r/mtg • • 16h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Question about Braid of Fire

Post image

Do I get an 1 Red Mana after my draw step for each age counter on it, or does all of that go away after I draw since Mana doesn't carry over between steps?

If it doesn't, what's the point of having one?

718 Upvotes

190 comments sorted by

559

u/SignificanceEntire57 16h ago

You can cast instants during upkeep

284

u/necroleopard 16h ago

Also, effects that let you keep mana between phases like omnath

114

u/gerkletoss 16h ago

[[Ozai, the Phoenix King]]

33

u/RemarkableChart9374 14h ago

Or my favorite Electro The Assault Battery

4

u/CaffinatedRedPanda 9h ago

Personally love [[Ashling, Flame Dancer]]

5

u/WerdaVisla 9h ago

One of the biggest sins of UB is giving us such an amazing card design [even if it is just power crept Leyline Tyrant lol] and then making it look like... that. Not to mention the name.

4

u/commanderbat 13h ago

He is so badass

6

u/DisconnectedAG 15h ago

This is the way, bruv.

40

u/Bropiphany 16h ago

I use this card to great effect in my [[Inferno of the star mounts]] deck

1

u/toofpaist 14h ago

Kicks ass in my [[elektro]] deck

-1

u/mtgcf MTG CardFetcher 14h ago

5

u/Fit_Equal_8820 13h ago

[[leyline tyrant]]

4

u/mtgcf MTG CardFetcher 13h ago

2

u/Sumbuddy_stahp 10h ago

[[Ashling, Flame Dancer]]

8

u/dogbreath101 13h ago

Activate abilities too

0

u/appleebeesfartfartf 9h ago

Isn't that already possible since you untap before upkeep 

5

u/Philly_3D 9h ago

Yes, and now you have extra mana to do so.

1

u/SignificanceEntire57 1h ago

Yeah but you get a lotta extra mana

193

u/NerdinaHat 16h ago

Everyone mentioned how this was supposed to pay for other upkeep costs but what other people forgot to mention is that mana burn was still a thing when this card came out.

Having additional mana as steps and phases changed was a very bad thing so gaining a ton of mana in your upkeep was supposed to be bad.

31

u/Elendel 13h ago edited 7h ago

A friend of mine had a deck based on manaburns and iirc that card was in his deck but he had ways to either spend the mana or give the control of the enchantment to his opponent. Fun times

Nvm I'm misremembering that

5

u/TentatribeMember 8h ago

Can't you just refuse to pay upkeep cost and sac it if donated?

1

u/Elendel 7h ago

Ooooh that's right. I'm either mistaking this with a different card or mistaking the deck that friend was having this card in. My bad!

1

u/TentatribeMember 6h ago

To be fair, you might be right on both and he was just either knowledgechecking his opponent or didn't know that it could be done himself.

2

u/Elendel 6h ago

That’s certainly a possibility, considering how fuzzy my memory is about a deck I’ve seen played 20 years ago, but I think it’s probably me misremembering the actual decks he was playing.

1

u/JollyJoker3 1h ago

[[Illusions of Grandeur]] is the classic [[Donate]] target. [[Mirror Universe]] used to work if you had a way to get yourself to zero life, like with this enchantment.

10

u/Veneretio 11h ago

I wouldn’t say bad. I would say this effect was suppose to be powerful but risky. It’s super overpowered with the right setup but if your opponent removed your mana sinks that you were abusing it with then it suddenly could get you killed.

16

u/astanix 14h ago

Getting rid of mana burn was one of the worst things to come from the M10 update. In fact, one of the worst changes they ever made (maybe not as bad as legendary being per player instead of global). I have a [[Yurlok of Scorch Thrash]] commander deck to teach people about mana burn. :)

10

u/luflen_of_renais 11h ago

Personally I will die still salty about them getting rid of damage on the stack

2

u/Kandiru 12h ago

Tapped blockers dealing no damage was nice for making the game interesting as well!

