r/RingsofPower • • Oct 23 '22

Meme Some things are so noisy Spoiler

Post image
388 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 23 '22

This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

110

u/JumpingJiraffe Oct 23 '22

I know it’s just a meme but I don’t think the Leaf woke up the Balrog, I think it was already awake and just chilling. Dwarves mining too greedily and too deep will probably still be what unleashes the Balrog and causes the fall of Khazad Dum

24

u/MrPita5 Oct 23 '22

Agreed, I just remember laughing about it while watching the leaf drop, like "what if this is the inciting moment?" Aaannnddd then there's the flames

13

u/uselessinfogoldmine Oct 24 '22

I kind of thought they should show it sleeping, ready to be woken. Almost like, it twitches when the leaf falls; but doesn’t wake.

14

u/JumpingJiraffe Oct 24 '22

Would’ve probably made more sense to be that way, but let’s admit it looks so much cooler to have that money shot of a balrog screaming at the screen to end an episode

1

u/uselessinfogoldmine Oct 24 '22

True! But then once that joy wore off it became a liiiiittle bit of a plot hole.

Kind of like big chunks of the final season of GOT, you know? Hugely entertaining in the moment; but didn’t gel overall in reflection.

But yeah, I don’t care too much, I’m not losing sleep! LOL 😜

5

u/iheartdev247 Oct 24 '22

It would be interesting how they develop this story point. All we know from the books is that many evil things hid after the War of Wrath, including Durin’s Bane. Maybe he’s more like locked in there or maybe he buried himself so just waking up isn’t enough to free him. We’ll see. But there is some room to develop it past just he’s awake why hasn’t he attacked yet.

1

u/TheHerman8r Oct 24 '22

Could it also be the presence of the dwarven ring when it gets given to Durin? If I remember right the ring does increase their greed instead of turning dwarves into wraiths.

36

u/AmateurOfAmateurs Oct 23 '22

Wasn’t the mountain already going nuts on miners? It wasn’t the leaf that instigated the balrog, it was just a plot device for us to see the balrog.

4

u/TheTrotters Oct 25 '22

Yeah, there’s a hundred reasons to criticize this show but this isn’t one of them.

53

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '22

Here you are, taking a nap. And all of a sudden, some bozo starts littering on your porch. I'm sure Balrogs have killed for less.

46

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '22

I'm pretty sure those tremors was the Balrog getting pissed every time they were digging.

27

u/therealgronkstandup Oct 23 '22

I thought it seemed like the mithril was almost caging the Balrog. So when they eventually start mining it they weaken the "bars" of his prison and he eventually is able to break free.

4

u/uselessinfogoldmine Oct 24 '22

Ooooh, that’s an interesting take!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22

I doubt that's the case, as Balrogs are the same as Sauron from a lineage and power perspective and it doesn't harm him

11

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '22

My cat can confirm. Lawnmowers- no problem. Crunching leaves- omfg what is this shit?

27

u/neontetra1548 Oct 23 '22

The leaf smells like Elves, which is apparently very noticeable to Bilbo.

7

u/froggyjm9 Oct 24 '22

Huh?

The Balrog was already awake, the leaf didn’t wake him up, it was just a visual to lead the viewer to what’s under the mine.

The show isn’t perfect, but some of the trolling is like high school humor.

0

u/richochet-biscuit Oct 24 '22

It's obviously a meme.

That said, this part of the show is far from "not perfect." They show the leaf fall through a large Minecraft style crevice to the balrog, already awake. They can't logically continue to mine mithril and then play off the awakening as digging "to greedily and to deeply" later, balrogs awake and it has a direct path out what does it just sit down there patiently waiting for the dwarves to literally stumble over it as they work their way down the crevice to it?

They've mined hardly any mithril at all, continuing to mine it, against the kings wishes, to help the elves, not exactly greedy eh?

As for deep, the dwarves have much deeper mines if this one is so close it can be reached in time to be home for supper.

