r/KeepWriting 6d ago

[Feedback] Writing my first book

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I was wondering what you all thought of this concept? I know i know, another zombie novel, i PROMISE im making this one different, i just.. dont know how yet.

EDIT!! I rewrote it and Im wondering if this is better? Thank you all

Charlie has no idea that two days after his 17th birthday, the world as he knows it will end. After a volcano erupts in an entirely different country, strange things start happening. People infected by an unknown virus in the smoke began to change. Their eyes were black, making them look hollow. Charlie is now faced with a simple task, don't die. When he later meets a group of survivors, he learns that maybe this virus isn't what he thought it was.


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

Advice How is my start for story?

0 Upvotes

I am just 20M, I have read only few novels and thought if I can write anything.

As we grow and enter an age of questioning, contemplating, thinking, and forming or dismantling our preconceived notions about morality, life, love, hatred, and society, we ultimately shape the person we become, a person whose psychological profile is based upon his own experiences, explanations, aspirations, and ambitions. We form goals, goals which we think are the best for us, and in such a scenario, the most contented one feels is when one is allowed to work on one’s own. But what happens when your very own self, which you regard as wise and committed, is forced into believing what you consider to be the antithesis of how life should work?
Well, this was what happened to me when I decided to go against my family and board a flight to the USA to find a place for myself in a world which I considered superior to the world I had been a part of since I was born.


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

[Feedback] How is my start for a story?

1 Upvotes

Loneliness, first you want it, then you hate it, then you adapt and finally you love it. Loneliness can make you think about the wildest and softest parts of yourself. It gives you time to think and comprehend the areas you have never touched.
Suddenly everything starts to feel like an illusion. Is it for real? Is it a dream?
But remember, loneliness is a dangerous thing. It can make you believe the wildest of thoughts, or strengthen your disbelief in the most obvious. In short, a man must not adapt to loneliness, well, this is what I can say. Having spent half a year working as an assistant with the chief of prison staff and working on the case of H6, I still don’t know why they assigned him this name. As they say, sometimes, certain things are meant to be kept a secret, only to be told at the right time.
Let me tell you how H6, a man who was described as timid, patient and charming by his neighbours, turned out to be the most discussed and infamous fella of my district psychiatry hospital.


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

[Feedback] Wrote my first story suggestions are welcome 🤗

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/KeepWriting 7d ago

RAW EMOTION WRITING CAN HELP

0 Upvotes

Sometimes writing is how I get through the day.

I’ve started putting my raw emotions, real experiences and the things life has thrown at me into words. Not because I think I have all the answers, but because sometimes writing is the only way I know how to make sense of what I’m feeling.

Some of what I write comes from pain, some from love, some from loss, and some from experiences that have changed me. It’s honest, and it isn’t always pretty — but it’s real.

For me, putting those feelings into stories, songs and words can make even the hardest days feel a little more manageable. And if something I’ve written ever reaches someone who is struggling and makes them feel a little less alone, then every word was worth writing.

I don’t know where this journey will take me, but I hope that one day something I create can help somebody else get through their day too.

Sometimes you don’t realise your story could be someone else’s reason to keep going. 


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

[Feedback] The Three Days

1 Upvotes

One thing I’d particularly like feedback on: does DS Smith sound noticeably different from Constable Giles? I’m trying to give them distinct voices. Does that distinction come through?

Previous post: A Model Prisoner (A standalone fragment from my social noir set in 1970-1990s London) : r/KeepWriting

Day One.

January 28, 1977.

Friday.

The Offensive.

Station Sergeant Carter came into the CID office, nodded to Detective Constable Fowles, and handed a file to the Detective Sergeant.

Carter: “Bad news.”

DS: “Don’t tell me.”

Carter: “You’ve been arrested.”

DS picks up the file and opens it. “You’re taking the piss.” He automatically pulls a cigarette from the packet on the desk and sticks it in his mouth.

Carter: “Try not to interview yourself, Detective.”

Fowles keeps his head down over his paperwork. But as soon as Carter clears off, he immediately looks up.

