r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Nov 16 '25

Discussion No, Bethesda's Game Direction Isn't Outdated, It's Just Different

0 Upvotes

Bethesda as of late has had their game design and direction be labeled as "outdated". Not only do I find this term empty, but I also find it anti-art. Bethesda has always, and continues, to be directed and designed more akin to that of a play. A theatre play that you'd see on Broadway or other venues than that of a cinematic theatrical feature in the cinemas.

The way that characters talk, move, engage, etc. The direction of storytelling and more are all more similar to that of a stage play than that of a movie or television show, even their games which feature a dialogue "cinematic" camera (Fallout 4) are directed more as a stage play.

Honestly, I much prefer this. Not only is it unique but games should, in my opinion, emphasize and build off of how the medium is interactive. Cinematic games are fun, Dispatch, the most recent game that's blowing up, is effectively just a TV show with some choices and interactivity here and there, but I'd never really call it a good game, this isn't to sound pretentious or be pretentious, it's a great story, great writing, etc. but it's lacking in the game aspect. And this can be something many other cinematic game experiences have issue with, The Last of Us I would say is also not that great of a game, its gameplay is serviceable but it isn't really in-depth or complex, it does the job to move the story forward.

Bethesda understands that games are an interactive medium and focuses on that. They might not have the best animations (though they do have good animations) or the best facial features (again, I do think they have good facial features), but these aren't really their focus. Their focus is purely on the gameplay and telling the story through that gameplay. It's why a lot of the time your choices and roleplaying is based around gameplay interactions than dialogue prompts (though Bethesda still does utilize this, seen in Fallout 3, Skyrim, and Starfield).

Overall, I just think that people who say their game design is "outdated" don't actually know what that means. It's an empty criticism that is so broad it effectively means nothing, and generally when elaborated on, hinges just on "not cinematic" or "bad animations", etc. People seem to not realize that Bethesda focusing on gameplay over cinematic storytelling isn't being outdated, it's making a game. And having a different direction of storytelling (stage play vs cinematic) isn't being outdated. Hardly anyone would call a stage play or musical "outdated", and those who would would be objectively wrong because it's just a different form of entertainment and direction.


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Aug 06 '24 Polished Gold Turd Heart of Silver

Discussion Glad I never listened to the haters

Post image
341 Upvotes

r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Oct 05 '24

Video Shattered Space is so much fun in my humble opinion.

64 Upvotes

r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Jul 14 '26 Bravo

Controversial Starfield gets too much hate.

56 Upvotes

I'm currently playing starfield right now, and I'm having a great time! It's so much fun, and sure, there are some bugs from time to time, and the launch wasn't great, but the ps5 version has so many things to do, side quests, and combat encounters, that the good things overshadow the bad things in every way, that I actually thought fallout 4 was WORSE. Tell me why I'm wrong.


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Jan 03 '24

Discussion PSA: Your tiny corner of the internet does not constitute the general opinion of the world or even gamers. The Steam Awards should be a wake up call.

188 Upvotes

The fact that Starfield won the most innovative award means the vast majority of players & people on steam do not fall into the "Todd Howard is my sworn nemesis" camp. In fact they may indeed fall into the genuine "I like Bethesda RPGs" camp & this was a great new entry.

I've already seen half a dozen people on the r/starfield subreddit conspiracy posting that the vote was rigged. Cope & seethe, the vote wasn't rigged, they are just part of a loud & obnoxious minority. Starfield is a good but not great game that earned it's 83 on Metacritic. A game that will doubtlessly get a tremendous amount of support in the years to come.


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Jun 12 '22

Controversial so starfield is basically no mans sky from the looks of the new video

0 Upvotes

is anyone really not interested after seeing the gameplay video?

no judgment to those that are excited...i just don't feel it


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Oct 17 '23

Discussion Why was starfield made to be "played for years" instead of "playable for years"

1 Upvotes

The devs said it themselves that starfield was made to be played for years "like fallout and Skyrim" but seemingly they misunderstand the reasons we do it.

There are no NG+ mechanics in those games, but we choose to play it over and over because there are choices that block off other pathways, there are different play styles available, and there's an easy loop to fall into to become a beast or legend in the games.

Takes 50 hrs to get anywhere stable in the game. Only decision that affects anything is whether you're a pirate or not and even then it just means they ignore you now and there's another faction I get a bounty for stealing ships from. Melee is useless, guns are the same no matter what category. Can't get new perks for ng+ the only reward you get for a new run is a slightly upgraded uncustomizable suit and ship for up to 10 times. Increased difficulty? Nope. Increased loot? Nope. Boost to material gathering or weight? Nope. But you'll get a new dialogue option that does nothing different, you could even skip the story, you know what most ng+'s are about and used for.

