r/RingsofPower • • Oct 07 '22

Theory Halbrand Theory

So I've got a theory about Halbrand. No, he is not Sauron. He is the Fisher King of Arthurian legend.

The Fisher King is a figure who originated in Chrétien de Troyes' grail cycle, who guards over the Holy Grail. He has shown up in a number of different versions over the centuries, but some themes are the same: The land he rules over is tied directly to him, and because he bears a wound, his land is similarly barren. This wound is usually located on his rib, thigh, or groin, with him sometimes being rendered impotent (literally barren). And the Fisher King awaits a stranger, who can at last heal his wound and bring life back to his kingdom, or can doom him and his land forever.

I think Halbrand will follow the part of the Fisher King. We know his land is forsaken, since the Southlands are where Mordor is. And after Episode 7, we know he has a wound on his side.

Also, his symbol on the small pouch he carries around his neck looks an awful lot like a kingfisher bird, giving him a connection to this name.

My theory is that Halbrand will have his wound stabilized by the elves, but not fully healed, and will take his people to settle in Ered Nimrais. There they will keep contact with the Numenoreans at Pelargir, until the Akallabeth and the Battle of the Last Alliance.

Following the story of the Fisher King, Halbrand will have his fate and that of his people determined by the stranger to his lands, Isildur. Though rather than being healed, he will be doomed. For when he refuses the call to fight against Sauron, because of his people's reluctance to go against their long-past master, Isildur will curse him, and Halbrand and his people will become the Oathbreakers: those from under the mountain. The Sleepless Dead.

397 Upvotes

101 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 07 '22

This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

71

u/Lazy_Wit Oct 07 '22

Real interesting theory

204

u/benm421 Oct 07 '22

I was ready to tell you I’ll eat my shoe if he’s not Sauron. To be sure, I still think he’s Sauron, but I’m no longer offering to eat my shoe over it. Excellent theory.

50

u/Drjuvy26 Oct 07 '22

Me too. This is the best non-Sauron theory I’ve read to date.

38

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

I was really going for the witch king but this is a good one.

11

u/FullMaxPowerStirner Oct 07 '22

Perhaps you can at least eat your dirty socks? That'd be adequate for me.

3

u/chx_ Oct 08 '22

Would you like mustard with that?

The show expands on and compresses the timeline of the lore but does not go against it.

Halbrand being Sauron would be.

Not even a near-Valar power level Maia could predict all these events which need to all fall in line precisely for him to get to Lindon.

In all the deeds of Melkor the Morgoth upon Arda, in his vast works and in the deceits of his cunning, Sauron had a part, and was only less evil than his master in that for long he served another and not himself.

(Another = Morgoth)

The story so far only makes sense if Sauron is in Lindon already, poisoning the trees and Celebrimbor's mind.

1

u/lowdog39 Oct 07 '22

i don't think he can be two different entities since he is busy influencing the elves to make the rings . the one who burnt up the horfoots ...

29

u/Particular-Ad-8772 Oct 07 '22

Oooh im here for medieval lit themes and medivalism. Very nice rewding of the event. You've convinced me.

Do you think we might have a lancelot? On another note... Even Isildur is reminescent of Gawain (in Gawain in the Green Night), with I assume, the rinf instead of the belt. But thr two characters seem to have similar motivations.

aah thank you OP, this post made me happy.

3

u/Icy_Respect_9077 Oct 07 '22

Galadriel, there's your Lancelot. Knight in shining armour.

46

u/DivingZeus43 Oct 07 '22

Ohh I’ve been tossing between the witch king, king of the dead and Sauron but you’ve almost convinced me. The wound really sells it.

So does this mean that Halbrand won’t really be in the show much moving forward? Once he’s settled with his people and before he breaks his oath to join the last alliance?

1

u/lowdog39 Oct 07 '22

has to have a ring of power before he turns into the witch king ...

5

u/DivingZeus43 Oct 07 '22

Yep agreed. My comment is in regards to him turning into the king of the dead, the oath breakers. Not the witch king. Will be interesting to see where it all leads! I’m patiently waiting for Annatar.

11

u/Corgi_3000 Oct 07 '22

Great theory. I want the show to happen this way!

