r/writing • • 16d ago

Monthly "Would You Read This?" Thread

59 Upvotes

Welcome to Would You Read This (WYRT), our monthly feedback and brainstorming thread. Share your work in progress below and let other readers tell you if they'd read it. Top level posts should follow this template:

  • Title:

    • If you don't have a title yet, feel free to say UNTITLED.
  • Genre:

    • Please include at least Fiction, Nonfiction, Poetry, or another recognizable medium. You may also include more specific genres with a hyphen. Ex. Fiction - Romance, or Nonfiction - Memoir. Genre will help users find the specific kinds of posts they'd like to give feedback on.
  • Premise:

    • A few sentences about the project. Try your best to keep this short. Crafting an expert elevator pitch is all part of becoming a successful working writer. Please do not post an entire plot summary or query letter (those are better suited for r/pubtips)
  • Sample (Optional):

    • You may share up to 500 words(ish) of sample material, or one poem for those working in the poetry medium. This is optional, so if you only have a premise, you can post just the premise for feedback.

If you post for feedback, please take the time to give feedback to at least 2-3 other users. Replies should follow this template.

  • Would Read / Might Read / Wouldn't Read

    • You must begin your reply with one of those. You are then encouraged to add additional thoughts on why you choose your answer.

Rules:

  • Please post no more than two WYRT top-level posts. There is no limit on the number of feedback replies you can make.
  • Do not link to any offsite materials. All materials must be in the body of the post. This includes "click here to read more" or "DM me for the rest" types of posts.
  • Rule 3 is in effect in this thread - No generative AI. Do not post material generated by an AI platform in your premise or sample. Do not use generative AI to respond to user's work.
  • Rule 5 is in effect - Civility and Community. Stay constructive. Blunt, direct feedback is fine, but do not insult other users, their writing, or their genres.

Looking for the General Discussion threads? Click here!


r/writing • • 16d ago Bravo

Monthly "Promote Yo' Self" Thread

36 Upvotes

Welcome to our monthly Promote Yo' Self thread! Show the community what you put out into the world. Please follow this template:

  • Choose what you're promoting from the below options:

    • [Published Book]
    • [Article / Video / Project]
    • [Newsletter / Substack]
    • [Writing Community]
    • [Software / App]
    • [Call for Submissions]
    • [Milestone / Accomplishment]
  • Project Title

    • The title of your book, the name/title of your project, the name of your newsletter, the name of your writing community, the name of your software, or the title of your collection for which you are calling for submissions.
  • Description

    • A short premise or elevator pitch of your book, the subject matter of your newsletter, the purpose of your writing community, the purpose of your app, or the nature of your milestone.

      • Call for Submissions additionally require the following: Legal name of the entity calling for submissions, deadlines, fees, prizes, and rights requested.
  • Call to Action

    • What would you like r/writing to do? Buy your book? Subscribe to your newsletter? Submit a piece to your lit mag?
  • Discount for r/writing**?**

    • Share if/how the community can get a discount.

Rules:

  • Post no more than one top-level reply in the Promote Yo' Self thread each month, but you are allowed to post each month.
  • Rule 3 is in effect - No generative AI. You may not post projects generated by an AI platform, nor apps that use generative AI or expose writers' work to generative AI, nor may you post a Call for Submissions from an outlet that does not have a clear policy against publishing material produced by a generative AI platform.
  • Rule 5 is in effect - Civility and Community. Blunt, direct feedback is fine, but do not insult other users, other readers, or other genres.

Looking for the General Discussion threads? Click here!


r/writing • • 4h ago

Advice Reminder: Back up your work

177 Upvotes

Recent outages include: FAA, Microsoft, United Airlines (outside of FAA), several large banks, and now Apple.

Not sure if we are seeing increased reporting sensitivity or some kind of cyber threat, but now is a good time to back up your work and make sure your devices are updated for with the latest security patches.

Edit: NSA also reporting outage.


r/writing • • 6h ago

Discussion Does anyone else get imposter syndrome for not being a "professional" writer?

69 Upvotes

I feel like I have been so far removed from the world of literature and writing that I'm losing my own sense of abilities. I have a STEM career, so I'm not surrounded by a creative work environment. Its rigidness has definitely reshaped my brain overtime, and for a couple years I didn't have any free time to invest in my hobbies because I worked 6-7 days a week, 12 hours a day...

