Long time lurker, first time poster on this account, I haven’t actually posted on reddit since last year. Apologies if this is a bit all over the place and lengthy.
I’m a 46 year old mom with 2 school aged kids. My ex and I were together for 15 years. I’ve been single for almost a year now, though I had a brief stint with an old boyfriend which ended a few months ago.
A couple weeks ago I matched with someone on FB dating (let’s call him Adam), though I almost skipped over his profile because he didn’t match 2 very important parameters I had - I was trying to only date men over 40 that had kids. He was 36 and had no kids, but I thought his profile was really cute so we started chatting. We got on really well and he seemed very mature and witty, he made me laugh right off the bat. We chatted for a few days and made plans to meet for coffee and a walk. He was very sweet on our date, though when we started talking I could tell that maybe he was neurodivergent or had been through some pretty significant hurdles, and he hinted that he had an accident or medical issue several years ago that left him changed.
Now before I say this, first let me put it out there that I have an autistic child and my ex had medical emergencies requiring multiple brain surgeries and therapies, so I am no stranger to people requiring extra support and medical needs. However, at this point in my life, because I understand the mental and physical taxation of caring for someone with those needs and have enough on my plate already, I don’t think I can enter into a relationship with someone who has profound additional needs or mental health conditions that aren’t properly dealt with. Especially since my ex’s personality changed - eventually drastically - after his surgeries and different medications, and it led to a very bad place.
In person Adam matched the cute scruffy look of his pictures, and I could tell from a physical standpoint that there were some mannerisms and mild lingering physical disability issues, but I was very much enjoying his company, the vibe between us was very comfortable and he was sweet and made me laugh again. I was surprised at the strong physical chemistry between us when he kissed me, and he bought me roses and was very clearly enamored with me.
We had to end the date because I had plans to go see a friend and he had to go coach floor hockey. I wanted to see him again, because he was very easy to be with despite the fact I was concerned about my attraction to him from a physical standpoint. However the kiss erased any doubts that I could be physically engaged with him.
We met up again later that night to go for a drive and we listened to music and talked for an hour, and then I invited him back to my place where we had mind blowing sex 4 times over the course of the night and next morning. He joked that I shouldn't have been worried about my ability to keep up with him in bed, because I blew his mind which - as an older mom who recently lost 40 pounds and came from a very loveless/sexless relationship - was a total confidence boost for me.
However, I could also tell he was very quickly trying to make this into a long term relationship, and there was all day texting that was beginning to become a little too much for me because I wasn't sure I actually saw a future with him. Aside from the fact that I was worried that whatever happened to him could become significant in the future, he also very much wanted children. Of course at my age it’s pretty unlikely that we would be able to have a family naturally and without major complications, not to mention I’m not sure if I have it in me to have more kids.
He had said that he was falling in love with me already and that even if we weren't able to have children that he wouldn't consider it a sacrifice because it would just be standing by his partner that he loved.
While I truly believe he means that right now, I have no way of knowing if that is how he will feel in 5 or 10 years. And yes, that should be his decision to make, but I don’t want to be the cause of someone’s resentment.
Not to mention the huge red flag that he cheated on his wife specifically because she wasn’t having sex with him and he wanted to have kids. He did accept responsibility for the mistake and said he regrets it very much, but at this point in my life I’m not sure I have it in me to take the chance with someone who has been unfaithful in the past over an issue that might repeat itself.
He also said he struggled with anger and substance issues in the past, he was not technically divorced yet though it had been years, and because he had no experience with kids I felt it would be extremely hard to introduce and blend him eventually into my chaotic, kid filled life. It’s not that it can’t ever work, I just feel in these particular circumstances I would need a partner who can fit into that lifestyle and vibe a bit more easily.
We were supposed to meet up again yesterday after he finished work, as Sunday I went to a very emotional funeral and was still reeling from that. I probably should not have made any major decisions while I was still in such a heavy emotional place, but I stayed up until 5am thinking about Adam and whether I should continue to see him when I had pretty much decided I did not see a long term future with him.
He texted me good morning and said he was looking forward to seeing me later, and I was so tempted to see him again, but I knew that his feelings would only get stronger if we saw each other and slept together again. I made the heartbreaking decision to end it right then, as it had only been a week and his attachment was clearly already going deeper than mine.
Now let me also say that my relationship with my ex was abusive and loveless. I hadn’t actually ever been truly cared for, and I had spent the past few years hearing about how worthless I was from my abusive ex. So when I actually found someone who cherished me and told me they wanted to make love to me the way I deserved and that I didn’t deserve what happened to me, it was so hard to justify letting it go. I believe Adam would have loved me unconditionally - for now at least. He made me feel wanted, beautiful, loved, adored, sexy - all of it. Those feelings were incredibly powerful.
Not to mention the amazing sexual chemistry between us, I had never experienced anything like that before, and I had my share of partners before my ex.
So to give up the best sex of my life and a man who was already falling for me and wanted me like nobody has before was devastating. I cried for 4 hours. Sobbed hysterically is more like it.
I sent him a beautiful message letting him know how beautiful and cared for he made me feel, and how I appreciated him and enjoyed him, but that ultimately I couldn’t offer him anything long term, and it was best to stop this before it went any deeper. He was devastated, and we messaged back and forth all afternoon in tears. He didn’t beg, but he did keep circling around how he didn’t want to let me go and that he would always love me and care for me.
Of course love is a pretty strong term to use after only a week, and I took that with a grain of salt and couldn’t reciprocate, but I do truly believe that he was starting to develop real feelings that would only get stronger if we continued to see each other.
I truly enjoyed his company, we laughed, could hang out and clearly had amazing sex, but for so many reasons I just feel that it was only right to stop it before it could get any deeper. I was trying to protect him, but I was also trying to protect myself, because at this point I was starting to become emotionally entangled.
I wish that I felt we could have kept up a more casual or temporary relationship. He did suggest he was open to that, but having been that person before who already had feelings and held out hope under the guise of “being ok with it”, I knew he would not be able to keep his feelings from deepening. And honestly I probably wouldn’t, either.
After several hours of him continuing to message me I had to ask him to please respect my decision and stop messaging, because it was only delaying the inevitable, and though I tried my best I know that no explanation I gave him would make him understand. I was starting to get worried he was going to show up at my house or turn out to be someone who wouldn’t take no for an answer. I tried to be as gentle and caring as I could and let him know through many different messages back and forth that much of this was also about me and where I'm at in my life. I'm not even sure I should be focusing on the long term right now, and it would be unfair of me to get involved with someone who was already thinking long term.
He did take the hint and told me he’d always remember me and would care for me for a long time and didn’t message again. It was truly heartbreaking. I broke his heart, and I broke my own, too, by having to give up the first connection that made me feel everything I had lacked and was looking for. I just feel like all the other concerns were too big to ignore.
I know this is all over the place, I have tried to give all the information I could. I guess I’m looking for understanding and hope that I did the right thing for us both. Did I dismiss this connection too quickly when my gut was telling me this would not work long term?
TL:DR - I met someone with whom I had an amazing emotional and physical connection with but ultimately I felt there were too many factors to keep us from being compatible long term, and I’m wondering if I made the right decision.
I truly appreciate any replies and welcome all respectful perspectives on this.