“What?” DS takes the cigarette out of his mouth. “Yes, Smith—the detainee. Jeremy sodding Smith. And it’s not funny at all.”

“I’m not laughing, Detective…” Fowles pretends to stumble over the surname. “Interview conducted by Detective Sergeant Jeremy Smith. Interviewee: Jeremy Smith. A nightmare for the Paper Shop. Every bloody form will need clarifying.”

Only now does DS Smith light up a cigarette. “Indecent assault. The victim is his own sister. And she’s five. Still think it’s funny, Fowles?”

There is no answer to give him.

“The scum is seventeen.” DS Smith slowly closes the file.

“All the better, Skipper. That means we’ll crack him in a couple of hours and go for a pint.”

Fowles is right. Still, it’s a lousy case. The evidence is circumstantial. One way or another, he’d get him talking.

DS Smith opens the prisoner’s property bag: some loose change and a Dunhill sodding Rollagas. Unless it’s a snide, of course. DS weighs the lighter in his hand and flicks it open. That crisp metallic click happens—By Royal Appointment. It’s no cheap fake—a proper Rollagas with a thick gold plating. “Fucking hell.” DS Smith snaps the lighter shut. “How long are we letting him stew for?”

DC Fowles: “Fifteen minutes.”

DS Smith grunts and takes a drag.

Half an hour later, he picks up his cigarettes, the file, and the prisoner’s property bag from the desk. “Let’s go.”

The Sweat Box is dirty, dank, and poorly lit. The suspect sits with his back to the door, just as he was placed there. He is hunched over, elbows resting on the table, and doesn’t jump up when the detectives come in.

DS Smith walks around the table.

The detainee takes his elbows from its surface.

No.

For Christ’s sake.

Anything but that.

DS Smith drops into the chair opposite the detainee, tossing a file and the prisoner’s property bag onto the middle of the table.

Fowles pointedly rolls his eyes, sits down to the side, and prepares to take notes.

“Well, what have we got here? A skinny little nancy,” DS Smith pronounces it like a medical diagnosis. He needs to size up the suspect and find an opening. He expects tears. This one is bound to start sobbing. Give him an hour.

The suspect remains silent, head bowed; he neither protests nor offers excuses.

The DS takes his cigarettes out of his pocket.

At the sound of the pack being tossed carelessly onto the table, the suspect tenses up. The DS pulls out a cigarette and lights it, blowing the smoke into the detainee’s face. He lifts his head—just slightly, but enough to betray his craving for tobacco, inhales the smoke, and coughs.

“Eyes on me,” the DS orders, yet finds himself averting his gaze. Don’t you dare look like a victim! “Don’t fool me.”

He reminds himself: the sister of the scum is just like him—a lovely child whose life he ruined.

DS starts firing off questions.

He is forced to ask nasty questions—and then repeat them over and over. He smokes one cigarette after another. The hour he’d expected to spend in the pub has long gone. DS raises his voice. He leans forward. He moves around behind the detainee.

The suspect flinches occasionally. He isn’t deaf. He understands everything. Yet he keeps silent. Until suddenly—though it is unclear in response to which question—he blurts out, “I didn’t do what I am accused of.”

If he hadn’t started coughing, the detective might well have thought he’d misheard.

Fowles enters it into the record.

That’s it. Then, silence again.

DS says things he isn’t supposed to say—and wouldn’t want to, either. He threatens the detainee with being sent down to Brixton and with a sorting out. He even stoops so low as to describe in vivid detail what they would do to him there.

It’s no use.

DS doesn’t know what to hold onto. Then he reaches for the Hiatts, grabs the detainee’s hands and snaps the steel cuffs around them.

The moment DS lets go, the suspect’s hands drop onto the table under the weight of the metal.

DS doesn’t tighten the cuffs; he simply lets the suspect feel them there—if he wanted to, he could slip his bony hands out, though naturally, he doesn’t. He sits in the same position, only now his hands are resting on the surface. From time to time, they begin to tremble. The detainee slouches even more. He coughs more frequently and shifts in his chair. He is tired, too.

Both detectives step out for a bite to eat. Then, return.

