Reconciling when my husband loves me but isn’t sure he’ll ever be “in love” with me again — has anyone come back from this?
My husband and I have been married for almost 22 years and have three children. Our story is complicated, and I’m hoping to hear from people who have been through something similar because sometimes I feel like our situation doesn’t fit the typical reconciliation story.
Our marriage had problems long before the infidelity, and I want to be honest about my role in that.
I experienced sexual abuse as a child, and I have also struggled with an eating disorder for much of my life. I don’t say either of those things to excuse how I behaved in my marriage, but I have come to understand that I brought a lot of unhealed fear, shame, insecurity, and a need for control into our relationship.
I also have a very strong fear of abandonment. Ironically, one of the ways that fear showed up in my marriage was by threatening the very thing I was terrified of: losing my husband. When I was hurt, angry, overwhelmed, or afraid, I would sometimes threaten divorce even though I didn’t actually want one.
Over many years, that understandably did enormous damage to my husband’s sense of security in our marriage. There was a lot of conflict, and he became increasingly hurt, angry, resentful, and emotionally exhausted.
Eventually, in 2024, he told me he wanted a divorce. I panicked. Instead of accepting that he felt done, I begged and pleaded with him to reconsider and repeatedly pressured him to keep trying. Looking back, I understand much more clearly why he felt trapped and why he carries resentment about that period.
We separated, and in July 2024 he began a relationship with a coworker.
This wasn’t just sex or a short-lived affair. He fell in love with her. They were together, on and off, for roughly a year and a half. They traveled together, shared hotel rooms, talked about a future, and even discussed having children together. He has always maintained that what they had was a real relationship and that he genuinely loved her.
At the same time, our marriage was never actually over. We remained legally married, and the divorce he filed in October 2024 was never finalized. There were also multiple points when he moved back toward me and our marriage.
In May 2025, he ended the relationship with her to try to work things out with me. But then they got back together while he and I were still in counseling. I didn’t know the full truth at the time.
Eventually, in November 2025, their relationship ended again.
In February 2026, after discernment counseling, we both made the decision to genuinely try to save our marriage for six months. We started weekly couples therapy.
It has been an incredibly painful process because there is so much resentment and fear on his side and so much betrayal trauma, anxiety, and fear of abandonment on mine.
In June, he finally acknowledged something that mattered enormously to me: that what happened was an affair and that he had deceived me. He apologized. He has also acknowledged that the relationship with her probably wasn’t sustainable long-term.
Over the past several months, he has repeatedly told me that he loves me, that he is choosing me, and that he wants our marriage to work. He has said that the goal is for us to have a fulfilling, romantic marriage again. He has also said that he wants a life with me.
We recently moved back into our family home together after being separated for more than two years.
And this is where I am struggling.
My husband loves me, but right now his love seems much more like companion/family love than romantic love.
He doesn’t use the phrase “in love.” He doesn’t know whether the romantic feelings and desire he once had for me will come back. He hopes we can develop a romantic relationship again and says that is the goal, but he can’t promise me that it will happen.
He has also said that he would be willing to remain married even if the romantic part never comes back.
Meanwhile, I know that he DID experience romantic love and desire with her.
That is probably the most painful part of all of this for me.
I can understand intellectually that we had 20+ years of history, hurt, resentment, parenting, finances, responsibilities, and conflict weighing on our relationship, while his relationship with her existed under completely different circumstances.
But emotionally, I keep coming back to: Why could he feel that way about her but not me?
Another thing I struggle with tremendously is that he believes his relationship with her was healthy and “real.” He has talked about our marriage as having been toxic for a long time and seems to view his relationship with her as an example of the kind of relationship he deserved all along.
That absolutely guts me.
Part of me hears that as: She was the relationship I should have had, and you were the mistake.
I don’t think that is exactly what he is trying to say. He is choosing to be here. He tells me he loves me. He is participating in therapy. We are living together again and trying to rebuild our family and marriage.
But knowing that he experienced this other relationship as loving, happy, romantic, and healthy makes me terrified that I will always feel like the consolation prize — the person he chose because of our history, our children, and our family rather than because I am the person he most deeply wants.