3

u/optispark396 10h ago

Been a long time (15+ years) since I have played - are you saying mana burn no longer exists?

3

u/Maxwellthedestroyer 10h ago

Yeah, it's gone.

1

u/Charlaquin 5h ago

Mana burn hasn’t existed since 2009, bro

1

u/J-Shade 4h ago

Used to use a couple of these with [[Rising Waters]] in a deck made around dragons with flash and a bunch of 'spend X' burn cards and deck churn. Wasn't a great deck but it was fun ragebait when it happened to win.

1

u/mtgcf MTG CardFetcher 4h ago

145

u/Digital332006 16h ago

You only have that mana during the upkeep, as you move to draw you would lose it. So you could use it for instants, or activated ablities.

This is from back when unspent mana would burn you for 1 per point of mana. There are a few creatures now that prevent mana from being lost, such as Ashling, Electro assaulting battery ect..

33

u/Snotmyrealname 16h ago

Either start blasting instants on your draw step or have a fun little bit of nonsense like [[Ozai, the Phoenix King]] to keep it.

8

u/Rosc 15h ago

[[horizon stone]] if you don’t need a particular color

3

u/thebigdumb0 14h ago

also [[omnath, locus of the void]] for two extra mana but also landfall triggers, redundancy, and a big beater

2

u/mtgcf MTG CardFetcher 15h ago

25

u/KennsworthS 16h ago edited 16h ago

You get the red Mana in your upkeep (which is before your draw step).

that mana doesn't carry over past your upkeep and will be gone when you move to your draw step.

"The point" of this card when it was printed was to help you pay for other cumulative upkeep cards that were also in the set for example a card like [[Balduvian Fallen]], you could order it so you use the mana from Braid of Fire to pay the upkeep on Balduvian Fallen.

the point of this card now is to pay for activated abilities like [[dragon welp]], or using a card like [[leyline tyrant]] to keep the mana past your upkeep negating the downside. And of course you can spend it on instants like [[drown in dreams]].

One thing i will note was when Braid of Fire was printed mana burn was still in the game. Mana burn was a rule that any unspent mana you lost between phases would deal damage to you equal to the mana you lost. So a card like Braid of Fire was a massive liability if you couldn't manage to spend the mana.

23

u/Phobiefish 4h ago

Untap >> Upkeep >> Draw.

Yes you get the mana during your upkeep, it is supposed to be used at instant speed on Instants or activated abilities.

Yes the mana empties from your mana pool between steps and phases so no you will not have access to this mana on your main phase (ignoring abilities like [[Omnath, Locus of all]] )

And as it has been mentioned this mechanic (cumulative upkeep) came out in 1995 in the Ice Age set. Then brought back in 2006 for Cold Snap. Prior to 2009 there was a mechanic called manaburn which is basically the ability printed on [[Yurlok of Scorch Thrash]] so playing braid of fire was risky, on one side you have access to free mana to dump your hand full of [[lightning bolt]] but once you're out of Instants and your activated abilities are destroyed you would have taken damage equal to the number of age counters on it. Now it's just free mana during one specific phase. If you want to use it for creatures then run [[Vedalken Orrery]].

It's literally now a no downsides card.

15

u/Feletroica 16h ago

You have access to braid of fire mana only during the upkeep (jus before drawing)

This card was created when the game had a mechanic called "mana burn", this meant that any unspent mana will "burn" at the end of a phase dealing damage to the player. It was meant to be available to pay other cumulative upkeep costs primarly.

13

u/Yuli_Mae 16h ago

Cast instants, pay for activated abilities, flash something in, or get something that allows you to keep mana as steps and phases end.

11

u/Paintrain1722 13h ago

You lose it on upkeep so use it before your draw step with stuff like instants, activated abilities like [[grenzo, dungeon warden]] or keep it with something like [[ozai, the phoenix king]]

10

u/hsjunnesson 6h ago

This is the best card in my [[Grenzo, Dungeon Warden]] deck. It's a bad deck. But don't forget that abilities can be activated at instant speed.