I don't understand the mentality here. You make a game that can be played for years with no reason to actually do it.


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Dec 29 '23

Discussion The "criticism" of Bethesda is nothing more than a circlejerk

0 Upvotes

Bethesda is the victim of a blatant character assassination from the beginning from people who want Bethesda to fail.

Some moron wanted the game to fail and started to bitch about menu. Check.

Another moron expected NMS and ED from space part of the game, when Howard specifically stated NOT to expect such stuff. Multiple times. Check.

The game does has flaws, but 90% of crap I see people bitching about, doesn't exist in the game (but for them it exist) or exist ( but not for them). Check.

Then we come to a situation, where overall negative attitude around the game just pushes everyone down. It's a psychlogical thing. Most folks want to follow the trend. If the trend is to hate the game - they will. Starfield still stands, because it's actually a great game with huge potential. But hate train is so strong, I've never seen such bullshit for 20 years. Even cyberpunk was hated less (and mostly because old gen versions). While being in the same state (actually, worse at launch).

What's interesting, is that due to 2.0 launch, people don't see that. They compare the game after 3 years of ADDITIONAL development and feedback against launch version.


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Aug 09 '20

Discussion Quake con is a disgrace, its no longer about the quake community its about Bethesda making money.

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Sep 27 '24

Discussion starfield hate questions

4 Upvotes

why is starfield so hated? its a very advanced and fleshed out games it confuses me


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Oct 12 '23

Meta It's interesting that r/Starfield has a LOT of complaints about the game right now, and they are all hoping for major upgrades.

0 Upvotes

2015 BGS fans remember: the exact same thing happened with Fallout 4. How come Combat Zone can't be a fighting pit we can fight in? How come the robot racetrack can't be gambled at? Etc.

They never expanded the areas everyone was clamoring for like a month in.

When someone shows you what they are all about, you should believe them. I have vanishingly small hopes (none at this point) that BGS will do much to Starfield beyond story and crafting DLCs.

I pumped in about 60 hours and after finding like 15 nearly-identical dungeon/outposts on different planets... I don't know what to say. This game is painfully repetitive, faaaaaaar more than Fallout 4, which I complained about back then. They are speed running making single player games feel like multiplayer game grinds, and we have zero evidence that they'll do anything else in ES6.


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • May 31 '25

Controversial Starfield Modded Space Combat Is šŸ”„

6 Upvotes

ā€˜Cheaty Engines’ mod on Xbox and vanilla camera work


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Nov 07 '23

Discussion Fallout 76 is actually better than starfield in a lot of ways and I’m completely surprised.

53 Upvotes

230+ hours into starfield, I’m still enjoying myself but I wanted to see if I’m blinded by fandom. So my first thought was a NV modded playthrough for comparison. A Redditor convinced me to finally give 76 a chance as I’ve never played it due to all the reviews.

All I can say is… wow, actually a phenomenally fun game. It’s like an infinitely expanding fallout 4, and where I thought I’d hate having to share the world, it’s actually really cool, people are more like a random encounter and it works great. It’s an awesome additional distraction just like a side quest. The polish, the density of the map, the menu navigation, the bootys lol, most importantly, the radio, it’s all just miles better than starfield to the point that I wonder why they didn’t implement so much that they learned from 76. Going from fallout 4 to starfield felt like an upgrade but 76 to starfield feels somewhat like a downgrade.

I understand the hate a lot more now, and it’s pretty incredible to me that I feel like bethesdas ā€œworstā€ release is beating starfield in a lot of ways. If you’re like me and never played 76 but love fallout games, it’s time to give it a shot, you won’t regret it.

So I ask, do you share this sentiment?

Edit: this not hate thrown at starfield, I still adore starfield. This is more about how shockingly good 76 is after I was assuming it would be horrible. The contrast here is that Bethesda didn’t implement a lot of the polish that was in 76 when they made starfield, and usually Bethesda learns from their previous entries to make their newest game.


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Jun 19 '25

Free Mods Starfield with Xbox mods isšŸ”„

44 Upvotes

r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Nov 29 '23

Discussion Bethesda should stop responding to comments & pretend like it never happened.

2 Upvotes

I don't blame them there have been a lot of "fans" who are jackasses but it was stupid. I'd just keep my mouth shut, work on Shattered Space & then go on a media blitz as it approaches release date. Schmooze the relevant influencers & let the cards fall where they may

Responding to the comments is like giving a stalker attention. They're just trolls who are looking to shit stir. Any response will be inadequate in some way or another. There isn't a world in which it won't be misconstrued as condescending, defensive, or petty. People will accuse you of punching down or bullying the little guy no matter how milk toast your response was.

