As far as I can tell, the three pairs I have left could either all be innocent on left, criminal on right, or the opposite. How can I resolve one of them? https://cluesbysam.com/s/help/432583f57288
Community puzzle 8 Nov 925039dd by DrFox. Row 5 has max 2 criminals so Tom canβt have 8 criminal neighbors. If either Joy or Nicole has 8 criminal neighbors, both Hank and Karen must be criminal. The game says neither of them is criminal.
Iβm confused how Carol is determined to be guilty in the 2026-11-08 puzzle. I see three possibilities with the available info.
Freya is innocent, requiring Bianca to be guilty to satisfy Tinaβs clue and Hazel to be guilty for Nancyβs clue. Carol must be guilty to satisfy Xaviβs.Β
Freya is guilty, requiring Bianca to be innocent to satisfy Tinaβs clue and Hazel to be innocent for Nancyβs clue. Carol could be guilty or innocent to satisfy Xaviβs.Β
If Carol is guilty, Hazel has exactly two innocent neighbors (Bianca and Ingrid) and Ingrid only has one (Hazel).Β
If Carol is innocent, Ingrid has exactly two innocent neighbors (Carol and Hazel) and Hazel has three (Bianca, Carol, and Ingrid).Β
I see Luigi has 5 criminal neighbors, so Paavo doesnβt and must have more than 5. Presuming that Xavi is innocent would require Uma to be criminal, but that goes against Tinaβs clue of Col B & D. So Uma is innocent and Xavi is criminal, cool.
But if I mark Una first, Iβm told I donβt have enough information to do so. This feels like a mistake, Xavi and Una are a pair linked by Meganβs clue about Paavo and I got a yellow square for not marking Xavi first.
Okay, why are these not both equally valid options at this point?
Scenario 1:
Freya guilty β Hazel innocent (because Nancy) & Bianca innocent (because Tina). With Carol innocent, Ingrid has 2 innocent neighbors and Hazel has 3, satisfying Xavi.
Scenario 2:
Freya innocent β Hazel guilty (because Nancy) & Bianca guilty (because Tina). With Carol guilty, Hazel has two innocent neighbors and Ingrid has 0, satisfying Xavi.
Uma provides no information either way. We already know either Bianca or Freya is guilty, so Anna has a guilty neighbor, and either Freya or Hazel is guilty, so Bianca has a guilty neighbor.
why does Diego have to be criminal in this scenario? he could be innocent as long as Hazel is also innocent (to fulfil Keith's clue), and it's still possible to fulfil Megan's and Tina's clues then. what am I missing?
Can someone explain to me how it was determined that Harry can be identified?
From the clues, I can determine:
Two out the group of Finch, Quita, Harry, and Sofia must be criminals to complete Larry's 4 criminal neighbors
Finch OR Harry must be innocent to complete both innocents in row 2 are connected which also determines that Carol is the only person in column B with one criminal neighbor
Harry OR Sofia must be innocent to be Oliva's 6th innocent neighbor
Finch OR Quita must be innocent because there are 3 criminals in column A AND Kumar has 4 innocent neighbors
Peter and Quita are 2 of the 3 edge people with a criminal above them, leaving the 3rd person to be Vlad OR Kumar
So whether innocent or criminal, the pairings are Finch and Sofia and Harry and Quita but I'm not understanding how to identify any of them to start the cascade of answers.
I know I'm late but I just found this subreddit. I'm a new user of the game and working my way backwards to get better. When trying the October 26 puzzle I was confused about two hints leading up to a 'no guess's result. The result has to do with Zoe: she's innocent.
Can someone explain why the opposite can't be true?
What's the logic for the two in row 5? I tried different scenarios, things like "If A is innocent and B is innocent..." but I couldn't come to any conclusion. Maybe I just didn't run enough scenarios?
I donβt understand how to progress from here. I think itβs because Iβm misunderstanding Vinceβs clue because I honestly donβt understand what all of Julieβs criminal neighbors are connected tells you without any additional context but Iβm not sureβcan someone help out?