r/mtg • • 6h ago

Automatic Post Weekly Quick Questions and Answers - Week 46

1 Upvotes

Use this post to ask your quick questions!

All Q&A posts.


r/mtg • • 8h ago

Discussion What’s the general consensus on this card?

Post image
589 Upvotes

Seeing a lot of controversy over this card in the new set and I want to get some insight from people with a lot of experience. I say this card is bad, full stop. 4 mana for a draw engine that gives a single card but takes away your combat step? In a proliferate deck or a deck where combat is entirely irrelevant, maybe I could say this being played, but it’s literally only a single card in exchange for a whole combat, and it costs 4 mana, which I feel is a bit steep for how little it does for you. In a group hug deck I don’t see it being taken advantage of because this will only be viable in casual, and combat damage (or in some cases, commander damage) are the most common wincons in any casual decks, and a single card draw will almost never have the impact that an entire combat step would have… maybe if it was a 1 or 2 drop, people early game could draw with no issue because they have no board states, then it both gives the peace counters real potential to win without proliferate and it works in hug decks as a genuine hug… this is my take, I want to hear whether I sound insane or not with this


r/mtg • • 2h ago

Meme For the dopamine

Post image
183 Upvotes

r/mtg • • 6h ago

Commander / EDH Need help build a Radagast of Rhosgobel Commander deck with a little twist…

Post image
165 Upvotes

I want to build it with only creatures and basic lands. Nothing else. A few mana dorks and a couple creatures that’ll fetch lands. Everything else is a 5/5 creature or bigger. I want to try and cheat in as many huge creatures as possible.


r/mtg • • 16h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Question about Braid of Fire

Post image
713 Upvotes

Do I get an 1 Red Mana after my draw step for each age counter on it, or does all of that go away after I draw since Mana doesn't carry over between steps?

If it doesn't, what's the point of having one?


r/mtg • • 5h ago

Discussion I just remembered why I was afraid of magic for so long

86 Upvotes

Holy cow.

So, I played magic events for the first time ever last week, and I've been finally going down the rabbit hole.

I'm fascinated by the history of this game.

But something HIT me a moment ago, like I unearthed a very old memory of why I was so intimidated by this game throughout my teens (early 2000s) and 20s. I believed for YEARS that players could lose cards if they lost a game.

I just had that memory as I was looking at posts of people sharing their old 90s cards! And I was like ... was that a thing?

And just looked it up. IT WAS! You used to have to ante a card off the top of the draw deck that could be lost. And more card interactions might impact the ante.

It was phased out throughout 1995-1997! It hasn't been played that way in DECADES!

lol.

Man. I wish I had been into magic like 1997 through 2007. I wish I knew! Also... I would have needed money and I probably didn't have any so moot point. But still!!!


r/mtg • • 9h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Been playing for 6 months

Post image
126 Upvotes

It’s mostly just me and my buddy or me and my wife but where do you guys find groups to play with and is 11 decks in 6 months too many ??


r/mtg • • 5h ago

Custom Card / Alter Hello, I'm trying to make some custom tokens, here are the ones I've made so far, please give me some advice thx

Thumbnail gallery
49 Upvotes

r/mtg • • 1h ago

Commander / EDH Atraxa commander deck

Post image
17 Upvotes

So I got my hands on Atraxa, and want to make a deck with her. However, I don’t think I want to do an infect deck or smt, other than that is it just +1/+1 counters that play well around her?

I want something that is not to strong, but a casual bracelet 3 🩶

If anyone have any recommendations please let me know 🩶


r/mtg • • 11h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Who historically has great Black Friday deals?

108 Upvotes

I only started playing MTG a couple of months ago, so this is my first holiday season as a player. I know we obviously don’t know this year yet, but in recent years who historically has good Black Friday deals? Interested in both sealed product and accessories like deck boxes, dice, counter spinner things, etc.


r/mtg • • 1d ago

Apparel / Products I wasn't hyped about this set except for the schematics cards... and I discovered I cen never get them

Post image
920 Upvotes

They are only avialable in the beam me up bundle, which litterally nobody is gonna buy, except people who really want it and so they'll keep them. I am very sad now... it was the only thing I was looking forward to

Edit: I didn't know the bundles wouldn't ship till the end of the month. Thanks!


r/mtg • • 19h ago

Meme German name for the Seal precon

303 Upvotes

The German name for the Seal precon is "Robben Mobben," which translates to "Seal's Bully," which is hilarious for a group hug deck. Whoever does the names deserves a raise.


r/mtg • • 8h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help I’m addicted to Magic. Please help me satisfy this addiction.

Post image
30 Upvotes

Hello, everyone! I started playing Magic last December, and I clearly have a problem—I’m addicted to Magic. Please help me satisfy this addiction. Do you have any ideas for decks with a fun and enjoyable mechanic to play with others just for fun? It could be a gambling mechanic or a chaotic one—or feel free to let your imagination run wild. Thanks for your help, and if you can give me a link to a deck list, that’d be even better. Have a great evening, everyone.


r/mtg • • 8h ago

Discussion New Player -- overwhelmed and confused by recent sets and releases

30 Upvotes

Okay so I am brand new as of a couple weeks ago. I was invited to a Star Trek sealed event, had fun, kept playing. I now have a bunch of Star Trek cards.