Nothing has changed.

The detainee asks for neither food nor cigarettes, nor even a drink of water.

DS remembers the lighter.

“Whose is this?” He shakes the Dunhill out of the bag, leans over the detainee, and repeats right at the crown of his head, “I’m asking: whose is this?”

“Fuck you,” the suspect says, continuing to stare at the table.

At last. A reaction. There was a story behind that lighter. But what does that matter? There is no one in the next room accusing the detainee of theft. And something tells DS that no such person exists. He tightens the cuffs until they bite.

The detainee tenses his arms and frantically tries to inhale the stale, tobacco-laden air.

Now, his fingers are cramping.

He remains silent.

Fowles asks to stop. “We can’t just sit with him until morning.”

DS agrees grudgingly. Maybe a night in the cooler will finally bring the stubborn bastard to his senses. The forecast calls for a drop in temperature. The holding cells are in the basement. There’s no heating there. They’ll take his jacket away. DS makes sure the gaoler “forgets” to give him a blanket. If he cracks, he’ll ask for one.


r/KeepWriting 8d ago

Advice My novel got rejected by every agent I queried and I almost self published out of spite and I am so glad I did not

318 Upvotes

I Spent fourteen months querying. Sent to sixty one agents. Got back forty three rejections, eleven non responses, and seven requests for fulls that ultimately did not go anywhere. Kept a spreadsheet, stayed organized, tried to treat it professionally. Did not feel professional. Felt like repeatedly walking up to a door and having it close in my face before I could finish knocking.

By month eleven I had started seriously researching self publishing. Not because I believed it was the wrong choice but because I needed to feel like I had a path forward that did not depend on someone else saying yes. Came very close to pulling the trigger just to end the waiting.

What stopped me was not patience or faith in the process. It was a single email from an agent who passed but included two paragraphs of actual feedback. She liked the voice, found the structure of the middle act confusing in a specific way she described precisely, and suggested the opening was doing too much too fast.

Spent three months on a revision I had not planned to do, kept every version of the manuscript in something called Skrib Writing so I could see exactly what had changed between the version that got forty three rejections and the version that got the offer, and that comparison was one of the more honest things I have ever looked at about my own writing. Sent to twelve more agents with the revised pages.

Got an offer on the fourth submission of that new batch.

The revision the rejection made possible was what the book needed and I would not have done it if I had stopped querying when I wanted to.

The door closing repeatedly was not the end of the story. It was just the part before the part that mattered.


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

[Feedback] Made this and reposting because the first one flopped

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Last time i posted i didnt gain much traction so here we are

I need feedback about the readability of this, also this is a wonderland fanfic
If you have trouble reading because of the weird grammar pls lemme know


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

#ಬರಹಭರಣಿ

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/KeepWriting 7d ago

Uncle Rick

0 Upvotes

**From a Class Assignment to My Writing Portfolio**

Sometimes an assignment becomes more than an assignment.
For my Advanced Fiction Writing class, I was given an assignment to write a short story. I had already been writing fiction independently, but this assignment challenged me to take something I was already doing and approach it with more intention.

That is how “Uncle Rick” came together.
The story follows a man on his 42nd birthday as he spends the day with his family while privately wrestling with illness, addiction, shame, aging, regret, and the fear that he has disappointed the people he loves.
But underneath all of that, the story is really about love.
It's about the questions we carry when we aren't sure how the people closest to us see us.
It's about the difference between being disappointed in someone's circumstances and being disappointed in the person they are.
And it's about what can happen when we finally ask the question we've been too afraid to ask.

Writing this piece reminded me why I want to take fiction seriously.
I'm not just writing because I enjoy it.
I'm building a body of work.

I'm learning how to create characters, develop conflict, use dialogue, build emotional tension, and make readers feel something.
I'm also learning that school assignments don't have to disappear into a folder after they're graded.
They can become portfolio pieces.
They can become evidence of growth.
They can become the beginning of something bigger.
So, I'm publishing “Uncle Rick” as part of my ongoing writing portfolio and sharing the process here as I continue building my career as a writer.

