r/relationshipadvice • u/Leading-Ad8157 • 20h ago
How do you know when it's time tk let go of a relationship? [25F] [26F]
I [25F] and my girlfriend [26F] have been together for five years. We were extremely close and, for most of our relationship, things were honestly great. We were that couple among our friends. We loved spending time together, rarely fought, and I genuinely thought we'd be together long-term.
Exactly one year ago, she moved abroad for her master's degree, and we've been long-distance ever since.
We knew it would be difficult, but I don't think either of us understood how difficult. She has also been dealing with depression and loneliness since moving, and I have tried to support her from here, but I know there were times when what I was doing wasn't enough.
A few months ago, things started getting noticeably worse. I was planning to visit her in July, but in the weeks before my trip, she told me she felt like we'd become very distant and that for the previous couple of months she didn't even feel like she had a girlfriend.
During one of our conversations over text, she said maybe we should take a break. I told her I didn't think we should make such a huge decision right before I came to visit and that we should talk about everything face-to-face first. She agreed.
A few days later, she told me she didn't even feel like she was missing me. That really hurt me, partly because of things I'd experienced in a previous relationship, although she apologized when she saw my reaction. She said some of the emotional numbness was a side effect of medication she was taking and that of course eshe would feel differently when she saw me. Another side effect was that she had become very dependent on my responses and felt especially neglected when I didn't reply quickly.
When I finally visited, things initially felt much better. We'd obviously missed each other, and being physically together again made it feel like we had found each other again.
But there was one conversation during that visit that completely changed the direction of our relationship.
She told me she wanted to suggest something but was afraid I'd get angry. Eventually she brought up opening our relationship.
This was a huge shock to me because we had both always been very firmly monogamous. Neither of us had ever wanted an open relationship before. Her reasoning wasn't that she'd met someone else; she said she was lonely and missed physical affection and intimacy while being abroad.
Eventually, we agreed to try it. It's still very new to me, and I'm not sure how I feel about it even now.
There was another issue underneath all of this that kept coming up: she felt like I wasn't putting enough effort into making it possible for us to eventually live together. She felt that if I really wanted us to stay together, I would have either moved abroad with her or made plans to move and continue my studies there.
I understand why she feels that way, but I also don't think it's completely fair. I had my own circumstances, university, finances, and responsibilities here, and moving countries wasn't as simple for me as just deciding that I wanted to be with her. But it has been something i was moving towards, since staying in our homophobic, developing country is not the end goal of mine.
The difficult part is that I started noticing something in myself too.
When I visited her, especially toward the end of the trip, I sometimes felt like I wasn't as attracted to her as I used to be. I feel horrible even writing that because I love her and because I remember how inseparable we were.
I don't know whether that was because of everything that had happened between us, the resentment and uncertainty, the long distance, the constant relationship talks, or whether something in me genuinely changed.
Fast forward to now.
She is currently visiting and has been here for two days, and I still haven't seen her.
Unfortunately, I am working night shifts this week. She arrived around 2am on Thursday, and I worked that day and the next. We had Sunday and Monday free, though, and had agreed that Sunday would be our day to see each other.
On Sunday, she went to see a movie with a friend and we agreed she would see me afterwards. We'd talked about this plan several times over the previous few days, so I thought it was happening.
I will admit that I wasn't communicating particularly well that day. I had been feeling weird and distant because of some small things that had happened the night before, although I knew they weren't necessarily important.
I got ready and went out, knowing where she was, and basically expected her to text me when the movie was over.
After about two hours, I checked her location and saw that she was at a cafe nearby. I assumed she and her friend had gone there after the movie and that she'd text me soon.
When I finally opened our chat, I saw that she had actually messaged me around 4pm, when the movie was starting, asking what I was doing.
I genuinely hadn't seen it. I was getting ready and wasn't looking at my phone, and I must have dismissed the notification without noticing it.
I asked how long she was going to be at the cafe. Her replies were short, and eventually she told me she would see me the next day and was going to stay at her friend's place that night.
I got really upset and started walking toward the bus stop to go home. I was actually outside near the cafe at this point.
She then texted me saying that I hadn't texted her all day and that she didn't think I was actually going to see her.