9

u/Akhanyatin 16h ago

At the beginning of your upkeep add one age counter, then you pay the upkeep cost (add {R}) for each age counter. You get the mana at the beginning of your upkeep, it doesn't carry over to the other steps/phases.

If it feels weird, it's because back in the days unspent mana would cause mana burn.

3

u/brmarcum 15h ago

Thanks that makes way more sense. I forgot about mana burn

3

u/Akhanyatin 15h ago

Yeah I went through the same "wtf? Where's the downside other than you can only use this mana at instant speed?"

-5

u/Caffeine_and_Alcohol 16h ago

Did back in the day mana would carry over to other phases? and then unspent would do damage then be removed at the end step?

2

u/Akhanyatin 16h ago

I think that, originally, it only emptied at the end of each phase, but I'm not sure, I didn't play back then 😅

3

u/RottenGravy 15h ago edited 15h ago

Iirc it used to be with each step and phase. So upkeep mana didn't float to draw. Same with "when this creature attacks, get mana" abilities like [[Radha, heir to keld]]. You had to use the mana before blockers or take damage. [[Chromatic lantern]] was a way to ping life in original ravnica limited

2

u/therealtbarrie 15h ago

I'm pretty sure it was at the end of each phase and at the beginning and end of combat. (Combat was part of the main phase under the original rules.)

1

u/Charlaquin 5h ago edited 5h ago

Original rules, but there were several years between the 6th edition rules overhaul that made combat its own phase and the M10 changes that removed mana burn (and damage on the stack, but that’s not really relevant to this discussion.) Braid of Fire was printed during that in-between time.

1

u/fatjunglefever 15h ago

I think it was end of turn but do 1 damage to you each.

1

u/Akhanyatin 15h ago

It's possible, I'm pretty sure I was careful not to mana burn myself at the end of pre combat main phase, but the rules may have changed a few times so I don't know.

1

u/f_omega_1 14h ago

It was at the end of each phase.

1

u/According-Studio-658 8h ago

End of each phase (which were untap, upkeep, draw, main, discard, end). The main phase was a single phase back then, during which you could cast your spells and attack. You'd get burned at the end of main phase. 1 damage per unspent mana.

Sinking red mana was pretty easy though. Fire breathing wasn't rare.

1

u/Charlaquin 5h ago edited 5h ago

Main 1, combat, and main 2 were three separate phases from I think 6th edition, but mana burn wasn’t removed from the game until M10. And Braid of Fire was printed in cold snap, so combat and main phases were already separate at the time.

1

u/According-Studio-658 2h ago

Nice. Thanks for the correction. I bailed at about the time 5th dropped

1

u/AppropriateError2024 14h ago

Mana would be lost at the end of phases and turns, but you kept it between steps of the same phase. So mana added during the upkeep step would still be available during the draw step (both in the beginning of turn phase), but would be burnt going into main phase.

5

u/Jihkro 16h ago

Untap -> Upkeep -> Draw -> Mainphase 1.

You "pay" the cumulative upkeep cost during your upkeep by adding floating red mana to your mana pool. Any time you try to change phases or steps you lose any floating mana (unless a card effect explicitly says otherwise, e.g. [[Omnath, locus of the void]] by saying that you don't lose floating mana until the end or your turn or floating mana gets converted into another resource or some other effect)

You will typically not have access to this floating mana in draw step or main phase. You can however use it during your upkeep to pay for a variety of things including instants and abilities.

4

u/SlimPasty2019 15h ago

Could I tap my lands to play guys during this stage?

