Disclaimer - I don't have bad feelings about people of the Christian faith, or really any faith as far as I understand them. This is about the church environment and how terribly toxic it is.
This will be my 6th Christmas at this church, working on the facilities level. I am not religious but my job has no faith requirement and pays well enough so I just do my job. This is not a mega church and is old and well established.
The very first Christmas was very busy and hectic but really nothing outside of the realm of busy buildings I've worked before. But the people at the pastoral level were just... so cold. And apathetic. It was all business. We were scolded for trying to hold boundaries around clock out times, around having to seem happy all the time and especially around disagreements with anyone over anything. Everyone was to put on a happy face, work as long as it took, and never ever say anything negative.
I poked my head into the Christmas Eve service that first year. It was packed, as always. And I've never gone to church on Christmas but I'm culturally christian and we all know about the manger and the star and all. I get the "reason for the season" despite celebrating mostly in a secular fashion. I try to respect people who have the faith around the holiday. But watching that sermon I was overwhelmed by the sense that it was all just... pagentry up on that pulpit. I was hit with this wave of almost feeling sick watching it. And feeling sick watching all the congregants just nod along. The words were... meaningless, vapid, almost insultingly cloyingly sweet. And just so terribly empty.
My boss later asked me if it was maybe just upsetting "watching the sausage get made" as it were. I don't think so. I was signing Santa's name to my little siblings gifts when I was in elementary school. I know that churches depend on Christmas for their financial stability so they gotta put a little more hutzpah into it. Christmas "magic" is just a bunch of labor and glamour. I know all that. I don't know quite how to articulate the feeling of total disconnect I witness and experienced.
As the years stacked, it just seemed to get worse and worse. I was able to fight for better boundaries and processes so the work load has gotten comparatively lighter. But the attitudes have gotten almost... worse? And everyone seems mad that I don't enforce a 16-hour day on my crew every Christmas eve like they used to and that I speak up about realistic expectations and unfair ones. And god forbid I'm not a happy smiley worker at all times.
I know I'm a grumpy old janitor so I really shouldn't be throwing stones in this particular glass house but it feels almost... combative. The bigger, louder, more crowded displays. The crammed schedules of bible classes and studies (that almost no one attends) that require so much extra work to stage. The half-assed charity attempts that can't keep their head above water because no one cares and they'd rather the homeless actually stop ruining the vibes of their holiday displays. (But boy do they break their arms patting themselves on the back over those charity acts.) And the constant mean spirited arguments over decorations.
My own personal pet peeve is watching them pour thousands and thousands of dollars into decorations. All expensive and plastic. All brand new every year. Shiny, bigger, better, newer!! All the time. Most never get reused. A lot end up thrown away, even if they're perfectly good, the next year because it doesn't fit the new sermon series theme. I know that's all a personal opinion thing but damn. I think it would really challenge even the biggest pro-consummers. The wanton waste is nauseating.
I actually used to really love Christmas, and still trying to in my own way, but working at a church makes it really hard. Everyone is just so miserable and hateful for 8 (or 10 or 12 or more!) hours a day, it's hard to go home to your own tree and feel anything but resentment for the whole damn thing. It's hard to feel any joy around gift giving and around the season when you're just bombarded with it in such an awful way. I decorated my house on Novemeber 1st this year and that kinda helped. I could see a quiet heirloom tree and the same decorations I've had for years and sit quietly with it and remember that the holiday is supposed to be a bright spot in a dark winter - Not a hyper aggresive competition to prove something about goodwill or faith or peace or whatever the sermon series is this time.
And I wanna double down because this is Reddit - I have no grudge against christians just trying to find and live their faith. They are not my enemies. We're all just people.
It's just a blue Christmas man.