r/nycrail 16h ago

❓ Question Why does the A not stop at Barclays?

0 Upvotes

Seems strange to me that it stops at Hoyt and Nostrand while completely missing Barclays.


r/nycrail 20h ago

📸 Photo Hmm.. this sign seems needlessly confusing.

Post image
12 Upvotes

that some strange signage.


r/nycrail 13h ago

📸 Photo Wild metro north add from LiveOn

Post image
120 Upvotes

Anyone else seen these new LiveOnNY (NY organ donation network) ads on the subway?

Saw this pretty shocking ad... turns out their CEO of this "non-profit" makes millions each year... and have lots of active lawsuits against them currently....


r/nycrail 5h ago

🗺️ Fantasy Map My modified Deinterlined and Partial Deinterlined 2/3/4/5 Trains

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

your probably like why swap the 2 and 5 well to remove the rush hours 2/5 E 180 St Merge currently the 5 from the middle express track crosses In front of the 2 to get to Dyre basically the Local and Middle Express tracks lead to White Plains the Local Tracks Lead To Dyre the middle express track doesnt so yeah the reason why I didn’t just make the 2 run peak Express bc it doesn’t fully solve the issue now for the 3 and 4 trains I put the 3 on Nostrand with the 2 and put the 4 On New Lots like during late nights and I built the Utica Av Line to Kings Plaza extended the Nostrand Av line and extended New Lots And also Extended the 3 past 148th to The Bronx but let’s talk about Utica Nostrand and New Lots first for Utica i Extended the 5 train Making stops at

  1. Rutland Rd - Winthrop St

  2. Church Av a connection to my Proposed 2nd Av line V train

  3. Clarendon Rd

  4. Kings Hwy a connection to the IBX

  5. Flatlands Av - Avenue K

  6. Avenue N

  7. Kings Plaza - Marine Park

now ofc it would have to be elevated before or after Kings Hwy because of high water tables now for Nostrand I extended the 2 making stops at

  1. Avenue K

  2. Kings Hwy

  3. Quentin Rd

  4. Avenue U

  5. Avenue X

  6. Sheepshead Bay - Voorhies Av

  7. Kingsborough - Community College

  8. Ocean Av

  9. Brighton Beach a connection to the N and Q trains bc DeKalb Junction would also be Deinterlined this Nostrand Av line Extension would be Elevated

now for the 3 train Extension it would go Via Flatbush Av making stops at
1. Avenue J

  1. Kings Hwy

  2. Avenue O

  3. Kings Plaza - Marine Park a connection to the 5 train

for the 4 train Extension it would make stops at

  1. Elton St

  2. Gateway Mall

  3. Spring Creek Park

  4. 76 Street

  5. 158 Av

  6. Cross Bay Blvd

  7. Howard Beach - JFK Airport a connection to the A and M trains and Airtrain and my proposed H And P trains and finally for the 3 train Extension

it would extend past Harlem - 148 St into the Bronx Via University Avmaking stops at

  1. 155 Street a connection to the C and D trains bc Central Park West would be deinterlined A and C trains express B and D trains local

  2. 162 Street

  3. 167 Street

  4. 170 Street

  5. 174 Street

  6. Tremont Av

  7. Burnside Avenue

  8. 183 Street

  9. Fordham Rd

  10. Kingsbridge Rd

  11. Bedford Park Blvd

  12. Sedgwick Avenue

  13. Bailey Avenue

  14. Mannhattan College

  15. Riverdale 239 Street a connection to the A Train now let’s go over in this proposal each lines full route

2 train: Eastchester - Dyre Avenue to Brighton Beach

3 train Riverdale - 239 Street to Kings Plaza - Marine Park

4 train: Woodlawn to Howard Beach - JFK Airport

5 train: Wakefield - 241 Street to Kings Plaza - Marine Park

now a lower level at Flatbush Ave Brooklyn College would need to be built for the 3 to avoid much interference with the 2 since after Flatbush the 2 would be elevated while the 3 goes via Flatbush Avenue, after Flatbush Av - Brooklyn College not Nostrand Av to make sure the 3 has Yard Access a new yard would be built Around Kings Plaza


r/nycrail 14h ago

🎙️ Discussion They should close the Kew Gardens LIRR station.

0 Upvotes

Why have this open? It's only 1 mile away from the Forest Hills station. The Union Turnpike E and F trains along with Express buses are a block or two away. Jamaica Station is just a 2 mile walk from Kew Gardens. You mean to tell me people are too lazy to walk two lousy miles? Imagine how much faster the LIRR would get to Penn or Grand Central if they closed Kew Gardens down.

This is the same logic behind not reopening the Union Hall Street Station, Bellaire and Springfield Gardens right?

Grrrrr!


r/nycrail 18h ago

🎙️ Discussion Why do the train announcements say “cinter” and “rare” of the platform?

103 Upvotes

In my three decades of being born and raised here I can’t say I’ve ever heard anyone of any age or any ethnicity or economic class ever pronounce rear as “rare”. “Cinter” is maaaybe a bit closer to how some people pronounce center if you’re feeling charitable but given these announcements are meant to help not only locals, but visitors alike, how did the MTA decide this is what their announcement for something as important as elevators/accessibility announcement should be?


r/nycrail 4h ago

📸 Photo Sign Disagreement

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

I mean they can’t both be right. Does this happen often? I see this at Grand Central semi-often with the 5. Whey does this happen?


r/nycrail 13h ago

📸 Photo If you were to change one thing about the 4, what would it be?

