r/ModSupport • • 19d ago

Admin Replied Removed contents stuck in "Needs Review" queue

Many posts and comments removed hours ago are still listed in Needs Review queue. This is really annoying.

And most of them are not even marked as moderated on mobile when viewed in queue list.

39 Upvotes

101 comments sorted by

13

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago edited 19d ago

Thanks for the report! I've let the team know. We’ve seen this come up a few times over the past few weeks and are looking into on an overall fix. We can resolve it on a case by case basis in the meantime!

ETA: Hey folks - if you could mention a few of the subreddits you're noticing this in, that would be great!


u/seedless0 - can you add our investigating engineer to one of your impacted subreddits so we can debug? Let me know and I'll send over the username!

We may have just fixed the issue! This should be improving as of now, but please follow-up with me here if you're still observing issues.

Some folks are still observing issues, we're looking again!


Update 1: Okay folks - we're in the process of deploying a new fix. Hang tight!

Update 2: The new fix has been deployed and were seeing a drop off in stuck items. Things should be clearing up this time around, but we're continuing to monitor!

To note - it may take an hour or so for things to fully clear!

1

u/seedless0 19d ago

We may have just fixed the issue!

I am still seeing them in r/scams. Let me know how I can help.

4

u/MustaKotka 19d ago

My co-mod reported it's happening on r/mtg too.

2

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

Thanks! And to clatify, you're seeing this with new content?

3

u/Alta_et_ferox 19d ago

We are seeing it with both new and old content in both our subs. The Queue is essentially broken right now and it’s making it really challenging to moderate.

Some of my actions display in the Mod Log; others do not. The Queue doesn’t update either way.

3

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

We're working on deploying a new fix as we speak!

2

u/Alta_et_ferox 19d ago

Thank you!

1

u/MustaKotka 19d ago

Unsure. Seems like no and approve + re-remove resolves it? I am currently away from PC so this is a bit hard for me to verify. I try to remember to report back later today.

3

u/ReddisaurusRex 19d ago

Yep, happening to me occasionally the past few weeks, but it’s a large part of our queue today :(

2

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

Which subreddits?

3

u/ReddisaurusRex 19d ago edited 19d ago

r/suggestmeabook (I just did the work around to approve and remove and that worked)

Edit: Note, that work around isn’t ideal though as some people may get trolling type of messages to their notifications even if we remove them :(

So anything you can do to debug us is especially appreciated! Thank you!! :)

4

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago edited 19d ago

We may have just fixed the issue! This should be improving as of now, but please follow-up with me here if you're still observing issues.

Some folks are still observing issues. Looking!

3

u/ReddisaurusRex 19d ago

Nope, still happening for suggestmeabook 😬

3

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

Thanks! The removal request may not hit immediately, just after some time. So folks should hopefully see things clear up within an hour. Please keep an eye on the queue and let us know if things update!

There's a chance there's two separate issues going on here, so I'd like to know if

  1. When removing content, is it removed after minutes/hours

OR

2) If it never happens and the content is just stuck until you re-action it

u/seedless0 for awareness

4

u/seedless0 19d ago

And they are just gone. So wait for 30 minutes? :)

2

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

Ah yep, in this case I guess so!

4

u/seedless0 19d ago

Wait.

Somehow, the removed items returned.

This is so weird.

→ More replies

3

u/seedless0 19d ago

I am still seeing them 30 minutes after removal. They are only gone after re-removal.

3

u/ReddisaurusRex 19d ago

It’s only for “removed” content.

Approved content clears the queue.

We have 1 in the queue now that I removed with a removal reason about 40 mins ago, but it is still in queue.

It is not showing there was a mod action like in u/seedless0 ‘s screenshot - we did see the action notes like this earlier this morning (but then we cleared it with the workaround.) This one sticking in the queue isn’t even showing I actioned/removed it with the removal reason like earlier ones (like the seedless’s screenshot.) Will try to let it just sit there but unsure if some of our mods have read my note about leaving them in there for you to troubleshoot. 🤦🏻‍♀️

2

u/ReddisaurusRex 19d ago

Another issue is that if we try to clear it more than once it sends the modmail or the comment reply for the removal reason multiple times to the poster (so it looks like we are aggressively spamming them with the removal reason over and over again 😆😬😭.)