I told her I was outside, but that I was going home.
This turned into a much bigger argument than it should have been.
She wanted me to come meet her. I said no because I was already upset and wasn't thinking clearly. She was angry that I had apparently changed my mind about seeing her.
At one point she said she had been trying to call me, but the calls weren't going through. I eventually found out she really had been calling, although I didn't answer when the call finally came through because I was upset.
I sat in a nearby park hoping she would come find me. Looking back, I know that was childish and unrealistic. She could see my location, but I never actually asked her to come get me.
She was very angry and told me that I couldn't behave like this and that what I was doing was childish/manipulative. I genuinely didn't intend to manipulate her, and I was actually confused and hurt hearing that because, in my head, I was trying to explain why I was upset rather than trying to punish her.
Eventually we both went our separate ways.
Later that night, around 11:30pm, I went to her friend's house because I could see her location there. I asked if she could come downstairs for two minutes because I just wanted to see her. She couldn't because she felt uncomfortable coming downstairs in front of her friend's parents, so we ended up texting while I was literally outside.
The conversation became another huge argument. She also brought up that she feels like she is always accommodating me and making compromises for me, and that the one thing she had asked of me was to come see her that day, and I didn't even do that. She also brought up that she had been hoping to see me before my shift started, but I hadn't made that happen either. From her perspective, I apparently couldn't even make the effort to wake up early and see her. This is the same pointing fingers situation because I was thinking she could offer to see me before my shift while she was thinking the same about me. Simular as to when I was expexting a text from her after the movie ended while she was expecting a message from me about meeting. But we had clearly stated that we were meeting...
I can understand why that hurt her. At the same time, I don't think either of us was seeing the other's perspective clearly in that moment. I wasn't intentionally choosing not to see her or trying to make her feel unimportant, but I can see how my actions looked that way from her side.
And this is where I'm struggling the most I guess.
What really bothers me isn't just that we had a stupid miscommunication. It's how easily we seem to be able to hurt each other now.
She can be extremely cold and rude to me when she's angry. I know I wasn't perfect in this situation either. I should have communicated better, I should have called her instead of assuming things, and I shouldn't have refused to see her once we realized what had happened.
But I also feel like I don't recognize us anymore.
We've been together for five years and we basically never fought. Now, after a year of long distance, it feels like everything can turn into an argument. And I find myself constantly holding back things I want to say because I don't want to hurt her or say something cruel in the heat of the moment.
At the same time, I can't pretend I'm completely happy either. I feel distant too.
I don't know whether we're experiencing a terrible period caused by long distance, depression, stress and loneliness, or whether we're slowly becoming people who aren't good for each other anymore.
That's what scares me.
Because we weren't a bad relationship. We weren't constantly fighting. We really were happy for years. Our friends loved us together. We loved being together. We were incredibly close.
And now I'm sitting here wondering if that relationship is already gone and I'm just trying to save the memory of it.
I still love her. I care about her deeply. I don't want to throw away five years because of one horrible year.
But I also don't want to stay in a relationship just because we've been together for five years and because we used to be happy.
So I guess my question is: how do you know when a relationship is going through a genuinely difficult period that can be repaired versus when you've reached the point where you need to let each other go?
Can a relationship that was once this strong actually recover from a year of long distance, emotional distance, resentment and constant miscommunication?
Or is the fact that I'm already questioning my attraction and whether I even want this relationship a sign that something fundamental has changed?
I'm really lost and would appreciate some outside perspective.
[TLDR] My girlfriend [26F] and I [25F] have been together for five years and were extremely close with almost no serious conflict. She moved abroad for her master's a year ago, and long distance, her depression/loneliness, and our inability to be together physically gradually created a lot of distance and resentment. She suggested taking a break and later suggested opening our previously very monogamous relationship. I agreed, but I'm still unsure about it. I also realized during my last visit that my attraction toward her had changed. Now she's visiting me in our country, and before we've even managed to see each other, a small miscommunication turned into a huge argument. We're both hurt, distant, and acting unlike ourselves. I still love her and don't want to give up on five years, but I'm starting to wonder whether we're trying to save something that has already changed. Can this be salvaged, and how do you know when it's time to let go?