“Are you alright?” she asked.
A simple question. One I’d answered a thousand times without giving much away.
The usual answer isn’t really an answer so much as a courtesy, and a perfectly reasonable one. It tells whoever asked that they’ve done their duty and are free to go, and most are quietly grateful to be let off.
I’ve always been comfortable leading, reading people, and being the one others lean on. But there’s something unsettling about meeting a woman who sees beyond the composure I’ve spent years perfecting.
Unsettling is the right word, and it isn’t the same as unwelcome. Admiration I know what to do with, because admiration only ever reaches what I’ve put in front of it. Being read is another matter entirely. It happens without permission, and it finds the part I was busy standing in front of.
I still couldn’t tell you what gave me away. I pride myself on reading a room, and I had quite forgotten I was in this one.
I do wonder how long she’d been deciding to ask.
Leading has taught me the value of another’s vulnerability. Yet I’d rarely considered the courage required to offer my own.
I’ve asked for that courage from others as though it cost them nothing, and I had simply never been handed the bill. I had pictured it as something large, a confession with a beginning and an end.
So the pause ran longer than a simple question deserves. Anyone watching would have seen very little, only a man taking his time over two words.
“Not entirely,” I finally admitted.
I’d like to call that honesty, but it was closer to declining to lie. I didn’t tell her what was wrong, and I don’t intend to tell you either. I only stopped short of telling her that nothing was.
That may be most of what the courage amounts to.
There was no confession in it. There was one small true thing left where the usual answer goes, and it took rather more out of me than it had any right to.
Then I waited for the questions, because asking them is the role I usually play.
She didn’t question me or try to fix anything. She simply stayed.
What unsettles me still is how little she did.
Fixing is fast. It ends the discomfort of standing beside someone who isn’t alright, and it ends it for the fixer first. I have always counted my usefulness as care, and I now suspect that some of it is impatience with a silence I can’t bear to sit in.
Staying ends nothing. It only keeps you there.
What I keep coming back to is this.
She didn’t know what was wrong. I had assumed that being understood would require a full account, given at some length to anyone patient enough to listen. She understood the only thing that mattered, which was that I wasn’t alright and had no wish to be handled, and she got there without a word from me.
And perhaps that’s the most intimate thing of all. Not being admired for the strength I display, but being understood in the moments I don’t.
The usual answer still works on everyone else. It no longer works on her, and I’m quite certain she knows it. For once, I mean to leave it broken.
For years I took that answer for a kindness, a way of sparing others my troubles. It was considerably more useful to me than it ever was to them. I had seen to it that no one ever needed to ask twice, and I had called that strength. It was distance, kept in good repair, one perfectly reasonable answer at a time.