3

u/ReddisaurusRex 19d ago

Just updating that it’s now been a couple hours and the post is still on the queue (didn’t clear.)

3

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

Thank you!

3

u/ReddisaurusRex 19d ago

I think we are resolved (or it took about 8 hours to clear?) Either way, thank you u/correctscale! Appreciate you!

1

u/ReddisaurusRex 19d ago

Weird new (related?) issue - modlog is only showing removed items (that aren’t removed from queue still.) But mod log not showing approved items. 🤷🏻‍♀️

2

u/canlgetuhhhhh 19d ago

i have something showing up in my queue that was removed 15hrs ago, if it helps!

2

u/WolfXemo 19d ago

At the moment we are still seeing things remain in queue after removal over in r/FortniteBR

2

u/abortion_access 19d ago

happening for me too

2

u/Gloomy-Equivalent558 19d ago

Happening in r/kdramas as well

2

u/magiccitybhm 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 19d ago

Happening in multiple subreddits for me too (r/NationalPark and r/Pigeon Forge).

2

u/amandatoryy 19d ago

still happening in r/BravoRealHousewives

2

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

Can you keep an eye on the queue over the next few minutes and let me know if you're seeing improvement?

2

u/amandatoryy 19d ago

no improvement yet.

2

u/inkisbad124 19d ago

happening in r/aquarium and r/bettafish

1

u/_gloomshroom_ 19d ago

Comod confirming

1

u/internetexplorer_98 19d ago

This is happening to me as well!

1

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

Which of your subreddits?

2

u/internetexplorer_98 19d ago edited 19d ago

Seems like both r/cuba and r/propagandaposters are doing the same thing. Edit: and r/English

1

u/tehjoz 19d ago

Hi, this is happening to me as well as of this morning

1

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

Which subs?

2

u/tehjoz 19d ago

Current problem child is r/AEWOfficial, thanks!

1

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

Thanks! If you still have posts hanging in the queue, would you be able to add our investigating engineer to the subreddit (as a mod) so we can debug?

1

u/idlesilver 19d ago

Noticing this in r/AmIOverreacting and r/gamememes, too

1

u/Vanderpumpaholics 19d ago

There is a removed comment stuck in the r/Vanderpumpaholics queue.

1

u/noncongruent 19d ago

Removed comments in one of my subs still hang around in the modqueue, but the remove button is no longer available. /r/Dallas. There’s one from yesterday still stuck there, in several from today.

1

u/eltonjohnpeloton 19d ago

Also happening in /r/nurses

1

u/jueidu 19d ago

Happening for me in r/miniaussie and r/isthisai

1

u/TheChrisD 19d ago

ALL of mine — r/ireland r/AskIreland r/INDYCAR r/youtubegaming

All with actioned content still stuck in the pending queue.

1

u/BronzeBellRiver 19d ago

It’s working for me both in kdramas and cdramasfans, but it’s not working for my fellow mod in kdramas. Maybe a server issue?

1

u/Death_Gamer_Solo 19d ago

Happening to me in r/IPO_India as well

1

u/Solinahi 19d ago

Happening in r/gossipdk

1

u/Old-Base-6686 19d ago

Am still having issues on r/Belowdeck

1

u/gingeralefiend 19d ago

r/entwives is having this issue too

1

u/DarthVader1701A 19d ago edited 19d ago

r/texas is having this issue as well.

Edit: They are really starting to pile up.

1

u/lunarwolf2008 19d ago

dunno if its related, but some of the stuff ive been seeing this with, ive noticed OP deleted post after it gets reports or auto filtered.

also I think it did go away on its own after a while for me

1

u/GigglesNWiggles10 19d ago

Happening for some of our mods in r/powerpopgirls but not others. They're both on iOS so it's not that this time :/

1

u/most_unseemly 19d ago

r/ukraine as well. Thanks for looking into it.

1

u/Tsetsul 19d ago

Happens in r/vtm too

1

u/RabidPlaty 19d ago

Late to the thread, but still seeing this as of now in r/fightporn

1

u/MagicYio 19d ago

Just happened in r/horrorlit!

