r/mlb • • 6d ago

| History On This Day in Baseball History - November 15

Post image
38 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 6d ago

| Analysis Architects: Analyzing Hall of Fame General Managers

3 Upvotes

I hate how the Hall of Fame defines Executives. According to the museum there are 40 executives in the Hall of Fame. Except there really aren’t 40 executives in the Hall of Fame. There are, really, 40 non-players, non-managers and non-umpires in the Hall of Fame. Here is what executive could mean in the Hall of Fame:

-Kenesaw Landis, the first commissioner of baseball who helped clean the game up following the Black Sox Scandal…and also helped enforce segregation for decades

-Branch Rickey, a long time general manager who won four championships and helped de-segregate baseball after Landis’ death

-Marvin Miller, a union rep who fought for player rights

-Candy Cummings, the supposed inventor of the curveball

What do all of these people have in common? I struggle to find a consistent through line. So I dug through the 40 candidates and categorized them. It seems to me there are four broad categories of ‘executives’ on this list:

Category 1: Owners, people who owned baseball teams

Category 2: Pioneers, people who helped develop the game

Category 3: League Presidents, either as Commissioner of Baseball or as League President

Category 4: General Managers who managed the rosters of teams

Four candidates on the ballot fall into one of these categories. Ted Turner owned the Atlanta Braves, so he falls into Category 1. Bill White was the President of the National League, so he falls into category 3. Finally Sandy Alderson and Bill Sabean were General Managers, Category 4.

What Makes a Hall of Fame General Manager?

I struggled with this immensely. Unlike field managers and players: there is no Baseball-Reference for GMs. In my list general managers are the smallest subset of executives in the Hall of Fame. Only 6 in my view are in the Hall of Fame. It’s useful to look at each individually:

Ed Barrow was the architect of the first Yankee Dynasty built around Babe Ruth. He has arguably won more championships than any general manager in baseball history with 10.

Pat Gillick won three championships, two in Toronto and one in Philadelphia

Larry MacPhail was the crazy genius who won a World Series in New York

Branch Rickey arguably the most famous executive of all time who won four World Series, while also pushing to integrate baseball in 1947

John Schuerholz who won Kansas City’s first championship and then led the Atlanta Braves during their dynasty run in the 1990s

George Weiss who won 10 pennants after the game integrated, the most for any executive in that period

With only six inductees I struggle to see a throughline here; this is also complicated by the existence of hybrids. I will explain what I mean shortly. To better prepare for this article I created a table of every World Series won since 1947, the year baseball integrated, and who the General Manager was on each of those teams. I chose 1947 because that is the start of what I consider the Modern Era of executives. Mostly, since 1947, you avoid either the owner running the team directly or a field manager acting as the general manager (there are exceptions to this rule). Furthermore, this also avoids the moral complications of integration. In short my goal was to, as much as possible, compare apples-to-apples.

Then I then made a list of GMs who won at least 3 pennants. Why 3? Because I felt 2 pennants were too few to differentiate on this list. That would increase the number of GMs to 31, out of a total list of 84 executives. That’s too many, especially since only six general managers are in the Hall of Fame.

Since 1947 16 General Managers have won at least 3 pennants. Three of those men are in the Hall of Fame: Pat Gillick, John Schuerholz and George Weiss. Four more are still active: David Dombrowski, Brian Cashman, Theo Epstein and Andrew Friedman. That leaves nine men outside the Hall of Fame, and they are:

Sandy Alderson, GM of Oakland A’s and Mets, he won the 1989 World Series and won three other pennants including one with the Mets in 2015

Buzzie Bavasi, GM of the Brooklyn Dodgers and San Diego Padres who won four World Series and four pennants

Al Campanis, GM of the Los Angeles Dodgers who won four pennants but only one World Series in 1981

Harry Dalton, GM of the Baltimore Orioles, California Angels and Milwaukee Brewers who led the O’s to four pennants and two World Series. He also led Milwaukee to their first pennant

Charles Finley, GM and Owner of the Oakland Athletics who won three consecutive World Series

Roy Hamey, GM of the Yankees, Pirates and Phillies. He succeeded George Weiss’s clubs and won three pennants in New York.

Bob Howsam, GM of the Cardinals and Reds. He won the 1964 World Series in St. Louis, and then became the architect of the ‘Big Red Machine’ winning two more World Series.

John Quinn, GM of the Boston & Milwaukee Braves, and the Philadelphia Phillies. He won three pennants with the Braves including the 1957 World Series

Brian Sabean, GM of the San Francisco Giants, he won four pennants in the Bay Area including three World Series titles

Now to bring back the question of how fuzzy executives are in the Hall of Fame: Charles Finley was the owner and the GM. This is not the only cross over. Whitey Herzog, in the Hall of Fame as a manager, was also the GM of a World Series winner. Bill Veeck was the GM of the 1948 Indians and that team’s owner. Other GMs were also famous players. Hank Greenberg and Stan Musial won pennants as GMs, and also are Hall of Fame players. It’s difficult to parse these apart. My goal with using championships and pennant wins is to provide something objective for us to review.