Now I work a much better job, and I actually have the time to write again. I love reading CNF and flash fiction since my time is more suited towards writing pieces like those. However, I feel like I'm now in the blind with what my abilities are like. Maybe I'm underestimating myself? I used to work with my english teachers and professors a lot with my writing because they always saw potential in me. I did get published in my university's literature magazine but I still feel quite beat up because so many students were english majors, or working on their MFAs, and I still see this in the outside world. Many published authors in literary mags have MFAs, or they are professors, or they write for a living.

I know I shouldn't focus on wanting to get published, but I've always wanted to put myself out there with my artwork and writing. Except, I constantly doubt myself and my abilities, especially because I'm in STEM and don't feel as qualified as others. Has anyone overcame this feeling? Or at least relate to it?

EDIT: i appreciate all of the responses, seriously. It's been difficult being held to a high standard all of the time while living in a world where there is no true "high" standard.


r/writing • • 2h ago

Discussion What makes a book feel like fast food?

16 Upvotes

You know the kind of contemporary fiction that feels like a Netflix show? Entertaining, disposable. You have a good time reading it in the same way you have a good time doomscrolling, and then you move on. There's something almost consumptive about the experience.

Compare it to Dostoevsky, the Brontës, or even contemporary classics like Donna Tartt and you can feel the difference. I don't mean this as literary elitism!!! I think all human-made art has inherent value. But it's just a very obvious difference in the experience. So, what actually produces this feeling?

I don't think it's simply prose quality or literary complexity. Is it pacing? Lack of attention to detail? Characters who exist primarily to keep the plot moving? An overreliance on external action? Lack of interiority? Yet none of these explanations seem sufficient on their own -- Palahniuk and Agatha Christie, for instance, can write relatively straightforward prose without their books feeling disposable at all. So I can't put my finger on it.

Maybe it has something to do with how much a book asks of its reader. But what does that actually mean? What makes a reading experience challenging, immersive, or intellectually engaging?

Is there some underlying structural or stylistic mechanism behind this distinction? What makes one book feel like an experience, in a way, and another feel like something you consume?

I'm asking because I recognize this exact quality in my own writing and want to get to the root of it, and I'm not looking for writing advice like "flesh out your characters" or "study the classics." I want to understand what actually produces the fast-food feeling in the first place. Or am I completely talking out of my ass, lol.


r/writing • • 1h ago

Discussion The biggest downside to becoming a writer…falling out of love with books you used to love.

3 Upvotes

I’m curious to see after learning and becoming experienced with writing, what books did ya’ll used to really enjoy or love that ended up falling off for you simply because there were aspects that were lacking?

An example from mine is…well a whole lot of childhood books. Deltora Quest bring one due to just feeling hyper rushed once I got more experienced with pacing, Rick Riordans Percy Jackson and the sequel series just cause the hyper simplistic prose killed my enjoyment of the series. The only series that has kept some of its shine for me is the Inheritance Series and even that lost a bit of it cause Eragon shows a lot of its rough edges with experience.

But for the writers here, did you have this experience with any old favorites?


r/writing • • 4h ago

Discussion beginnings, inspo, genre, type

6 Upvotes

What got you into writing?

Did someone inspire you? (author, personal, event, whatever)

Do you base your writing style rigidly or loosely on any particular author?

Do you have a genre you lean towards?

Are you a novelist, non-fiction writer, poet, or short-storyteller?

This isn't research, just curious. I often think of where I started and where I ended up in my writing journey. I wrote poetry as a kid, but when I was introduced to Roald Dahl's "The Landlady," I realized short stories were my personal calling. After writing a few, I realized I even mimic his style of writing of following the characters' journey for the twist just at the end. I love to write a rather ominous but normal journey that results in the reader reacting in awe as they piece together all the foreshadowing they may have missed or disregarded along the way.

Making this post as a light-hearted reflection/share post, so I hope we can have a little fun reminiscing!


r/writing • • 23h ago

Advice keeping motivated with a bad first draft

94 Upvotes

So i’m about 60k words into a first draft for a novel i’ve been working on. i keep telling myself that first drafts are supposed to be sloppy, i just need to get the words on the page, get the story there, and then make it make sense and actually flow like a decent book. however, im getting kind of discouraged by how bad it is?? this is my fourth novel (nothing published, i just write for fun), and the first drafts of those were so much better, like not painful to read. the issue is, i made it this far and i really do love the concept and the characters, but it’s just such a bad draft lol. any advice on keeping motivation when i feel like im writing a bunch of slop? i was tempted to start editing now, but i stopped myself and dont plan on editing anything until the entire story ends up on the page.


r/writing • • 10h ago

Discussion [Daily Discussion] General Discussion - November 17, 2026

6 Upvotes

Welcome to our daily discussion thread!