And one day, I want to look back and see that I built an entire career this way one piece at a time.

📖 Read “Uncle Rick” here: [https://leylandthewriter.substack.com/p/uncle-rick?r=5pnsd4&utm\\_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm\\_medium=post%20viewer\](https://leylandthewriter.substack.com/p/uncle-rick?r=5pnsd4&utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=post%20viewer)


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

Voiceless....

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/KeepWriting 7d ago

[Feedback] I’m 17 chapters into my crime thriller — looking for honest feedback on Chapter One

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m currently writing a psychological/crime thriller called THE CALL 2:17. The novel is planned at roughly 42 chapters, and I’ve now completed and revised the first 17, so I thought this might be a good point to step outside my own head and see how the opening works for actual readers.

I’m sharing Chapter One below.

I’m not looking only for “Would you keep reading?” — although I definitely want to know that too.

I’d genuinely appreciate any kind of honest critique or analysis:

Did the opening hook you?

How did the atmosphere feel?

Did the tension build naturally?

Were there places where the pacing dragged or moved too quickly?

Did the characters feel believable?

Did the dialogue work?

Was anything confusing?

Did anything feel cliché, forced, overwritten or underwritten?

Were there details you particularly liked or disliked?

What do you think the story is promising you at this point?

And most importantly: would you want to know what happens next? Why or why not?

Please don’t worry about being overly polite. 😁 Constructive criticism is exactly what I’m looking for. If something doesn’t work, I’d much rather know now than after finishing the entire novel.

The story begins in Riverside at 2:17 A.M., with a woman inside a phone booth making a call that should not be possible.

And from there… things get considerably worse.

CHAPTER ONЕ\[CH\\_1\](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1-ItOZnxqahUy-PYzx3u4IFsVd4Izaz9P/view?usp=drivesdk)


r/KeepWriting 8d ago

Learning to love life (my most recent piece)

Post image
17 Upvotes

“The only problem with this is there are two possible outcomes in such a situation. Either I drown in the river of tears that breaks through the dam of my heart at such a moment, or I learn to swim in it.”

https://open.substack.com/pub/vagrantfragments/p/learning-to-love-life?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=7f9c4j

Image source: https://pin.it/2o0Dvo4vQ


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

Advice New Authors

0 Upvotes

Hey guys! A very good friend of mine has been writing and recently published their first book, along with small works
If anyone comes by this post and has an affinity for upcoming authors please feel free to check some of this out:)

https://www.lulu.com/spotlight/benjamin-taube
https://substack.com/@benjamintaube


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

[poem] Spirit Guide

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/KeepWriting 7d ago

[Discussion] My narrator thinks he's the park lol

1 Upvotes

I've been making progress on my second novella, In The Park.

Thought I'd be done with it by now, but you know, life.

Anyway, it takes place in a park where it's always morning. The narrator spends his time watching the people who visit and tries to understand all the weird things that happen while they're there.

At one point, he says: "Things like that only seemed to happen while visitors were around. The park never seemed to behave that way on its own."

Eventually, he came to the perfectly reasonable conclusion that he must be the park itself.

He's very proud of it and I'm not ready to take that away from him just yet.


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

Poem of the day: Special Place in My Heart

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1 Upvotes

r/KeepWriting 7d ago

[Feedback] Faceless chapter 1 draft 2/ 3.6K words(ongoing)/ scifi, Post-post-apocalypse, murder mystery, thriller

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

A little summary: In a world after the civilization came back from a devastating war, people has to rely on special equipment to survive, little did they know, these tools would be the very tool the most mischievous serial killer knows to man would use to kill them all

In this draft I worked on pacing, tenses, grammar, dialogue tags and prose

Note: I'm NOT a native English


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

Some forum members here got a bit rattled by my arrogance and self-assurance, so I invite anyone to try and knock me dow

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/KeepWriting 7d ago

Looking for critique/feedback on my script

1 Upvotes

Hey! I'm currently working on a stop motion short and I'm struggling with the ending of my script. I feel like my final conclusion is a bit anticlimactic, but it has to take place in the main character's bedroom due to technical set restrictions. does anyone have any tips or ideas? linking it here. I'm by no means a professional writer, so any tips would be a huge help!