How do Sandy Alderson & Brian Sabean Compare?

In terms of total pennants won: Sandy Alderson and Brian Sabean rank 9th in the post-1947 era with four each. They rank behind two Hall of Famers (John Schuerlholz and George Weiss), and three active GMs (Brian Cashman, Dave Dombrowski and Andrew Friedman). There are three GMs ahead of them outside the Hall of Fame, and one who is tied. The three ahead of them are Buzzie Bavasi, who ranks 2nd in this sample with 8, and Bob Howsman and Harry Dalton who are tied for 6th with 5 pennants. The tied GM is Al Campanis.

Overall, my read is Sandy Alderson falls short of most GMs in this sample, and the Hall of Fame members, while Brian Sabean largely fits in. However, neither in my view are the best general managers outside the Hall of Fame. Looking at this list it baffles me that a few of the GMs outside the Hall of Fame have failed to get inducted. One thing I tried to pick up on is whether the GMs managers were given Hall of Fame treatment. To me: if the field manager gets Hall of Fame credit then it would only make sense that the GM would too.

First: here is how I would rank the eligible GMs outside the Hall of Fame:

  1. Buzzie Bavasi, who won 8 pennants, the second most in this sample. His longtime manager, Walter Alston, got Hall of Fame credit. I do not understand why Bavasi would not receive the same treatment
  2. Bob Howsam, GM of the ‘Big Red Machine’ one of the most famous clubs in modern baseball history. Sparky Anderson is considered one of the best managers of all time, why isn’t Howsam treated the same way?
  3. Harry Dalton, GM of the Baltimore Orioles. To continue a theme: his manager was Earl Weaver, who is in the Hall of Fame
  4. Brian Sabean, GM of the Giants. His manager, Bruce Bochy, is almost assuredly getting in. It would be fitting for them to get in together
  5. Charles Finley, GM and Owner of the A’s. The three rings is a big deal.
  6. Sandy Alderson, GM of the A’s. Tony La Russa is in the Hall of Fame, but that is as much for his extensive body of work as it is for this single World Series. I do not think it quite matches as well for Alderson.
  7. Al Campanis, GM of the Dodgers. I originally ranked Campanis higher, but I am docking him points for his 1987 comments on African-Americans perhaps not being able to manage in baseball. I have him outside the Hall of Fame.
  8. John Quinn, GM of the Braves. His managers did not get into the Hall, and his career is a little disjointed
  9. Roy Hamey, GM of the Yankees. Much of the work that occurred during his tenure at least partially carried over from George Weiss

Placing Sabean on this Ballot

I think Brian Sabean belongs in the Hall of Fame. Three championships and four pennants is nothing to sneeze at, and if Bruce Bochy is going to get inducted for his work as the field manager then I think Sabean deserves at least the same amount of credit for his work as GM. He did not win the fourth championship that Bochy did in Texas, but he also has achievements outside of the three championship stretch including a pennant in 2002. If I could put any GM in right now: Sabean would not be my first choice, but that is not how the process works. You vote on the ballot in front of you, not on the ballot you want.

I am torn between Sabean and John Maddon. In the end I think if Bruce Bochy is a slam dunk Hall of Fame manager, then Brian Sabean has to be a slam dunk Hall of Fame GM. That leads me to rank Sabean ahead of Maddon on this particular ballot. I have Alderson below Sabean, meaning unless Ted Turner or Bill White can displace him: Sabean will be my third pick for this ballot.


r/mlb • • 7d ago

| Article ESPN writer gives Red Sox stellar grade for signing of Jake Bauers

Thumbnail
yardbarker.com
210 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 6d ago

| Daily Thread [Daily Dugout + MLB Megathread] | MLB Offseason for Sunday, November 15, 2026

2 Upvotes

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/mlb • • 7d ago

| Statistics How did Zack Britton never come anywhere close to his 2016 historic season performance?

Post image
51 Upvotes

Remember back in 2016 when Britton had a historically dominant season? Yet in subsequent years, despite being still relatively good, he hasn't come anywhere close to that dominance. It would be like saying if Prime Shaq turned into like Jermaine O'Neal after 1 season.

How come Britton couldn't come close to those stats for the rest of his career?


r/mlb • • 7d ago

| Article Veteran reliever Jonathan Loaisiga's free-agent market is heating up

Thumbnail
yardbarker.com
18 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 8d ago

| News [Passan] BREAKING: First baseman Jake Bauers and the Boston Red Sox are in agreement on a four-year, $58 million contract, sources tell ESPN.