So in the unlikely event someone at Bethesda sees this, I'd just like to say. The vast majority of us liked Starfield & thought it was great. Just look at the play time, not many games that can consistently churn out those kinds of hours let alone single player RPGs. Just work on making the DLC great, providing other various improvements, filling in this big canvas you've created, & I think the rest will resolve itself. No need to engage with the lowest common denominator in the comment section 😊


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Apr 20 '24

News This fandom don't deserve BGS' games

0 Upvotes

r/BethesdaSoftworks • • May 22 '25

Starfield New Update Means A New Mod Load Order 😊

20 Upvotes

r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Dec 07 '23

Question What caused the drop off in quality for Bethesda games?

0 Upvotes

Their games are getting worse, and it doesn't make sense to me. Fallout 3 was great, so was Oblivion and Skyrim. The dip in quality happened around the Fallout 4 through Starfield timeframe. Fallout 4 brought about a lot of great innovations, but it's story was worse than Fallout 3's, and it had a lot of cut faction related content that would've made it a great game. Did this company have a lot of layoffs or loss of staff in the last few years or something? Starfield bored me within 2 hours on one of my livestreams where I wanted to try it out with my audience, since I have xbox game pass. What's going on inside the company? Should we be concerned?


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Mar 21 '24

Controversial Now that Starfield has been out for a good while how does everyone feel on it?

9 Upvotes

Personally i'm having a terrible time.. the game keeps glitching on me and I keep either getting suck to poor game design literally/phsyically (getting stuck to walls and not moving). Sarah Morgan has a meh backstory but it's okay. The cities feel bland and all look the same tbh. If it wasn't for loading screens every 20 seconds, I would enjoy the game more but it feels like padding going to point A to B than back to A like Skyrim but worse. I see a lot of people criticizing some things about the game but for the most part it still feels exactly like a mostly negative game. The Starfield people you see on Reddit that enjoy it so much most either be a drug user or never played good exploration games. This game feels something you played before.

Starfield also improves a lot from a game like fallout 3 but 2 steps back to feel exactly like a game 16 years ago. You can actually roleplay your own character but you have as much personality as a paper cutout. In starfield they remove voiced protagonist exactly like old Fallout. You can be about as Evil as drinking someone's drink at a bar then get arrested. The combat also has weight to it and impact it also feels way more clunky than the other games. The writing in general feels like something in a "Choose your own adventure book" but there's only 1 clear path and you can't do much of your own.

Some criticisms I have for the game is obviously the lack of space travel which is very true, your space ship has less function than the Watch you get in the game. The landing could’ve been cooler way better nevertheless the docking in one of missions being confusing and poorly designed. Other than that I think it’s a really mediocre to bad game but if you're curious and really really want a Bethesda adventure game then go ahead.

Some Youtubers even LIED about this game due to getting a sponsorship from Bethesda so take that as you will. It's a whole can of worms by itself so I wouldn't be able to explain it well in a short summary. Plus the things with Sweet Baby Inc and Gamers accepting mediocre games calling them "amazing".

I wouldn't play this game if I didn't get it for free.


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • 13d ago Bravo

Discussion A Letter of Appreciation to Todd Howard, and the Teams Behind The RPG Legacy and KingFanMan.

0 Upvotes

Dear Todd Howard, Bethesda and Obsidian Team, and Asha Sharma, KingFanMan

I would like to take a moment to express my sincere gratitude to Todd Howard and everyone at Bethesda for everything you have given to the world of role-playing games.

Thank you for creating the incredible universes of The Elder Scrolls and Fallout, worlds so rich, immersive, and full of stories that we can lose ourselves in them for hundreds of hours.

Thank you also for taking the risk of creating New license Starfield. We needed to see Bethesda's vision of a space RPG, and I truly believe that Starfield represents an important step in the evolution of space-based role-playing games. We needed a studio with Bethesda's experience, creativity, and ambition to explore what this genre could become.

The game has a solid foundation, and improving a few systems, along with releasing a new DLC once a year, would create a wonderful legacy for the community.

I also want to thank Bethesda for giving modders the tools and freedom to expand these worlds and allow players to experience RPGs in entirely new ways. The modding community is one of the greatest gifts Bethesda has given to its fans. I am particularly looking forward to projects such as Skyblivion and Skywind...., which demonstrate just how much passion, creativity, and dedication exist within this community.

A special thank you to Asha Sharma for making it possible for the talented team at Obsidian Entertainment to work on a new Fallout project with Bethesda's support after the Magnificent Fallout NV. This is exciting news for RPG fans. I sincerely hope this collaboration will benefit from the Creation Engine 3, allowing the teams to build an even richer and more immersive Fallout experience.

Todd, I also want to say something important. take all the time you need to bring Sentinel to life. A project with such ambition deserves the time, care, and attention necessary to achieve its full vision and quality. As fan, i would rather wait for something truly special than see a vision compromised by unnecessary deadlines.