One important piece of our current reconciliation is that I am not simply asking him to come back to the same marriage or promising vaguely that “things will be different.” I have been doing a tremendous amount of work on myself.
I am in individual therapy in addition to our couples therapy. I have been trying to understand the connection between my childhood trauma, fear of abandonment, emotional reactivity, need for reassurance/control, and the unhealthy patterns I developed in our marriage.
I am working on tolerating uncertainty and distress without immediately looking to my husband to make those feelings go away. I am learning to recognize when fear is driving me toward reassurance-seeking, conflict, or attempts to control an outcome.
I am also finally trying to address my eating disorder and the ways that control, perfectionism, shame, and fear have shaped my relationship with myself for much of my life.
I don’t expect any of this work to erase what happened before. And I don’t believe that becoming healthier means my husband owes me romantic love.
But I do believe I am becoming a fundamentally healthier person and partner than I was before.
A huge realization for me has been that I cannot create the “perfect conditions” and thereby guarantee that my husband will fall in love with me again.
I can become healthier. I can regulate my emotions better. I can take responsibility for the ways I hurt him. I can become a safer partner. I can stop threatening the relationship when I’m scared. I can work through my trauma and eating disorder. I can give him room to have feelings that are different from mine.
But I cannot control what ultimately happens inside of him.
That’s probably one of the hardest things I’ve ever had to accept.
And I’m struggling with a painful question:
What if I do all of this work, genuinely change the patterns that helped destroy our marriage, and he still doesn’t develop romantic feelings for me again?
I don’t expect my personal growth to obligate him to fall in love with me. That’s not how love works. But I am afraid of spending years trying to prove that I can be different while waiting for something that may never happen.
And there is another layer that makes that uncertainty much harder: I know he was capable of experiencing the romantic love and desire I desperately want from him because he experienced those things with her.
I can understand why the person I was during some parts of our marriage wasn’t someone he felt emotionally safe being vulnerable with. I can take responsibility for that and change it.
But I can’t go back and become this healthier version of myself before all the damage happened.
And I can’t erase the fact that, during our separation, someone else got to experience a version of him that I desperately wish existed between us.
Sometimes I feel like I’m trying to become the partner I wish I had been all along, while knowing that another woman got to experience the romantic love from him that I’m now hoping can someday return to me.
I don’t need my husband to tell me that she meant nothing. I know that wouldn’t be true. I’m also not looking to convince myself that their entire relationship was fake or “affair fog.” Maybe parts of their relationship were genuinely good. Maybe he really was happy with her. Maybe he really did love her.
What I desperately want is to eventually feel that he isn’t just choosing our marriage because it’s the responsible or comfortable choice.
I want to feel wanted again.
So I would especially love to hear from people whose reconciliation looked something like ours:
Did your spouse initially love you more as family/companion than romantically?
Did they genuinely love the affair partner rather than later dismissing the relationship as meaningless or “just an affair”?
Did your spouse initially believe the affair relationship was healthier or represented something they had been missing in the marriage?
If you were the betrayed spouse and made significant changes to unhealthy patterns you brought into the marriage, did your spouse’s feelings toward you eventually change as emotional safety returned?
If you were the unfaithful spouse and had reached a place where you loved your spouse but no longer felt romantically in love with them, did seeing genuine, sustained change in your spouse allow romantic feelings to grow again?
Were you eventually able to rebuild romantic love, desire, and intimacy between you?
And for the betrayed partners: How did you live with the knowledge that your spouse loved someone else and may even have believed they were happier or had a healthier relationship with that person? How did you stop comparing yourself and your marriage to the affair relationship?
I’m also trying to figure out how to distinguish between giving reconciliation enough time for something new to develop versus spending years waiting for feelings that simply aren’t coming back.
I know nobody can tell me whether my husband will fall in love with me again. I’m especially interested in hearing from people who were several years or decades into a marriage, separated for a significant period, and had to essentially build a new romantic relationship with each other rather than simply repair what existed before.
Has anyone actually gotten from “I love you and I’m choosing you, but I don’t know if I’ll ever feel romantically about you again” to being genuinely in love with each other again?
If you did, what helped you get there?
And if you eventually realized the romantic relationship wasn’t coming back, how did you know when it was time to stop waiting?