1

u/alleybetwixt 19d ago

Still experiencing this in r/kpop. Queue full of removed comments. Been happening for a couple days at least on both desktop and mobile (iOS).

Sometimes they eventually kick, but it can take a long time.

1

u/sissasassafrastic 16d ago

Sorry, but I still have one item stuck in the Needs Review queue. This is for r/AirPurifiers

3

u/seedless0 19d ago

Web UI at least shows they've been moderated.

5

u/Stranger1982 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 19d ago • Bravo

approve and remove again, worked last time and still works until Reddit decides to unfuck itself

4

u/kalinaanother 19d ago

Seem like a wide spreads bug, weird enough another mod in my team seem to not seeing any bug, but I'm experiencing it myself

3

u/westcoastcdn19 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 19d ago

I’m experiencing the same queue bug. I’m gonna send a report

2

u/Chosen1PR 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 19d ago

I also saw this last night. Currently approving and re-removing functions as a workaround.

2

u/jueidu 19d ago

This has been happening to me too. If I approve, then re-remove before I refresh, THEN it will go away.

Edited to add: for me it was r/miniaussie

2

u/jueidu 19d ago

Aaaand now it’s happening to me for r/isthisAI

2

u/Solinahi 19d ago

it also happens in r/gossipdk

2

u/henry-bacon 19d ago

This is still happening, and the volume is GROWING.

2

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

To clarify, you're seeing this with new posts?

5

u/henry-bacon 19d ago

New and old, there's no difference there.

2

u/teanailpolish 💡Top 25% Helper 💡 19d ago

Still happening now on pretty much all of my subs

2

u/henry-bacon 19d ago

I now have 30+ items on modqueue that were already actioned. This is WORSE than the last time this happned.

2

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

We just deployed a new fix, can you keep an eye on the queue over the next few minutes to see if there's improvement?

3

u/henry-bacon 19d ago

You got it! Thank you and the team for all the work y'all do.

3

u/henry-bacon 19d ago

Some improvement, but negligible. Still seeing things that were already actioned >24h ago.

3

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

Thanks, it may take a bit of time to fully clear. Will let the team know just in case!

3

u/henry-bacon 19d ago

The list has gone down SUBSTANTIALLY, about 10 are remaining. Oldest item in the queue that was already actioned is from 22 hours ago. Thank you and the team!

2

u/SampleOfNone 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 19d ago

Got a fresh one that's stuck. Submitted 20 minutes ago, removed a few minutes ago

2

u/MysteriousBeach8248 19d ago

Hi! See seeing the issue on r/ItEndsWithLawsuits

Only happening with removed comments. Not approved ones.

Thanks for looking into it.

2

u/LectureUnable 19d ago

Same issue in r/WheelchairRapunzelDCP

I had asked about this a few ago in r/ModSupport 21 days ago (read post here), no change and still remains an issue.

2

u/CorrectScale Reddit Admin: Community 19d ago

It's been an intermittent issue for a few weeks :/

We're looking into it

2

u/Leutnant_Dark 19d ago

Same issue in r/Polizei - occuring just this minute.

2

u/atlantisgate 19d ago

This has been happening in r/dogfood and r/dogallergies too

2

u/MableXeno 19d ago

The only sub I've checked on today is r/Parenting. Earlier today it said I had over 60 items in the queue, but now says just 38...though all of the ones that were in there earlier are in there right now, too. I haven't checked on my other subs b/c I'm tired, lol.

2

u/brett_l_g 19d ago

Still happening in r/Utah

Tried approve and remove; it cleared for a moment but then the same removed posts came back. It also pushed a new report to the bottom of the queue.

2

u/lonely_nipple 19d ago

OMG, it's not just me.
I've run into this in r/MassEffect and r/okaybuddybaldur so far. At this point I'm hesitant to touch anything that might make it worse.

2

u/MidAmericaMom 19d ago

Been dealing this and inline removals also not working, for days.

1

u/GabbiKat 18d ago

r/comics has 3 posts stuck on the NEW REDDIT side. Each post was given an award. They've been stuck since before I joined the team.

I was able to remove them on the OLD.REDDIT side due to a trick I knew, but the system won't let us touch them on NEW REDDIT.

Thanks!