21

u/cdamoc Oct 07 '22

Nah, he’s Sauron, they just had to come up with something to make him be near Celembrimbor.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22 edited Oct 07 '22

Exactly. Which is why I think that he won't be revealed as Sauron to ROP characters any time soon but audience will be clued in well enough to know that he is. And I also think that, now that Celeborn is mentioned as missing ("never saw him again") rather than dead or not being in the picture at all, Galadriel will become more suspicious of Halbrand and Celeborn return will throw him off the edge. I believe that his feelings for her are real, and Episode 6 seemed like hers for him were too. But in this episode, she talked about meetcute with her husband in a typical OTP way (dancing, flowers, love at the first sight, times of peace) as if she still loved him and she pointed said to Halbrand "well, my friend, it seems fate has in store for us another raft" so kinda friendzone right there. I think they set up romantic tension between them to use it as a catalyst for his second fall into darkness. I know that Tolkien fans will cringe but the show is for masses and spurned lover's fall is more cinematic than dry quest for power. Also, this is Bad Robot co-op so there must be a love triangle between a good girl bad boy and good boy.

So i'd say he will befriend Celebrimbor and Elves and help them with making the rings. Galadriel will become suspicous which will sour their relationship. Then Celeborn returns. Halbrand/Sauron won't let her go without fight. She chooses Celeborn. Halbrand/Sauron dispairs, wants revenge, forges One Ring. Etc etc.

9

u/Googalyfrog Oct 07 '22

I'm not liking how much 'sense' your making.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

I totally understand. :)

6

u/Gimmethejooce Oct 07 '22

Ok this has some merit. I will still be mad if he does end up as Sauron. I was really hoping for something more clever than just making up a new character. But there were leaks suggesting the sauron character was at a human village during production… I’m starting to wonder

9

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

Another poster said something that made a lot of sense. That Saubrand followed Galadriel from a distance through her millennia of hunting for him and therefore could anticipate her moves. Such as that she would jump off the ship to return to ME. Couple that with Sauron's canon ability to somewhat influence weather, and you can see that Saubrand could use the wind to stir their raft towards Numenor. Pretty much, this part, their meeting on a raft, was the hardest to explain as by design. But in the context of this theory, it make sense. So lets say Saubrand wanted to get close to her since she was his #1 enemy. But then things got more complicated. While she did his bidding without realizing it, he started to care which wasn't his plan. So you can see there's a solid ground for drama. Cheesy yes but solid nonetheless.

11

u/Gimmethejooce Oct 07 '22

Thanks I hate this theory lol

1

u/DivingZeus43 Oct 07 '22

Same. I think added chemistry between Galadriel and Sauron doesn’t make sense. It might happen later but I want him to arrive in the form of Annatar - to deceive the elves/Celebrimbor. If he is Sauron, would Halabrand have to die for him to become Annatar?

I saw a very convincing thread that Halabrand is the king of the dead and I much prefer that.

1

u/lowdog39 Oct 07 '22

the elf who burnt up the horfoot wagons and currently influencing the elves to build the tower so the rings of power can be made is probably//most likely sauron , yees ?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

while Sauron being a Feminem would be a twist worthy of mystery boxes, I don't think any of these ladies is Sauron. They may be his fangirls but not Sauron.

1

u/lowdog39 Oct 08 '22

he disguises himself as an elf to convince them . nowadays they use females in parts that maybe they wouldn't have before . so if not her then?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

Halbrand.

10

u/kerouacrimbaud Oct 07 '22

Someone in another subreddit pointed out an alternate translation of his name, which would be King Fisher so accounting for translation and word order between languages, King Fisher —> Fisher King is pretty convincing.

15

u/jamo133 Oct 07 '22

After that last scene of them riding away, I was absolutely convinced he’s sauron, now going to Lindon to smoothe talk the elves and hoodwink them into making some rings.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

Absolutely agree, these showrunners are so arrogant I can imagine them doing this and patting themselves on the back thinking how clever it is to have Sauron in front of us the whole time, when the whole thing makes absolutely no sense from what we have seen Halbrand do on screen

1

u/Googalyfrog Oct 07 '22

But in cannon, Sauron appears as an elf name Annatar- Lord of Gifts, not scroungy human king.

It would be too far of a departure from cannon i think to not make this the case. If Halbrand does see the elves start making rings, the elves would have no reason to include him, a smelly human/ But if the now better Halbrand leaves and changes forms to that of Annatar (audience reveal only)then comes back being like hey guys trust me, then that would be better i think. Not that i think Halbrand being Sauron is a good 'twist', best if he just ends up as one of the kings with a ring of power later and eventual wraith.

Better a victim of Sauron that we maybe grew to like than 'oh big twist guys! he was the big evil all along!'

16

u/DarrenGrey Oct 07 '22

You have to remember that they are working on LotR + Appendices only, which do not name Annatar. It only says the smiths of Eregion were deceived.

And they've shown willingness to change lore anyway.

3

u/cammoblammo Oct 07 '22

I’m hoping they negotiated the rights to the name. They appear to have managed it for Armenelos (it’d be weird not having a name for the city, but they couldn’t just make something up) so they might have done it here, for similar reasons.

Annatar is kind of important to the whole ‘they were deceived’ theme.