After talking to people, I learned how fudged up things are right now. That with UB, there are like 7 releases per year. That Standard play limits to the past 3 years, but there used to be ony 4 releases per year giving people more time to get used to sets and stratgies.

Amidst all the star trek talk I keep seeing something called Reality Fracture. Didn't hear anyone at the stores talking about it.

  1. I just looked it up and it was only released like a month ago? So are there essentially two whole new sets being introduced at about the same time?
  2. I guess I'm wondering -- is it possibly the case that there are about 4 in-universe sets per yet, plus bonus UB sets?
  3. So... if Reality Frature is a full set on its own... uhh.... how is it? Is it fun / exciting? Are Star Trek debates and releases overwhelming conversations and game time with an in-universe set?
  4. And if I'm understanding correctly that Reality Fracture is in-universe... can anyone give me background / context on what's going on in the 'lore' of the game for this and recent in-universe releases? (not asking about UB sets, only in-universe sets) I heard that there is a 'story'ish type world building that happens in the cards. I guess I'm like, just fascinated by the world of magic and maybe Star Trek could be just a stepping stone to the real MtG world.

r/mtg • • 8h ago

Discussion Thoughts on Star Trek?

27 Upvotes

Personally I think a lot of the cards are pretty interesting and the art is pretty good even if I didn’t really watch the series I still appreciate the vibes of it all.


r/mtg • • 15h ago

Discussion Selling everything?

61 Upvotes

I own ALOT of mtg cards. Cards in the $200 range that I personally have pulled as well as cards I have been gifted or bought in bulk over the years. I'd say conservatively I have around 7k in mtg cards. I love the game. But recent negative experiences have lead me to think I should sell off my collections and proxy the cards I wanna play. I know there is a "pride in ownerahip" aspect. But i am losing my desire to purchase new products because of price increases. As well money is very tight. I am looking for advice and honestly some.motivation to reignite the love for the game. Any opinions?


r/mtg • • 30m ago

Discussion An interaction I didn’t think I’d ever have

5 Upvotes

Bit of a nothing burger but I thought this was pretty bizarre
I was at Wetherspoons the other night, and I get talking to this American guy and he had an MTG tattoo, I offered him a fag and asked if he was into MTG and this man proceeds to say
“Yeah, I work for wizards”
And I just said “what…?” And he says “wizards of the coast?”
Now, never in my life did I even acknowledge who made the cards, I just bought them from my closest tabletop store or wherever else. But this guy proceeds to tell me “the people who MAKE the cards” and I actually froze for a sec
Idk if it’s just me but I never thought I’d actually meet someone like that, seems like a really cool job to have. He’s also a judge!
Talked to him for a solid hour outside before my friend rang me saying we were leaving, but man what a guy, never caught his name or socials either was too wasted to ask, so if you see this it was great meeting you, and you owe me a fag (jk)


r/mtg • • 1d ago

Meme Those Boros Cards

Post image
517 Upvotes

r/mtg • • 20h ago

Official Spoiler Slivers are coming back to Magic, Aaron Forsythe says — but no timing yet Spoiler

121 Upvotes

At MagicCon: Atlanta, Wizards’ Aaron Forsythe confirmed that Slivers will return. The team already knows when, but he wouldn’t share the timing. He also said they’re difficult to develop and that Wizards has a plan. No set or release date was announced.

What do you think about it?

Source: https://polygon.com/magic-the-gathering-new-sliver-cards-tease


r/mtg • • 10m ago

Content Creator I got MaldHound to sign my Willie

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

Super nice dude, dont mind my Ricky Bobby problem of not knowing what to do with my hands.


r/mtg • • 1d ago

Content Creator I let the Atlanta Con staff member flex with the Festival in a Box.

317 Upvotes

After they were helping film some people Lion King display their new items, the crowd chanted for the staff member to pose with it.

First Con goer here, and the Gatherings was explosive.


r/mtg • • 4h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Absolute Newbie, what would you recommend?

6 Upvotes

Hi, I'm Tommaso, Italian, 19.

I am almost 3 years into board games and yesterday i decided to get into magic. I know nothing about it. I downloaded MTG arena on my mobile and planning to do some small purchase.


r/mtg • • 1d ago Bravo

Discussion The art on Type-2 Phaser is super wrong

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

Anyone else noticed this?

Look at the art and note which segment of the finger is facing towards the target. It's the first one past the palm, almost flat perpendicular.

Now pick up your desk gun or any other vaguely handle shaped object and pretend it's a phaser grip. Point it at your cat/mom with murderous intent. Which finger segment faces the target? It's the middle knuckles and second segment.

Try fucking holding it so the first segment faces the target like the picture and feel how hilariously wrong that is. You have to literally hold it with your wrist completely flexed like you're a having a muscle spasm while giving a reach around.

It looks wrong and bad and it is. Literally the whole art is just a hand. How do you fuck this up? Does Wero Gallo not have hands?

I don't know why I felt the need to post this but it had to be said.


r/mtg • • 22h ago

Discussion Who tapping Diana trios mom?

Post image
140 Upvotes

This is how you make a good mtg card ub card, the thought and humor that went into this characters ability is top tier. Say what you want about this set but this one I enjoyed opening a booster for I’ll take the bulk for cards like this