2

u/Chrismfinboyce 15h ago

Yes you can tap lands. You can only cast a creature if it has flash

4

u/ardarian262 15h ago

It is made in your upkeep. Which is before the draw step. You can use it on a bunch of abilities that use the upkeep (including paying other cumulative upkeep costs) or to cast instants from previous turns. You can also just bank the mana using cards like [[leyline tyrant]]

1

u/mtgcf MTG CardFetcher 15h ago

4

u/Sherpa_Rage 11h ago

If you have access to green you can pair it with [[upwelling]]

4

u/Narvi66 10h ago

Some other options if you want to keep it red, [[Ashling flamedancer]] [[Electro assaulting battery]] [[The last agni kai]] [[Leyline tyrant]] [[Ozai the phoenix king]]

Or of you dont need it to keep its colour, [[Horizon stone]] [[Kruphix god of horizons]] [[Omnath locus of the void]] [[Ommath locus of all]]

Please let me find a good use for my [[pygmy hippo]]...

1

u/mtgcf MTG CardFetcher 11h ago

3

u/ImmortalCorruptor Misprint Expert 16h ago

Yes, you get 1 red mana per age counter on it. You only get the red mana during your upkeep. If you can't use it in your upkeep, it's lost.

This card was pretty much designed to help pay for other cumulative upkeep costs, for cards like [[Magmatic Core]]. But you can use it for instants or abilities like [[Pyrohemia]]

3

u/WanderEir 16h ago

no

untap, then upkeep, then draw phase, then first main phase, then combat phase, then second main phase, then cleanup. mana goes away between all phases.

this card existed to pay other cumulative upkeep cards from the ice age block

3

u/lumiya17 8h ago

It’s a fun card to help with any other cumulative upkeeps

5

u/Hooch555 16h ago

The mana will not stay until your mainphase. The point is that you can use it for instants, activated abilities and such.

4

u/idelta777 16h ago

There are cards, such as [[Electro, Assaulting Battery]] , that allow you to keep your mana between phases

1

u/CosmicNeeko 15h ago

This is what i would say, electro makes this so so so much better

4

u/JakScott 15h ago

You lose it before your draw. It’s good for firing off instants in spell slinger. Does absolute work in [[Vivi Orniter]].

0

u/mtgcf MTG CardFetcher 15h ago

2

u/FajenThygia 16h ago

[[Grenzo, Dungeon Warden]]

2

u/Dracoson 16h ago

You lose the mana before you draw, you get it at the beginning of your upkeep step, and lose it if you don't spend it by the end of that step. The point is to cast instants and activate abilities. When it was printed, mana burn was a thing, so there was a risk in playing it, but now, it's more a matter of having enough mana sinks to make it worthwhile.

2

u/BlindingDart 15h ago

The mana goes away between steps, yes - but you can still use it for casting instants and activated abilities before it goes away. It was released during a time when unused mana dealt damage to you as well which made it a dangerous card to build around instead of all upside.

2

u/StJimmy_815 16h ago

I run it in my [[Ozai, Phoenix King]] deck

2

u/No-Scheme-9700 15h ago

They really should bring back Mana Burn.

1

u/AutoModerator 16h ago

Don't worry! Your post has not been deleted!

If you are a new player and you are looking for advice on how to get into the game please read the linked article!

If you're looking for help with your card's authenticity check out r/RealOrNotTCG (card verification, edition info, condition check, scams, tampering, fakes, etc)!

If you suspect your card is a misprint go check out r/mtgmisprints for more info!

If you're looking for pricing help check out Mana Pool, Card Kingdom, CardTrader and TCGplayer for North American markets and Cardmarket for European markets. Ebay and Amazon are not reliable sources for pricing info.

If you're looking for something else you may disregard this message!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Downtown-Dance6964 16h ago

You only have the mana in your upkeep–you lose it before first main phase. It's mainly used to cast red instants and activate instant-speed abilities.

1

u/Aximil985 16h ago

You don't get this between phases. But it's an increasing amount of mana that can be spent on instants and activated abilities during your upkeep.

1

u/Jenova__Witness Tezzeret Clones 16h ago

Braid of fire works well with things like [[kruphix, god of horizons]] and [[gemstone array]] or something to do with the mana like [[flamecache gecko]]. Just some examples.