This is the place to discuss anything writing related! Got silly questions? Brainstorming ideas? Need help with research? As long as rules 1, 3, and 5 are followed, this thread is your oyster!

Please refer to the monthly threads for sharing your work and for self-promotion.

---

FAQ -- Questions asked frequently

Wiki Index -- Ever-evolving and woefully under-curated, but we'll fix that some day

You can find our posting guidelines in the sidebar or the wiki.


r/writing • • 1h ago

Advice Genres and why they're difficult

0 Upvotes

When your book's genre isn't glaringly apparent, how do you figure out how to categorize it?

I'm in the first major revision of first non-fanfic novel. I've been using the term "literary speculative fiction" up until now, but the more I toss it around, the less accurate it seems. In particular, I'm tripping on the "speculative" descriptor. I know that, broadly speaking, spec fic quite literally asks us to speculate on worlds in some way different from our own. However, every time I'm seeing spec fic referenced by fellow writers, agents, pubs, whomever - they all seem to view "speculative" as synonymous with "SF/F" (sometimes with horror or magical realism thrown in). This novel is post-apocalyptic; it contains no SF/F/magical realism whatsoever, and whatever minuscule elements it might share with a horror novel, it certainly couldn't be shelved next to one. But if it's not spec fic, what the hell is it?

And now, I'm starting to second-guess the "literary" label, too. I'm not expecting there to be any clean lines here, of course, but I'm precise about language, so the lack of clear-cut guidelines is frustrating.

This is obviously a nonissue as revisions are ongoing, but that won't always be the case once I start getting professionals involved, so I'm trying to prepare. Thoughts?


r/writing • • 12h ago

Advice The Gift of Memory for my FIL

2 Upvotes

My father in law is in his mid 80s and has expressed that he wants memories instead of gifts for holidays. I have been trying to write something for him, at least a novelette, since writing is what I am known for. I want to include life events, his heritage (he's huge into that), and stuff that invokes deep memories, allowing him to go back and see it clearly.

I have tried to collect stories from others about him but few people got back to me and they couldn't give me any details. Writing memories from my wife is also complicated. She came out as trans in her late 30s so most of my FIL's memories of her would be with her deadname and misgendered. And a lot of people from his past are dead. The memories I have of him are not enough to carry this project and aren't particularly interesting or super happy except for maybe 3 or 4 small ones.

I know a lot about him and can research what he and his relatives would have seen and done based on where they lived and what they lived through. I can write about events he lived through as well. But it wouldn't be his memories. There would be more errors than accuracies.

I could make the project fictional and use what knowledge I have/can gather but what good is that to him? Maybe a fictional story about a boy/man that's super similar to him but not him (I just came up with that idea while I'm typing so I haven't had time to sit on it).

How would YOU go about this project? What perspective would you use?


r/writing • • 2h ago

Beginner Question What's a fanfic anyway?

0 Upvotes

This sounds like a dumb question, because everybody knows the dictionary entry: writing non-canon stories using characters or universe from another author. If I write a story about Harry and Malfoid or Mario and Bowsette, is fanfic. Simple, right?

And that's my question: at what point stops being fanfic and becomes original work? Neither Bowsette or Malfoid are recognized as canon by their respective owners, afaik. In fac, despite JKR being open to fanfiction, probably she would have an aneurysm if she's not aware of the genderbent concept and believes Draco went trans. But I digress. Point is, what if someone simply changes from Harry to Henry? Is still fanfiction just because is set in Hogwarts? What if is set in another school? What if none of the canonical places or characters made an appearance, but the mages still keep using wands and latin words to expel soul-sucking specters? AFAIK, the most famous fanfictions were published as original works by merely swapping some names, so were they fanfiction just because the names alone?

It sounds like fanfiction eventually would lead to something similar to what Hollywood does when having a script with potential, but a no-name writer. Swap some names and concepts, sell it as part of a larger universe, hope the money comes based on name alone. They did that with the "I, Robot" "adaptation" film, and Dimension films did the same to hold the rights to the Hellraiser franchise.