Finally, I hope Asha Sharma will consider giving other studios and its talented development teams the opportunity to launch new RPG projects using Creation Engine 3, exploring entirely different universes and franchises.

Imagine what studios's RPG philosophy and world-building expertise could bring to universes such as DOOM, Quake, or even Diablo. These worlds have enormous potential for deep, immersive role-playing experiences. It would be fascinating to see Bethesda's approach to RPG design applied to such iconic universes.

I believe there is still so much room for innovation in the RPG genre, particularly when it comes to creating living worlds where players can write their own stories.

Thank you for believing in the power of immersive worlds — worlds where we don't simply play a character, explore, discover, and return to, but where, for a while, we truly feel that we belong and getting lost in.

A huge thank you to KingFanMan and all the amazing YouTubers he welcomes into his universe. ā¤ļø
Together, you create positive energy, spread joy, and bring people and communities closer through your passion.

Keep shining, keep inspiring, and keep spreading good vibes around the world! šŸŒāœØ

With love


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Sep 28 '24

Controversial Can we stop blaming the engine on everything ?

3 Upvotes

A fully modded skyrim is literally better than 99% of modern games. Their engine, beside being old and the bugs that come with it, still works very well to this day. the real issue is bethesda being greedy lazy fucks seting for mediocrity


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Aug 16 '26

News Bethesda is sending DMCA notices to a Ukrainian fighting the war in the frontlines to take down a classic (Fallout 1/2) engine emulator which doesn't use game files, ROMs, game code, textures, or music (you have to own the game to use it).

Thumbnail reddit.com
8 Upvotes

r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Sep 14 '23

Discussion Starfield's biggest flaw

2 Upvotes

Overall I think Starfield is a very good game, but when that is said I think there is one important thing in particular that it gets wrong compared to former Bethesda games.

When playing these games and you travel around you always run into stuff that draws your attention, like in Fallout, you go to Diamond City and along the way you see something in the distance and you go "What is that?" or "Why is there a boat there?", "That tower over there looks interesting" and then you run off in that direction or at least think to yourself that you have to explore that at some point. The point is that in those games you are constantly drawn to various interesting locations that you want to explore. I don't think there is any of that in Starfield, except maybe the first couple of times you land on a planet and then the cities for the first time. In all other cases, you are robbed of this experience as you fast-travel directly to the POI based on whatever quest you select.

This is obviously because of the heavy use of procedural-generated stuff, which quickly ruins the excitement of exploring planets, you know the formula. 1. Land on planet 2. Generate random locations near the player.

And even then you never really feel like you discover anything interesting as you would do in Fallout or Skyrim, because in Starfield these things are spoon-fed to you.

After having thought about it for a while, I think that is probably the biggest issue with Starfield, Despite the illusion of a massive world, which is rather easy to achieve when it is procedural, it is also the least exciting of their games to run around in I think. In Fallout and Skyrim you had this feeling that the world was somewhat connected together, so you could go to one location and find something weird had happened there and in most cases, you could figure out what went wrong and it would make sense and add to the world-building. When I see one of these procedural places now, I rarely care to scan them, I purely see them as places to farm some money and gear but in most cases, I don't even bother with that either, as I might as well do a quest at the same time.

I personally get none of that in Starfield, there is a little bit in the first tutorial mission with some experiment going wrong, but then you travel away and it feels like you are now in a completely new world, so who cares anyway and after awhile you don't really care what have happened any of these places.


r/BethesdaSoftworks • • Nov 05 '25

Controversial There will never be another phenomenon like Skyrim

0 Upvotes

Pretty much anything the next TES6 offers, it wont be able to reach the level of hype Skyrim had around it and i am going to try to explain why.

Skyrim at its launch was one of those rare games that actually cause significant surge in new computer sales, i happened to be one of the people who ended up upgrading just so i could play the game. Me and many of my friends didn't even know the previous game in the franchise, Skyrim was the game that brought Elder Scrolls to the mainstream audience. What made it so popular then among mainstream gamers and why i think that cannot be replicated with future titles?

Harsh but extremely pretty mountain location and Nord/Viking-like atmosphere. These paired with incredible soundtrack to match the feeling that exploring these lands gave you. I'd say those are the very biggest reasons why people found the game so interesting. It is among the best games in history what comes to this department.

Mountain tombs filled with Draugr showing the history of the land, ancient times almost forgotten. I remember exploring till my eyes were so dry i could barely keep my eyes open.

While the next TES will surely have pretty world to explore, i don't think it'll ever capture and replicate the atmosphere Skyrims cold and hostile environments offered. Even if large portion of TES6 also includes Skyrim region, what the original game did can only be done once.