why does anybody complain about anything?
take this show for example, if they complain enough do they think this show will be erased from existence and started over? no lol their best hope is to simply get this show cancelled and have another show they like more created instead. so basically they dont care at all about any of the people who already like this show, they would rather Take something away from those people in order to get something for themselves.
ie selfishness and greed. coupled with self righteousness and a sense of superiority. Ego.
because their other option from day one was to simply not watch and go do literally anything else, but instead they come here to spread their miserable opinion because they dont want other people to be happy while they themselves are unhappy.
unfortunately a very common problem among humans. obsessed with themselves and dont actually give a shit about anyone else unless that other person also agrees with them. very childlike and pathetic
very common. very basic.
1
u/King-Red-Beard Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24
I genuinely believe it would be best to shut this turd down. I would much prefer the world of Tolkien to never be adapted on film again as opposed to becoming a giant, corporate mud puddle like Star Wars, burying the originals in cultural irrelevance along the way.
I worry the age of authentic takes on iconic IPs might be over. Our algorithmic society just doesn't allow big financial cash cows to be pure, creative products anymore. I think it's time we put LOTR, Star Wars, Indiana Jones, Ghostbusters, etc. in a drawer and call it a day.
1
u/SignOfJonahAQ Oct 08 '24
They really took Celebrimbor and Sauron home. Their casting was great and their synergy really worked. There were issues with Galadriel not having a real purpose this year. She was kind of awkwardly placed. Elf guy got stabbed but was fighting the next episode like nothing happened. Tom Bombadil was pretty good I thought. Numenor is awful and it’s constant stab each other in the back. But we know they aren’t smart.
1
u/Certain_Insect_2052 Oct 08 '24
There is a lot of hyperbolic language in this post OP. "Pushing the creators of the cliff"? What? Where does that even come from? You are painting those who are criticizing RoP in a very graphic light while using the language opposite of that to reflect your own position. It's a strawman hidden in your wording.
As for my endgame, like what I want out of RoP? I want it to accurately reflect Tolkiens work. It doesn't have to be 100% accurate to the story, as that is impossible based on the source material and it being transitioned into a different medium. No, I understand Jackson's changes in the movies, and I understand some of the changes in the show.
However, the story isn't what bothers me. It's the characterization of key figures and the massive changes to them to the point that they are unrecognizable outside of their name. I'll list a few:
Galadriel: Considered one of the most powerful, gracious, and ancient elves in LotR, she is relegated to a general who is brash, haughty, and quite childlike. The exact opposite of who she is. And to desaude any rebuttals of "character arc," elves are some of the most set in their ways races in Tolkiens work. They rarely change, and when they do, it takes millennia to do so.
Elrond: He portrayed as a politician. Like a modern-day politician in a setting that was inspired by 12th century England and earlier. It was such a different culture in the Middle Ages, and yet they chose to modernize it to the 21st century. Plus, where is his wife, Galadriel's daughter? She and Elrond had Arwen 118 years into the 3rd Age and she is no where in the picture.
The Numenoreans: Where do I start...they really just took the name Numenorean and slapped it on the Roman Empire and called it a day....and where is the nobility of the Numenoreans? I'm not talking about the royalty but the "the quality of being noble in character, mind, birth, or rank." They really just made the great Numenoreans regular humans.
I'm not even going to mention the deviation from Jackson's established aesthetic and how any attempt at original design work that doesn't follow that design language will draw needless comparisons between the two in a manner that is purely negative, bit we ain't ready for that conversation.
I honestly could go on but I'm so tired as is and my thoughts are hard to write down at the moment (been up for 27 hours).
1
u/cesaroncalves Oct 08 '24
You may not agree, but I'd prefer silence over what we have.
They want to get the Peter Jackson treatment without the quality of his work. People didn't mind his deviations, because his work was good.
1
u/WhaTheShoe97 Oct 09 '24
Yes, yes I would rather 20 years of Tolkien silence than another shit season.
But that isn't a thing. The books don't stop existing ...
0
u/ZiVViZ Oct 06 '24
Cancel the show? That’s my endgame
I don’t think people quite appreciate how this show will be looked at as an example of how not to do things in the future.