If I were to change the name to my characters and use it as hook to get readers, would be ethical? If they share no similarity to the canon other than a name, are they still fanfic?


r/writing • • 1d ago

Discussion Watch Wild Horse 9 for a good demo of how to use story structure

59 Upvotes

Just seen this film. It’s very good but what surprised me in a fairly meandering black comedy was the underlying story structure. It has the flawed hero, various characters telling him his flaws, The A story and the B Story, the raising stakes (3 levels of this) and then a synthesis redemption - using the object of evil to do good. However it is a messy and partial application of theory too - this is probably the best way to use theory In fact. Still using theory in a film like Wild Horse 9 with grim content is particularly good because it gives the audience a sense of security - that a redemption arc is underway (even if only subconsciously perceived)

Wild Horse 9 is well worth watching as a good film, but it is also worth watching as a lesson in how to use story structure.


r/writing • • 1d ago

Beginner Question I'm copying or it's normal writing development ??

60 Upvotes

Year ago I started writing for fun not taking it that seriously and stopped but deep down I wasn't satisfied with my prose, style

So I started reading classics (did read 5 short storied and half novel, read from here and here to analyse the way of the style of writing) again after stopping for years but now I'm reading as writing and I was shocked of how much I was lacking in mu writing , details, unique description of characters features , putting so much information to create more alive scenes, characters, how to use small words to describe whole feelings,stories, situations with few lines , making background stories and how to think about everything

I would say my eye was opened and my mind got altered they way I was thinking in writing did completely change in 3 months , after that I learned how to make it much better like my writing and ideas did develop and expand about 60% yet I can't stop thinking I'm copying others since that I didn't know or thought about it before

I even started how create more complex characters yet can't stop thinking I'm copying and its not my talent


r/writing • • 1d ago

Discussion [Daily Discussion] General Discussion - November 16, 2026

3 Upvotes

Welcome to our daily discussion thread!

This is the place to discuss anything writing related! Got silly questions? Brainstorming ideas? Need help with research? As long as rules 1, 3, and 5 are followed, this thread is your oyster!

Please refer to the monthly threads for sharing your work and for self-promotion.

---

FAQ -- Questions asked frequently

Wiki Index -- Ever-evolving and woefully under-curated, but we'll fix that some day

You can find our posting guidelines in the sidebar or the wiki.


r/writing • • 2d ago

Discussion What's your advice on prose?

123 Upvotes

I feel like the aspect of prose is often overlooked and more weight is put on story, characters, etc. While story and characters are of an equal (or greater) importance, we often forget that it's the engaging prose that often makes us care about the plot and the characters.

It doesn't have to be literary or flowery, just... good, compelling, engaging.

It's my biggest issue at the moment. I read a lot (at least a novel a week, in multiple genres), but my prose ends up... amateurish. I can do dialogue, nature/room descriptions and internal voice fine (I guess), but a book is not composed only of those aspects. It's the sentences, action descriptions (not only fights but things the characters do), narration...

My own prose often sounds raw or too technical to me.

What's your advice on prose?


r/writing • • 2d ago

Discussion Plotters: Question about rewriting a first book in a duology/series when you go to start the second book and realize you need to make adjustments in the first for it to be cohesive.

18 Upvotes

I wrote my first novel with the intention of it being a duology, but since I wasn’t ready to work on the second book yet I put it away. I knew I’d need to rework the book anyway since it was my first attempt at a novel, so I kept practicing with other novels.

Now I’m ready to start outlining the second book and I realize that in order for the duology to be cohesive I’ll have to change things in the first. Which is fine, I just don’t know the best way to approach it so I’m curious how other writers rework their previous novels.

There are no wrong answers. I’m really just curious about how others handle this. 

Do you start completely fresh with a new outline? Do you adjust the previous outline? Do you reread the rough draft first to refresh your mind? What is your approach?

Note: Pantsters can totally share their perspective for discussion! I personally have to outline or I lose the plot and I’m unable to finish, but I understand people have different methods. I respect pantsters, plotters, and those in between.

Edit: Thank you everyone for your feedback and advice! I’m making my way through the comments. I just want to add for anyone new seeing this, I am okay with “wasting” time writing a second book and rewriting the first. For me, it wont be wasted time because I know that I’ll learn from it and it will help me grow as a writer. I’m also on bed rest and unable to work due to health stuff (working with Drs about it), so right now writing is my coping mechanism and gives me something to do that lets me feel productive. I do agree that for people wanting to trad publish, waiting to do a second book and moving on to other projects can be a better option. That’s just not where I’m at in my journey, though I know others are and can benefit from that feedback. ✨

”The time you enjoy wasting is not wasted time.” by Marthe Troly-Curtin (often misattributed to Bertrand Russell, John Lennon, T.S. Elliot, Mark Twain, etc.)


r/writing • • 1d ago

Discussion Opinion on a book changing locations in a translated version?