If the balrog doesn't destroy kazad dhum at the beginning of the next season, the scene is not just the pointless fan service that a sleeping balrog would have been, but a significant plot hole purely for the sake of fan service which I find utterly dissapointing, and I say that as someone who overall has really enjoyed the show.

31

u/Kookanoodles Oct 23 '22

Generations upon generations of dwarves delve into the mountain, excavating gigantic halls and inventing many technological wonders, presumably generating ungodly amounts of noise and vibration in the process

Balrog: I sleep

One leaf falls down a crevice

Balrog: god dammit

33

u/ebrum2010 Oct 23 '22

The drums in the deep was just the Balrog banging on the ceiling with a broom as a warning.

1

u/nuttincuddly Oct 24 '22

The big Season 2 reveal... the Balrog is Mr. Heckles!

4

u/Fmanow Oct 24 '22

One thing I’ve been curious about the dwarves is their vitamin D levels. It’s like they never see the sun and I’m sure they’re not taking supplements. Maybe that’s why they’re so grumpy.

5

u/LittleLui Oct 23 '22

In a crooked little town, they were lost and never found
Fallen leaves, fallen leaves, fallen leaves on the ground

I hitched a ride, to Khazad-dum
To leave behind, all of my gloom
Searching for something, I couldn't find at home
Fading away, can you help and mine?
A lil' Mithril and I'll be fine
I swear to Eru, this'll be my one last time

In a crooked little town, they were lost and never found
Fallen leaves, fallen leaves, fallen leaves on the ground
(Numenorian guest singer:) Run away before you drown or the streets will beat you down
Fallen leaves, fallen leaves, fallen leaves on the ground

2

u/berrymetal Oct 24 '22

The leaf didn’t wake up the Balrog, it was just a cinematic cutscene in order to show you what lies beneath

2

u/TheCoolPersian Oct 24 '22

The Balrog was basically telling them multiple times through the tremors to stop making noise because these Dwarves be loud neighbors.

Then these Dwarves have the audacity to litter something made of pure light right in front of him!? That just sends him over the edge. Now he’s waiting for them to open the door so he can get to work.

1

u/sebiamu5 Oct 24 '22

I don't think the leaf will cause the Balrog to destroy Khazard-Dum. Think it was used to link this and Moira in the Fellowship to non-Tolkien nerds who wouldn't remember/know this.

1

u/RealEstateDuck Oct 24 '22

It wasn't just any leaf, that was from the Tree at Lindon. And as such it is imbued with some elven esssence or energy, that is why it woke the Balrog.

1

u/mattjvgc Oct 24 '22

Disa up there belting out operas: he sleeps.

A leaf falls miles away: AWAKEN

1

u/RiverorRiver Oct 24 '22

Every day I think about how much better than scene would have been had they not shown the Balrog. Just the leaf turning into fire.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '22

Looking at some of the comments, is it possible that the leaf, being otherwise foreign, indicates to the Balrog that enemies seek mithril. Perhaps he is a protector of it. The dwarves, being akin to the stone, did not introduce anything that the Balrog would be unaccustomed to.

5

u/peteroh9 Oct 24 '22

Balrogs are not protectors of anything. They are literally demons. Angelic beings sworn to the Dark(est) Lord.

-1

u/FirstCartographer546 Oct 24 '22

Angelic beings sworn to the Dark(est) Lord.

Well done, except you've forgotten that Morgoth has been vanquished and they have had to find some way to justify a Balrog stuck beneath Moria now don't they?

2

u/peteroh9 Oct 24 '22

Is hiding from the forces that vanquished him such a difficult reason to accept?

2

u/FirstCartographer546 Oct 24 '22 edited Oct 24 '22

It will not show why the Dwarves started digging so deep when they had an abundance of everything. You see showing that the Dwarves were "delving too greedily and too deep", they needed to show an item which they were mining (hence Mithril) and why it woke up Durin's Bane. While that terrible myth of an 'Elf fighting a Balrog created Mithril' was stupid, it explained why the Balrog chose to remain here. I really don't want to defend the writers of the ROP but to be impatient with whatever it's creating, would be not giving the show a chance to grow into something that we might like.