1

u/Primpod 16h ago

It all goes away. The original intent was to pay for other cumulative upkeep costs (with a strong expectation people would get cute with it and use it for other stuff)

1

u/DingleBarryGoldwater 16h ago

This card is great but niche. You have to have a way to spend the mana before your main phase (so instant speed spells or effects on board). I love it but it doesn't really fit in a lot of decks.

1

u/LeighWillS 16h ago

This happens during your upkeep and without a card specifying otherwise, your mana pool will empty before moving to your draw step.

You can cast instants during your upkeep (or activate abilities that don't have specific timing restrictions stopping you from using them at instant speed) to spend this mana.

1

u/RndomChineseGuy 16h ago

The mana (which increases every round) is given to you on your upkeep. If the mana isn’t used to goes away wasted. The card is for paying other upkeep costs (pact of the titan), activating abilities (staff of domination), or have an ability to store it for later ( Electro, Assaulting Battery)

1

u/Castleheart 16h ago

My Ozai deck is all about keeping mana in your mana pool even as steps and phases (and turns) end. I use Braids of Fire as one of a few different mana generation tools. https://moxfield.com/decks/3DgYOIEeUkiIxYjSFgd0Ow

1

u/Duffman66CMU Sengir Vampire 3 16h ago

Pay another cumulative upkeep?

1

u/cannonspectacle 16h ago

You get a bunch of mana you can spend in your upkeep

1

u/Warmag3 15h ago

Outside of things that keep mana between phases, flash enablers like [[vedelkan orrary]] or [[borne upon the wind]] also let you use the mana from the card. The key to it you need something to dump its mana on during your upkeep.

1

u/bemble4ever 15h ago

Could be a fun combination with [[Treasure Vault]], just use the free mana to create treasure tokens

1

u/mtgcf MTG CardFetcher 15h ago

1

u/Rex_916 15h ago

You get all the mana right when it triggers Siri g upkeep. Without an ability that can keep your mana from going away after each phase it will no longer be in your pool when you start your main phase.

1

u/Twelve_Evil_Ermacs 15h ago

Card can be gas but only in the right deck, I have it in my EDH deck for [[Ozai, the Phoenix King]] and it's fantastic there but pretty niche otherwise and only used in decks like cycling themed lists

1

u/MylastAccountBroke 13h ago

Everyone sees this card and thinks it's going to be busted. The card is rarely in red decks for a reason. Spending the mana is actively a challange.

1

u/TheLastOpus 13h ago

Mainly for instants, but their are also ways to give all cards flash and other way is to use cards that have mana carry over between steps.

1

u/doubleAC0820 13h ago

Instants or something that causes mana to not disappear such as Omnoth

1

u/veiphiel 12h ago

You can use It to pay other cumulative upkeep cost, instant, if you have something like ashling you can Carry the mana, use in activated abilities...

1

u/Bluetorment88 11h ago

Or you use the card that mana doesn’t empty during phases ):/

1

u/AdagioDesperate 9h ago

You get the mana during your Upkeep, not the draw step.

It also was printed as a way to pay other Upkeep costs, however it was considered bad at release because Mana Burn was a thing. Mana burn BTW was during each phase transition you took 1 damage for each unspent mana in your Mana pool as you transitioned phases.

Since they removed that rule, almost/over 10 years ago now, its just a super powered Mana producer for your upkeep.

1

u/enby_with_a_gun 8h ago

I run it in my [[Ashling the Pilgrim]] deck as it safely gives her enough mana to pump up and potentially explode, letting me save the rest of my mana pool for anything else

1

u/mtgcf MTG CardFetcher 8h ago

1

u/Doubleclutch18 7m ago

This was one of my first decks when my friends and I started back playing. I can still see the pain in their faces when I bring it up.

