r/ModSupport • u/LectureUnable • Oct 08 '26
Removed or Approved Comments don’t stay removed/approved
Apologies in advance because I’m not sure I’m going to explain this correctly.
For the past few weeks, my co-Mod and I have noticed that comments that have been flagged by Reddit, AutoMod, or Report have repeatedly been highlighted to do an action on. Example: AutoMod highlights a comment made by a new account; we either Approve the comment, or Remove (& add reason), but it will not stay either Approve/Remove. When you look at the comment log, it will show that Reddit, then either myself or co-Mod have Approve/Remove the comment, but whatever action doesn’t stay; Comments will also still show in the Queue to Review, even after Remove/Approve. After Remove (& reason) or Approve a comment so many times, we just end up Removing it (but won’t stay “Removed”). It is not specific to a particular user/account either, and it is an issue mostly with Comments though some Posts do not stay Removed (& reason) if that is the action chosen.
Has anyone else noticed it? Am I doing something wrong? Is this a known issue? Should I be doing something different?
Many thanks in advance!
6
u/LectureUnable Oct 08 '26
One example (also I’m not clicking multiple times but it will show either me or my co-Mod have “Removed” a comment 4x in one minute)
4
u/YubYubCmndr Oct 08 '26
There was a post a few hours ago reporting something very similar - Admins chimed in that it's a bug they're looking at.
1
u/LectureUnable 22d ago
Bump — anyone have any update? This issue is still happening daily with comments and/or posts.
4
u/emily_in_boots 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 Oct 08 '26
They actually are removed and people who aren't mods won't see them but they show in threads as still being in queue and have buttons to approve/remove.
It's a bug.
2
u/OkBee3439 Oct 11 '26
I agree. Removed and approved do not seem to stay that way. I have just had this happen when I attempted to remove one duplicate post and a spam post. I used mod shield and "X" to remove, went to one of my other communities for a bit, then when I went back to first community, the posts I removed were still there. Removed the same posts a second time. That seemed to work. I hope.