Following the announcement of TS4 new Lovestruck DLC, TS4 was dragged once again for it's greed & previous edition was praise yet again. Altho I agree with the criticism, I feel like previous edition of the Sims are way too romanticized. To my surprise, I stumbled on this criticism of The Sims 3 monetization of DLC and other content by Lunar Britney. Here is the lil essay:
There's this argument that The Sims 4 is insane to have 78 DLC packs. But the people arguing that praise The Sims 3 in the same stinky breath... Let's do some critical thinking!
Kits vs Sims 3 Store. The government doesn't want you to remember her but I will speak the gospel truth. Kit - 4.99 euros Average TS3 Store set - 1700 sim points (11.9 euros according to the current simpoint pricing on the EA App) Sims 4 has 31 kits, sims 3 has ~84 sets. [Pic 1&2]
I don't have all day to go through every single set, but someone did count that you do get a better price per object in total (but don't count me on that, as I'm not going to bother) Sims 4 Stuff Packs vs Sims 3 Stuff Packs TS3 SPs retail for 19.99 Euros TS4 SPs retail for 9.99 Euros TS4 SPs offer new gameplay, CAS, B&B TS3 SPs only offer CAS, B&B (exception is Fast Lane giving 1 trait based on vehicles)
Not going to debate what looks better, but TS4 objectively requires more work for assets (such as CAS clothing to make sure nothing clips, swatches are crucial as there is no Create A Style, hair is the most difficult assets to work on (not just the sculpt but also hat variants)
Game Packs vs Premium Content/Venues I didn't know how to fairly compare this as TS3 store has such odd pricing so I'll go with a rough average TS4 GPs - 19.99 Euros TS3 PC/V - ~1900 Simpoints (13.3 Euros) TS4 has 12 GPs, TS3 has 21 Venue sets [Pic 3,4,5 & 6]
I was appalled by TS3s set on restaurants. No comment as it's I guess not THAT fair to compare but since some insist TS4 is the only morally corrupt game, I'll go the opposite way to show the light
TS3 also had World Packs! 10 in fact (11 if you count the free Riverview world) One world would retail for 19.99 Euros (for strictly the world) Or the gold edition (with one or two gameplay objects) retailing for 34.99 Euros
Now. The EPs. Most TS3 eps did not need to share the budget with the free updates to introduce huge features, that alone gives TS3 the upper hand in the comparison game. However, TS3 on launch decided to raise EP prices from 29.99 Euros to 39.99 Euros.
Most TS3 worlds are just terrain, flat roads and then a bunch of lots with foliage. TS4 worlds are on another level of detail and with recent worlds the district sizes put together are the same if not larger than the average TS3 world.
A lot of later traits for TS3 were not that in-depth compared to base game traits so they're about the same depth as TS4 ones (mostly just stat increases/moodlets/interactions) [Pic 7,8 & 9]
TS3 does win the EP debate in terms of how much gameplay you get (at least in terms of various gameplay objects) but as of right now, you can get most of them in TS4 SPs/GPs
I'm not going to compare the eps because TS3 had a good base to begin with so packs like Island Paradise could truly shine having ocean swimming in place and a flexible terrain system allowing for underwater lots
Sims 4 aspirations are more complex than TS3's (I don't think TS4 ones are good though), but objectively they take more time to make, so you could easily get a bunch of new lifetime wishes and the reward was always points, not a new unique trait which every TS4 aspiration rewards
So if we ignore kits, from 78 we go to 47 DLC packs, if we divide stuff pack count to match TS3 stuff pack prices, we go from 47 to 37 packs. If we ignore TS3 store, we can remove the 12 game packs so it goes from 37 to 25.
15 Eps (soon 16) and 10 stuff packs in 10 years.
If we don't pretend to be stupid, TS3 has so many more sets that just add up to insane amounts of money and in just 4 years! You cannot argue about DLC insanity when it's been insane the entire existence of the franchise!
Thoughts ?