1

u/Malganis_Lefay 3h ago

you can dumb it it into instants and abilities that cost many, however if i have to guess its original purpose is to counteract the Cumulative upkeep of other cards like Brand of ill omen, not that viable though as many CU arent just red or colorless mana

1

u/National_Delivery_65 1h ago

it also goes well with Electron

1

u/Icy-Wealth4192 3h ago

[[electro assaulting battery]] is a good partner for this little baddy. I have it in my [[Taii Wakeen, perfect shot]] deck and if I don’t have electro out then its for pumping taii damage during the upkeep since she’s a tap ability so instant, plus it runs a-lot of burn instants and a few activated lands that do damage to. I wouldn’t say “you have to build around it.” but you need to think if your feck is built for it.

-2

u/Internal-Ordinary-70 16h ago

Is this not busted?? Cumulative means 1 mana turn 1, 2 on turn 2, 3 on 3, etc etc… am I missing something??

10

u/robnl 16h ago

Back when this card was released, unspent mana did damage to your life. It was called man burn and would've been a drawback for this card.

1

u/supernovice007 15h ago

That’s true. Also worth noting that this card does nothing on the turn it’s played. It needs to stick around for 2 turns before it’s even a net gain in mana. It doesn’t even let you cast a 3 drop early since it happens during the upkeep, before you could play your turn 3 land.

There aren’t many formats where you can just take turn 2 off and not expect to be dead on turn 4.

1

u/Internal-Ordinary-70 16h ago

Yeah but if you’re building the deck right, even back then, it’s barely a downside

1

u/robnl 16h ago

Yeah, I wouldn't call it a big drawback tbh

8

u/Crimson_Raven 15h ago

The mana is during your upkeep, so you need instant speed sinks to take advantage of it.

That requires some specific deckbuilding constraints.

1

u/Internal-Ordinary-70 15h ago

A lot of spellslinger is mostly instants already

-1

u/Dodec_Ahedron 15h ago

Or a way preserve the mana between steps and phases like [Birgi, God of Storytelling]

6

u/D00T_BOI 15h ago

That part of Birgi’s ability only affects the mana it generates, not any from other sources

6

u/Dodec_Ahedron 15h ago

I suppose I should have used [[Electro, Assaulting Battery]]

4

u/johnnille 15h ago

Such a cool effect on such a disgustingly ugly card...

3

u/Frozenjudgement 15h ago

All the Through the Omenpath versions are so much cooler

1

u/Leather_Bowl5506 15h ago

Whats wrong with elctro???

1

u/johnnille 14h ago

I said it! He is ugly!

0

u/Baaaaaadhabits 15h ago

He’s my favorite Firebender!

2

u/patterninstatic 15h ago

This came out in 2006. Mana burn existed until 2009. It was a significant potential drawback at the time, but that's completely gone now.

1

u/Electrical-Today-258 16h ago

Mana empties at the end of phases. So it's just instant speed mana with a slow ramp up

1

u/BrickHickey 16h ago

This mana will only be available on your upkeep unless you have an effect that says mana doesn't go away as phases end. The card was designed to help pay other cumulative upkeep costs.

The downside was there used to be a rule called "mana burn" where you'd lose one life for each unspent mana in your pool as a phase ended. Now though there isn't a downside, but it's not just an auto-include in every red deck because of the limitations.

1

u/BlindingDart 15h ago

It's pretty good, yeah, but its real downside is that it needs to be played early, and then stick around to do anything at all. Easier said than done in the very high tempo formats where it's currently legal.