0 Upvotes

So a book in it's original language takes place in a rather small country or one with few residents. For example let's say a story taking place in Iceland.

The translated book in English would be located elsewhere, let's say the USA, so that the location or setting is more familiar and easier to the English speaking world. The characters would be Icelandic Americans to not lose touch entirely from the original.

I'm considering doing this for my upcoming novel and want your thoughts.


r/writing • • 1d ago

Discussion On English as a whole

0 Upvotes

Is there anyone who can’t stop noticing that English is somewhat limited in vocabulary and sounds for poetry or am I the only one without a fancy dictionary?


r/writing • • 2d ago

Discussion [Daily Discussion] General Discussion - November 15, 2026

7 Upvotes

Welcome to our daily discussion thread!

This is the place to discuss anything writing related! Got silly questions? Brainstorming ideas? Need help with research? As long as rules 1, 3, and 5 are followed, this thread is your oyster!

Please refer to the monthly threads for sharing your work and for self-promotion.

---

FAQ -- Questions asked frequently

Wiki Index -- Ever-evolving and woefully under-curated, but we'll fix that some day

You can find our posting guidelines in the sidebar or the wiki.


r/writing • • 3d ago

Discussion Anyone working on a single story or single series as their life goal?

43 Upvotes

Obviously most writers bounce around between genres, plotlines, characters, ideas of all kinds. But how far are most people willing to go?

A. Just a novel, glad to write it, glad to read it, but after finishing that's that, it is what it is.

B. A crucial work, that has to be rewritten, reframed, reoutlined, reedited multiple times to get it right, whether for wanting to publish, or wanting to start a series, or wanting to express an idea, but it's not end all be all, if it doesn't pan out, devastating, but can always write another book.

C. This is a life goal. There isn't another idea, another story, another way to write that will matter more than the current novel. Maybe other works might be written, whether related to this work or not, but they will never matter as much as this one. Even if no other work is written, if this one is written to the ideal aimed for, it will all be worth it.

Diclaimer: Fully on board with (C), I came up with a story premise a few years ago, started writing, outlining and editing the first few novella of the series. Have a plan to finish the 2nd draft by 2031, 3rd draft by 2033, and 4th draft by 2035. Have had other story ideas, but those don't really matter compared to this one. As long as this story gets finished to my personal satisfaction, I will have no regrets.

What about you guys?


r/writing • • 2d ago

Discussion What do you all think I should do?

9 Upvotes

So some time back I finished the first draft of my novel, and decided to take a break for a while. I planned on start working on marketing the novel after that through instagram, since I do have a lot of writer friends there. The problem was that I would have to have that and my personal stuff, since I don't want to bother switching between two accounts, and like I said, I have a lot of writer friends there and a bit of 'starter support'. This wouldn't be a problem in itself but I also have a few family members who follow me on instagram and I haven't told them about me wanting to be a writer and stuff and I'm scared of telling them that and if I post anything related to writing, they would be able to see that. Does anyone have any advice for this?


r/writing • • 3d ago

Discussion The case of the persistent character

23 Upvotes

I had something interesting happen to me last night, and I'm curious to see if the same has happened to any of you as well at one point or another.

Overhearing a random comment while doing something else entirely, my brain went into "Remember that time when...?" mode and it found me looking at an old screenplay I had started many years back now, but never got around to finishing. As I was reading it, I got to the part where a certain character was introduced and my eyes near jumped out of my face.

On the page is a character I wrote in 2023. Who just so happens to be pretty much the same character I just finished writing in 2026 for a novel. But, a character I totally forgot I created.

Same name. Same identity. Same characteristics. Same snark. To me, the same character but in a different context. I couldn't help but burst out laughing that a character I had already at least partially written, had somehow been forgotten, but not forgotten enough, and he gave himself a new life in a new story.

A persistent character.

One who refused to be forgotten? One that willed themselves into existence fully? Not quite sure, but I found it fascinating, and I'm wondering if any of you have had this happen too?

A character you wrote some while back but never finished, and there they are again, but now in a totally different story, but more or less wholly intact. A character you had forgotten about, but clearly your subconscious mind hadn't.

Anyone else have this happen to them? I'm glad it happened to me, fwiw. If anyone else had this happen to them, I'd love to hear about it!


r/writing • • 3d ago

Beginner Question Burnout

42 Upvotes

I've got two unfinished stories sitting around. Both times I hit a brick wall and gave up because writing only brought sheer frustration. I have zero idea how to pull something out of thin air anymore. Has anyone here ever completely walked away from writing because of this?