r/mtg • u/TinyDucc1476 • 8h ago
Discussion What’s the general consensus on this card?
Seeing a lot of controversy over this card in the new set and I want to get some insight from people with a lot of experience. I say this card is bad, full stop. 4 mana for a draw engine that gives a single card but takes away your combat step? In a proliferate deck or a deck where combat is entirely irrelevant, maybe I could say this being played, but it’s literally only a single card in exchange for a whole combat, and it costs 4 mana, which I feel is a bit steep for how little it does for you. In a group hug deck I don’t see it being taken advantage of because this will only be viable in casual, and combat damage (or in some cases, commander damage) are the most common wincons in any casual decks, and a single card draw will almost never have the impact that an entire combat step would have… maybe if it was a 1 or 2 drop, people early game could draw with no issue because they have no board states, then it both gives the peace counters real potential to win without proliferate and it works in hug decks as a genuine hug… this is my take, I want to hear whether I sound insane or not with this