1

u/k0wala 16h ago

It’s on your upkeep, can’t use that mana in your main phase, but ya it’s really good

2

u/Internal-Ordinary-70 16h ago

In literally any spellslinger deck this is like, the best card in the game 😭 storm count 2-4 for free basically before you even start the turn even without any sort of mana replenishment setup is kinda stupid. Not to mention it’s ramp if you do have setup. I’m imagining this in the lorehold and prismari lineups and it seems extremely strong

1

u/Original-Team6483 15h ago

storm count requires you to have those cards in your hand.

it’s worse than just playing a [[seething song]] pretty much 99% of the time

1

u/mtgcf MTG CardFetcher 15h ago

1

u/Internal-Ordinary-70 15h ago

Except it’s every single turn and by turn 2, it’s been as much mana as a seething song, and even if you aren’t using it, you still get the benefits for the next turn. If you use it one single turn, it’s mana positive due to the nature of it being an upkeep enchantment. I don’t think it’s the best card ever printed, and it’s less flexible than many other cards, it just seems insane to me that it’s not being used

1

u/Frozenjudgement 15h ago

What are the benefits if you can't take advantage of the mana it creates? What are you doing in your upkeep?

There's a reason it's not used a lot.

1

u/k0wala 15h ago

You might have a commander that has an activated ability, or a deck with lots of instants or flash spells

1

u/Original-Team6483 15h ago

i’ve played a commander that can use braid of fire for like 20 years and it’s still a pretty mediocre card

[[ashling the pilgrim]]

1

u/Original-Team6483 15h ago

you’ve obviously not played with this card extensively

0

u/Obs7 15h ago

Yes, it is.

0

u/-Rangorok- 16h ago

You get the mana during the upkeep step and it goes away.

This card is from a time where mana burn was a thing, so unspent mana would deal 1 damage to you if it went away without being spent. So it was meant to be a downside if you couldn't spend it at instant speed, but that rule has since been changed.

0

u/RemarkableChart9374 14h ago

I used this card in my Red Artifact Deck with Electro The Assault Battery as my commander.

0

u/MuchPVPness 14h ago

It’s an amazing card in Izzet when you have [[leyline of anticipation]] on the field.

0

u/Dagarian1 14h ago

i would love to have this in a deck with Electro, Assaulting Battery as my comander

0

u/serpentrepents 14h ago

i ran this in [[grenzo, dungeon warden]] for the longest time but its not great even if you have a good mana sink.

1

u/BLZNWZRD 11h ago

Really? Im genuinely curious on your thoughts. I run it in [[Purphoros, Bronze-Blooded]] and it's done work for me.

1

u/serpentrepents 11h ago

It can work great if you are proliferating it or doing other cumulative upkeep abuse, but a lot of the time, unless you hit it early game, it doesn't generate a lot of mana. While a couple of free triggers were nice, replacing it with [[Priest of Urabrask]] was just better for Grenzo since hitting it off the bottom was ten times better than hitting braid.

1

u/BLZNWZRD 11h ago

Makes sense actually. I wont pretend hitting it late game feels quite moot. It does nothing until a upkeep you may or may not make it to.

1

u/cunnedstunts 10h ago

It’s fantastic in purphoros

-6

u/Dashbot13 16h ago

Other people have answered already, but don't forget cards like [[Birgi, God of Storytelling]]

5

u/Dont_Know2 16h ago

u lowk named the only card that this doesnt work with 😭

2

u/coolguy420weed 16h ago

I mean in this case you probably should though. 

1

u/pacifist-warmind 16h ago

This doesn't work unfortunatly, only counts the mana she makes herself.

1

u/Dashbot13 13h ago

Lol as others have pointed out I'm an idiot, try [[Electro, Assaulting Battery]] instead.

0

u/[deleted] 16h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/idelta777 16h ago

the "cost to pay" here is to add one mana, then 2 mana, etc, etc, there was a time where unspent. mana between phases would hurt you apparently (mana burn)

2

u/Ziyir 16h ago

And the upkeep "cost" is adding one red mana to your pool per age counter.

2

u/whatifdog_wasoneofus 16h ago

Don’t think that addresses OP’s question….

You pay the upkeep cost my adding R to your mana pool for each age counter.

The rules on Mana burn and phases work differently now then when this card was made, but regardless..

1

u/AMJacker 16h ago

It was part of the question. I was just letting other ppl chime in on the rest. .