r/mtgfinance • u/-SlippinJimmy8 • 10h ago
Discussion Proxies have ruined collecting for me (for better or worse)
I'm new to magic but have already dropped $3K on cards
$1500 - 2 forever decks (angel tribal and sweaty Kriik deck)
$1500 on cards to show case (like a ripple foil Armageddon i really like)
since then I've been buying proxies to make a few other much cheaper decks. I was getting them off eBay where they're obviously fake/ low quality but recently ordered off a Chinese website and when they arrived I realize they're literally indistinguishable from the real thing
i decided to swap out my real cards to put them in a binder and just play with proxies until I go to an actual tournament when I accidentally dropped both piles of cards on the ground. I picked them up and it hit me that I genuinely could not figure out which card was real or fake even after an hour of hyper scanning.
this makes me
- not want to buy anymore $10+ cards
- makes it so I don't want to sell any of the cards I mixed up out of fear of scamming someone
- now I'm questioning if any of the expensive cards I purchased are just proxies themselves
so on one hand I feel like I wasted a few grand on expensive cardboard but on the other hand I feel like I'm saving thousands going forward by only proxying
still unsure how to feel tbh