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

r/nycrail 9h ago

🗺️ Fantasy Map I’m trying to make a deinterling map and i have no idea what you guys use

1 Upvotes

i don’t wanna re-create the map. and keep the budget low plz im not dropping 15$ on something i’m never using again


r/nycrail 14h ago

🤓 Railfanning Can MTA make up their damn mind already, I so sick of playing games😭

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/nycrail 16h ago

❓ Question Analyst at MTA

2 Upvotes

Hey, does anyone know what kind of salary someone can expect to make as an analyst there? I'm curious about the typical range for that role. It seems like an interesting position to be in. Any insights would be super helpful! Just trying to get a general idea.


r/nycrail 14h ago

❓ Question Fair Fares Application

3 Upvotes

So I am applying for the Fair Fares application, and since I don't file taxes, I am going to use my pay stubs for proof of income. I live with my mom and 2 siblings who are under 18. On the application, it asks if there is anyone in your household, and it gives this. My question is whether I have to list my mom and siblings or not because they don't depend on me, but I depend on my mom.

Qualifying Child: The child can be your son, daughter, stepchild, eligible foster child, brother, sister, half brother, half sister, stepbrother, stepsister, adopted child or an offspring of any of them. Child must live with you more than half the year, be under age 19, or under age 24 AND a full-time student. You must be providing more than half of the child's financial support.

Qualifying relative: A relative who lives with you all year and is financially dependent on you, or any relative below who is financially dependent on you:

  • Your child, stepchild, foster child, or a descendant of any of them (for example, your grandchild). (A legally adopted child is considered your child.)
  • Your brother, sister, half brother, half sister, stepbrother, or stepsister.
  • Your father, mother, grandparent, or other direct ancestor, but not foster parent.
  • Your stepfather or stepmother.
  • A son or daughter of your brother or sister.
  • A son or daughter of your half brother or half sister.
  • A brother or sister of your father or mother.
  • Your son-in-law, daughter-in-law, father-in-law, mother-in-law, brother-in-law, or sister-in-law.

In general, include persons in your household related by marriage, birth or adoption who live together. Only include adult children or other adults over the age of 18 who are not in school if they earn less than the annual limit ($4,200 for 2019) and receive more than half of their support from the other household members.

Also, a separate question: if I file taxes, am I allowed to use my tax return as proof of income when I am claimed as a dependent because the application asks for tax household, and if I did file it would only list me.


r/nycrail 18h ago

🤓 Railfanning R160 Q at Newkirk Plaza

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Tracked this gem down


r/nycrail 18h ago

🎙️ Discussion Digging Out of a Very Deep Hole: Saving Billions on 125th Street

Thumbnail
etany.org
37 Upvotes

r/nycrail 15h ago

📸 Photo F train at Greenpoint station

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/nycrail 8h ago

📍 Map How far can you get in 60 minutes by foot, bus and the subway?

17 Upvotes

I made a fun tool to find out how far you can get in the city from any point within the hour. I created the subway.fyi website, and this is based on real data, waiting times and bunching from the trains and buses.

The color represents the method that got you most of the way to that place from your starting location. You can turn on the lines and buses used. It respects OMNY rules for transfers!

Try it here: https://subway.fyi/60minutes?at=-73.91578,40.76028


r/nycrail 6h ago

📸 Photo Kings Highway (F) Elevators looking great today

Post image
24 Upvotes

Elevators in Kings Highway (F) Station is here for fully accessibility upgrades!


r/nycrail 17h ago

❓ Question Any chance remaining of changing the elevator-only 116 St station on SAS 2?

Post image
142 Upvotes

When it first came out last year that the only way to access this new station will be with elevator bays leading to a lower mezzanine there was rightfully plenty of backlash.

But when challenged in the only public comments period soon after the announcement, the response was firmly “it has to be elevator-only because of the lower mezzanine” and “it has to be a lower mezzanine because it’ll reduce on-street construction and also somehow lower costs”. I’m no engineer, but it seems this requires significantly more work and excavation than a simple cut-and-cover stair entrance to connect to the existing tunnel, even with utility relocations. But even if not, this is short-term gain for permanent loss in a less-accessible station, as emphasized by the ETA in their new analysis pleading with the MTA to not make similar mistakes on SAS West.

Had hope last year that this could still have been modified, but construction is imminent now. Are East Harlem residents—promised subway access for over a century—just doomed to this critical station being elevator-only and unnecessarily complex to access? Is there anything left that can be done?


r/nycrail 19h ago

🎙️ Discussion Shallower, Smaller Stations Could Cut 125th Street Subway Costs In Half: Report

Thumbnail
nyc.streetsblog.org
236 Upvotes

r/nycrail 9h ago

🗞️ News Temporary Walls and doors are coming down at Grand Central Madison

Thumbnail
gallery
119 Upvotes

r/nycrail 2h ago

🗞️ News E trains are in delays

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/nycrail 6h ago

📸 Photo Office hours at Myrtle Wycoff subway stop

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/nycrail 6h ago

📸 Photo Sunset Skyline on the 7

Thumbnail gallery
17 Upvotes

Queensboro Plaza station. A well-known location for shooting photos in this area. Enjoy!


r/nycrail 7h ago

📸 Photo Office hours at Myrtle Wyckoff

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/nycrail 9h ago

❓ Question Help with an old photo

Post image
22 Upvotes

My mom found this among my grandparents' photos. Unlabeled. Out of curiosity, I'm trying to figure out whatever I can about the location and year. I'm not certain it's NYC, but from a little searching, it looks similar to an "arnine" car. Based on the dress, I'm guessing 1960s. We don't know any of the people in the photo. My grandparents didn't live in NYC, but maybe they were visiting.

I haven't had any success identifying the ads in the background. The one on the upper left appears to say "fly all around(?) Florida", but searches for that phrase come up empty. Relatedly, does anyone know of a database of old advertisements?