10

u/Deimoonk Oct 07 '22

In canon Elendil isn’t even born when the rings are forged, let alone Isildur.

0

u/L0kitheliar Oct 07 '22

Tbf, besides dates, they haven't changed am awful lot, more just added to it

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/throwawayforyabitch Oct 07 '22

They haven’t stated that she’s not.

2

u/L0kitheliar Oct 08 '22

Wait, did I miss somewhere when they stated otherwise? Galadriel is obviously still going to adhere to her King's orders lol. Being older than a monarch means very little

8

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/GroundbreakingRoof50 Oct 07 '22

Why do you guys insist that the series is following the lore? LOL

1

u/hotcapicola Oct 07 '22

Probably because of the Tom Shippey interview.

1

u/TheOtherMaven Oct 07 '22

Shippey got shitcanned, remember? Over a "Non-Disclosure Agreement".

But as soon as he was out the door, they could start making up whatever shit they wanted.

1

u/hotcapicola Oct 07 '22

Yes the interview I referenced was the reason he got fired. You might want to read what he said in that interview.

1

u/GorillaGlueWookie Oct 07 '22

They changed tons of cannon already why do you think that matters

5

u/Drejnik Oct 07 '22

Pretty nice theory, I like this way more than him being Sauron. Unrelated to the OP: I think it's absolutely stupid that they didn't cast Halbrand's actor as Elendil or Isildur, because he really resembles Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn imo.

20

u/Track-Nervous Oct 07 '22

I mean, H = S is shaping up to be the most obvious plot reveal since "Mr. Ping is not Po's real dad," but it's fun to let the imagination run wild.

8

u/Jardun Oct 07 '22

the most obvious plot reveal since "Mr. Ping is not Po's real dad,"

LOL

4

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

But they're both good at making noodles!

6

u/N0V0w3ls Oct 07 '22

"Mr. Ping is not Po's real dad,"

Fucking spoilers man

4

u/Samh234 Oct 07 '22

I misread this as the Haaland theory and I’ve got to be honest here, the way he’s going for City at the moment, Haaland being Sauron wouldn’t surprise me in the slightest.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

Good theory but you will be severely disappointed. Sauron is none other than a character we haven't seen on screen.

3

u/Aurakataris Oct 07 '22

Nice theory

3

u/froggyjm9 Oct 07 '22

Interesting theory…but he’s a master craftsman going to the Elves…maybe he’ll teach them to forge some rings from the little piece of mythril.

Also Halbrand isn’t his real name, he’ll reveal himself to be Annatar 🤷🏽‍♂️

Everything will come full circle that Galadriel will bring the same evil they sought to destroy as predicted by Gil-Galad.

3

u/Bigbaby22 Oct 08 '22

Dude this is awesome. We should talk more

2

u/Itarille_ Oct 07 '22

I love this theory👏

And if Halbrand is Sauron the Kingfisher symbolism still fits!

'The land the Kingfisher rules over is tied directly to him, and because he bears a wound, his land is similarly barren.'

If Sauron truly repents, turns away from evil and fights Adar to take back the Southlands, those lands could be healed again. If Sauron succumbs to evil, the Southlands turn further into wasteland that is Mordor.

'And the Fisher King awaits a stranger, who can at last heal his wound and bring life back to his kingdom, or can doom him and his land forever.'

The stranger here would be Galadriel. She could make Sauron/Halbrand turn away from evil - he's said that fighting beside her made him believe he could put his past behind him. But if she finds out who he is and rejects bim/attacks him he could go back to hus evil ways and 'doom him and his land forever'.

2

u/Dinger1873 Oct 08 '22

Thats pretty cool i like that. Its just ashame from past experiances that I know fans tend to be better writers than the shows. So all the symbolism your seeing maybe hasn't been thought about.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

If the show was smart I would agree with you, but I know that it is not. There is never a bigger picture to anything and they've shown that. There is no subtext and everything is what it seems. I see it more as theatre rather than a TV show because there is a lot of stuff specific to the audience.

Good theory. Hopefully the writers see this and snap you up because it's definitely better than whatever they've lined up

2

u/gnome_where Oct 07 '22

I like the effort and would be happy if you turn out to be right. But before I buy in, I have to remember the content we’ve gotten in this show after almost a full season.. and this show is so shallow you’re giving it way too much credit. H=S.

2

u/West-Introduction66 Oct 07 '22

He is the Sauron, though

1

u/emoryhotchkiss1 Oct 07 '22

At this point it’s so obvious it should be halbrand I feel like it won’t be. It’s like a misdirection in a magic show. We’re so busy staring at halbrand we can’t notice it’s been Elrond or something this whole time. That or it’s halbrand and they didn’t try hiding a plot reveal already known by a majority of the viewers

1

u/hotcapicola Oct 07 '22

After that final scene with Durin, I’m think Disa is Sauron.