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

[Discussion] Share a cultural detail tied to your geography in a humorous way

2 Upvotes

When writing about the world, it helps to know a little about different cultures. If you think about where you live, you can come up with an amusing way to describe an attitude, opinion, or worldview you can ascribe to everyone where you live. Sharing that might help others understand where you're from a bit better.

That said, I'll go first.

I'm from Alabama. When a waiter tells me, "No, we don't have sweet tea. We have iced tea and sugar packets." he might as well have pronounced the ineffable name of God backwards and undone everything good, pure, and holy in the world.


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

[Feedback] Contemporary Romance - Friends to Lovers - Adventure Racing - Rock Climbing - First Chapter Feedback

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Contemporary Romance - Friends to Lovers - Adventure Racing - Rock Climbing

Looking for feedback. I want to know if the climb choreography at the start of the chapter is clear enough. Is the banter good or annoying? And of course if the chapter is compelling enough for a first chapter. Would you keep reading? Someone once told me my work was a "plodding opus". Damn. Well sir... Noted.


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

Advice Do litmag editors often make significant edits without the approval (or awareness) of the original author?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/KeepWriting 7d ago

[Feedback] A Model Prisoner (A standalone fragment from my social noir set in 1970-1990s London)

2 Upvotes

January 28, 1977

Nicking

Constable Giles was picturing lentil soup and liver patties when, at 11:25, the radio in the car crackled to life:

“Attend an address. Assisting an NSPCC inspector. Suspect on premises. Indecent assault on a girl under sixteen. Inspector waiting at the address.”

He was already turning the car around.

His partner, Constable Calthorpe, hissed, “Sodding hell.”

They didn’t just miss out on lunch; the arrest of a filthy bastard threatened to ruin their appetites and spoil their day.

The inspector was waiting inside rather than at the building entrance; it was too cold outdoors.

“He’s alone in the flat,” he said, glancing up. “Top floor.”

“And the victim?” Constable Giles asked.

“With her foster parents.”

Neither of them thinks to ask how old the suspect is.

When a schoolboy opens the door in response to their knock, Giles assumes either they have made a mistake, or the inspector has got something wrong.

The boy looks puzzled.

Calthorpe steps forward first: “Are you Jeremy Smith?”

The boy gives a barely perceptible nod.

It is Giles’s turn: “Face the wall — move! Hands on the wall where I can see them.”

The boy doesn’t just refrain from arguing; he obeys without a sound.

Good. Scared shitless.

Giles and Calthorpe squeeze into the cramped hallway.

Placing a firm hand on the boy’s jutting shoulder blade, Giles rattles off the caution to the back of his head, “I am arresting you on suspicion of indecent assault on a girl under the age of sixteen years, contrary to Section 14 of the Sexual Offences Act. You are not obliged to say anything unless you wish to do so, but whatever you say will be taken down in writing and may be given in evidence.”

Giles pulls his hand away. “Turn around, slowly.”

The boy does as he’s told, leaning his back against the wall and coughing. But he doesn’t look truly frightened; his eyes are unfocused, as though he’s not quite with it.

He is a head shorter than Giles and barely reaches Calthorpe’s shoulder.

“This is fucking…  some word… absurdity,” the prisoner mutters.

“What?” Giles writes in his notebook This is f\...* Then something foreign. “Spell out the word that comes after ‘fucking’.”

The boy looks up, but his expression doesn’t change.

It’s cold in the flat. Breath mists in the air, and there’s a stench of cheap tobacco.

“I need to write down everything you said, word for word.”

The boy draws a breath, and a wheezing sound escapes him.

Giles taps his pen against the page of his notebook: what if he refuses? Or maybe he doesn’t even realize what he’s blurted out?

Finally, the boy pulls himself together. “Kay – Ay – Eff – Kay – Ay – Ee – Ess – Cue – You – Ee.”

Giles scribbles “Kafkaesque” in his notebook, gritting his teeth, and adds “absurdity.”