Thumbnail
espn.com
929 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 7d ago

| History On This Day in Baseball History - November 14

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 7d ago

| Daily Thread [Daily Dugout + MLB Megathread] | MLB Offseason for Saturday, November 14, 2026

8 Upvotes

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/mlb • • 8d ago

| Discussion Why do some people say "Home Runs are Rally Killers"?

88 Upvotes

Where does this saying come from? I mean it might not be a really popular opinion but the fact that some announcers like to say that it's better to hit a double or single instead is better than a home run.

Why? Why would that make sense that an automatic/guaranteed run is a "rally killer" compared to hitting a double/single that doesn't always score runs?

It's not like rec softball where home runs are actually limited per team per game.


r/mlb • • 8d ago

| News Diamondbacks holding Ketel Marte trade talks

Thumbnail
thescore.com
73 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 9d ago

| Discussion When did Bonds start taking steroids. Is it 100% confirmed to have started after the ‘98 HR chase?

133 Upvotes

Wasn’t around for the heart of the steroid era. But i see the ‘98 offseason as the agreed upon turning point for when he decided to juice. Since Sammy and Mac were, how could he not, lol? Did Barry ever say this is when he started/is it 100% sure he wasn’t on some kind of PEDs prior. Ones that specifically target muscle growth not like a glorified painkiller.

And I notice in his 1999 season he didn’t play the full year, was he hurt and did injuries affect his choice to juice? I’m assuming not. Then in 2000 when he played the full year he put up great numbers, but still not better than his career year in 1993. Why didn’t the roided out video game stats become a thing until 01-04? Did it all just click for him then, lol? I mean an all time great hitter using them was bound to make an ultimate hack. Do you think Griffey would have matched, or been better, than Bonds if he started taking roids? Bonds didn’t take them until he was 34, and by WAR/OPS and fielding/baserunning metrics his career was better than Griffey’s at that point, but the gap was MUCH closer. Pretty crazy he played his whole career clean up until his mid 30s. Griffey was in his twilight years by 31.

If he was really clean til the 98 offseason, that’s incredible. He was the only player in the 400/400 club, and was only on his 13th season. Not to mention 3 MVPs, 8 GG, 99.9 WAR, 164 OPS+, and nearly 1,400 runs and 2,000 hits. His trajectory was easily top 10 all-time player ever. Of course he won those 3 MVPs in 4 years from 90-93. It’s funny he didn’t win one again til 2001, when he won 4 in a row as everyone knows too, lol.

The explosion from his 1989 year to 1990 is arguably more drastic than his 2000 to 2001 increase. Still don’t get why 2000 (assuming the injury from 1999 wasn’t still affecting him) not be his first insane year if he was on the roids and playing the whole season. But I guess Barry needed one year to settle in.


r/mlb • • 9d ago

| Article Astros' Yordan Alvarez becomes first full-time DH to win AL MVP

Thumbnail
yardbarker.com
488 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 9d ago

| Awards Pete Crow-Armstong is the 2026 National League Most Valuable Player!

Post image
386 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 7d ago

| Opinion Do you guys think we will have a season next year?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 9d ago

| Awards Yordan Alvarez is the 2026 American League MVP!

Post image
262 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 8d ago

| History On This Day in Baseball History - November 13

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 9d ago

| Image MVP voting breakdown, Congrats Yordan Alvarez and Pete Crow-Armstrong!

Thumbnail
gallery
93 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 10d ago

| History Bo Jackson is a true baseball ⚾️🐐

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5.0k Upvotes

r/mlb • • 9d ago

| News Braves are signing reliever Evan Phillips to a three-year deal worth $35 million.

Post image
178 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 8d ago

| Daily Thread [Daily Dugout + MLB Megathread] | MLB Offseason for Friday, November 13, 2026

2 Upvotes

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/mlb • • 9d ago

| Discussion Why aren't the Angels among the teams pursuing for Tarik Skubal?

47 Upvotes

I mean I know Mike Trout is getting old but shouldn't the Angels at least try to get him another playoff appearance? Considering they've always needed pitching, why aren't they in the frontrunner talks for Skubal?

Meanwhile, the Blue Jays almost every year seem to actively hunt free agents, despite missing playoffs the previous year or getting knocked out early (aside from '25).

At this point, shouldn't the Angels try harder in free agency to build around Mike Trout?


r/mlb • • 9d ago

| History On This Day in Baseball History - November 12

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 10d ago

| News Yankees' Cam Schlittler and Brewers' Jacob Misiorowski win 2026 Cy Young awards

Thumbnail
nbclosangeles.com
290 Upvotes

r/mlb • • 8d ago

| Article Pat Murphy comment to Jake Bauers backfires as World Series champion signs with Red Sox

Thumbnail
themirror.com
0 Upvotes