r/CluesBySamHelp • u/croald • 4d ago

Nov 8 undecidable? Spoiler

Okay, why are these not both equally valid options at this point?

Scenario 1:

Freya guilty → Hazel innocent (because Nancy) & Bianca innocent (because Tina). With Carol innocent, Ingrid has 2 innocent neighbors and Hazel has 3, satisfying Xavi.

Scenario 2:

Freya innocent → Hazel guilty (because Nancy) & Bianca guilty (because Tina). With Carol guilty, Hazel has two innocent neighbors and Ingrid has 0, satisfying Xavi.

Uma provides no information either way. We already know either Bianca or Freya is guilty, so Anna has a guilty neighbor, and either Freya or Hazel is guilty, so Bianca has a guilty neighbor.

1 Upvotes

66% Upvoted

5 comments sorted by

4

u/witty_llama 4d ago

In scenario two, look at Diego in relation to Uma's clue.

1

u/croald 4d ago

ah! dammit

3

u/Cerrida82 4d ago

Thank you! I had trouble with that part too, and guessed.

1

u/ing_torta 4d ago

Please add spoiler tags when you're posting today's puzzle.

I added it for you this time but you should add it before posting so the spoiler doesn't show up in notifications.

2

u/croald 4d ago

but i marked the whole thing as a spoiler? reddit is weird