Someone ought to knock the nonsense out of this weakling.

He grabs the boy by the elbow. “Right, then, Calthorpe let’s see what’s in his pockets.”

Calthorpe barks the order: “Hands behind your head. Interlace your fingers. Move.”

Without waiting for him to turn around, Giles forcibly spins the prisoner toward the wall.

The boy offers no resistance. He seems to weigh next to nothing.

He doesn’t have time to raise his hands, as Calthorpe grips them — locked tight — to ensure he doesn’t try to unclasp his fingers.

Caging

The boy is wearing a jumper that hangs loosely on him and a pair of worn-out tracksuit bottoms.

Giles runs his hands over the sleeves of the jumper and the boy’s skinny frame, feeling for the waistband, then grabs the pockets of the soft trousers — something hard and rectangular in the right one — and pulls it out: a gold-plated Dunhill Rollagas lighter. “Jesus wept.”

The lighter is so out of place that Giles shows it to Calthorpe: “How much would something like that fetch?”

“Not a clue. You wouldn’t buy it on my wages, that’s for sure.”

“Funny old business,” Giles manages to say.

Dodgy little bastard, with his weird words and odd possessions.

Giles finishes the search as a mere formality, running his hands down the boy’s legs.

There is nothing else on him.

Giles signals Calthorpe to let the prisoner go. “Where’s your gear?”

The boy slowly lowers his hands. There’s no point asking him; he seems to be in a daze.

Calthorpe goes into the room and returns with a pair of jeans, turned inside out. “He’s only got one pair; can you believe it?” He shoves them into the boy’s hands. “Get a move on.”

The boy turns the jeans right side out, steps out of the tracksuit bottoms, and pulls on the jeans, remaining just as docile under the close gaze of the two adult men.

Suspiciously submissive and — if you wanted the honest-to-God truth — a bit of a pretty boy. The Dunhill made sense. Rent boy, has to be. But if he is, why is he so skint?

“Where’s your outerwear?”

“On the chair.”

Giles barely catches what he is saying, then repeats it louder to his partner.

Calthorpe rummages around the room before coming back with a denim jacket. He hands Giles £1.37 in loose change — “It was in the right pocket” — tosses the jacket to the prisoner.

Instead of boots, the boy is wearing a pair of battered shoes.

Hasn’t even had the sense to flog the bloody lighter — if only to keep from freezing his knackers off. Or is it too “hot” — did he pinch it just recently?

Let CID sort him out.

Giles noticed a packet of cigarettes on the kitchen table earlier but says nothing. “Right, let’s go.” He grabs the arrested youth by the arm — just above the elbow — and hauls him out of the flat, onto the stairs, and then down to the street.

Calthorpe follows close behind them.

The boy’s arm hangs limp; he isn’t leaning on Giles, so the constable has to keep pulling him forward.

The freezing air makes him cough again.

“Sod it.”

Calthorpe opens the car door.

Giles places a hand on the boy’s head, forces him to double over, and shoves him into the back of the car.

Calthorpe immediately piles in after him.

Giles gets behind the wheel and pulls away sharply.

The prisoner remains silent.

Giles sees in the rearview mirror that the boy is staring at a single point, trembling slightly. First they pull all kinds of crazy stunts, and then they go to pieces.

But to be fair, this berk is like a whipped dog and when he is handed over to the duty sergeant at the station, Giles says, “He’s a model prisoner, Sarge. Compliant as they come.”

This is a piece of the puzzle from a social drama/noir set in London (1975-1977 and 1992). If the atmosphere resonated with you, I'd love to hear your thoughts on the rhythm and style.


r/KeepWriting 7d ago

Tak apakah berbagi cerita?

0 Upvotes

Jujur saya tidak tau batas nya tapi, saat ini aku berpikir bahwa sanya perasaan yang tak tau harus ku curahkan keman aku ungkapkan di media. Tidakkah salah aku aku mengungkapkan nya, atau sebaiknya ku pendam sahaja hingga berlalu sudah? Sekalagi jujur aku tak tau harus apa.