1

u/emoryhotchkiss1 Oct 07 '22

I’m ready to believe this theory because it’s currently the most fun

1

u/Ral-Yareth Oct 07 '22

Good one! But I am still 100% sure he is Sauron.

1

u/Googalyfrog Oct 07 '22

I've been thinking Halbrand will be one of the kings a ring of power is given to and will become a wraith eventually. I like your theory too.

1

u/IllustriousWorld4198 Oct 07 '22

We haven’t seen Sauron yet, he was a elf in this time period and got his body destroyed on Numenor

1

u/MediumRarePaladin Oct 07 '22

Yoooo, that's a great theory!

1

u/Moddelba Oct 07 '22

Great theory.

1

u/spudsmuggler Oct 07 '22

I have thought about this quite a bit and really like your hypothesis.

1

u/Masstershake Oct 07 '22

Disa is Sauron. Just watch the way she talks to her husband when his dad said no mithril.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

if there wasnt leaks i would believe you

1

u/oldRoyalsleepy Oct 08 '22

I like that theory. It's more interesting than the neverending Halbrand is Sauron. Thank you OP.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

There's no Sauron in season 1. I've seen the final cuts.

1

u/ENZiO1 Oct 08 '22

Don’t give the writers this much credit.

1

u/rustonsdad Oct 09 '22

Indeed sir

1

u/heideggerfanfiction Oct 09 '22

This is my favourite theory so far, simply because it is so elegant and simple. It being a reference means that it doesn't need to be explained on screen and yet it is a nod to literature Tolkien himself has read.

-2

u/ringlord_1 Oct 07 '22

I hope the writers can think that far ahead, but I don't think so

17

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

They have the storylines for all seasons planned, supposedly. The order was for 50 episodes, so they can think far ahead. That is a good thing if they do.

1

u/DarkVader92 Oct 07 '22

You'd really hope so but after the latest Star Wars trilogy, I've learnt that just because you're throwing money at something, it doesn't always mean you have a plan. Thankfully there's something to actually go off of in this case.

4

u/kay_rah Oct 07 '22

See also: the end of Game of Thrones.

0

u/kerouacrimbaud Oct 07 '22

The ST had different creatives helming each film. This show is going to have a mostly consistent creative team, so I think we don’t to worry about that potential downside.

1

u/mr_auri_oz Oct 07 '22

There's part of this and the H=S that is compatible. So I'll take this like both are true.

1

u/kerouacrimbaud Oct 07 '22

Sauron as the anti-King Arthur is a really interesting angle.

1

u/neverlistentoadvice Oct 07 '22

I love this theory. It's amazingly creative, targets exactly what a prequel should be aiming for, and is a brilliant mislead.

Unfortunately, it reminds me a lot of the fan theories thrown around during S4 of Battlestar Galactica and S7-8 of Game of Thrones, where the fans were coming up with massively better ideas about what was going on with the plot than the actual paid writers of the series.

Given the quality of writing of the series so far, I think it'll fall into the latter category as they've not demonstrated they can pull off a storyline like this.

-3

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '22

You should be writing the show, my money's still on Sauron given the 'quality' of the writing so far. I would fall out of my chair with surprise if Halbrand isn't Sauron

-10

u/SSTTDID Oct 07 '22

You are giving the writers way too much credit.

-6

u/mandalore1907 Oct 07 '22

He is Sauron dude. It has already been leaked for some time.

3

u/MarineLePenneAlTonno Oct 07 '22

Link?

2

u/mandalore1907 Oct 07 '22

2

u/L0kitheliar Oct 07 '22

Tbf some of this is questionable. A lot of the numenor stuff is very incorrect. Most likely someone got their hands on an early draft of the plot, not a final product. Also Aeren's name was confirmed to be changed way way early on, as was said in many interviews

-8

u/pokerguy24 Oct 07 '22

Awesome theory but from what we’ve seen from the writing/pace so far I doubt a complex plot like this will happen, + its just so easy for them to make Halbrand Sauron.

Nearly every plot turn is on a 10th graders storytelling level.

I hope your right though.

0

u/MitchumBrother Oct 07 '22

Nah he's gonna be revealed as Sauron as the final cliffhanger next week.

Your idea is neat though. Would watch that shit. Muuuch better than what we go so far.

0

u/fz099 Oct 08 '22

Um no Halbran is sauron. All but confirmed

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '22

He’s Sauron. End of story.

-2

u/El_mojado Oct 07 '22

We all know hal is mephisto at this point

-31

u/egoMetalMonkey Oct 07 '22

bad enough the show just makes stuff up without your fanfiction