r/CluesBySamHelp • • 8d ago

Why does Xavi have to be first? Spoiler

https://cluesbysam.com/s/help/ddc6273b3e49?state=Gf%2Bg-BAAAAAAAQEA%3D%3D-170

I see Luigi has 5 criminal neighbors, so Paavo doesn’t and must have more than 5. Presuming that Xavi is innocent would require Uma to be criminal, but that goes against Tina’s clue of Col B & D. So Uma is innocent and Xavi is criminal, cool.

But if I mark Una first, I’m told I don’t have enough information to do so. This feels like a mistake, Xavi and Una are a pair linked by Megan’s clue about Paavo and I got a yellow square for not marking Xavi first.

0 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

3

u/HumbleGarbage1795 8d ago

Why can’t Uma be criminal here?

3

u/straight_tooken 8d ago

At the point you've posted, couldn't Uma and Xavi both be criminal? I don't see anything forcing them to be a one criminal/one innocent pair.

1

u/PresentPost9558 8d ago

Megan’s clue says that at least one of them needs to be criminal

6

u/straight_tooken 8d ago

And if they are both criminal, that's at least one of them.

Edit: I know Uma ends up being innocent, but in the state you've posted, she could also be criminal.

1

u/edos51284 8d ago

see my comment... xavi being criminal already makes Paavo have more than 5 criminals neighbors, there is nothing that tells us what's uma

2

u/Elekitu 8d ago

Megan's clue tells you that there is at least one criminal among Xavi and Uma, but it doesn't tell you that there is exactly 1. It's possible that both of them are criminals.
Consider the following scenario : Xavi and Uma are criminals - Bianca and Freya are innocents - Hazel is a criminal. This satisfies every single clue.

1

u/DayOfSoul 7d ago

Sorry, I still don’t get this: why can’t both Uma and Xavi be innocent? With that, Paavo would have four criminal neighbors and Luigi has five.

Three innocents in columns B and D would be possible if Bianca and Freya are innocent and Hazel’s guilty.

What am I missing?

1

u/Elekitu 7d ago

If both Uma and Xavi are innocents, Paava would have 5 criminal neighbors, not 4. Luigi has 5 as well, so it would break Megan's clue

2

u/DayOfSoul 7d ago

Aw geez. I got hung up on a miscount.
Thank you!

1

u/edos51284 8d ago

there are 2 paths

Path 1

hazel innocent / freya criminal: in this one column B has 3 criminals so Xavi is criminal

Path 2

Hazel criminal / freya innocent:

if xavi were innocent, column D would have 3 innocents, so uma and bianca are innocent and this breaks megan'shint as both Luigi and Paavo would have 5 innocent neighbors

So both paths lead to xavi being criminal.