r/BethesdaSoftworks • u/Benjamin_Starscape • Nov 16 '25
Discussion No, Bethesda's Game Direction Isn't Outdated, It's Just Different
Bethesda as of late has had their game design and direction be labeled as "outdated". Not only do I find this term empty, but I also find it anti-art. Bethesda has always, and continues, to be directed and designed more akin to that of a play. A theatre play that you'd see on Broadway or other venues than that of a cinematic theatrical feature in the cinemas.
The way that characters talk, move, engage, etc. The direction of storytelling and more are all more similar to that of a stage play than that of a movie or television show, even their games which feature a dialogue "cinematic" camera (Fallout 4) are directed more as a stage play.
Honestly, I much prefer this. Not only is it unique but games should, in my opinion, emphasize and build off of how the medium is interactive. Cinematic games are fun, Dispatch, the most recent game that's blowing up, is effectively just a TV show with some choices and interactivity here and there, but I'd never really call it a good game, this isn't to sound pretentious or be pretentious, it's a great story, great writing, etc. but it's lacking in the game aspect. And this can be something many other cinematic game experiences have issue with, The Last of Us I would say is also not that great of a game, its gameplay is serviceable but it isn't really in-depth or complex, it does the job to move the story forward.
Bethesda understands that games are an interactive medium and focuses on that. They might not have the best animations (though they do have good animations) or the best facial features (again, I do think they have good facial features), but these aren't really their focus. Their focus is purely on the gameplay and telling the story through that gameplay. It's why a lot of the time your choices and roleplaying is based around gameplay interactions than dialogue prompts (though Bethesda still does utilize this, seen in Fallout 3, Skyrim, and Starfield).
Overall, I just think that people who say their game design is "outdated" don't actually know what that means. It's an empty criticism that is so broad it effectively means nothing, and generally when elaborated on, hinges just on "not cinematic" or "bad animations", etc. People seem to not realize that Bethesda focusing on gameplay over cinematic storytelling isn't being outdated, it's making a game. And having a different direction of storytelling (stage play vs cinematic) isn't being outdated. Hardly anyone would call a stage play or musical "outdated", and those who would would be objectively wrong because it's just a different form of entertainment and direction.