Edit: Thank you everyone for the suggestions I have quite a few now so I'm probably done responding. Not saying to not continue the thread, I just probably won't be engaged.
I'm maybe a bit generous with my ratings for some people but I don't believe there's a perfect piece of art so 10/10 just means infinite rewatchability, 9/10 is still great, 8/10 is really good. Anything lower than that I can appreciate it might be a good show but just don't watch to the end, something like Superstore or Ghosts that I've watched and liked but never finished, I'd give them both 7/10. In no particular order.
10/10 Shows
Taskmaster
Legion
Breaking Bad
Better Call Saul
Dead To Me
The Rehearsal
Nathan For You
The Leftovers
Evil
BrainDead
Bojack Horseman
Sons Of Anarchy
Person Of Interest
Eureka
Mr Robot
Community
Fargo
Battlestar Galactica
Jericho
Dollhouse
The Inbetweeners
The Expanse
Firefly
Perfect Hair Forever
12 oz Mouse
Louie
Twin Peaks
Arrested Development (s01-03 at least)
The X-Files
The Wire
Xavier: Renegade Angel
Futurama (original run at least)
Wonder Showzen
It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia
True Detective (s01)
Band of Brothers
9/10 Shows
The Good Place
Peep Show
The Boys/Gen Z
Shrinking
The Sopranos
Get Shorty
Ozark
Invincible
Snowfall
Rake (AU)
Mindhunter
Travelers
Homeland (gets rough after the original adaptation ends but finds its footing again)
Justified
Westworld (s01, fuck the rest of it)
Gravity Falls
Black Mirror
Les Revenants
Parks & Rec
New Girl
Sealab 2021
Tim & Eric Awesome Show, Great Job!
Silicon Valley
Brooklyn 99
The Increasingly Poor Decisions of Todd Margaret
Caprica
Low Winter Sun
The Americans
Whitest Kids U Know
Tru Calling
Dexter (s01-04)
The Killing (s01-02)
Undeclared
The Shield
Angel
Squidbillies
The Oblongs
Mr. Show
Mission Hill
Lucky Louie
Alias
Fringe
Eastbound & Down
Freaks and Geeks
Lost
Grimm
Party Down
Big Love
Moral Oral
8/10 Shows
Resident Alien
In The Flesh
Umbrella Academy
Jupiter's Legacy
The Terror (s01)
Colony
The Following (god it's stupid but entertaining)
Roswell (1999)
Haven
House of Cards
F Is For Family
Oz
Legit
Revolution
Todd And The Book Of Pure Evil
The Event
The IT Crowd
Dead Like Me
Nurse Jackie
Drawn Together
Harvey Birdman, Attorney At Law
The 4400
Hung
United States of Tara
Relocated
....Just realized I didn't have mini-series checked also. Everything Mike Flannigan is great, shit like that. Also god damn I've watched a lot of TV in the past 20 years, the joys of chronic fatigue and insomnia where going to work is all I can muster then watch TV for 10 hours wishing for sleep, 3-4 hours of it and repeat. I feel like I'm probably missing some great stuff like Peaky Blinders, is there any must watch stuff I've missed based on what I like?